Trial date set for men charged with firearms offences in case linked to Carlow shooter
Shane Kinsella, with an address at Tynock, Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, and Daniel Quinn Burke of 1 Allendale Lawns, Baltinglas, Wicklow, appeared before Judge Desmond Zaidan at Naas District Court this afternoon.
The men, both aged 21, were charged with four firearms offences in March 2024 along with Evan Fitzgerald – the young man who fatally injured himself with a shotgun in Fairgreen Shopping Centre on Sunday.
All three faced four charges: two charges in relation to possession of weapons and two charges in relation to the possession of ammunition under the Firearms Act.
The three men have been remanded on bail since March 2024.
During a hearing for Kinsella and Quinn Burke in relation to the charges this afternoon at Naas Discrict Court, Judge Desmond Zaidan withdrew the charges against Evan Fitzgerald whose death he described as 'a suicide'.
Zaidan said that the withdrawl of the charges against Fitzgerald was done under the direction of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Charges are dismissed as a matter of course if a person facing charges has died.
Kinsella and Quinn Burke will face trial for the firearms offences at Naas District Court on 18 June.
The pair were charged with possession of .45 calibre M1911A1 semi-automatic pistol, as well as a 7.62mm G3 assault rifle and a range of ammunition.
'Hiding behind my court'
During the proceedings, Judge Zaidan said that he 'wished to clarify' recent reporting on the bail conditions of Evan Fitzgerald, who used a legally-owned shotgun to carry out the shooting in Fairgreen Shopping Centre on Sunday.
He had no prior convictions or known links to serious crime, which meant there were no grounds to oppose bail when he was charged with firearms and explosives offences last year, the court heard.
Fitzgerlad's bail conditions were also relaxed after a period of months because he had so closely complied with all of the conditions initially imposed on him.
Taoiseach Micheál Martin said yesterday that a review of bail laws is already underway, but added
that there are 'constitutional limits' on reforms around bail in Ireland
.
Advertisement
Addressing press reporters in the court, Judge Zaidan delivered a prolonged address from bench, during which he stressed that gardaí had consented to granting bail for Evan Fitzgerald and the other accused men last year.
'I don't want anyone hiding behind my order,' Zaidan said.
'Gardaí consented to bail – no judge in Ireland can go behind that. Once gardaí consent to bail, bail must be granted.'
'That's the way it was dealt with on 4 March 2024. There has been some sensational headlines about objecting to bail recently,' the judge said.
Zaidan later described news coverage of Evan Fitzgerald's bail as 'embarrassing', and said that he had received multiple phone calls from acquaintances asking him about it.
'You can see as a human being where I'm coming from. The gardaí consented – amen - which means my role was done,' he said.
He then formally gave effect to the next sitting of Naas circuit court on 18 June, where Shane Kinsella and Daniel Quinn Burke will face th efirearms charges.
USB stick
During the proceedings, solicitor Tim Kennelly revealed that a USB stick had been duct-taped to his client Shane Kinsella's bedroom window on Sunday, the same day that Evan Fitzgerald shot himself in Fairgreen Shopping Centre in Carlow.
Kennelly said that the USB stick was stuck to the window in a sealed bag. He explained that a capital letter 'E' was written out in duct dape above the USB stick on the same window.
Detective Garda Brian Foran told the court that the USB stick had been retrieved by gardaí as part of investigations into the Carlow shooting on Sunday.
Kennelly said that Shane Kinsella had not been able to see the contents of the USB stick, and argued that he was entitled to see it.
Garda Foran said that gardaí in Carlow were 'dealing with this', and said that he did not wish to comment on the USB stick.
Judge Zaidan told Foran: 'it exists, they're entitled to it', and ordered that the defence be allowed access to the content of the USB stick.
Separately, gardaí confirmed that a postmortem of the body of Evan Fitzgerald had concluded today.
