Montana lawmakers reject proposed ban on mRNA vaccines
Lalain Reyeg administers a COVID-19 booster vaccine and an influenza vaccine to Army veteran Gary Nasakaitis at the Edward Hines Jr. VA Hospital on Sept. 24, 2021 in Hines, Illinois. (Photo by)
The Montana House of Representatives on Wednesday voted overwhelmingly against House Bill 371, a measure that would have banned mRNA vaccines — used primarily in COVID-19 vaccines and booster shots — and made it a misdemeanor to administer the shots.
Introduced by Greg Kmetz, R-Miles City, the contentious bill revealed deep-held beliefs by some lawmakers about the safety and efficacy of the vaccine technology that became common during the global coronavirus pandemic.
Currently, the Food and Drug Administration has approved mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines and boosters from Moderna and Pfizer. The FDA has also approved a Moderna mRNA vaccine for respiratory syncytial virus.
Kmetz said he became politically active during the pandemic, starting when then-Gov. Steve Bullock, a Democrat, ordered non-essential businesses to temporarily close down. He said his wife lost her job in the healthcare field for not getting vaccinated, and a friend's grandson was hospitalized for one of the rare side effects attributed to the COVID-19 vaccines.
'If an individual is told a product will prevent them from getting sick, and yet the actual outcome of taking the product does not result in that effect, then the product is a scam,' Kmetz said. 'Another thing that really bothers me is all vaccine manufacturers are 100% free from all liability … We are talking about a real bad product, and people have absolutely no recourse for damage.'
Rep. Brian Close, D-Bozeman, gave his own story in opposition to the bill. Close said he has an autoimmune disease, and diabetes, and if he got COVID-19, he would be at high risk for ending up on a ventilator or dying.
'Every six months I get my COVID booster so I can stand here and serve my constituents and my family,' Close said. 'There's thousands of people in Montana with compromised immune systems or who can't afford to travel out of state to get a COVID vaccine.'
Rep. Melody Cunningham, a Missoula Democrat, shared her experience working in hospitals and hospice care during the pandemic and the 'tsunami of death' she witnessed before a vaccine was available to the public. She also criticized criminalizing what is a life-saving treatment, and removing individual freedom for healthcare officials and individuals to make their own informed decisions.
Additional proponents to the bill claimed the COVID-19 vaccines had led to many fatalities and increases in other conditions such as cancer and myocarditis, many using personal anecdotes to illustrate their points.
But, Rep. John Fitzpatrick, R-Anaconda, said he opposed the legislation on three grounds — 'history, Montana legacy, and numbers.'
He said advancements in medical treatments during the last hundred years were key in increasing life expectancy and overall population health in America. He also pointed to two people from Montana who were key in helping develop vaccine technology nearly a century ago.
One, Maurice Hilleman, helped develop vaccines for meningitis and pneumonia, measles, mumps, hepatitis A and B and more. Millions of lives each year are saved because of the work Hilleman, a Montana State University graduate, accomplished, Fitzpatrick said.
But, Fitzpatrick's main reason to oppose the bill was rooted in hard numbers.
While he acknowledged that proponents talked about side effects from the vaccine and alleged increases in fatalities or other diseases, those numbers pale in comparison to the hundreds of millions of vaccine doses administered in the U.S., he said.
According to the World Health Organization, 67% of global citizens have received at least one COVID-19 vaccine. In the United States, more than 670 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccine have been administered, more than 95% of which were mRNA-based vaccines.
'Covid is 390 times more deadly than the vaccine,' he said. 'The purpose we come for in this building is to craft public policy for the welfare of our constituents. And we're being asked to adopt a public policy that promotes what? It promotes death.
'This is bad policy, this bill needs to be parked in the red parking lot.'.
House lawmakers voted against the bill 34-66.
