DA rejects Simelane, Nkabane departmental budgets
This after the party this week voted against budgets of the departments of human settlements and higher education led by Thembi Simelane-Nkadimeng and Nobuhle Nkabane respectively.
This decision was taken as a direct response to President Cyril Ramaphosa axing trade and industry deputy minister Andrew Whitfield, of the DA, last week for defying his order that none of the members of his executive were allowed to go to the US at the height of the diplomatic tensions between the two countries.
The DA in response argued that Ramaphosa had been harsh on Whitfield and that it was not acceptable that he fired him for such a minor transgression while he still kept Simelane and Nkabane in his cabinet.
Unlike Whitfield, the DA argued, Simelane was accused of corruption and Nkabane stood accused of lying to parliament. Instead of dealing with the two ministers who were facing serious allegations, Ramaphosa decided to axe Whitfield for going on a trip without getting permission, the DA argued.
DA MP Luyolo Mphithi on Wednesday said his party was voting against Simelane's budget vote because of the corruption allegations she was facing.
Mphithi said the DA was concerned that instead of firing Simelane, Ramaphosa had moved her from the department of justice to human settlements.
'You'd think that the response to this that the president would have shown minister Simelane the door, he did not. He asked for the report that he stayed with for three months,' said Mphithi. 'And even though the DA sustained pressure asking the president to act, he lacked courage to act and instead decided to dump minister Simelane at human settlements, one of the most important departments for South Africans.'
'It seems that this president does not take an issue with the fact that a person accused of corruption sits in his cabinet and will have to look after a budget of R30bn that is set aside for South Africans,' he said.
Ideally, Mphithi said, the DA would not have a problem with voting for the department of human settlements' budget as it relates to people's housing and security but they could not do it because of the allegations faced by Simelane.
'The DA will always support the granting of funds to house the vulnerable at the same time fast-tracking jobs and growth to give many more South Africans the dignity of being able to buy and own their own houses,' he said. 'And though this budget and the department have many challenges under normal circumstances it would be supported. However, we sit with a minister who faces corruption allegations who has not been accountable to the South African public. And it is because of this we struggle support this particular budget.'
Mphithi and the MK Party's Thulani Gumede raised several issues with the human settlements budget presented by Simelane, saying it was not dealing with some of the key issues faced by South Africans in the sector.
'A critical examination reveals a fundamental flaw, an overall real decline in the department's budget. None of its five main programmes demonstrates above-inflation increases,' said Gumede.
'This systemic underfunding of human settlements initiatives will inevitably worsen existing backlogs and impair the progressive realisation of adequate housing.'
He said his party could not vote for as it would mean they accepted the decrease in allocation.
'I asserted during the committee meeting last week and I reiterate now that this draft budget must be rejected. It's real term decline across key programmes particularly in integrated human settlements and informal settlements upgrading directly contradicts the constitutional obligation to provide adequate housing and the strategic goals of the national development plans,' he said.
'Accepting this budget will constitute a retreat from addressing deeply entrenched structural inequalities and the pressing needs of the vulnerable communities for basic services and dignified living conditions.'
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
30 minutes ago
- Mail & Guardian
Former deputy president David 'The Cat' Mabuza has died
Former deputy president David Mabuza. (Delwyn Verasamy/M&G) Former deputy president The cause of the death of Mabuza, who served as the country's deputy president from February 2018 to February 2023, was not immediately clear. Mbalula said Mabuza had dedicated his life to the service of the people of South Africa from his days in the struggle against apartheid to his leadership as premier of Mpumalanga and later as deputy president. 'He was a committed cadre who carried the values of unity, discipline, and transformation,' he said. 'On behalf of the African National Congress, we extend our heartfelt condolences to his family, friends, comrades and the people of South Africa. We have lost a patriot, a freedom fighter, and a leader who served with humility and conviction. 'May his soul rest in peace, and may we honour his legacy by continuing the work of building a united, non-racial, non-sexist, democratic, and prosperous South Africa.'
