A settler accused of killing a Palestinian activist is to be freed. Israel still holds the body
The video shot by a Palestinian witness shows Yinon Levi brandishing a pistol and tussling with a group of unarmed Palestinians. He can be seen firing two shots, but the video does not show where the bullets hit.
Witnesses said one of the shots killed Awdah Hathaleen, an English teacher and father of three, who was uninvolved and was standing nearby.
The Israeli military is still holding Hathaleen's body and says it will only be returned if the family agrees to bury him in a nearby city. It said the measure was being taken to 'prevent public disorder.'
The confrontation occurred on Monday in the village of Umm al-Khair, in an area of the West Bank featured in 'No Other Land,' an Oscar-winning documentary about settler violence and life under Israeli military rule.
In a court decision obtained by The Associated Press, Judge Havi Toker wrote that there was 'no dispute' that Levi shot his gun in the village that day, but she said he may have been acting in self-defense and that the court could not establish that the shots killed Hathaleen.
Israel's military and police did not respond to a request for comment on whether anyone else may have fired shots that day. Multiple calls placed to Levi and his lawyer have not been answered.
The judge said Levi did not pose such a danger as to justify his continued house arrest but barred him from contact with the villagers for a month.
Levi has been sanctioned by the United States and other Western countries over allegations of past violence toward Palestinians. President Donald Trump lifted the U.S. sanctions on Levi and other radical settlers shortly after returning to office.
A total of 18 Palestinians from the village were arrested after the incident. Six remain in detention.
Eitay Mack, an Israeli lawyer who has lobbied for sanctions against radical settlers, including Levi, said the court ruling did not come as a surprise.
'Automatically, Palestinian victims are considered suspects, while Jewish suspects are considered victims,' he said.
Levi helped establish an settler outpost near Umm al-Khair that anti-settlement activists say is a bastion for violent settlers who have displaced hundreds since the start of the Israel-Hamas war. Palestinians and rights groups have long accused Israeli authorities of turning a blind eye to settler violence, which has surged since the outbreak of the Israel-Hamas war, along with attacks by Palestinians.
In a 2024 interview, Levi said he was protecting his own land and denied using violence.
Some 70 women in Umm al-Khair said they were beginning a hunger strike on Friday to call for Hathaleen's body to be returned and for the right of his family to bury him in the village.
Israel's military said in a statement to the AP that it would return the body if the family agrees to bury him in the 'nearest authorized cemetery.'
Hathaleen, 31, had written and spoke out against settler violence, and had helped produce the Oscar-winning film. Supporters have erected murals in his honor in Rome, held vigils in New York and have held signs bearing his name at anti-war protests in Tel Aviv.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
25 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Elizabeth Shackelford: Gaza's starvation is America's shame
Early in my foreign affairs career, I mostly avoided working on Israel and Palestine. The issues were fraught with emotion. I didn't think I understood it well enough to have an informed position. I believe the same sentiment that led me to avoid the topic before is what shapes many reactions (or nonreactions) to this conflict today. But we must not mistake passion for knowledge. Many have become outraged at the ongoing war and famine in Gaza, including hundreds of former members and leaders of Israel's own military and intelligence services. Yet my social media feed is still replete with zealous defenses of the Israeli government, regardless of its actions, and accusations of antisemitism for anyone who says otherwise. This passion is driving other people to look away. I have empathy for the history that drives these hardened positions, but they are emotional, uninformed and deadly. It's time for us all to face the reality that Israel's government is committing atrocities in Gaza and is doing so with American support. Hamas' war crimes against Israelis (and Palestinians) do not change that calculation. The people of Gaza deserve basic humanity regardless of Hamas' actions. If you disagree with that statement, look at the photos of skeletal children in Gaza — who make up half of the strip's population — and tell me they are terrorists who deserve that fate. Even if Israel's own assertions about aid delivery in Gaza were accurate, Gazans, and the hostages, would still be starving. Israel claims that 1 million meals are being distributed a day, which is only one-sixth of the food the population requires. This would be grossly inadequate under ordinary circumstances, but it comes after an 11-week blockade this spring. Gazans are already severely malnourished, so meeting basic needs requires much more, including specialized treatment to prevent people from dying from eating foods their bodies can't process in their deteriorated state. The fact is this: International law and basic human