Martin says defamation reforms will happen ‘quickly'
Defamation laws in Ireland will be changed as quickly as the Government can achieve it, the Taoiseach pledged, as he praised a 'first-class' BBC journalist at the centre of Gerry Adams' successful libel action.
Mr Adams took the BBC to court over a 2016 episode of its Spotlight programme, and an accompanying online story, which he said defamed him by alleging he sanctioned the killing of former Sinn Féin official Denis Donaldson, in which he denies any involvement.
Advertisement
Last month, a jury at the High Court in Dublin found in his favour and awarded him €100,000 after determining that was the meaning of words included in the programme and article.
The BBC, which was found by the jury not to have acted in good faith nor in a fair and reasonable way, was also ordered to pay the former Sinn Féin leader's legal costs.
At the time, the director of BBC Northern Ireland Adam Smyth said there were 'profound' implications from the jury's decision.
'As our legal team made clear, if the BBC's case cannot be won under existing Irish defamation law, it's hard to see how anyone's could – and they warned that today's decision could hinder freedom of expression.'
Advertisement
Spotlight reporter Jennifer O'Leary said she had entered the witness box in the trial with 'nothing to hide, only sources to protect and I want to thank them for trusting me'.
The broadcaster's legal team was granted a stay in the payment of the full award as it takes time to consider an appeal.
Asked if he agreed with the BBC's assessment of the case on Thursday, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said: 'I think the defamation laws need to be changed – we're going to change them.'
Mr Martin said the Government would pass the legislation 'as quickly as we can' and paid tribute to Ms O'Leary.
Advertisement
'I think we do need to get it through to create a balanced environment for commentary and for investigative journalism.'
He added: 'Jennifer O'Leary is a first-class journalist.'
Former Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams outside the High Court in Dublin, after the libel action concluded (Brian Lawless/PA)
Among the key provisions in the Defamation Bill highlighted by government are the abolition of juries in High Court defamation actions, which is hoped to reduce delays and legal costs; and of protections against strategic lawsuits, also known as SLAPPs actions, viewed as having a chilling effect on public interest journalism and press freedom.
The draft laws also include a statutory power for the Circuit Court to issue a 'Norwich Pharmacal' order, allowing a digital services provider to identify an anonymous poster of defamatory statements online.
Advertisement
Mr Martin, who took legal action against Google at the High Court for information about who had financed fake ads which claimed he had endorsed specific cryptocurrencies, added: 'We've published heads of the bill, and (Justice Minister Jim) O'Callaghan is going to proceed, we're going to do it in this Government.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
19 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Watch: Minister jeered for claiming most Channel migrants are children and women
A Cabinet minister was jeered by a BBC Question Time audience after claiming that most Channel migrants are 'children, babies and women'. Darren Jones, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, said: 'The majority of the people in these boats are children, babies and women', adding that he felt it was a 'controversial' thing to say. But statistics for the year to March 31 last year from the Migration Observatory showed 75 per cent of those arriving in Britain in small boats were adult men. Separate Home Office data showed that 83.6 per cent of arrivals over the year to this March were men, with 12.5 per cent women and the rest of undetermined gender at the time of the release. When he was jeered, Mr Jones rebutted: 'You're told not to challenge the audience on Question Time – but I'm going to. 'Let me tell you, when you're there on the site seeing these dinghies put together by these organised criminal gangs, which are clearly not safe, and when you see that the majority of the people in these boats are children, babies and women.' Zia Yusuf, the head of Reform UK's 'Doge' cost-saving unit, interrupted Mr Jones to say: 'No, they're not. No, they're not.' The audience applauded when he added: 'North of 90 per cent of them are adult men.' Mr Jones said: 'I'm saying that this is controversial for a reason. Let me tell you the story. 'When there are babies and children, put into that position by human-trafficking gangs, who are coming across in the Channel with skin burns from the oil from those boats mixing with the salt sea water, I would ask any of you to look at those babies and children and say, 'go back to where you came from'. 