Pocock says politicians using encrypted messaging apps damages ‘health of our democracy'
Independent senator David Pocock says the use of encrypted messaging platforms by politicians to avoid scrutiny is damaging to Australian democracy, urging the government to act on recommendations from the information commissioner and the National Archives that such messages should be retained.
In a report on Wednesday from the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) and the National Archives, a survey of 22 government agencies found 16 allowed use of messaging apps, three did not allow their use, and three did not have a policy.
Of the 16 agencies, eight had policies around the use of these apps and, of those, five did not address security classification requirements, six did not address archive requirements and five did not address FoI search requirements.
The report has recommended agencies review or develop policies for encrypted messaging apps and address issues around retention of information for FoI purposes. The two agencies will re-examine the issue in two years.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Pocock urged the Albanese government to give 'careful attention and prompt action' to the report, saying there were strong probity and transparency arguments for keeping records of all communications related to government decision-making.
'The use of messaging apps to deliberately avoid scrutiny through freedom of information is deeply concerning and will have long-term negative impacts for the health of our democracy, good governance, and the accountability of our decision-makers,' he said.
When Kevin Rudd was lobbying the then Turnbull government to advocate for Rudd to be appointed United Nations secretary general in 2016, it was reported in letters Rudd released that Rudd and Malcolm Turnbull had communicated about the matter over encrypted app Wickr.
A freedom of information request seeking access to these messages was ultimately rejected by the prime minister's office, stating the messages could not be found.
In a separate 2021 decision by the then information commissioner, Angelene Falk, the government claimed it could not find reported WhatsApp communications between the then foreign affairs minister, Marise Payne, and her Indonesian counterpart related to the Morrison government's decision to recognise West Jerusalem as the capital of Israel.
The rise of encrypted messaging apps that have messages set to delete has presented a problem for freedom of information requests. If crucial government communications are sent over apps such as Signal and WhatsApp and are not retained, they cannot be obtained under FoI, and are also unable to be retained for the purposes of the National Archives.
For FoI decisions where it is found that the documents have not been retained, the OAIC has no powers to penalise government officials for failing to retain the information, with responsibility falling to the National Archives under the Archives Act.
But to date it has not been enforced in previously identified cases.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The Australian information commissioner, Elizabeth Tydd, acknowledged that a view held by some agencies – that not every communication needs to be considered a public record subject to FoI – needs to be balanced with the public interest.
'There can be a privacy preserving dimension, if those records are destroyed, and so this holistic approach to information governance, inspired by digital government and our digital era, really needs this kind of joined up approach.'
Tydd indicated public servants would have a role in ensuring their ministers' offices retained messages.
'We have an act, the FoI Act, that actually recognises that government information is a national resource and should be used for public purposes,' she said.
'So that's a real strength, and bringing that to the table in this report, coupled with the APS values of stewardship … really ensure that if we equip the [Australian public service] to do this well, with joined up guidance, then we have greater transparency, greater accountability and a more participative, healthier system of democracies.'
A spokesperson for the National Archives said the agency 'takes seriously any known cases of unauthorised disposal of government records regardless of technology used to create them'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Scots schools to convert gender-neutral toilets to single-sex after Supreme Court ruling
Currently, 52 schools across 11 council areas in Scotland only offer gender-neutral toilets Around 18 Scottish schools that previously offered gender-neutral toilets will convert back to single-sex facilities following a legal ruling. The schools, in Aberdeenshire, Argyll and Bute, the Scottish Borders and Shetland, will add separate bathrooms for boys and girls. It comes after a landmark ruling at the UK Supreme court, which declared a woman is defined by biological sex under equalities law. Figures obtained by the BBC show that 52 schools across 11 council areas in Scotland only offered gender-neutral toilets. Of those, 10 are located in Shetland. court ruling before deciding how to respond. Meanwhile, City of Edinburgh Council said it was "considering what changes may need to be made". The local authority plans to provide an update over the summer. Five other councils - Clackmannanshire, East Ayrshire, North Ayrshire, Midlothian and Perth and Kinross - confirmed they had at least one school in their area which offered no single-sex facilities. They did not provide an update on any changes to provision since then. South Ayrshire, Moray, Stirling and South Lanarkshire councils said none of their schools offered any gender-neutral provision. In April, a Scottish judge ruled that all state schools must provide separate male and female toilets following a legal case brought by parents against Scottish Borders Council. The decision, handed down at the Court of Session in Edinburgh, came after Sean Stratford and Leigh Hurley challenged the council's policy at Earlston Primary School, where their eight-year-old son had been a pupil. Rosie Walker, solicitor for the parents and partner at Gilson Gray LLP, welcomed the judgment. She said at the time: "This case, on top of the Supreme Court decision last week, gives focus to the importance of protecting sex-based rights a nd single-sex spaces." Ms Hurley, 39, who works at the school as a pupil support worker, first raised concerns in late 2023 about the school's broader transgender inclusion policies, which included allowing a pupil to socially transition and participate in sports in line with their gender identity. She later discovered the school planned to have no sex-segregated toilet facilities, and that children could face punishment for "misgendering" peers. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. She said: 'We just want all children to be safeguarded. We have great empathy for any child, but we just wanted our rights respected at the same time, and that wasn't happening.' The couple ultimately withdrew their son from the school, citing emotional distress and concerns about their younger daughter, who would have also been expected to use gender-neutral toilets once she enrolled. Stratford, 42, said: 'We've won, but common sense says we should never have been in this position in the first place. We brought this to their attention when it was still a building site.'
