logo
After study on insurer profits, Florida regulators didn't follow up, author says

After study on insurer profits, Florida regulators didn't follow up, author says

Miami Herald03-04-2025

Last month, Florida's current and former insurance regulators said the state never finished a 2022 study showing insurers losing millions of dollars while their affiliates were making billions.
On Thursday, the author of that study said she believed it was completed and that regulators never told her it wasn't.
'In our mind, we had our final draft,' said Jan Moenck, an analyst with the Connecticut-based company hired by regulators to produce the report.
To some lawmakers, the testimony appeared to contradict testimony by Office of Insurance Regulation Commissioner Mike Yaworsky and past Commissioner David Altmaier.
'What is being revealed basically said they lied to us,' said Rep. Dianne Hart, D-Tampa.
Yaworsky strongly denied that he misled lawmakers.
'The idea that I lied somehow around that is just flatly false,' he said after the hearing.
Last month, House Speaker Daniel Perez, R-Miami, ordered hearings by a House committee after the Herald/Times revealed that the state had commissioned a study examining insurers' use of affiliate companies.
Florida-based insurance companies have long used affiliate companies, which charge the insurance company for services, such as handling claims or writing policies, sometimes at inflated prices.
The state's study, capturing data between 2017 and 2019, was the deepest dive into the business practice. Moenck found that Florida-based insurers had a net loss of $432 million, while their affiliates had a net income of $1.8 billion.
The industry overall spent $680 million on dividends to shareholders during the period.
The report was produced in April 2022, at the height of the insurance crisis, but never given to lawmakers. Instead, lawmakers focused on making it harder to sue insurance companies.
Altmaier, who commissioned the report, told lawmakers last month that the initial report 'certainly raised some red flags,' and his office intended to follow up.
Yaworsky said he didn't learn of the report until October 2024, when the Herald/Times' lawyers demanded his office turn it over. The newspapers first requested it in 2022, before Altmaier left the office.
Yaworsky said the report was incomplete because 23% of insurance companies never responded to the office's request for data and because it didn't provide the level of detail of insurers' finances that the state needed.
Moenck agreed that it is up to the client to decide when a report is finished. She said more information on finances would be helpful but difficult to obtain.
'I don't know that a person would ever be able to capture that unless you had a forensic accountant looking at each company on an individual basis,' Moenck said.
After turning over her report in 2022, she said she asked whether regulators wanted a verbal presentation about her findings or had any other questions.
'We did not receive any requests for additional work or follow-up on the reports,' Moenck said.
Committee chairperson Brad Yeager, R-New Port Richey, said the fact that regulators didn't follow up was 'telling.'
At least one more hearing, to find forensic accountants who can investigate further, will be scheduled, Yeager said.
'We've asked questions and we've gotten good answers, but I think those good answers have provided more questions and some concern,' he said.
Earlier Thursday, his committee advanced a bill that would require insurance companies to turn over more details about their relationships with affiliate companies.
'The report, I think, made everybody step back,' said the bill sponsor, Rep. Griff Griffitts, R-Panama City Beach, referring to the 2022 report brought to light by the Herald/Times.
Yaworsky said he welcomed getting more details about insurance companies' practices. He has asked for more oversight of insurers' affiliate companies.
'For years now, we have called for more scrutiny in this space,' Yaworsky said. 'We've gotten some, but at other times, the Legislature has said 'No thank you.''

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

GOP leadership unleashes fury on Dem governor ahead of blockbuster congressional hearing
GOP leadership unleashes fury on Dem governor ahead of blockbuster congressional hearing

Yahoo

time11 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

GOP leadership unleashes fury on Dem governor ahead of blockbuster congressional hearing

FIRST ON FOX: House Republican leadership slammed Democratic Gov. Tim Walz ahead of a blockbuster congressional hearing addressing sanctuary city policy this week. GOP Whip and Minnesota Rep. Tom Emmer wished Walz "good luck" before the former vice presidential candidate is set to testify alongside Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker and New York Gov. Kathy Hochul at a House Oversight Committee hearing on Thursday. "From hurling outrageous insults against ICE agents to offering a multitude of taxpayer-funded benefits to illegal aliens in Minnesota, Tim Walz's immigration agenda can be summed up easily: pro-illegal alien, anti-Minnesotan," GOP Whip Emmer told Fox News Digital. "If Tim Walz thinks he will be able to defend his abysmal record before Congress, then he's even more of a buffoon than I thought. I only have one thing to say to Timmy as he heads to Washington this week: GOOD LUCK." Handful Of House Democrats Join Republicans In Sanctuary City Crackdown Emmer paired his comments to Fox News Digital with a new video slamming Walz's various immigration policies titled "Protecting Illegals, Not Minnesotans: That's the Walz Way." Read On The Fox News App The three "sanctuary governors" will face a barrage of questions from members of the committee this week, as anti-ICE riots raged in Los Angeles over the weekend and the Trump administration continues to ramp up deportations across the country. Though the term "sanctuary city" is not legally defined, illegal immigrants will flock to the mainly Democrat-led regions to reduce the likelihood of deportation. Sanctuary cities often refuse Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) requests for information, like arrests or releases, and typically deny ICE detainer requests to hold jailed illegal migrants beyond their release date. California Republicans Slam Newsom, Bass For Letting La Burn With Riots Amid Trump Immigration Blitz House Oversight Chairman James Comer, R-Kentucky, said in a media advisory for the upcoming hearing that "The governors of these states must explain why they are prioritizing the protection of criminal illegal aliens over the safety of U.S. citizens." "Sanctuary policies only provide sanctuaries for criminal illegal aliens." Comer explained. "Former President Biden created the worst border crisis in U.S. history and allowed criminal illegal aliens to flood our communities." "The Trump Administration is taking decisive action to deport criminal illegal aliens from our nation but reckless sanctuary states like Illinois, Minnesota, and New York are actively seeking to obstruct federal immigration enforcement." 'Sick Puppy' Tim Walz Should Never Have Been On Dems' 2024 Ticket, Trump Says The hearing is scheduled for Thursday, June 12 at 10 a.m. ET. Fox News Digital reached out to Walz but did not receive a article source: GOP leadership unleashes fury on Dem governor ahead of blockbuster congressional hearing