decency demand that Israel provide the basic needs of the civilians trapped in areas it occupies. No military necessity or advantage is served by denying them food. Humanitarian organizations are ready to provide that aid. But Israel has blocked those capable of delivering aid at scale and replaced them with a cynical show: a paramilitary organization with inadequate capacity and experience. The result is not only failure to relieve the starvation, but also death at distribution sites. Over 1,000 people have been killed trying to secure food so far, shot down by Israeli forces and American contractors reacting to the predictably chaotic scenes that Israel created. As Jeremy Konyndyk, president of Refugees International and former director of the U.S. government's foreign disaster assistance program, indicated in a recent interview, the crisis in Gaza can be managed if Israel simply allows access to real humanitarian organizations. The geography is small, and the population of 2 million is far less than in other complex humanitarian crises, such as Sudan. The immediate emergency is solvable. This famine is a policy choice. It's important to understand as well that 'famines have momentum,' as Konyndyk said. The standards for categorizing a situation as famine are exceedingly high and hard to document in the best of conditions. By the time you reach famine levels of hunger, human suffering increases exponentially. The catch-22 of not being able to muster up enough concern over deteriorating food security until it reaches a point in which the population is permanently damaged has plagued humanitarians for decades. I saw it myself in South Sudan years ago. Starving to death is a horrific way to go, but things are so bad in Gaza that people suffering from mass malnutrition will die of disease before starvation can set in, so the pace of death will rapidly escalate. International responses are often hampered by terminology. Have we reached famine levels? Does it qualify as a genocide? Waiting for official use of these terms is dangerous, as it allows culpable leaders to continuously classify disasters just below what is considered unacceptable. But whatever you call this, it is unacceptable. And since the United States is Israel's largest supporter, its sole defender today at the United Nations and supplier of most of its weapons of war, we have leverage. Because Israel has chosen to starve an entire population, that leverage gives us responsibility. I have friends in the U.S. government who still say it's not that simple, that Israel would stay on this path regardless of America's actions. I say to them: Prove me wrong. At a minimum, we would stop our complicity. A majority of the Senate voted down an effort to stop the sale of bombs and firearms to Israel in response to widespread suffering in Gaza just days ago. Shame on the senators who refused to support even a small gesture to pressure Israel to change its path and Gaza's future. To the 24 Democrats who voted to stop our complicity, thank you. Elizabeth Shackelford, a foreign affairs columnist for the Chicago Tribune, is a program director with the Institute for Global Affairs and a lecturer at Dartmouth College. She is currently co-writing the book 'How US Foreign Policy Really Works' and is also the author of 'The Dissent Channel: American Diplomacy in a Dishonest Age.' She was a senior fellow at the Chicago Council on Global Affairs and a career diplomat with the U.S. Department of State.
The Hill
25 minutes ago
- The Hill
The Latest: Israel plans to take control of Gaza City, drawing international condemnation
Israel said early Friday that it plans to take over Gaza City, drawing rejection from the Palestinians and international condemnation. The decision, agreed in a late-night meeting of its security Cabinet, marks a further escalation of Israel's 22-month war with Hamas. It also provoked worries in Israel over the fate of hostages still held by Hamas. Another major ground operation would almost certainly exacerbate the humanitarian catastrophe, in which Israel's air and ground war has pushed the territory toward famine. Hamas said people in Gaza would 'remain defiant against occupation.' Here's the Latest: UK, Spain, Turkey and Australia criticize Israel's Gaza City plan Israel's plan to escalate military operations in Gaza drew international condemnation Friday. British Prime Minister Keir Starmer urged Israel to reconsider, saying the expanded offensive would do nothing to end the conflict or secure the release of the remaining hostages. 'Our message is clear: a diplomatic solution is possible, but both parties must step away from the path of destruction,' Starmer said. Spain's Foreign Minister José Albares said Israel's plan would 'only lead to more destruction and suffering.' Turkey's Foreign Ministry said the escalation marked a new phase of Israel's 'expansionist' policies in the region. 'Israel must immediately halt its war plans, accept a ceasefire in Gaza, and begin negotiations toward a two-state solution,' it said in a statement on Friday. Australia also condemned a further occupation of Gaza. Foreign Minister Penny Wong said a two-state solution is the only pathway to secure an enduring peace: a Palestinian state and the State of Israel, living side-by-side in peace and security within internationally recognized borders.
