Scottish Government accused of undermining Ardrossan harbour
The Scottish Government said earlier this year it was considering renationalising the harbour to ensure Ardrossan remains the mainland port for Arran.
Read More:
However, former Labour MP for Cunninghame North - now largely North Ayrshire and Arran - Brian Wilson has raised concerns after submitting a Freedom of Information request.
The Herald columnist asked for communications concerning Ardrossan between transport secretary Fiona Hyslop and (Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd).
Wilson wrote: "One interesting line had either slipped through the net or been left in deliberately, in which the chief executive of CMAL, Kevin Hobbs, wrote, the week following Ms Hyslop's instruction: 'We do not believe and have expressly stated that resilience at Ardrossan (given the entrance through the roundheads and turn) will never be as resilient as Troon given the open sea approach'.
"In other words, the chief executive of CMAL could hardly have been clearer that they have no interest in pursuing what, in public, has been their obligation and the Scottish Government's aim. So the question now is whether Ms Hyslop's 'instruction' is ever intended to prevail?
"I make no claim to nautical expertise but that is not the issue at stake. The real question is whether, consistent with Mr Hobbs' comments, CMAL and Transport Scotland have been (and still are) working to ensure that Ardrossan never again will be the gateway port for Arran.
"If that is the case – as I believe it is – the people of Arran and Ardrossan have, for the past decade, been cynically and cruelly deceived. To that, I object strongly – and call for an inquiry into the full circumstances, without evasions or redactions."
Under current regulations, the Scottish Government does not have the power to force a sale of the Ardrossan harbour.
It's understood negotiations are ongoing between CMAL and Peel Ports over a potential deal.
A Transport Scotland spokesperson said: 'This Government is fully committed to Ardrossan serving the Arran route and to investing in the harbour to ensure that the service is fit for the future.
'We want to see progress just as much as local campaigners do. However, as was explained to them when they met recently with CMAL, Transport Scotland and CalMac, a timeline can only be reasonably established and published should actual purchase and transfer of control of the port be successful.
'It is wholly appropriate that CMAL leads on the Ardrossan negotiations. Should ownership transfer be successful, CMAL would be the asset owner and responsible for taking forward any development works at Ardrossan. As owners of 26 ports and harbours across Scotland, they also bring essential experience to these complex discussions.
'We will of course update Parliament and the local community once there is progress and an outcome to report, however, CMAL and Peel Ports need time and space to undertake and conclude negotiations.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
34 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Ferries Scotland: SNP told to hand Ferguson Marine 'distinguished future' with urgent investment
A cross-party Holyrood committee has published a damning report into the ferries saga and the future of Ferguson Marine. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... SNP ministers have been told to bring forward urgent investment to give the publicly-owned Ferguson Marine shipyard a 'distinguished and positive future'. The plea comes from a cross-party committee of MSPs that has highlighted multiple and repeated failings at the Port Glasgow site. These cited failings include leadership and board instability, inadequate internal audits, serious weaknesses in contractor oversight, and governance failures around exit packages for senior staff. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Work on the MV Glen Rosa is not now expected to be completed until spring next year (Picture: Jeff J Mitchell) | Getty Images These issues, together with the delays and huge cost overruns associated with the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa vessels, have caused significant reputational damage to the yard. Holyrood's Public Audit Committee now said it believed urgent investment was needed to make sure it could be competitive once again. During the committee's consideration, Ferguson Marine announced the cost of the MV Glen Rosa had risen to £185 million and was delayed once more, this time until early 2026. The two ships, which were meant to be delivered in 2018, will now cost an estimated £460m – up from the original price tag of £97m. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The committee has expressed its serious concern over the increased cost and further delay to the ferry and has now called on the Scottish Government to give urgent clarification about where the additional funds are coming from. The new report also notes the yard does not have any further orders lined up beyond its existing contract to deliver on the MV Glen Rosa. Today's report also warns the organisation has failed to meet the standards expected of a publicly funded body. The committee has called on the Scottish Government to urgently improve its oversight to address some of the long-standing weaknesses at the yard. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Committee convener Richard Leonard said: 'It is clear to the Public Audit Committee that there has been a long-standing weakness in the management, governance and financial sustainability of this yard. That there are currently no further orders raises significant concerns for us about the future of the last commercial shipyard on the Clyde and its workforce. Labour MSP Richard Leonard 'This is a state-owned yard and the Scottish Government must do more to ensure that not only is its future secure, but that the MV Glen Rosa can be delivered as soon as possible. There has to be better oversight and governance of the work that is ongoing.' He added: 'There is no doubt that the yard has suffered significant reputational damage and that the workers at Ferguson Marine deserve better, the communities waiting for a new ferry deserve better and the people of Scotland deserve better. 