Discretion is the best part of valour, Karnataka High Court reminds makers of Thug Life film
The High Court of Karnataka on Friday asked actor Kamal Haasan's Raajkamal Films International (RKFI), Chennai, to file its statement of objections, if any, against the applications filed by the Kannada Sahitya Parishat (KSP) and an advocate, who want to be part of proceedings in its petition seeking protection for the release of the Tamil film Thug Life in Karnataka.
Justice M. Nagaprasanna passed the order while adjourning further hearing till June 20 on the petition, filed by the RKFI, which had also sought a direction to retrain the Karnataka Film Chamber of Commerce (KFCC) from issuing any instruction in relation to banning release and distribution of Thug Life in Karnataka as the KFCC had demanded an apology from Mr. Haasan for his controversial statement that 'Kannada is born out of Tamil'. Mr. Haasan is one of the directors of the RKFI.
'Stupid statement'
Earlier, Senior Advocate S. Basavaraj, who appeared for the KSP, termed as a 'stupid statement' the actor's remark on Kannada, while placing some books before the court on historical background of the language.
Mr. Basavaraj also questioned how a person, who set his house on fire can seek the help from the court to douse the blaze, while pointing out that opposition for the release the film was a result of his statement on Kannada without any basis.
'Again, I am repeating, discretion is the best part of valour,' the court orally told the petitioner's advocate while adjourning the hearing, to which the petitioner's advocate said he would convey it to the petitioner.
Earlier observations
During an earlier hearing on June 3, the court had said it was 'of the prima facie opinion that, if a sentence of apology had been included while concluding the communication [from Mr. Haasan to the KFCC], it would have concluded/ended all controversy and the unrest or disharmony in the State of Karnataka' on release of the film.
Also, the court on June 5 adjourned the hearing as the petitioner's advocate had said the screening of the movie would not be insisted upon till the dialogue/trialogue with the KFCC to resolve the issue after Mr. Haasan chose not to go by the suggestion made by the court to apologise to put an end to the controversy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
2 hours ago
- News18
Thug Life Makers Claim Karnataka Govt Not Acting Against Threats: 'Not A Single FIR Filed'
Last Updated: Kamal Haasan landed in a controversy recently during the Thug Life audio launch event in Chennai, where he made a statement linking the origins of the Kannada language to Tamil. The makers of Kamala Haasan's Thug Life have alleged that the Karnataka government is not protecting them from threats amid the actor's 'Kannada born out of Tamil" remark. Recently, the makers filed a plea in the court seeking protection and claimed that the state government has not filed even a single FIR as of now against groups who are openly threatening them. 'A fringe group issued threats of large-scale violence, including the burning of theatres and attacks against members of the Tamil linguistic minority residing in Karnataka. Despite these open and public threats, not a single FIR was registered, nor was any prosecution initiated by the State Government. On the contrary, the government appeared to adopt the position of the very fringe elements that issued those threats. We are aggrieved by this inaction and are now before the Supreme Court, seeking enforcement of this Court's past directions," Advocate A Velan said, as quoted by Hindustan Times. The plea of the Thug Life makers argued that such inaction violates the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. The Supreme Court has now sought the state government's response on this. For the unversed, Kamal Haasan landed in a big controversy recently during the Thug Life audio launch event in Chennai, where he made a statement linking the origins of the Kannada language to Tamil. 'Actor Shivarajkumar is my family living in another state. That's why he is here. That's why when I started my speech, I said 'my life and my family is Tamil'. Your language (Kannada) was born out of Tamil. So you are included in that line," he said. The actor's remarks quickly went viral and triggered backlash from pro-Kannada groups in Karnataka. The film was also banned in Karnataka, and a complaint was also filed against the actor. Later, Haasan also wrote a letter to the Karnataka Film Chamber of Commerce (KFCC) and claimed that his comment was 'misinterpreted'. 'It pains me that my statement at the Thug Life audio launch, spoken out of genuine affection for the legendary Dr. Rajkumar's family, especially Shiva Rajkumar has been misunderstood and taken out of context. My words were intended only to convey that we are all one and from the same family and not to diminish Kannada in any way. There is no dispute or debate on the rich legacy of Kannada language," he wrote. First Published:
