Taxpayer funded satellite had 'deep-seated problems' from launch
Photo:
Supplied / Environmental Defence Fund
An Auckland University physics professor says a taxpayer-funded satellite that is missing in space had persistent and deep-seated problems.
The government paid almost $30 million towards MethaneSAT which
lost contact
on 20 June and is believed to be unrecoverable.
New Zealand joined the mission in 2019, hoping to boost science, track farm emissions, and grow our space sector.
The mission has been plagued by
delays
, first to its launch date and then to the arrival of its promised data about global methane emissions.
The University of Auckland has been waiting to take over the mission control at its new, partly taxpayer-funded Te Pūnaha Ātea Space Institute.
The announcement of the satellite's demise came just two days after the latest deadline for handing control over to university staff and students.
University of Auckland physics professor Richard Easther did not work directly on the project but says MethaneSAT has had persistent issues.
He told
Morning Report
losing contact with the satellite was not good news.
"There seems to be a consistent effort to put a sort of happy face on the situation but the concern that we have as a community is that MethaneSAT as a space craft seems to have had fairly persistent and deep-seated problems, pretty much from launch."
Some of this relates to the decision to use sub systems that don't have what's known as flight heritage, he said.
He said for most of the year it had been in orbit, it was not functioning properly.
While some good has come out of the mission, it was a lot less than expected, he said.
New Zealand Space Agency deputy head Andrew Johnson said every space mission faces risks and unfortunately some had been realised in this mission.
Losing contact was "extremely disappointing news, there's no hiding that at all".
But the legacy of this investment would live on, he said, like the mission control centre set up at University of Auckland.
"That's now given New Zealand the capability to participate in missions in the future."
Johnson said he doesn't think the MethaneSAT team mislead anyone.
"The reality is all missions face issues, there is a technical judgment about what constitutes 'normal' and that's been an evolving situation but I think when they have had those issues, they have been willing to talk about them and we've certainly had plenty of discussions with them behind the scenes as well."
This mission was an important step forward in New Zealand's space industry, he said.
EDF, the environmental non-profit behind the satellite mission, says
an investigation is underway
.
"Launched in March 2024, MethaneSAT had been collecting methane emissions data over the past year. It was one of the most advanced methane tracking satellites in space, measuring methane emissions in oil and gas producing regions across the world.
"The mission has been a remarkable success in terms of scientific and technological accomplishment, and for its lasting influence on both industry and regulators worldwide.
"The engineering team is conducting a thorough investigation into the loss of communication. This is expected to take time. We will share what we learn."
RNZ has been asking about problems with the satellite since September and was previously told its issues were "teething problems".
Asked if the public had been kept adequately informed, Minister Judith Collins said she had nothing to add and questions should go to the New Zealand Space Agency, which is part of the Ministry for Business, Innovation and Employment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
7 hours ago
- Scoop
Taxpayer Funded Satellite Had 'Deep-Seated Problems' From Launch
An Auckland University physics professor says a taxpayer-funded satellite that is lost in space had persistent and deep-seated problems. The government paid about $30 million towards MethaneSAT which lost contact on 20 June and is believed to be unrecoverable. New Zealand joined the mission in 2019, hoping to boost science, track farm emissions, and grow our space sector. The mission has been plagued by delays, first to its launch date and then to the arrival of its promised data about global methane emissions. The University of Auckland has been waiting to take over the mission control at its new, partly taxpayer-funded Te Pūnaha Ātea Space Institute. The announcement of the satellite's demise came just two days after the latest deadline for handing control over to university staff and students. University of Auckland physics professor Richard Easther did not work directly on the project but says MethaneSAT has had persistent issues. He told Morning Report losing contact with the satellite was not good news. "There seems to be a consistent effort to put a sort of happy face on the situation but the concern that we have as a community is that MethaneSAT as a space craft seems to have had fairly persistent and deep-seated problems, pretty much from launch." Some of this relates to the decision to use sub systems that don't have what's known as flight heritage, he said. He said for most of the year it had been in orbit, it was not functioning properly. While some good has come out of the mission, it was a lot less than expected, he said. New Zealand Space Agency deputy head Andrew Johnson said every space mission faces risks and unfortunately some had been realised in this mission. Losing contact was "extremely disappointing news, there's no hiding that at all". But the legacy of this investment would live on, he said, like the mission control centre set up at University of Auckland. "That's now given New Zealand the capability to participate in missions in the future." Johnson said he doesn't think the MethaneSAT team mislead anyone. "The reality is all missions face issues, there is a technical judgment about what constitutes 'normal' and that's been an evolving situation but I think when they have had those issues, they have been willing to talk about them and we've certainly had plenty of discussions with them behind the scenes as well." This mission was an important step forward in New Zealand's space industry, he said. 