A spokesperson said the results will not be released 'for operational reasons' – as is standard procedure in major garda investigations.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
11 hours ago
- Sunday World
Man accused of threatening to burn woman's home down released on bail
Garda Liam Finn objected to bail due to the nature of the case A labourer accused of threatening to burn his female housemate's Dublin home down has been released on bail pending possible extra charges. Valentin Ursachi, 41, formerly of Park Boulevard, Tyrrelstown, Dublin 15, was charged with making a threat to damage the woman's residence in a way likely to endanger her life during the alleged incident on Friday. He appeared before Judge John Brennan at Dublin District Court yesterday. Garda Liam Finn objected to bail due to the nature of the case, alleging "he threatened to burn his housemate's house down," and he added that further charges were "most likely". However, in subsequent exchanges with defence solicitor Tracy Horan, he agreed that the imposition of specific conditions would allay his fears. Dressed in a cream jacket, white trousers, and a navy and beige top, Mr Ursachi, who did not address the court, listened to the proceedings with the aid of a Romanian interpreter. Judge Brennan ordered him to stay away from the property, surrender his passport within two hours of release, and not apply for replacement travel documents. He was also instructed to have no contact with the complainant and to sign on once a week at a Garda station. The complainant was not required to attend or give evidence at the bail hearing. Legal aid was granted after Ms Horan submitted a statement of her client's means and told the court that the man was working on minimum wage. He must appear again on September 19 for the DPP's directions to be conveyed and possible further charges.
Sunday World
11 hours ago
- Sunday World
Enoch Burke sister Jemima left without compensation despite quashing of conviction
The finding was made in judicial review proceedings brought by Ms Burke (30) after she was arrested, charged and convicted within a matter of hours A sister of controversial teacher Enoch Burke will not be awarded damages despite a ruling quashing her conviction for a public order offence. Jemima Burke was not afforded fair trial rights when she was convicted at Ballina District Court in Co Mayo on June 20 last year, the High Court found. The finding was made in judicial review proceedings brought by Ms Burke (30) after she was arrested, charged and convicted within a matter of hours. The DPP did not oppose the quashing of the conviction but had sought to have the case remitted for a re-hearing before a different district court judge. However, Ms Justice Sara Phelan did not consider it appropriate to do so. The judge also did not consider an award of damages to be necessary or appropriate. Ms Burke had been convicted and fined €350 under Section 6 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1994, which makes it an offence for a person in a public place to use or engage in any threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour with intent to provoke a breach of the peace or being reckless as to whether a breach of the peace may be occasioned. She used her phone to film the coroner and several staff from Mayo University Hospital Her arrest and conviction came after she attended an inquest in Swinford, Co Mayo. During the inquest lunch break, while outside on the public street, she used her phone to film the coroner and several staff from Mayo University Hospital. Ms Burke was arrested by a garda. She was taken to Ballina garda station, detained in a cell, and then taken to the district court, where her case was heard immediately after she refused to sign a bail bond. Ms Justice Phelan said it appeared the district court judge was of the view that it was in Ms Burke's best interests to have the trial immediately. This was because if she was to be remanded in custody pending her trial, the ultimate penalty was unlikely to be a custodial sentence equal to or longer than the remand period. But Ms Justice Phelan said it was evident the minimum requirements of a fair trial had not been met. Ms Burke was not afforded time to prepare her defence, for example, by way of considering whether to engage legal representation, request disclosure, ascertain if CCTV footage was available, review mobile phone footage, or ascertain if there were witnesses available.
Irish Times
4 days ago
- Irish Times
Student (20) charged with multiple counts of rape of male in Dublin
A 20-year-old student has been charged with multiple counts of rape and sexual assault of another male in Dublin four years ago. The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was aged 16 and a juvenile at the time of the alleged sexual abuse over a three-month period in 2021. He was arrested on Friday and charged with six counts of rape and eight for sexual assault at a specific address in south Co Dublin. He appeared before Judge John Brennan at a late sitting of Dublin District Court. Detective Garda Liam Conway said the young man replied 'No' when each charge was put to him. The court heard the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has directed that the man would face 'trial on indictment'. That means, due to the nature of some of the charges, he will be tried in the Central Criminal Court. READ MORE Det Garda Conway confirmed the accused was a minor when the alleged offences occurred and there was no objection to bail provided he obeyed a series of conditions. Judge Brennan ordered him to provide gardaí with a contact phone number, remain contactable at all times, notify them of any address change, sign on at a north Dublin Garda station and surrender his passport. Furthermore, he told the man that it was a condition of bail that he must not communicate with the complainant, directly or indirectly, including by social media. Defence counsel Kevin McCrave consulted with the accused who did not address the court, before telling the judge his client consented to those terms. Judge Brennan warned there would be consequences for breaching the terms and the barrister stressed that he would explain that to his client, who has yet indicate a plea. Bail was set at €750 and he was ordered to appear at the Children's Court in September to be served with a book of evidence and returned for trial to the Central Criminal Court. Legal aid was granted after the court heard the accused was a student, on social welfare and unemployed.