'But it doesn't have to be this way. Our committee believes that the yard can once again be competitive. There is no shortage of potential work. With investment, and better oversight, this yard, which has a distinctive and proud history, can have a distinguished and positive future.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Louise Gilmour, GMB Scotland secretary, said workers must be allowed to restore their reputation, which the union claimed had been unfairly damaged by delays and overspends affecting the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa. GMB Scotland secretary Louise Gilmour | Andrew Cawley She said: 'People have short memories, but, before these misjudged and ill-planned contracts, this yard successfully built a third of CalMac's current fleet, including the original Lord of the Isles. 'Workers must now be given the chance to restore what was a worldwide reputation for excellence that has been damaged through no fault of their own. Before being turned into a political football, they delivered a steady stream of ferries serving Scotland's islands and must be allowed to do so again.' A Scottish Government spokesperson said the 'decision to take Ferguson Marine into public ownership saved the last commercial shipyard on the Clyde'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'We are ensuring the long-term future of the yard and the workforce and will invest up to £14.2 million in the yard over the next two years in order to help it modernise and secure future business,' the spokespersons said. "Scottish ministers expressed their disappointment and frustration to the board of FMPG at the confirmation of a further delay and increased estimated cost to deliver the Glen Rosa. They also made it clear to the yard's leadership that it must take immediate and sustained action to restore trust, enforce delivery discipline, and bring the project under control.
The Herald Scotland
37 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Urgent investment needed to secure future of Ferguson Marine
It has faced difficulties in delivering two new ferries, Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa, both of which are late and over-budget, and recently missed out on a £175m contract to build seven new ferries of CalMac. The yard has no further contracts lined up after it delivers Glen Rosa, now due in early 2026, and an audit published in December 2024 highlighted "a material risk and uncertainty over FMPG's ability to continue as a going concern, for at least 12 months from the date of signing the accounts". Read More: Having considered that audit, Holyrood's cross-party Public Audit Committee has released its report into the future of Ferguson Marine. The committee comprised convenor Richard Leonard (Scottish Labour), deputy convener Jamie Greene (Scottish Liberal Democrats), Colin Beattie (SNP), Graham Simpson (Scottish Conservatives), and Stuart McMillan (SNP). It found "multiple and repeated failings, including leadership and board instability, inadequate internal audit, serious weakness in contractor oversight and governance failures around exit packages for senior staff", with trade union involvement in decision-making minimal and considered inadequate. Frequent changes among senior management had an adverse effect on governance, while weak internal controls and lack of internal audit until recently contributed to poor oversight. In addition, payments approved to a contractor and exit packages for senior executives bypassed Scottish Government approval. The report highlighted an incident in which Ferguson Marine was hit with a £48,000 tax bill from HMRC after entering into a contractor payment arrangement for a secondee from CMAL (Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited) who was initially seconded to FMPG, later moved to FMPG's payroll, then - without proper board approval - switched to being paid as a self-employed contractor. The committee expressed serious concerns over the yard's viability as a going concern going forward, saying considerable investment will be needed to safeguard its future. It urged the Scottish Government and Ferguson marine to finalise and publish a credible long-term business plan to secure sustainable work; invest in modernisation to make the yard more competitive; strengthen governance structures and ensure future funding and investment decisions are be subject to rigorous value-for-money tests and proper approval. Committee Convener Richard Leonard MSP said: 'It is clear to the Public Audit Committee that there has been a long standing weakness in the management, governance and financial sustainability of this yard. That there are currently no further orders raises significant concerns for us about the future of the last commercial shipyard on the Clyde and its workforce. 'This is a state-owned yard and the Scottish Government must do more to ensure that not only is its future secure, but that the MV Glen Rosa can be delivered as soon as possible. There has to be better oversight and governance of the work that is ongoing. 'There is no doubt that the yard has suffered significant reputational damage and that the workers at Ferguson Marine deserve better, the communities waiting for a new ferry deserve better and the people of Scotland deserve better. 'But it doesn't have to be this way. Our Committee believes that the yard can once again be competitive. There is no shortage of potential work. With investment, and better oversight, this yard which has a distinctive and proud history can have a distinguished and positive future.' Responding to the committee's report, GMB Scotland, the biggest union at Ferguson Marine, echoed calls for investment and the direct award of contracts, including the replacement for Lord of the Isles, to the Port Glasgow yard. Louise Gilmour, GMB Scotland secretary, said workers must be allowed to restore a world-class reputation unfairly damaged by delays and overspends affecting the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa. She said: 'People have short memories but, before these misjudged and ill-planned contracts, this yard successfully built a third of CalMac's current fleet, including the original Lord of the Isles. 