'We have been transparent' Chief scientist at Environmental Defense Fund and mission lead for MethaneSAT Dr Steven Hamburg told Morning Report they did not know what went wrong. "We got a communication with the satellite over the North Pole on the 20th of the month and all things were normal and it was over the Pacific so when it got to Antarctica, the next station, there was no communication and we've had none since." Asked about the criticisms of lack of communication, transparency has been key to the mission, he said. "And we have been transparent. All the data's made public and we did transfer it back to the manufacturer of the bus which allowed us to try and make it more efficient in its wanted to automate a lot of processes so we could automate the amount of data that we were going to collect. "They were working on that when unfortunately we lost contact." There was a very small chance they would be able to reactivate the satellite and get it back. "We were able to observe it using another satellite to look at it and it does not currently have power and so we are working it, we continue to work it but we have to be realistic, the probability of recovery is... diminishing." There has been substantial data collected, he said. "The earth science New Zealand team is working with that data and that's really a first because of the very high precision we have with MethaneSAT, allowing us to see much lower emission rates and at very fine spacial scales, they have a look at emissions across large regions from the agricultural sector that we never had before." EDF, the environmental non-profit behind the satellite mission, says an investigation is underway. "Launched in March 2024, MethaneSAT had been collecting methane emissions data over the past year. It was one of the most advanced methane tracking satellites in space, measuring methane emissions in oil and gas producing regions across the world. "The mission has been a remarkable success in terms of scientific and technological accomplishment, and for its lasting influence on both industry and regulators worldwide. "The engineering team is conducting a thorough investigation into the loss of communication. This is expected to take time. We will share what we learn." RNZ has been asking about problems with the satellite since September and was previously told its issues were "teething problems". Asked if the public had been kept adequately informed, Minister Judith Collins said she had nothing to add and questions should go to the New Zealand Space Agency, which is part of the Ministry for Business, Innovation and Employment.
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Mātauranga Māori science fair applies traditional thinking to modern-day problems
William Anaru said Te Arawa Lakes Trust always intended to expand the fair beyond Rotorua. Photo: Supplied/Cornell Tukiri A Rotorua-based science fair engaging tamariki in mātauranga Māori is expanding its registrations to the entire country for the first time. Te Tūkohu Ngāwhā Mātauranga Māori Science and Design Fair is run by Te Arawa Lakes Trust and, this year, it will be held from 23-25 July at the Rotorua Energy Events Centre. Te Arawa Lakes Trust environment manager William Anaru (Te Arawa) said the fair began as an idea five years ago to engage more tamariki around Rotorua in science. "The science fair wasn't just aimed at your traditional western science model, we also incorporated mātauranga Māori, sustainable design, we've got an art component and, this year, we are looking at climate resilience." Since it began, the fair has grown significantly, with a huge variety of projects, from exhibits on rongoā Māori to a camera used to identify invasive catfish, he said. "Last year, the winner of the science fair, their team actually put in an exhibition that looked at whether or not Hinemoa could hear the flute of Tutanekai, when the sound was going across the lake, so the level of things that kids are testing these days is pretty remarkable." The team determined that, yes, [ Hinemoa could have heard Tutanekai's koauau] (flute) across the waters of Rotorua, although Anaru said, these days, there was a lot more background noise. "It's not just baking soda volcanoes - there's quite a lot of variety," he said. Anaru said Te Arawa Lakes Trust had always intended to expand the fair beyond Rotorua. This year, students as far afield as Fielding, Tokoroa, Auckland and Whangārei had entered. "We just want to continue to grow it and grow it and grow it, because some of the ideas that these kids have, they are pretty awesome to hear. "It's all about providing a platform for them to showcase their ideas and show it to an audience that is open to soaking up some of that stuff." Mātauranga Māori has assisted larger projects in the Rotorua, such as uwhi - a large harakeke mat that was used to suppress invasive weeds on the lake beds, he said. "There are definitely things that our ancestors - not just the ancestors of Māori, but from around the world - there's ideas that have been shared for