New York Times
26 minutes ago
- New York Times
The Desperate Struggle to Squeeze Aid Into a Starving Gaza
Despite what Israel says are its efforts to bring more food and other aid into Gaza in recent days, the United Nations and other aid groups say it is falling catastrophically short of what is needed to stop fast-accelerating starvation there. International experts warn that Gaza is fast plunging into famine, with the number of Palestinians dying from hunger-related causes shooting upward over the past month. Gaza reached that point after Israel escalated its prior siege of the territory to block virtually all aid from March to May, aiming to pressure Hamas into releasing hostages still in Gaza. When Israel allowed aid back in, it did so mostly under a contentious new aid delivery system that resulted in the killings of hundreds of Palestinians and kept all but the strongest and luckiest from getting food. Now Israel is pausing the fighting in some parts of Gaza each day to help aid convoys move, approving some imported food for sale in Gaza and allowing aid to be airdropped. But all of it is far too little, far too late, aid officials say. Nothing less than a cease-fire will allow the necessary avalanche of aid to flow safely into Gaza, they say. Israeli leaders' decision instead to greenlight the recapture of Gaza City throws the aid system into further doubt. To have a real impact, aid agencies say Israel needs to allow in the hundreds of thousands of pallets of aid languishing outside Gaza — enough to cover around 100 soccer fields, they say — and help ensure that the aid can be distributed safely. Letting in small numbers of trucks and airdropping supplies is little more than a public relations stunt, aid officials contend. 'It's a joke, it's all just theatrics,' Bushra Khalidi, an aid official working on Oxfam's response in Gaza, said last week. 'We're talking about two million people. It's not 100 trucks or a pausing or a few hours of calm that is going to meet the needs of a population that has been starved for months,' Ms. Khalidi said. 'Starvation has a long-term impact, and it affects growth of children, and it's not something that you can reverse by throwing energy bars from the sky.' Israel says that the level of hunger has been exaggerated and that it is doing its best to lessen it. Israel's military spokesman has said there is no starvation in Gaza. The Israeli agency coordinating aid for Gaza did not respond to a request for comment. Israel has also blamed the United Nations for not bringing in more food, while the organization says that Israel frequently denies or delays its requests to bring in convoys, among other challenges. Many aid workers say airdrops endanger desperate people while feeding only a few, and only those physically able to retrieve it. During previous airdrops, people have been injured by falling aid; others have drowned or crossed into combat zones to retrieve packages that fell there, officials say. When he recently saw a plane drop aid by parachute, Mohammed Abu Taha, 43, who is sheltering in southern Gaza, ran toward it. By the time he arrived, other Palestinians were fighting over the remaining bags of food. 'People are too desperate,' he said. 'I ran a lot and got nothing at all.' Each airdrop delivers at most two truckloads of aid, and usually less, aid officials said. 'Airdrops are the most ineffective, expensive way of delivering aid possible,' said Bob Kitchen, who oversees emergency response at the International Rescue Committee, a group working in Gaza. With nearly one in three people going without food for days at a time, according to the United Nations, clinics treating malnutrition are at or over capacity. Children are becoming too weak to scavenge through trash for food or even to cry, aid workers say. An international group of experts said in late July that famine thresholds had been reached across much of Gaza. Health officials there say scores of people have died from malnutrition, including dozens of children, though aid workers say that is probably an undercount. Aid workers say that number could potentially climb to the tens or hundreds of thousands without a rapid surge in aid. Weakened by months of extreme deprivation, people have few defenses left to stop illnesses as ordinary as diarrhea from killing them. And those diseases are rampant. The number of people with acute watery diarrhea increased by 150 percent from March to June, and those with bloody diarrhea by 302 percent, health data from aid agencies shows. Those figures, which include only people who can reach medical centers, are most likely an undercount, according to Oxfam. Staving off famine therefore depends not only on food, but also on fuel to run hospitals, cooking gas to make meals and clean water and sanitation to keep waterborne diseases in check — all of which are absent or nearly absent from Gaza, aid workers say. Aid agencies have received 200 to 300 trucks in Gaza each day for the past several days, the Israeli agency coordinating aid said. They mainly carried flour along with prepared meals, infant formula, high-energy biscuits, diapers, vaccines and fuel, the United Nations said. Before the war, Gaza received 500 to 600 trucks a day of aid and goods for sale. The flour provides calories, but will not save those who are severely malnourished after nearly two years of deprivation, aid workers say. Malnourished people need specialized feeding and care. Yet hospitals have few supplies left. David M. Satterfield, who served as special envoy for Middle East humanitarian issues in the Biden administration, said the only practical solution was to 'flood the zone' with aid. 