'Workers must now be given the chance to restore what was a worldwide reputation for excellence that has been damaged through no fault of their own. 'Before being turned into a political football, they delivered a steady stream of ferries serving Scotland's islands and must be allowed to do so again. 'Ministers and their civil servants insist direct awards are not straightforward but what could be more straightforward than Scotland's publicly-owned shipyard working in tandem with Scotland's ferry operators. 'Whoever is to blame for the failures around the most recent contracts it is not the workers. 'They deserve the support of ministers and that starts with being given the chance to build the kind of ferries they successfully completed for generations. 'The yard needs a steady pipeline of work and that can start with the Lord of Isles.' Ferguson Marine was one of six yards to make it to the second stage of the tender process for seven new CalMac ferries, but the contract ultimately went to Remontowa Shipbuilding in Gdansk. A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government's decision to take Ferguson Marine into public ownership saved the last commercial shipyard on the Clyde. "We are ensuring the long-term future of the Yard and the workforce and will invest up to £14.2 million in the yard over the next two years in order to help it modernise and secure future business. "Scottish Ministers expressed their disappointment and frustration to the Board of FMPG at the confirmation of a further delay and increased estimated cost to deliver the Glen Rosa. "They also made it clear to the yard's leadership that it must take immediate and sustained action to restore trust, enforce delivery discipline, and bring the project under control. 'This will be delivered alongside the development of the business's future commercial strategy, which is being spearheaded by a new CEO to enable Ferguson Marine to win new business in its target markets.'
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
Drivers face being charged to use Clyde Tunnel
Drivers may be charged to use the Clyde Tunnel under plans being considered by council bosses. The tunnel is not a designated A road so Transport Scotland has no responsibility for its management. However, funding for its operation and maintenance is the same per kilometre as a standard road, and estimates suggest this leads to an annual shortfall of £820,000 for the city. Councillors are now exploring the possibility of introducing a driver congestion charge and tolls for the tunnel, which would only apply to non-residents. Speaking at last week's full council meeting, Councillor Angus Millar said: 'The council has no specific proposals to introduce any road user charging in Glasgow. However, members will be aware that the council has repeatedly stated its interest in further exploring possibilities around a boundary congestion charge and potential tolling at the Clyde Tunnel — both with exemptions for Glasgow residents.' The tunnel first opened to traffic in 1963 and an estimated 23.7 million vehicles pass through it each year. Millar, who oversees climate policy, the Glasgow Green Deal, transport and city centre recovery, highlighted ongoing discussions with Transport Scotland and Cosla, the national association of Scottish councils. He said: 'Transport Scotland has expressed interest in Glasgow and Edinburgh taking a lead role in exploring road user charging, and we anticipate further discussions with City of Edinburgh council.' The Glasgow MSP Paul Sweeney said: 'It is not sustainable for Glasgow city council to continue maintaining the Clyde Tunnel without a means of raising additional funds, with around 10 per cent of the city's entire annual road maintenance budget being eaten up by the maintenance-intensive tunnel. 'Over the past decade, Glasgow city council has lost the equivalent of a full year's worth of funding as a result of disproportionate SNP cuts to Glasgow, compounded by the constrained council boundary, meaning that many of the region's most prosperous households do not contribute to the city's tax base. 'While I believe Transport Scotland should be responsible for what is a nationally significant trunk road, it is clear Glasgow city council cannot continue to plug an annual funding shortfall of £820,000 on the Clyde Tunnel. Therefore, introducing a toll for vehicles passing through the city that are not registered within the city council boundary seems like a reasonable proposal in line with European norms.' The proposals are still in the early stages, with legal and regulatory checks required before any implementation. These checks are unlikely to occur until after the Scottish parliamentary elections next May. Millar welcomed a commitment from Transport Scotland and the Scottish government to undertake a legislative review. The Scottish Green councillor Blair Anderson raised the topic during the meeting, asking for an update on the city's plans following the Scottish government's promise to empower councils to introduce such schemes. Anderson emphasised the environmental benefits of toll charges, stating: 'The only way we can meet our climate targets is moving people from cars to public transport. A road user charging scheme would give us the money to make Glasgow's buses publicly owned, reliable, fast and free.' Annie Wells, a Scottish Conservative MSP for Glasgow, said: 'It's outrageous that the SNP-run Glasgow city council is even considering a Clyde Tunnel toll to plug the funding gap caused by their own government short-changing local authorities. 'This 'tunnel tax' would punish workers, families and hospital patients travelling to the Queen Elizabeth Hospital. Many of the hospital's dedicated staff commute from outside the city, and this charge would clobber them simply for driving to work.'