'It's right that we take a humanitarian response for those people who are put in those positions, and as the Government's policy states, dealing with the criminal gangs who are exploiting vulnerable children to use that route, and then tackling the people who should not be using it, and making sure that they're not staying in this country. 'You can do both of those things without politicising it.' 'The focus is tackling these vile gangs' Downing Street failed to provide any evidence to back up Mr Jones' comments. No 10 said Sir Keir Starmer had confidence in the Chief Secretary to the Treasury. Asked to provide evidence, the Prime Minister's official spokesman said: 'The Government is absolutely focused on tackling these vile smuggling gangs that risk lives in the Channel.' Asked again, he said: 'The focus of the Government is tackling these vile gangs that deal in human misery. That is why our joint work with the French is vital to tackle these gangs.' When it was suggested to him that Mr Jones was effectively gaslighting the nation with his remark, the spokesman said: 'Again, our focus is on tackling the gangs.' Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, said Mr Jones 'is completely out of touch with reality', adding: 'Since 2018, 73 per cent of small boat arrivals have been single adult men. Yet Labour MPs like Jones still push the fairytale that these boats are full of women and babies. It's a dangerous distortion of the truth.' The UN's International Organisation for Migration estimates that a record 82 migrants, including 14 children, died in attempts to cross the Channel last year. But officials believe this is an underestimate, with dozens more reported missing over recent months. At least 12 have died so far this year. Some 14,812 migrants have crossed the Channel so far this year in more than 260 boats, a record high for the first six months of any year since boats started arriving in 2018. Last month, Sir Keir Starmer came under fire after using a speech to declare that the UK risks becoming an 'island of strangers' unless it introduces stricter immigration controls. Several of his own backbenchers, including veteran MP Diane Abbott, expressed outrage at the remarks, for which the Prime Minister appeared to express regret this week. Downing Street set out an immigration white paper last month, which Sir Keir said would see his Government 'take back control of our borders' and bring net migration down. It was seen as a move to combat the rise of Nigel Farage and Reform, which had sweeping gains at local elections last month.
The National
32 minutes ago
- The National
Peter Krykant spoke from Scotland to the world – but work isn't done
Peter Krykant stepped into that void. Peter first caught my attention when he openly dared to break the law by opening a safe consumption space. I was working to end the drug war in the United States at the time, lobbying Congress and the White House, and Peter's actions were galvanising. 'How a Man With a Van Is Challenging UK Drug Policy' was how the New York Times described Peter in a 2020 article. His actions were inspiring. I was reminded of the civil disobedience of the racial justice movement of the 1960s, of the ability to make the law – this seemingly entrenched part of society – look cruel, unjust, and stupid. Peter Krykant in his safe consumption van"I obviously don't want to be arrested, but I'm willing to put myself in that position and I think it'll only reflect badly on the government if that happens," he told the BBC. His bravery was enlivening. It was not just his boldness that caught my attention; it was also the other aspects that drove him. Peter never chose to work on drug policy. He had lived experience. He knew first-hand the stigma that comes with using drugs, where terms like 'junkie' or 'fiend' are common parlance, even in the media. His battle was not just with politicians; but with society itself. He showed us all the value of centring people with lived experience when it comes to changing policy. In a social media post a week ago discussing overdose death, Peter lamented: 'I lost my first family member when I was 15, my uncle. Then my cousin around 17 years ago. Another cousin December 2018, my aunt and uncle's only child, then in September 2021 the youngest death, my cousin who left a 5-year-old daughter. 