thousands of years between different groups. "There's elements of all those ideas that input into modern science, as well as mātauranga, so I do think there are solutions for everything that we've got facing us." Anaru said people just had to be open and willing to adopt some of those ideas, and that was why they wanted to give children from around the North Island a platform to showcase their ideas. Whangamarino School principal Rehua Mihaka (Ngāti Pikiao, Ngāti Rongomai) said they have been involved with the fair for the last two years. Last year, projects among the school students focussed on the water quality of Lake Rotoiti, which was right on the school's doorstep. "This was really good for our tuākana [older class] to actually monitor the mauri - or the life of our waters - how clean it was, how polluted it was and gauge what can we do as kaitiaki to fix te mauri o te wai." At this stage, Mihaka said having a hands-on experience might not mean a lot to the kids, but one day, they might look back, and realise the connection between water quality and health. "Ko te kōrero ka hoatu au ki ngā tamariki, ki te ora te wai ka ora te whenua, ka pērā hoki ki te ora te whenua ka ora te wai, ki te ora te wai me te whenua ka ora te tangata. "It's all about us giving back to our taiao [environment] and those are the sorts of teachings we want our tamariki to come away with." The fair definitely improves the tamariki's understanding of the western sciences, as well as mātauranga Māori, he said. When the kids see mātauranga Māori and western science being treated equally, they get very excited. "Ka tino harikoa ngā tamariki ki te kite i te tauritetanga o ngā mātauranga Māori ki tō ngā mātauranga pūtaiao. "They actually do get excited, when they find those findings within their studies." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
Lost satellite cost NZ extra $3m because of delays
Artist rendering of MethaneSat. Photo: Supplied / Environmental Defence Fund A satellite that has been lost in space cost taxpayers $32 million, $3m more than originally planned, because of delays. The extra cost was to staff a mission control that will now never be used to drive the satellite. Leading scientists say too few questions were asked before deciding to invest in the mission, and red flags were missed. However New Zealand Space Agency and scientists who worked on the mission say New Zealand has gained valuable experience. The Space Agency, which sits inside the Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment (MBIE), says multiple delays to the satellite's launch meant University of Auckland needed more money to keep employing staff at its mission control centre. The agency says $26m of the total was spent on New Zealand-based organisations. Delays to the launch pushed out the date when the university was meant to take over the mission control. The handover was then delayed another six months when the satellite was handed back to its manufacturer to work on unspecified problems. The handover was finally due to happen in late June, when the satellite was lost. The final cost to the government included $6m to the MethaneSAT organisation for flight software and other items, $12m to Rocket Lab for scoping and establishing the mission control, which it ran for the first year after launch, $6m to the University of Auckland to operate the mission control centre after Rocket Lab handed it over, and $6m to Earth Sciences NZ (formerly NIWA) for a science programme to measure farming's emissions methane from space. The final $2m was for MBIE to manage the programme. Earth Sciences NZ says the agricultural science programme already has a wealth of data and will continue as planned. The lead scientist for MethaneSAT says there's very little chance the satellite will be recovered. The mission is a collaboration with the US-based Environmental Defense Fund. Its chief scientist and MethaneSAT mission lead Dr Steven Hamburg said they did not know what caused the satellite to lose power and become unresponsive on 20 June. "There's a very small chance, we were able to observe it by using another satellite to look at it and it does not currently have power. We are working it, we continue to work it, but we have to be realistic the probability of recovery is diminishing." Hamburg said a group was investigating the cause. RNZ has been asking about problems with the satellite since September and was previously told its issues were "teething problems" . Hamburg said the MethaneSAT had been transparent, and the Space Agency said the mission had kept people as informed "as possible." However University of Auckland physics professor Richard Easther said the space craft carrying the methane detector "seems to have had fairly persistent and deep-seated problems, pretty much from launch." He said for most of the year it had been in orbit, it was not functioning properly. Associate Professor Nicholas Rattenbury of the Department of Physics at University of Auckland said he sympathised with those involved in the mission, but the question needed to be asked of whether New Zealand should have taken a closer look "under the hood" before investing in MethaneSAT. Dr Rattenbury questioned who was asking questions on behalf of taxpayers about the mission design, satellite construction and testing before the government committed the money. He said the science sector had "very limited resources" to spend. Space Minister Judith Collins has declined to comment on the loss or whether the public had been adequately informed during the mission. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