'It's not rocket science,' he said. It is too late to reverse developmental and cognitive harm to young children who have been malnourished for months, experts say. 'The damage is already done, and that's going to be a lifelong impact for a lot of people,' said Beckie Ryan, the Gaza response director for CARE. 'What we can do is mitigate that going forward and stop it getting worse. But it does require a huge amount of supplies and aid to be able to come in as soon as possible.' The death toll from the war has passed 60,000, according to Gaza's health ministry. Israel cut off aid to Gaza in retaliation for the October 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel in which some 1,200 people were killed and around 250 were taken hostage. Limited aid deliveries later resumed under a United Nations-run system, until March, when Israel imposed another total blockade. In May, Israel largely replaced the U.N. aid system by backing a new operation mainly run by American contractors. Israeli officials said that was the only way to ensure the food would not fall into Hamas's hands. At least 859 Palestinians seeking food from the private sites have been killed since May 27, in most cases by Israeli soldiers, according to the U.N. Human Rights Office. Israeli officials have said they fired shots in the air when crowds came too close or endangered their forces. The violence has renewed calls to allow the United Nations to resume managing aid. The New York Times reported that the Israeli military had never found proof that Hamas systematically stole aid from the United Nations — a charge Israel frequently repeated. 'We are struggling to understand why you need to come out with parallel shadow systems, when we had a fully functional aid distribution system in Gaza managed by the U.N. and international agencies,' said Jamil Sawalmeh, who oversees ActionAid's Gaza response. Even with Israeli pauses in fighting, it is dangerous for aid trucks to move around Gaza. While Israel is approving more movement by aid groups, which have to be coordinated in advance, teams still faced delays and other obstacles, the United Nations said. The American ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, said on Wednesday that the number of the U.S.-backed sites could soon quadruple. An Israeli security official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity in line with military rules, said Israel was increasing the number of trucks entering Gaza, including by withdrawing some forces and working to open a third crossing into the enclave. Even when trucks can move, little makes it to the aid warehouses where humanitarian agencies collect supplies before distributing them. Most of it is taken by the thousands of Palestinians, including some armed gangs, who regularly wait near the trucks' route to grab whatever they can, aid workers say. But doing so can be deadly, with 514 killed since May 27, mostly by Israel's military, according to U.N. figures. On Wednesday, Ehab Fasfous, 52, a resident of the southern Gazan city of Khan Younis, inched toward the trucks' route, aware, he said, that Israeli soldiers could open fire if he ventured too close. He shared a series of videos of the mayhem he saw next: hundreds, perhaps thousands of people closing in on the trucks from every direction. At one point in the videos, which he said he took, a man menaces another person with a knife near a bag of flour. Mr. Fasfous went home empty-handed. 'They've deprived us of so much that now we're behaving like animals,' he said. Only those who can brave such dangers get aid, aid officials say. The people most in need — like pregnant women, older adults or the sick — receive only what aid groups bring them, unless they can pay the astronomical prices of what little food is available in markets, aid workers say. 'We have to find a way for assistance to reach the weakest,' said Antoine Renard, the World Food Program's director for the Palestinian territories, who visited Gaza this week. The price of flour has dropped precipitously in recent days, according to Gaza government statistics, but it remains unaffordable for all but the few who still have resources. Yaser Shaban, 58, spends his salary as a Palestinian civil servant and his savings on flour, canned food and herbs at the market. If he goes to a privately run center or tries to take aid from a truck, 'I have no guarantees I'll bring something back,' he said. 'And if I get killed, what chances does my family have then?' he said. Adam Rasgon and Abu Bakr Bashir contributed reporting.
