Legislation to support survivors of residential abuse ‘a huge breach of trust', says Opposition
Legislation to provide enhanced health and education supports to survivors of abuse in residential institutions could end up reinstitutionalising them late in life,
the Dáil
has heard.
TDs on Wednesday night passed, by 87 votes to 71, the Supports for Survivors of Residential Institutional Abuse Bill, which was first introduced last year.
The legislation was sharply criticised by the Opposition, with
Sinn Féin
TD Darren O'Rourke saying it did not give 'survivor status for social housing applications' to those supposed to benefit from it.
He said they could end up in nursing homes and 'the idea that the people involved would be reinstitutionalised at a late stage in their lives is simply unconscionable'.
READ MORE
Labour's Ciarán Ahearn said the legislation 'is already a huge breach of trust because it ignores entirely the survivors' repeatedly stated need' for the full Health Amendment Act (HAA) card.
The legislation provides for an 'enhanced medical card' but the HAA card includes a much broader range of services including home nursing and support services.
Mr Ahearn said people would receive little more than the regular medical card, which was 'wholly inadequate for their needs'. He said 'lest it be forgotten, they have experienced the worst forms of abuse possible at the hands of the State as well as the church'.
Independent TD
Catherine Connolly
said she had 'watched 22 years of apologies and more than 100 years of institutionalisation' and 'each scheme has been defective'.
She said the Magdalene scheme led to the Ombudsman 'absolutely castigating its discriminatory nature and maladministration'.
'We are here today doing the exact same thing, telling survivors we have listened to them and then absolutely ignoring them,' she said, adding that it was 'all to save a few euro'.
'It would have been much simpler all along just to give a payment to every survivor and their families in terms of education.'
The Bill aims to enable ongoing health and education supports to survivors of abuse in residential institutions.
Minister for Education Helen McEntee said 'our overall objective is to make sure that nobody is left without a home and nobody is put in that position.
'Local authorities are very mindful of the individual circumstances people find themselves in,' she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
18 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Expert group warned military air traffic control staffing issue would re-emerge
An expert group urged four years ago for a special payment to be given to military air traffic controllers to dissuade them from leaving the Defence Forces for the private sector. It is understood the 2021 report was not acted upon, and the service is now facing a new staffing crisis. The group's report argued that problems with the operation of military air traffic control services would continue to emerge every few years if issues continued to be tackled on an ad hoc basis. The report, drawn up by a joint Department of Defence and Defence Forces group, recommended introducing a service commitment scheme that would boost pay for air traffic control personnel. READ MORE The report said 'stability must be ensured through retaining experience and stopping air traffic service personnel numbers dropping further'. It urged adopting a 'blended approach of incentives and undertakings' to minimise 'premature voluntary retirements'. 'Having a pathway for personnel who complete training to take up a role (and technical pay) specific to their skill set, or the ability to pay qualified controllers the appropriate technical pay after completing their training, would mitigate the impact of gaps within the unit,' the report said. It is understood the 2021 report was not acted upon, and the service is now facing a new staffing crisis. Last week it emerged that an acute shortage of trained air traffic controllers (ATCs) at the Air Corps ' only base at Casement Aerodrome in Baldonnel, Dublin, is expected to lead to military flight operations being restricted to a five-day-a-week, daytime-only schedule. [ Parlous state of Defence Forces once again laid bare Opens in new window ] The move will have huge implications for rescue, medical and policing services that use the Baldonnel airbase. The 505 Squadron, which is responsible for air traffic control, is supposed to have 21 personnel but in recent years it has been operating at about 50 per cent capacity. Five personnel are due to depart shortly for the private sector, necessitating the move to a reduced schedule, which takes effect from June 7th. The 2021 report recommended reforms to training, recruitment and retention. However, it warned that having non-military personnel run the air traffic service in its entirety or contracting it out to an external provider is 'not an option'. The report said there should be a minimum of 32 personnel in the air traffic control unit. It said personnel undergoing training should have to make a four-year commitment. [ State attempting to reach settlements with Air Corps chemical victims, Tánaiste says Opens in new window ] The Air Corps is responsible for air navigation in airspace designated for use by the Defence Forces. In 2016 the retirement of key personnel led to a restriction on operations. A full 24-hour service was restored in 2021. The joint review group was established to identify options for the long-term sustainability of the air traffic service at Baldonnel. The report said issues related to the air traffic service in the past were 'largely dealt with in an ad hoc manner'. 'Maintaining such an approach will lead to problems continuing or re-emerging from time to time every number of years.' It said the military air traffic service is 'a strategic asset' that ensures air connectivity for the State. 'Casement Aerodrome is the only secure military airfield within the State, and is itself a strategic asset. Military air traffic service plays a vital role in maintaining this capability and in ensuring the security of operations in interactions with other agencies,' the report said.
