
US appeals court overturns murder-kidnapping conviction in 1979 missing child case
A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ordered Pedro Hernandez, serving a prison sentence of 25 years to life, released from custody unless the state grants him a new trial within a time frame deemed "reasonable" by a federal judge.
It will be up to the office of Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg to decide whether to seek what would be a third trial in a case that dates back nearly a quarter-century and was originally brought by Bragg's predecessor, Cyrus Vance.
A spokesperson for the DA's office, Emily Tuttle, said "we are reviewing the decision."
In a 51-page response to a habeas petition filed on his behalf, the appellate panel sided with Hernandez in ruling that a state trial judge contradicted federal law in his instruction to jurors during their deliberations and thus swayed the verdict against the defendant.
The instruction at issue centered on the jury's question as to how it should treat statements of confession Hernandez gave during hours of interrogation by investigators without a lawyer present.
Hernandez, now 64, was found guilty in 2017 of kidnapping and murdering Patz, who vanished nearly 40 years earlier as he walked alone for the first time to a school bus stop two blocks from his home in Manhattan's SoHo neighborhood on May 25, 1979.
The boy, who was never found, became one of the first missing children whose faces would become ubiquitous as emblems printed on the sides of milk cartons to publicize their disappearance in hopes of stirring investigative tips.
The mystery of the Patz case captured U.S. media attention and endured as one of the country's most infamous child disappearances until police arrested Hernandez in May 2012.
Because of a lack of physical evidence or contemporary witnesses in the case, the 2016-2017 trial - Hernandez's second after the first ended in a hung jury in 2015 - hinged almost entirely on his purported confessions.
Hernandez, who worked in a bodega near the bus stop and was 18 at the time, told investigators he strangled the boy and then placed his body in a box left in a trash pick-up area outside the store.
His lawyers argued the admission was the result of police coercion as well as severe mental illness that altered his perceptions of reality, making him especially susceptible to confessionary delusions and hallucinations.
According to case records, Hernandez initially admitted to the crime without being advised of his so-called Miranda rights to avoid self-incrimination and to have an attorney present. Then, after he was read his rights and had agreed to waive them, he was videotaped twice making statements of confession.
On the second day of deliberations in the 2017 trial, the jury sent a note to the judge asking whether jurors must disregard the two videotaped confessions if they concluded that this initial, non-Mirandized one was involuntary.
The judge wrote back: "The answer is, no," which the appeals court ruled was both improper and "manifestly prejudicial." The verdict against Hernandez was returned after seven more days of deliberation.
Jurors ultimately rejected "substantial evidence" presented by the defense pointing to another man who was long considered a suspect, Jose Ramos, a convicted pedophile and boyfriend of Patz's babysitter, according to an account of the case in the appeals court ruling.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
3 minutes ago
- The Independent
Suspect in American Idol exec killing used couple's gun and then called 911 after deadly shooting
The man accused of killing American Idol executive Robin Kaye and her husband inside their Los Angeles home allegedly used the couple's gun in the shootings – and called the police after the shooting, authorities said. Raymond Boodarian, 22, allegedly used a gun owned by Kaye and her husband, Thomas Deluca, to kill the couple, Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman revealed Monday during a town hall, according to Eyewitness News. After the fatal shooting of the 70-year-old pair, Boodarian called 911 from his cellphone and provided his name, which was how police tracked him down, Hochman added. "We're having phenomenal numbers on crime reduction. That being said when two wonderful people end up dead in their own home, those crime statistics fall kind of flat," LAPD Deputy Chief Marla Ciuffetelli told town hall attendees. The LAPD said they've ramped up patrols throughout the Encino area, where the couple lived, as some residents now say they are worried about crime in the neighborhood. 'The crime is out of control,' Encino resident Deborah Palace told Eyewitness News. 'You don't even feel safe going to sleep in your own home.' Boodarian, who had battery charges against him dismissed before he was placed in a conservatorship last year, was arrested five days after the killing 'without incident,' police said. Three misdemeanor cases against Boodarian were dismissed last year, with court documents revealing that in the months prior, he was deemed mentally incompetent. After a mental health evaluation, he was then placed in a conservatorship, allowing another adult to be in charge of his major life decisions, according to NBC Los Angeles. The mental health evaluation's findings were not made public, but court records indicated that he was released from jail. Boodarian's also faced charges of brandishing a knife and criminal threats against his stepfather in 2023, as well as battery against his mother and sister in 2024. All three misdemeanor cases were dismissed late last year. The Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office declined to say how Boodarian's mental health evaluation may affect their ability to prosecute the new murder case. Authorities said Kaye and Deluca were shot to death on July 10, around the same time that a neighbor called 911 to report seeing a man scaling a wall that surrounds their home. 'While there were no signs of forced entry or trouble at the location during the investigation, it is now believed that the suspect had gained entry into the residence through an unlocked door,' police said. Kaye and Deluca had returned home to find the suspect, which ultimately led to a deadly confrontation. Boodarian is believed to have run away after the shooting. The couple hadn't been seen for several days when officers were called back to the home for a welfare check and found their bodies. According to local reports, the pair was found in different rooms of their home, with Deluca in the bathroom and Kaye in the pantry. The couple died from multiple gunshot wounds, authorities said. Kaye worked as a music supervisor for American Idol from 2002 to 2023, according to her IMDb biography. She contributed to nearly 300 episodes of the singing competition show. She also won three Guild of Music Supervisors awards for her contributions to the reality show. Before working on the talent show, Kaye launched her own record company, SyncroniCity, in 2000. Deluca also had a music career, working as a songwriter and musician. His album 'Down To The Wire' was released by Epic Records in 1986, according to his website. His most recent effort, 'Street Rock,' came out in 2022. A spokesperson for American Idol said they were 'devastated to hear of Robin and her dear husband, Tom's, passing.' "Robin has been a cornerstone of the 'Idol' family since 2009 and was truly loved and respected by all who came in contact with her. Robin will remain in our hearts forever and we share our deepest sympathy with her family and friends during this difficult time,' the statement continued. Their deaths are being investigated by the Los Angeles Police Department's Valley Bureau Homicide Division.