Republican rep indicates he will be 'a no' on Trump-backed rescissions measure if AIDS relief cut
Republican rep indicates he will be 'a no' on Trump-backed rescissions measure if AIDS relief cut

Yahoo

time11 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Republican rep indicates he will be 'a no' on Trump-backed rescissions measure if AIDS relief cut

As the Trump administration and congressional Republicans eye passage of a rescission proposal, Rep. Don Bacon, a Nebraska Republican who doesn't shy away from bucking President Donald Trump, has indicated that he won't support it if it guts an AIDS relief program. The president's proposed clawbacks include millions of dollars pertaining to global health programs. "I told them I'm a no," the congressman said of the measure, according to the New York Times. "I just want to make sure we're funding the medicine. We want to prevent AIDS, it's a noble program, it's George Bush's legacy. I put the marker out there; we'll see." In a post on X last week, Bacon described "The President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR)" as "a noble program that America can be proud of funding." But in a statement to Fox News Digital on Monday, Bacon said, "If PEPFAR is gutted, I am a no. But I'm told that only parts of the program will be cut. I'll need more details," The rescission package "proposes to rescind $400 million from the PEPFAR program, which is appropriated $4.4 billion annually to provide bilateral assistance to countries, many of which do not support American interests, such as South Africa," a White House official told Fox News on Monday. Read On The Fox News App House Republicans Push For Spending Cancellations As Elon Musk And Conservatives Demand Deeper Budget Cuts "The $400 million rescission eliminates wasteful programming that does not serve the American taxpayer," the official said, while maintaining that the "package does NOT rescind any life-saving assistance and in fact, continues to make available billions of resources to implement life-saving medicine, medical services, as well costs necessary to deliver these services to maintain all current individuals on treatment." Bacon was the only House Republican to vote against a measure to rename the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America. "I thought it was dumb. That's what people told me — they said, 'It's so dumb; just vote for it.' That argument didn't work on me," he said, according to the Times. Gop Lawmaker Blasts 'Dumb' Trump Comment On Zelenskyy Despite 'Perfect' Criticism Of Putin House leaders have pressed Bacon to keep more of his views to himself, telling him to, as the congressman put it, "quit kicking President Trump in the nuts," the outlet reported. But the lawmaker indicated that he would only press back when he believes it is needed. "You can't be anti-everything," Bacon noted, according to the outlet. "I like what the president has done on the border, so I have no problem with that." "I'd like to fight for the soul of our party," he said, according to the Times. "I don't want to be the guy who follows the flute player off the cliff. I think that's what's going on right now." Pro-ukraine Gop Rep. Bacon Declares 'Real Republicans Know That Putin's Russia Hates The West And Freedom' Bacon has served in the House of Representatives since article source: Republican rep indicates he will be 'a no' on Trump-backed rescissions measure if AIDS relief cut

DNC chair ripped David Hogg over party infighting in leaked meeting audio: 'Really frustrating'
DNC chair ripped David Hogg over party infighting in leaked meeting audio: 'Really frustrating'

Fox News

time18 minutes ago

  • Fox News

DNC chair ripped David Hogg over party infighting in leaked meeting audio: 'Really frustrating'