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Nobuhle Nkabane stands firm against opposition criticism of higher education budget
Higher Education Minister Nobuhle Nkabane says she will not dignify direct attacks at her other than focus on the task at hand of serving the people of South Africa. Image: Facebook Higher Education Minister Nobuhle Nkabane on Thursday said she would not dignify the attacks levelled against her when the DA and some opposition parties rejected her department's budget. Nkabane presented her department's budget for the 2025/26 financial year in the National Assembly two days after doing so in the National Council of Provinces, where the DA, MK Party, and the EFF rejected it. The department has been allocated R142.4 billion and is set to increase at an average annual rate of 4.4% to R150 billion in the next financial year and R158 billion in 2027/28. 'This growth is not sufficient to meet growing demands for additional resources,' she said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ The Technical and Vocational Education and Training colleges have been allocated R14 billion, and both the Sector Education and Training Authorities and the National Skills Fund have a combined R26 billion. The National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) is allocated R48.7 billion, and its allocation will increase to R51 billion next year and R53.4 billion in 2027. Nkabane said the allocation was not sufficient to meet the growing demand for access to higher education. 'We continue to seek efficient ways of allocating limited resources to ensure that no deserving learner is left behind.' She also said NSFAS remained committed to implementing a comprehensive student funding model for higher education to address the needs of the 'missing middle'. 'The National Skills Fund has set aside R3 billion over a three-year period.' Nkabane said the allocation for university education increased from R91.7 billion to R96 billion, with a R1.4 billion deficit on the universities' budget. 'We continue to work with National Treasury to find a sustainable adjustment to the universities' budget,' she said. Tebogo Letsie, ANC MP and chairperson of the Higher Education Portfolio Committee, said they would ensure that the department, NSFAS, and universities were accountable. 'We will ensure public resources are used efficiently, effectively, and transparently to deliver the ANC vision,' he said. Letsie took a swipe at the DA for its stance to reject the department's budget because they don't believe Nkabane should be the minister. 'When you vote in 2026, remember them, they will be saying your poor child must not go to school and university because they have a problem with the minister,' he added. MK Party MP Mnqobi Msezane said they rejected the budget because they don't have confidence in the Ministry and Director-General Nkosinathi Sishi, who they claimed faced allegations of gross misconduct, fraud, and corruption, and was not suspended or investigated by Nkabane. 'We don't have confidence in the Ministry and the department to oversee this budget,' Msezane said. DA MP Matlhodi Maseko said the higher education system was being systematically eroded by incompetence, deception, and the unchecked abuse of power in the system. 'The minister has repeatedly given conflicting representations to this House,' she said in reference to the SETA boards' chairperson appointment scandal and listed other challenges in the department under Nkabane's watch. Maseko said President Cyril Ramaphosa should remove Nkabane without delay. 'The future of our youth depends on strong, ethical, caring leadership, and until there is accountability at the very top, every rand in this budget will be another drop in a leaking bucket,' she said. EFF's Sihle Lonzi accused the DA of cherry picking which budget to support and also criticised it for discovering corruption in the department after former deputy minister Andrew Whitfield was fired from the executive. However, Lonzi said his party would not support the budget after presenting a seven-point plan to rescue the department. 'We have no certainty that the R142 billion is going to be used correctly,' he said.
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Allowing GNU to dictate foreign policy is ‘micro-management'
Minister Ronald Lamola said he is following his commitment to the Constitution of South Africa by implementing foreign policy objectives. South Africa's foreign policy is dictated by several existing frameworks and not the whims of parties within the government of national unity (GNU). This was the sentiment relayed by Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Ronald Lamola in the build-up to his department's budget speech on Thursday. GNU members have been critical of South Africa's stance on international issues, accusing the ANC of inserting its own bias into foreign relations. 'Follow procedure' A Freedom Front Plus (FF+) delegation this week returned from the United States, and a DA parliamentarian earlier this year called for an overhaul of the nation's foreign policy. Lamola stressed that his department's work was bound by the African Union's Agenda 2063, South Africa's framework document on national interest, the Foreign Services Act, and the Constitution of South Africa. He stated that the ANC, as the previous majority leader in parliament, followed all required paths of participation and consultation in formulating and enacting the current policies. The minister urged any parliamentarian or party that wished to change the mandate of his department to follow parliamentary procedure. 'If there is any GNU partner that wants a review or consultation on the foreign policy, they can initiate the process,' said Lamola. 'We are implementing the policy perspective of the South African government, so there is no basis for anyone to complain because we are not out of line,' he explained. GNU opposition FF+ leader Corner Mulder earlier this week called President Cyril Ramaphosa's meeting with US President Donald Trump a 'failure', saying their visit had a different tone to the star-studded visit in May. Mulder said his delegation was told that in order to better diplomatic ties with the US, the ANC needed to denounce the 'kill the boer' chant. Additionally, farm attacks needed to be declared a priority crime, land expropriation without compensation must be scrapped, and US companies must be exempt from employment equity laws. In the same month as Ramaphosa's visit, DA spokesperson on International Relations Emma Powell called for a 'consensus-based' review of how South Africa portrayed itself on the international stage. 'In light of the critical need to grow our economy and create jobs, South Africa's foreign policy must now be driven by an unwavering commitment to our country's domestic growth, rather than being dictated by the ANC's historical and fraternal allegiances,' Powell stated. 'Micro-management' Lamola said they would not promote policy positions put forward by GNU members simply because they had earned a seat at the collective governance table. 'There is no political party that, just on the basis that they are a member of the GNU, can impose its policies on South Africans. 'It's shocking that they would want us to implement what is not in the law, but implement what [they] themselves as political parties want us to do. That is not in the interest of South Africans,' Lamola said. He added that all GNU members had agreed to uphold the Constitution of South Africa and existing policies, and that allowing any one member to dictate policy changes would be against the spirit of the GNU's statement of intent. 'It's not practically possible, but that also becomes micro-management. In all our international platforms we go to, we seek a mandate from Cabinet [first].' US participation in G20 Lamola was asked about the US' participation in the G20 summit to be held in Johannesburg in November, with the minister urging US officials to play a constructive role in the gathering. He said the G20 was a consensus-based organisation and that the US had a pivotal role in shaping the G20's policies. 'It is important they make contributions towards the outcomes document…and work towards a consolidated final declaration,' 'It would be great if the US participates so that the outcome is embraced by all member countries,' said Lamola. NOW READ: FF Plus claims White House officials want ANC to publicly denounce 'Kill the Boer' chant