The Independent
3 minutes ago
- The Independent
Trump administration orders DoJ to question Ghislaine Maxwell on Epstein
The Justice Department plans to contact Ghislaine Maxwell to obtain additional information concerning the case of paedophile financier Jeffrey Epstein. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche announced the move, stating he expects to meet with Maxwell soon, acting under the direction of Attorney General Pam Bondi. Maxwell, an associate of Epstein, is serving a 20-year sentence after her 2021 conviction on charges related to her role in a scheme to abuse multiple minor girls with the deceased financier. This development follows the DOJ's recent memo which concluded that its review of Epstein's files did not uncover evidence of further third-party wrongdoing or a so-called 'client list'. Maxwell's attorney confirmed discussions with the department, saying his client would testify truthfully, and motions have been filed to unseal grand jury transcripts in the Epstein and Maxwell cases.


The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
Epstein bombshell as Trump official offers to MEET Ghislaine Maxwell after her family fear ‘she'll be killed like perv'
A LEADING Trump official has announced his intention to seek a meeting with Jeffrey Epstein's associate Ghislaine Maxwell. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche today revealed his plans to meet with the disgraced British socialite. 7 7 7 7 7 He posted on X: "Justice demands courage. "For the first time, the Department of Justice is reaching out to Ghislaine Maxwell to ask: what do you know?" He added that he had contacted Maxwell's counsel on the direction of Attorney General Pam Bondi. "I intend to meet with her soon. No one is above the law—and no lead is off-limits," he wrote. Maxwell is currently serving a 20-year prison sentence after being found guilty of child sex trafficking and other crimes. But her family has suggested that "government misconduct" could be used as new evidence to challenge her imprisonment. Her brother Ian Maxwell, 68, hopes to get her out of jail using new evidence. He recently told the Daily Mail that he fears for his sister's life. A statement from Blanche posted on Bondi's X account reads: "President Trump has told us to release all credible evidence. If Ghislane Maxwell has information about anyone who has committed crimes against victims, the FBI and the DOJ will hear what she has to say. "Therefore, at the direction of Attorney General Bondi, I have communicated with counsel for Ms. Maxwell to determine whether she would be willing to speak with prosecutors from the Department. "I anticipate meeting with Ms. Maxwell in the coming days. "Until now, no administration on behalf of the Department had inquired about her willingness to meet with the government. That changes now." Maxwell's attorney David Oscar Markus told Axios that discussions with the government are underway. Since Epstein's death, speculated has been rife that he blackmailed prominent figures involved with his heinous crimes. It comes after the final footage of Jeffrey Epstein alive was finally released six years after his death. He was in prison at the time as he waited for a major trial over sex-trafficking charges. 7 7 The disgraced financier was found hanged in jail on the 10 August, 2019. But ever since his death there has been speculation and conspiracy theories that others were involved. The Department of Justice (DoJ) announced this month that Epstein died by suicide - despite rife conspiracy theories to the contrary. One key claim centres around a rumoured client list of individuals - although the Trump administration has now denied this list exists. Maxwell's brother told the Daily Mail: "There's such overcrowding in Tallahassee that higher-category prisoners are being placed there and it's becoming a facility that is more dangerous – we've got to get her out of there. "Normally she spends a lot of time in the prison library helping other prisoners with things like form filling, but she has to go from A to B and isn't always surrounded by guards. "It's a possibility someone might get to her. "I don't want to be dramatic but you can't discount it. Look what happened to Epstein."