Kmetz has another bill, House Bill 418, which would criminalize mRNA vaccine use in animals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Advocates denounce immigration enforcement raid at Southern New Mexico dairy
Advocates on Monday denounced a recent immigration enforcement raid carried out by Homeland Security Investigations agents that led to the arrests of 11 workers at a southeastern New Mexico dairy farm. María Romano, coordinator of the Lea County office of the New Mexico worker and immigrant rights organization Somos Un Pueblo Unido, said the raid in Lovington — the first of her knowledge in the area — has stoked fear among immigrant communities as tensions surrounding immigration enforcement spike nationwide. "People are sad. They're angry. But more than anything, they're scared," Romano said in an interview in Spanish. In a June 4 post on X, formerly Twitter, the El Paso field office of Homeland Security Investigations — the federal law enforcement agency housed within U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement — announced agents had arrested 11 "illegal aliens for violations of fraud & misuse of visas, permits & other documents" during a raid at Outlook Dairy in Lovington. ICE's Facebook page noted the raid in a post Saturday, adding, "Criminal employers who hire illegal workers put other employees and our communities at risk. Plus, they undercut their competition by exploiting illegal alien labor, making it harder for legitimate American businesses to stay afloat." Outlook Dairy manager Isaak Bos declined to comment on the raid when contacted by The New Mexican on Monday. He told the Albuquerque Journal the workers provided false paperwork. Of the 11 people arrested during the raid, Romano said 10 were from Guatemala and one was from Mexico. While she doesn't know where the Guatemalans are currently, she said, she believes the Mexican worker is now back in Mexico. ICE did not immediately respond to The New Mexican's request for more information on the raid, including the location of the 11 people arrested. The Lovington raid and Romano's response to it come amid rising tensions between federal immigration enforcement and immigrant communities across the U.S. Thousands of protesters took to the streets in Los Angeles over the weekend to denounce the Trump administration's immigration crackdown. President Donald Trump deployed hundreds of National Guard troops to quell the demonstrations, while California Gov. Gavin Newsom announced plans to sue the president over the move, calling it an "unmistakable step toward authoritarianism" in a social media post Monday. U.S. Rep. Gabe Vasquez, a Democrat who represents much of the southern half of the state, on Monday advocated for the Trump administration to "reverse course to restore peace" and maintain focus on reforming the "broken" immigration system. "Raiding workplaces, turning federal agents and the military against American citizens, and transforming our streets into war zones is not how we enforce our immigration laws," Vasquez said in a statement. He added, "We need real immigration reform rooted in due process, public safety, and compassion, not inflamed tensions and conflicts in the street.' In response to the Lovington raid, Somos Un Pueblo Unido issued a news release calling on local and state officials to "push for humane immigration laws" while demanding transparency from ICE and protecting "the rights of all New Mexicans, regardless of immigration status." The organization also provides materials and organizes workshops to ensure immigrants know — and know how to exercise — their civil rights. It's something Romano encourages people to do. "We've spent many years telling people: 'Understand your rights. Learn your rights. Even if you're undocumented, you have rights,' " she said. Romano added, "We have to be very well-informed about our rights and avoid any missteps — because we already know where we'll end up."
Indianapolis Star
an hour ago
- Indianapolis Star
Woman accusing Hogsett aide of sexual harassment dragged out of Indianapolis council meeting
One of three women who has alleged she was sexually harassed and abused by a former top aide to Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett was forcefully removed from the June 9 Indianapolis City-County Council meeting by sheriff's deputies as she tried to relay her concerns to council members. Lauren Roberts said she took time off work and crowdfunded to raise money for a flight from her home in Denver to Indianapolis, where she lived while working for Hogsett's mayoral campaign in 2014 and 2015, so she could speak to council members. After minutes of interruptions and a spat with Council President Vop Osili about a two-minute time limit, Osili ordered a sheriff's deputy to escort Roberts out of the council chambers when she refused to stop talking. Yelling at the deputy to stop touching her, Roberts was dragged forcefully out of the council meeting while dozens of her supporters chanted, "Shame!" The encounter overshadowed a meeting where the council ultimately voted not to approve the final payment to the law firm responsible for investigating the Hogsett administration's handling of the alleged abuse. Many councilors are questioning why the final report omitted mentions of late-night texts and messages that the mayor sent Roberts and another woman whose complaints launched the investigation. Roberts is one of two women who alleges she was sexually harassed or assaulted by top Hogsett aide Thomas Cook and received messages from the mayor that she said made her uncomfortable. Video captured at the meeting by reporters also depicts two sheriff's deputies pushing back Roberts' supporters, including Democratic strategist Elise Shrock, who can be heard telling a deputy to stop touching her breasts as he tries to remove her