'I carried his coffin. His daughter standing over the grave asking when daddy would be back, it doesn't get any easier.' (Image: Twitter/Peter Krykant) The politicians feared him because he did not cower. Invites to meet with the first minister or calls with other leaders, attention from the media, a rise in profile, these things can often make someone play the political game of access, plaudits, and incremental change. Not Peter. He continued to speak truth to power and call them out for inaction. He didn't care who he offended or if an invite was rescinded. His was a crusade to save his friends and family. When I started to write about Scottish drug policy, I felt a sense of imposter syndrome, as someone who was not living in Scotland. A good friend connected me with Peter, who was then always there to help guide me. I asked him about what impacted people were asking for, what policy changes he wanted, and included them in my articles. When we finally met at the International Drug Policy Reform Conference in Arizona in October 2023, he was warm, full of banter and good chat, reminding me of friends I miss from back home. READ MORE: Peter Krykant: Scotland must act on drug deaths even if the UK won't Peter and I were not especially close, but in recent months, his social media posts revealed someone who was struggling and there is now guilt that I could have reached out to connect again amid his challenges. I am sure those closer to him feel similar. His legacy is centring impacted voices in the drug policy debate and advancing a saner drug policy in Scotland, notably the opening of a legal safe consumption room in Glasgow. But his fight goes on. Drug deaths are astronomical – and the day after he died one Scottish newspaper led its front page with the headline 'Safe drugs room sparks 175 complaints on needles litter'. Peter would have torn this newspaper apart for its NIMBYism, the stigma, and the desire to lambast a life-saving intervention because of litter complaints when drug deaths have just risen by a third. Peter's legacy is strong, and he will be sorely missed across the globe, but the hard work remains. Michael Collins is a native Glaswegian who lives in Atlanta. He is the former director for national affairs at Drug Policy Alliance.
BreakingNews.ie
32 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Irish bishops accuse Israeli government of ‘genocidal actions' in Gaza
Irish bishops have accused the Israeli government of 'genocidal actions' and 'ethnic cleansing' in the Gaza Strip. The Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference called for arms supplies to Israel to be 'cut off' and urged parishioners to lobby their local politicians. Advertisement It said that during the month of June, all parishes on the island of Ireland are being asked to express their solidarity with the suffering of Palestinians. 'In Gaza people are starving and adequate aid is being denied; it seems clear that famine is being used as a weapon of war. Already over 600,000 Palestinians have been displaced,' it said. 'The evidence points to a staged strategy of ethnic cleansing aimed at removing the Palestinian people from their homes and their homeland. 'It is becoming increasingly clear to people on the ground that these are genocidal actions sanctioned by the Government of Israel.' Advertisement Israel's 20-month military campaign in Gaza has killed nearly 55,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza's health ministry. The military operation has destroyed vast areas of Gaza and displaced around 90% of its population, often multiple times over. A two-and-a-half-month blockade imposed by Israel when it ended a ceasefire with Hamas have raised fears of famine and a new Israeli and US-backed aid system has been marred by chaos and violence. 'What is happening in Gaza – and the West Bank – is the death of tens of thousands of non-combatants, many of them women and children,' the Irish bishops said. Advertisement 'This is unconscionable and disproportionate. It is immoral for world leaders to stand by inactively in the face of this outrageous tragedy for humanity.' The bishops urged people to lobby their political representatives, support humanitarian aid and to pray for the conflict to end. It added: 'There is an urgent need for the international community to intervene, cut off arms supplies and bring the carnage to an end. 'This will call for courage on the part of leaders. Examples of courage are being given every day by heroic doctors, nurses and aid workers risking their lives in service of the wounded and those who have been displaced.' Advertisement The statement, issued on Friday, quoted Pope Leo XIV from a general audience he gave on May 28th, where he said parents in the Gaza Strip 'clutch the lifeless bodies of children and who are continually forced to move in search of a little food and safer shelter from bombing'. 'I renew my appeal to the leaders: ceasefire, release all hostages, fully respect humanitarian law.' Israel launched its military operation in Gaza after Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 hostages on October 7th, 2023. The militants still hold 55 hostages — less than half of them believed to be alive — after more than half the captives were released during ceasefires or other deals. Advertisement