Several Democratic National Committee officers are accusing DNC vice chair David Hogg of leaking an audio recording exposing infighting, as the 25-year-old progressive reformer faces possible ouster. Politico first obtained about two minutes of audio from a May 15 Zoom call in which Democratic National Committee Chair Ken Martin is heard accusing Hogg of impacting his ability to lead. Hogg, 25, was elected vice chair in February but is currently at risk of losing that role after stirring tensions with party leadership. A survivor of the 2018 Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting in Parkland, Florida, Hogg has been vocal about how his group, Leaders We Deserve, is planning to spend $20 million to support progressive – and primarily younger – candidates challenging incumbent Democrats in safe districts during the next election. "It has plenty of warts, and we're all trying to change those, for sure, but the longer we continue this fight, the harder it is for us to actually do what we all want to do, which is make a difference in this country again," Martin said in the recording, as the party is trying to regroup following Democrats' 2024 election defeat. About 10 people were on the call, including Hogg, other DNC officers and staff, according to Politico. "I deeply respect you, David. I, too, was looking forward to working with you, but this has created a situation, and I'll be very honest with you, for the first time in my 100 days on this job," Martin continued, "The other night I said to myself for the first time, 'I don't know if I want to do this anymore.' And partly, not because of the stress and all the naysayers, right? I'm used to that. I spent 14 years as a chair. I'm used to getting beat up on." "But you know, this is, this is really, everything you know from this election, this credentials report, how Malcom's been treated in this to you know, the fact the election itself, how Shasti and Jeanna were treated in this," Martin said. "I'm just quite frustrated to be in this position because what you've done, whether you like it or not, or know it or not, David, I'm trying to – no one knows who the hell I am, right? I'm trying to get my sea legs underneath of me and actually develop any amount of credibility, so I can go out there and raise the money and do the job I need to to put ourselves in a position to win." "And again, I don't think you intended this, but you essentially destroyed any chance I have to show the leadership that I need to," Martin said. "So, it's really frustrating." Several party officers alleged in statements to Fox News Digital that Hogg was behind the audio leak. "Breaking news: a human being had a frustrating day at work. That's all Ken expressed on that call – I was there," DNC Vice Chair Malcolm Kenyatta said. "For weeks, I've pointed out David's causal relationship with the truth. He proves he has no relationship with integrity if he's willing to record and leak private conversations." "The Democratic Party is not the past. The Democratic Party is what we do next. The endless, self-serving narratives – and the deliberate leaking of private conversations – by David Hogg and his allies must stop," Jane Kleeb, president of the Association of State Democratic Committees, said in a statement to Fox News Digital. "Instead of helping to rebuild the party he's supposed to serve, he's attacking it for personal gain," Kleeb continued. "That might boost his PAC's fundraising, but it erodes trust in the very institution we're trying to reform and strengthen. I'm proud of Chair Martin and the reforms we're advancing, which includes keeping the DNC out of primaries so voters decide on Democratic nominees. Just this past month, we made historic gains in traditional red states like Nebraska and Mississippi. People's lives will be better. That's the work that matters." The Democratic National Committee is holding an electronic vote beginning Monday on whether to nullify the February elections of Hogg and Kenyatta as vice chairs. Oklahoma DNC member Kalyn Free filed a formal complaint with the DNC alleging that the February election of the two male vice chairs violated the DNC's gender-balanced rules, yet Hogg has claimed the DNC is using the vote to push for his ouster as he tries to reform the party. Hogg responded to the leaked audio in a statement to X. "There's a lot going on right now. Here's what matters: Trump just nationalized California's national guard in his latest step on his authoritarian march to stomp out dissent against mass deportations," Hogg said, referring to the anti-Immigration and Customs Enforcement riots in Los Angeles. "Republicans want us turning on each other so they can continue getting away with this. While Chair Martin and I have had our disagreements we are both in this to build the strongest party possible." "Our nation is in a moment of crisis and the people are looking for us to lead," Hogg said. "This is a distraction that prevents us from doing that. Do not help the GOP." Hogg also said that "a lot of people are accusing me of leaking this recording," sharing messages from the Politico reporter seeking comment on the story. He did not affirm or deny whether he was behind the leak. "BS. It was you. Everyone knows it," New York Democratic state Sen. James Skoufis responded on X. "Leaking audio of a private call with party leadership is a disgrace and shows how deeply unserious and uncommitted you are to building a better, stronger, more inclusive Democratic Party." Martin, meanwhile, said in a statement that he's "not going anywhere," and he took the job as DNC chair "to fight Republicans, not Democrats." "As I said when I was elected, our fight is not within the Democratic Party, our fight is and has to be solely focused on Donald Trump and the disastrous Republican agenda," he said. "That's the work that I will continue to do every day." In statements to Fox News Digital, more DNC officers voiced support for Martin, as well as condemnation of Hogg. "We have a lot of work to do as a party, and Chair Martin is doing it," DNC Associate Chair Stuart Applebaum said. "I have total confidence in his leadership. The stakes are so high right now that we can't afford distractions like the ones that David is creating." "Like Chair Martin said, infighting is a waste of time when Donald Trump and the Republican Congress is taking healthcare and food away from millions of Americans," DNC Vice Chair Artie Blanco said. "Ken wouldn't be here today if not for SNAP and Medicaid. That's the type of passionate leadership we should want for our party. The fact that someone would secretly record and share audio of him candidly discussing that is more a reflection of their character than the Chair's. Begs the question, what are their true intentions." DNC Associate Chair Shasti Conrad, who was briefly mentioned on the recording, said in a statement to Fox News Digital, "During the DNC Officers call, we all were operating under the assumption that this was a confidential call amongst colleagues. Does David Hogg benefit from this? Yes. Regardless, how are we able to lead if there is no trust?" Fox News Digital also reached out to Hogg and Leaders We Deserve seeking comment on the recording, but they have yet to provide a response.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store