and others from the meeting who surrounded Roberts to protect her. One deputy told Roberts to "walk like a lady" before grabbing her to remove her from the room. "Do you have a daughter?" Roberts asked the deputy as he approached her. Moments later, four deputies surrounded Roberts and pushed her out of the chambers. Several councilors said after the incident they were disturbed by Roberts' removal and took issue with Osili's strict adherence to the time limit for public comments, considering the severity of Roberts' allegations. "I've never seen anybody taken out like that," said longtime Democrat Frank Mascari, who was first elected in 2011. "I really feel terrible she was taken out that way." Democrat Jared Evans said he was "disgusted at what just transpired." "This is a local issue that people are protesting," Evans said. "Why they are speaking is because they have not had an outlet with which to speak to this council." Just before the meeting, council Democrats released a statement criticizing Hogsett's leadership and calling for several reforms, including dissolving the city's human resources department and appointing an inspector-general. But the Democratic caucus of 18 members stopped short of saying Hogsett should resign, a belief voiced by two councilors — Democrat Andrew Nielsen and Democratic socialist Jesse Brown — and dozens of people who attended the June 9 council meeting. "Public trust is a sacred obligation continuously earned through principled moral leadership and responsible governance," the statement from the council's Democratic caucus said. "The mayor's past and recent conduct has compromised that trust and weakened the moral authority of the office. His actions are inconsistent with the ethical expectations we hold for ourselves and one another as stewards of this great city's future." 'We won't allow facts to be buried': Hogsett investigative report omissions raise concerns, Republicans call for additional details An outside law firm's investigative report, presented to the City-County Council's investigative committee May 29, found that Hogsett's administration acted within the law during investigations of Cook's alleged misconduct. Three women told IndyStar that Cook sexually harassed them while he was their supervisor, and one said that Cook sexually assaulted her. The report compiled by the Chicago-based law firm Fisher Phillips raised concerns about why Cook was allowed to stay on as the mayor's chief of staff for 68 days following a 2020 city investigation that found Cook had violated city policy. Days later, an IndyStar story raised questions about factual contradictions in the law firm's probe and the omission of suggestive late-night texts that Hogsett sent two of Cook's alleged victims, Caroline Ellert and Roberts. All but one councilor — Democrat Ron Gibson, who released a statement before the meeting backing the law firm's report and the mayor's leadership — ultimately voted Monday night to postpone a vote on the additional $300,000 owed to Fisher Phillips for the $450,000 investigation. "Fisher Phillips did exactly what they were hired to do: they reviewed all evidence provided within the scope of the investigative committee's authority and authored a report that included all the information they deemed relevant given their significant expertise," Gibson said in a statement. "That report was clear: Mayor Hogsett followed all applicable law and policy whenever an issue was reported to him." The council's Administrative and Finance Committee will hear public comment on the report in its next hearing on June 17 at 5:30 p.m. A few council members vowed to listen to the women's testimony during that upcoming committee meeting. "I promise, whoever the victims are, they can speak 10, 15, 20 minutes," Mascari said. The council Democrats said they would soon introduce a proposal that would, among other changes, establish an independent human resources board to replace the city's current human resources division and make the Office of Equal Opportunity an independent agency. They also called to update all anti-harassment, anti-discrimination, retaliation and non-fraternization policies. Dozens of people came to the meeting to call for Hogsett's resignation, saying his leadership and interactions with young women employees show that he presides over a problematic workplace culture. Maggie Adams-McBride, a former Hogsett administration employee who recently resigned after she said her harassment complaint against a mayoral appointee was mishandled, called on the mayor to resign, and for voters to hold Osili accountable at the ballot box for silencing Roberts. Wearing a white T-shirt with the words "Bye Hogsett" drawn with black marker, near east side resident Brianna Dines said she's believed the mayor should resign since IndyStar first reported the allegations against Cook in July 2024. Megan Alderman, a north side resident who also believes Hogsett should resign, said the mayor's texts asking if Roberts' boyfriend knew how "feisty" she is sent a chill down her spine. The messages remind her of past instances of sexual harassment she says she has experienced. "There was something so inappropriate, something so deeply wrong," Alderman said. Lawrence City Councilor Kristine Krone, who campaigned for Hogsett in 2023 before learning of the allegations against Cook, said the mayor should have pushed out his top aide as soon as an internal 2020 investigation discovered his alleged misconduct. Now, she said, Hogsett should resign so the city can work to restore its ethical standards. "It's not just politics. It's not just stupid stuff that goes on at work that you talk about at the water cooler," Krone said. "You are the leader of our city and you work for us. He's got to understand that the decisions that he makes (reflect on) who we are as a city."