Daily Mirror
11 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Everything we know as explosions boom across large city and conflict escalates
The potential for an all-out war between Israel and Iran has increased today after Benjamin Netanyahu's country this morning attacked Tehran, which is Iran's capital Israel has today attacked Iran's capital Tehran - targeting the country's nuclear programme. General Hossein Salami, the commander-in-chief of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), was killed during Israel's overnight strikes. Air-raid sirens rang out as Israel declared a state of emergency, following the violent attacks on several nuclear and military sites across Tehran and surrounding areas. The potential for an all-out war between two bitter Middle East adversaries has increased as tensions were already high over Tehran's rapidly advancing nuclear programme. "This is not a one-day attack," an Israeli military source told CNN, describing the attacks as "preemptive, precise, combined offensive". Fatalities and injuries are likely, though exact figures for each have yet to be confirmed by authorities. Iran has temporarily closed its airspace over Tehran, and all departures and arrivals have been suspended at Israel's Ben Gurion Airport, which is near Tel Aviv. Black smoke seen over Iran's main nuclear enrichment facility Black smoke rose today over Iran's main nuclear enrichment facility at Natanz, though it wasn't clear how bad the damage was. Iranian state television briefly showed the live picture with a reporter. Natanz is partially above ground, partially below ground, with multiple halls of centrifuges spinning uranium gas for its nuclear program. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had said Israel targeted the site in Friday's attack. Natanz previously has been targeted by the Stuxnet cyberattack and multiple sabotage campaigns likely carried out by Israel. Australia and New Zealand condemn strikes Australia and New Zealand's governments have condemned the Israeli strikes. Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong said she was 'alarmed by the escalation' between Israel and Iran, which she said risked further destabilizing an already volatile region. New Zealand's Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said the strikes were 'a huge concern' for his government and 'potentially catastrophic' for the Middle East. 'The risk of miscalculation is high,' he said. The two countries were among five that enacted travel and financial sanctions on two far-right Israeli government ministers Wednesday, accusing them of 'inciting extremist violence' against Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. Iranian state TV says head of Revolutionary Guard is feared dead Iranian state television says the head of Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard, General Hossein Salami, is feared dead after an Israeli attack. It added that one other top Guard official, as well as two nuclear scientists, were also feared dead. The report offered few other details. Iran's Revolutionary Guard, created after its 1979 Islamic Revolution, is one of the main power centres within the country's theocracy. It also controls Iran's arsenal of ballistic missiles, which it has used to attack Israel twice during the ongoing Israel-Hamas war in the Gaza Strip. Headquarters of Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard is ablaze An Israeli attack on Iran has set the headquarters of Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard ablaze, state television reported Friday. A reporter on air said he was unable to get closer due to the intensity of the fire in Iran's capital, Tehran. Multiple sites in the capital had been hit in the attack, which Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said targeted both sites of and officials leading Iran's nuclear program and its ballistic missile arsenal.
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
Ben Fordham unleashes withering spray as Albanese fails to meet housing target because of immigration
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and his government has been slammed by radio host Ben Fordham over Australia's worsening housing crisis. It follows the release of a report from the Government's National Housing Supply and Affordability Council (NHSAC), showing Australia will miss its own housing targets. According to the report, housing construction is at its lowest point in a decade, with just 177,000 new dwellings completed in 2024, well short of the government's 233,000 target. The Council warned that housing is not being built quickly enough to meet growing demand and relieve affordability pressures. 'The Council's analysis shows that expected new housing supply will be insufficient to meaningfully improve housing affordability for all households,' the report stated. It forecasts that only 938,000 new dwellings will be completed across Australia over the five-year Housing Accord period ending 30 June 2029, far below the 1.2 million target. No state or territory is expected to meet its allocated share. On Thursday, Fordham lashed out at the government, blaming slow building rates and rising immigration for exacerbating the crisis. 'The Albanese government promised to build more houses, today they're building less. They promised to lower immigration, today, they're bringing in more,' he said. 'The PM will tell us he's bringing down the migration numbers... and building as many homes as he can, but we're not seeing it.' 'We simply can't build the houses fast enough. What we need is a sharp focus on skilled migration and coordination of housing supply policy with immigration numbers.' The NHSAC report also pointed to persistent challenges such as labour shortages, low productivity, and rising material costs as major factors dragging down new supply. Shadow Minister for Housing and Homelessness, Senator Andrew Bragg, has slammed at Labor's performance, saying the government had failed to support the very people responsible for delivering new housing. 'Labor has failed to get the houses built because they have done nothing to help the people who build houses: builders, tradespeople and developers,' Bragg said. He further highlighted that the government's flagship $10billion Housing Australia Future Fund (HAFF) failed to deliver a single new home during the previous term. 'Instead, it was acquiring existing housing, thereby making the supply problem worse... Labor's Housing Infrastructure Fund also failed to build any homes with $1.5 billion,' he added. Housing Minister Clare O'Neil last week pointed to bureaucracy as a major barrier to construction. 'It's just too hard to build a house in this country,' O'Neil told the ABC. 'And it's become uneconomic to build the kind of housing that our country needs most: affordable housing, especially for first home buyers.' One person arrives to Australia to live every 44 seconds according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). Under the Albanese government, overseas migration reached record highs. In 2022–23, net overseas migration hit 536,000, the highest in Australia's history. While in 2023–24, it dropped to 446,000, and is expected to fall to 340,000 in 2024–25. As of March 2025, the national median dwelling price surpassed $1million for the first time, reaching $1,002,500, following a 0.7 per cent quarterly increase. The annual growth rate slowed to 5.9 per cent in March 2025, down from 9.5% the previous year New data about Australia's migration will be released on Friday.