Mint
3 hours ago
- Mint
How to Train Your Dragon Box Office Collection Day 1: Mason Thames's fantasy adventure film makes bumper opening
How to Train Your Dragon Box Office Collection Day 1: Hollywood's latest fantasy adventure film 'How to Train Your Dragon' is making waves at the box office after bumper opening, in IMAX 3D format, on June 13. Inspired by Cressida Cowell's New York Times bestselling book series, Universal and DreamWorks Animation's live-action is a remake of the 2010 animated film How to Train Your Dragon. Directed by Dean DeBlois, the movie raked in ₹ 4.88 crore net at the India box office on its opening day, according to film industry tracker Sacnilk. It amassed ₹ 2.96 crore net from its original English version and ₹ 1.1 crore net from Hindi shows. Rest of the earnings, ₹ 36 lakh and ₹ 46 lakh came from Tamil and Telugu screenings. Featuring stellar cast, including Mason Thames, Nico Parker, Gabriel Howell, Julian Dennison, Bronwyn James, Harry Trevaldwyn, Peter Serafinowicz, and Nick Frost in pivotal roles, the movie is captivating the audience. Notably, Gerard Butler reprises his role as Stoick the Vast from the animated films. Produced under the banners DreamWorks Animation and Marc Platt Productions, it debuted at CinemaCon on April 2, 2025 while it was released in the United States by Universal Pictures on Friday. Its sequel is slated for June 11, 2027, release. According to Hollywood Reporter, the movie amassed a whopping $11.1 million from preview shows in the US. A massive $8.6 million earnings came from regular Thursday previews while the rest $2.5 million came from June 11 early access screenings. The movie received 99% Audience Score on Rotten Tomatoes. Amid a massive $82.5 million projected earnings on Day 1 across 4,356 theatres in North America, the movie is expected to record the best opening ever in the How to Train Your Dragon franchise, Deadline reported. The official description of the movie states, 'On the rugged isle of Berk, where Vikings and dragons have been bitter enemies for generations, Hiccup stands apart. The inventive yet overlooked son of Chief Stoick the Vast, Hiccup defies centuries of tradition when he befriends Toothless, a feared Night Fury dragon. Their unlikely bond reveals the true nature of dragons, challenging the very foundations of Viking society.'
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Nagarjuna addresses changing trends in Tollywood and Bollywood: 'It can't be fantastic all the time'
Picture Credit: Facebook Veteran actor Nagarjuna who is gearing up for the release of the upcoming film 'Kuberaa', starring Dhanush in the lead, recently weighed in on the ongoing comparisons between Bollywood and the southern film industries. During an interview with Galatta Plus, Nagarjuna shared that he believes these trends are cyclical, and no industry remains at the top forever. When asked if Bollywood has lost it's spark in contrast to a booming southern film industry, the actor dismissed it saying, "These narratives keep changing." He explained that it's like an actor or director having a bad time of 4-5 years. He further explained, "Everything cumulative probably happened there, and films didn't work. And then they say the whole film industry is gone. In my time, in the Telugu film industry, it has happened four times. And I believe the fourth time will come now, very soon. I'm very sure, it's my hunch." Nagarjuna was also asked about filmmaker Naga Vamsi's recent prediction of a "bloodbath" in Tollywood due to changing audience tastes and underperforming films. The actor disagreed with it but also shared the need for timely reinvention. He about how films like mentioned that Tourist Family' in Tamil, 'Court' in Telugu, and 'Anaganaga' on OTT are working so well. He shared that audience's tastes are changing and as filmmakers, they have to keep that in mind. "They have to change fast. If we don't look at the future, things could be pretty bad. I feel that's what happened in Hindi. Now they'll change. It can't be fantastic all the time", he said. On the work front, he will be seen next in 'Kuberaa' joining Dhanush and Rashmika Mandanna in the lead. The movie will be released on June 20. He will be further seen in Rajinikanth's film 'Coolie' which also includes the brief appearance of stars like Aamir Khan, Upendra Rao and Pooja Hegde.