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Indicted Charlotte councilwoman Tiawana Brown picks up 2 challengers in election
Tiawana Brown, a Charlotte City Council member indicted on wire fraud charges, will face at least two challengers with political experience if she runs for reelection this year. The first-term Democrat was indicted alongside her two adult daughters in May on charges of wire fraud conspiracy and wire fraud. They're accused by Charlotte's U.S. attorney of filing false applications for federal pandemic relief loans and spending loan money on personal expenses, including a lavish birthday party for Brown. The crimes allegedly occurred before Brown joined the council. All three pleaded not guilty in their first court appearance. Brown, who represents west Charlotte's District 3, has pledged to stay in office and run for reelection. She's eligible to run 'until convicted of a felony,' Mecklenburg County Board of Elections spokeswoman Kristin Mavromatis previously told The Charlotte Observer. An indictment is not proof of guilt, and Brown has not yet received a trial. But weeks before candidate filing officially opens, a pair of notable candidates have already declared their intentions to run: former Elizabeth City Councilman Montravias King and community activist Joi Mayo. Charlotte's primaries are scheduled for Sept. 9. In the heavily Democratic District 3, the winner of that primary will carry a significant advantage into November's general election. Mayo confirmed to the Observer she will run in the Democratic primary for District 3. She's also launched a campaign website and social media. While it will be her first time campaigning for public office, she's been an active organizer in southwest Charlotte for years. A Virginia native, Mayo moved to Charlotte in 2012 for a Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools teaching job after earning degrees from Elon University and the College of Charleston. She became a homeowners association president in the Nations Ford area and was elected president of the Southwest Area Neighborhood Coalition in 2019. Mayo left teaching in 2022 to work full-time for nonprofits. She founded Transforming Nations Ford in 2024 to work on neighborhood beautification and historic preservation. The group also advocates for responsible growth and investments in parks and recreation, transit and public safety. Her platform includes supporting public safety initiatives such as SAFE Charlotte and Alternatives to Violence; increasing permanent affordable housing; and funding workforce development. Despite the high-profile nature of Brown's indictment, Mayo said the news was 'not necessarily' the driving force behind her decision to run for the District 3 seat. She was mainly spurred, she said, by a desire to increase community engagement within city government. 'I'm just excited to get out there,' she told the Observer. King's statement announcing his campaign for the district also didn't directly reference Brown's indictment. The announcement said he 'enters the race with a deep commitment to smart growth, public safety and government transparency in one of the city's fastest-growing districts.' King is best known for his 2013 for the Elizabeth City City Council while a student at Elizabeth City State University. He made national news when his eligibility for the race was challenged due to his on-campus address. King ultimately was ruled eligible and won a council seat. He currently works as a nonprofit executive and renewable energy consultant, and he previously worked as a teacher and legislative assistant for Democrats in the North Carolina legislature. On his campaign website, King lists a platform focused on equitable growth, public safety, sustainability and transparent government. 'District 3 is changing fast. We need to make sure that development doesn't outpace infrastructure, that public safety keeps up with growth, and that residents have a voice in the decisions shaping their neighborhoods,' he said in his campaign announcement. The official candidate filing window for the 2025 municipal elections runs from July 7 to July 18. Brown won an open three-person Democratic primary in 2023 before defeating Republican James Harrison Bowers by a margin of 78.6% to 21.2% in the general election to secure her first term.
