What Musk's fracture with Trump means for GOP's future: ‘Beating heart of the Republican Party'
Musk unveiled the creation of the so-called "America Party" after Trump signed into law his massive tax and domestic policy bill, which Musk staunchly opposed due to concerns that it would increase the federal deficit.
"Today, the America Party is formed to give you back your freedom," Musk said in a July 5 X post.
While there is an appetite for a third party in the U.S., Musk's so-called America Party is not likely to pick up steam and the tech mogul would have better luck driving reforms in the Republican Party, according to experts.
"Elon's effort will go nowhere," Republican strategist Matt Gorman said in an email to Fox News Digital. "But I don't doubt it'll make a lot of consultants rich in the process."
Meanwhile, Gorman said candidates undoubtedly would prefer an endorsement from Trump over financial backing from Musk – the largest donor in the 2024 election cycle who contributed approximately $295 million to Republicans.
"If given a choice between a Trump endorsement or $20 million in ads from Elon, it's not even a contest," said Gorman, who previously served as the communications director for the National Republican Congressional Committee. "They'd take the Trump endorsement every single time."
Political columnist Kristin Tate said that while Musk was helpful in driving public support from wealthy Silicon Valley Americans for Trump, it's unlikely these same tech leaders would abandon Trump and follow Musk instead.
"Trump is the beating heart of the Republican Party right now," Tate said in an email to Fox News Digital.
"Elon Musk would be better off trying to shape politics from within the Republican Party," Tate said. "A third party effort is doomed to fail. Most of President Trump's supporters see the effort as hostile to Trump and will not support Musk. Meanwhile, all Democrat voters have been conditioned to despise Musk, so they will not support him either."
Tate said Trump and Musk should attempt to repair their relationship because "both men bring something important and unique to the GOP.
"By leaving Trump, and the GOP generally, Musk will chisel off a small fraction of Republican Party voters – a fraction that will not be nearly big enough for his new party to win elections, but could be a spoiler for Democrats in elections with extremely tight margins," Tate said.
Alex Keyssar, a history professor at Harvard Kennedy School of public policy, said that given dissatisfaction with the two-party system right now, it's possible that more third-party candidates could win state and local elections. But it's unclear if that would translate over to national elections because the rules governing elections and who may appear on ballots pose additional limitations for those candidates, he said.
"There's a lot of popular sentiment looking for something else that is creating pressures for a third party," Keyssar told Fox News Digital. "In that sense, Elon Musk is on to something."
Still, voters don't appear interested in a third party affiliated with Musk. While 49% of U.S. voters said they would consider joining a third party, 77% said they weren't on board if Musk created it, according to a new Quinnipiac University poll released Wednesday.
Musk's relationship with Trump first started to unravel, at least publicly, in May toward the end of Musk's tenure overseeing the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).
Shortly after Musk's exit from DOGE, the two traded barbs over the "big, beautiful bill," where Musk said Trump wouldn't have won the 2024 election without his backing. Likewise, Trump accused Musk of going "CRAZY" over cuts to the electric vehicle credits that benefit companies like Tesla, and said Musk had been "wearing thin."
Meanwhile, Trump isn't counting on Musk's political party taking off anytime soon, and told reporters July 6 that he believed another party "just adds to confusion."
"Third parties have never worked, so he can have fun with it – but I think it's ridiculous," Trump said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Preserve capital, don't swing 'for the fences,' portfolio manager says
STORY: "If you have investments that generate current income, you have the ability to take advantage of the most powerful force in the universe, and that's compound interest," Dean said. Until President Trump's trade policy is settled, "this is not a time to be buying dips [on stocks]," he added.
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Honors 81st Anniversary Of Guam's Liberation From Japan
President Donald Trump marked the 81st anniversary of Guam's liberation from Japanese occupation with a message honoring the American forces who reclaimed the Pacific territory on July 21, 1944. The Presidential statement emphasized America's continued commitment to defending its territories and interests through military strength. 'As Imperial Japanese forces tried to hold their ground, they struggled to withstand the full might of the U.S. Armed Forces,' Trump said in his White House message. The battle for Guam lasted three weeks across challenging terrain. American forces fought through jungles, caves, and rugged hills to regain control of the strategically vital island. The victory positioned U.S. forces within striking distance of ending the war in the Pacific. The liberation came at a steep cost. More than 1,200 service members and over 1,000 Guam residents died during the campaign. Trump characterized the 1944 victory as 'a bold reassertion of American sovereignty at a time when our future and our freedom were in peril.' 'Under my leadership, the United States remains committed to upholding a foreign policy of peace through strength,' the president stated. He pledged that America would 'never waver in defending our interests, our citizens, our territory, and our glorious way of life from all enemies, foreign and domestic.' The liberation ended nearly three years of Japanese occupation that began December 10, 1941. Guam served as a crucial base for subsequent American operations in the Pacific theater.
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
GOP Senator Gets Fooled By Obviously Fake Fed Chair Resignation Letter
Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah) posted — and then deleted — what appeared at first glance Tuesday to be a resignation letter from Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, President Donald Trump's nemesis of the past several months. Trump has repeatedly argued that Powell should either lower interest rates across the country or resign. He has gone so far as to hint at — and then backtrack on — the idea that he may fire Powell himself. The letter briefly shared by Lee, however, is clearly a fake, and Powell is not going anywhere immediately. The formatting of the letter is strange, with line breaks at odd intervals. But most tellingly, the words around an official-looking blue seal stamped to the letter appear to read: 'OEOD OF GOVERYAEB EIREBAL RESERVE SIEIVA.' ADVERTISEMENT In other words, gibberish. Lee told a reporter for The Hilland others that he swiftly deleted the image after realizing he had not confirmed its authenticity. A spokesperson for the senator did not immediately respond to HuffPost's request for comment. Trump appointed Powell as chair of the Fed back in 2017, although he has tried to distance himself from that decision in recent days. Sen. Mike Lee tweeted (and appears to have deleted) what he appears to believe is a resignation letter (??) from Powell — Jordain Carney (@jordainc) July 22, 2025 Related...