Irish Times
21 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Ryan Moore delivers ‘incredible' ride to win French Derby on Camille Pissarro
Ryan Moore's deadeye judgment in pressure-cooker situations has rarely been better illustrated than by Camille Pissarro's thrilling French Derby victory at Chantilly on Sunday. The Irish horse delivered Aidan O'Brien a second success in the €1.5 million Qatar Prix Du Jockey Club following St Mark's Basilica's dominant victory in 2021. Covid pandemic restrictions meant Moore couldn't travel to France on that occasion. It left veteran local rider Ioritz Mendizabal to do the relatively straightforward steering. It's hard to argue, though, that most other jockeys would have got Camille Pissarro into the prestigious winner's enclosure. READ MORE A stall one draw in a massive 18-runner field was a plus but not so much that it didn't come with complications too. Crucial to the picture was how O'Brien's second-string, Trinity College, was in box three. Wayne Lordan got him out quickly and along with the English runner, Bowmark, ensured a strong pace. Moore slotted in behind in their wake. It still left him with the dilemma of when to go on a doubtful stayer and as the local hope Cualificar, as well as Bowmark's stable companion Detain, challenged on the outer, Moore's sangfroid must have been strained. The Englishman opted for a dive on to the rail that momentarily, and ironically, looked like it might be impeded by none other than Trinity College. But when the 7-2 favourite got through the gap he stretched and got to the line half-a-length in front of Cualificar. Detain was a neck back in third with Trinity College a further neck behind in fourth. Camille Pissarro became just the fourth ever Irish-trained winner of France's premier Classic. It sets the all-conquering Ballydoyle team up perfectly for this Saturday's Derby at Epsom. Ryan Moore reacts after winning the French Derby on Camille Pissarro. Photograph: Hugo Mathy/AFP via Getty Images 'It was actually a very smooth race. Gosden's horse [Bowmark] and our horse went forward, and they got well spread out,' Moore said. 'I didn't want to come out too early and I knew I was going to have to hope for a little luck. But because he has so much speed and can whip in, he's able to find a way through. Aidan has always had a lot of belief in this horse.' Nevertheless, it was Detain's rider Christope Soumillon who convinced O'Brien the extended 10-furlong trip would be within Camille Pissarro's capabilities after riding the colt to finish third in the French Guineas. The Belgian was the first to congratulate Moore and pat the winner. Describing Moore's ride as 'incredible', O'Brien pointed to the Eclipse, or perhaps a drop back to a mile as potential targets for the winner. 'Christophe was delighted with him the last day and he said to come here with him. But what a ride Ryan gave him. He had a lovely draw as it's very difficult when you're wide. He was wide the last day when he ran in the French Guineas, he was very wide all the way. 'But if you have a draw and you have class like he was, then Ryan was prepared to wait. There was no rush getting him there and I don't think he could have waited any longer. 'He's a very classy horse. Obviously, he's a Group One winner on Arc day (2024 Prix Jean Luc Lagadere) when Christophe rode him. He had a great run in the French Guineas. 'It's a difficult race to win and you need a horse with a lot of speed, and they have to get a mile and a quarter as well. It's a very important race and it makes him a very important horse now. He's a perfect, big, powerful, black horse by Wootton Bassett,' Ireland's champion trainer said. It was an 11th French Classic victory for O'Brien, while Moore had previously won the 'Jockey Club' in 2014 on The Grey Gatsby. Focus will now turn to Epsom and what Moore will pick. Delacroix is widely presumed to emerge as O'Brien's number one hope. Topping Moore's mini-masterpiece on Sunday will take some doing.
Irish Times
36 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Lutnick downplays tariff court ruling impact on US-EU talks
US Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick downplayed the impact of legal uncertainty around US tariffs on negotiations with the European Union during an interview with Fox News on Sunday, saying talks were ongoing. Lutnick was asked about a Reuters report quoting an unnamed EU official close to negotiations who said the legal uncertainty of the tariffs in the US gave the EU 'extra leverage.' 'You can't listen to silly people making silly comments,' Lutnick said. 'All of the countries that are negotiating with us understand the power of Donald Trump and his ability to protect the American worker.' A US trade court blocked most of President Donald Trump's tariffs in a sweeping ruling last week that found the president overstepped his authority by imposing across-the-board duties on imports from American trading partners. A US federal appeals court paused that ruling a day later, allowing the tariffs to go into effect while it considered an appeal by the Trump administration. READ MORE Lutnick said the ruling 'maybe cost us a week, but then everybody came right back to the table.' Trump in late May threatened 50 per cent tariffs on all European goods by June 1st but days later delayed the effective date to July 9th to allow for time to negotiate. Trump also said on Friday that he would increase tariffs on imported steel and aluminium to 50 per cent from 25 per cent, leading the European Commission on Saturday to say it could consider countermeasures. Speaking on ABC News, White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett said the US needed to protect its steel industry for national security reasons in light of economic rival China's steel production. 'We have to show strength,' Hassett said. 'We have to have a steel industry that's ready for American defence.' Meanwhile US Treasury Secretary Bessent said he believes President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping will speak soon to iron out trade issues including a dispute over critical minerals. US President Donald Trump on Friday accused China of violating an agreement to mutually roll back tariffs and trade restrictions for critical minerals. 'What China is doing is they are holding back products that are essential for the industrial supply chains of India, of Europe. And that is not what a reliable partner does,' Bessent said in an interview on Sunday with CBS. 'I am confident that when President Trump and Party Chairman Xi have a call, that this will be ironed out. But the fact that they are withholding some of the products that they agreed to release during our agreement – maybe it's a glitch in the Chinese system, maybe it's intentional. We'll see after the President speaks with the party chairman.' – Reuters
