‘Bewilderment': Open disgust as four umpire dramas rock Aussies
Third umpire Adrian Holdstock was the central figure in four DRS controversies on day two of the Frank Worrell Trophy series opener in Bridgetown, two of which involved West Indies captain Roston Chase.
During the opening over of the day, the West Indies were 4-57, still trailing by 123 runs, when Chase squeezed an in-ducker from Australian seamer Josh Hazlewood towards fine leg for a single.
Believing the ball had grazed the front pad, Australian skipper Pat Cummins called for a review, with the tourists celebrating after a spike appeared on Ultraedge the frame before the ball struck Chase's bat.
However, the Australians were left baffled when Holdstock handed down a not-out verdict, with Cummins and Hazlewood seeking clarification from the on-field officials.
'Hazlewood was a little bit concerned. He thought there might have been just a little bit of a spike, hitting the pad first,' former Australian batter Greg Blewett said in commentary.
'I actually think the right decision was made.'
(it'll never happen) specialist tv umps for test cricket #WIvAUS https://t.co/fu6LZJHqMG
— Adam Collins (@collinsadam) June 26, 2025
Former West Indies all-rounder Carlos Brathwaite later explained that Holdstock ignored the spike because it took place between frames on the vision.
'That little spike in the frame before, I'm being told, is in between frames,' Brathwaite said.
'Anything in the centre of (the graphic) is what they consider to be the Ultraedge frame, not the edges on the left or right.'
Chase, unbeaten on 1 when the incident occurred, survived through to lunch unscathed, combining with wicketkeeper Shai Hope for a 67-run partnership for the sixth wicket to swing momentum back in the West Indies' favour.
However, the right-hander was given out LBW early in the afternoon session after Cummins produced an unplayable delivery that kept low and struck him on the knee roll.
Believing there had been an inside edge, Chase immediately called for a review, but because the bat and pad were close together, there was no obvious spike on Ultraedge, with Holdstock upholding the on-field decision.
Chase departed for 44, but former West Indies bowler Ian Bishop suggested there was a small deviation as the ball passed his bat.
'I disagree with the decision,' Bishop said in commentary.
'I disagree with the technology there, I thought he hit that.
'I feel sorry for the officiating team there, but in my view, that clearly should have been not out.
'(Chase) is in bewilderment.'
Former West Indies seamer Shakeera Selman continued: 'It seemed to have taken the inside edge of the bat.
'We all felt there was an edge before it came into contact with the pad.'
Clearly Roston Chase felt the inside edge as he signalled for the DRS almost immediately. Visual evidence backed it too - the big deviation. TV ump choosing to not rely on UltraEdge murmur as well as visual deflection was kinda baffling... #WIvAUS
— S Sudarshanan (@Sudarshanan7) June 26, 2025
Guys…did Roston Chase not edge that ball onto his pad? Please help me here - that seemed a poor use of technology #WIvAUS
— Carl Lewis (@Carl_LewisZA) June 26, 2025
The drama didn't stop there — later in the afternoon session, Hope was dismissed for 48 after Australian wicketkeeper Alex Carey held onto a stunning one-handed chance low to his left, caught off the inside edge.
However, the on-field umpires requested for Holdstock to check the grounding, with the third official awarding the dismissal after consulting slow-motion replays that suggested the ball may have touched the ground despite never leaving Carey's outstretched glove.
West Indies coach Darren Sammy threw his arms up in disgust when the verdict appeared on the big screen, with the crowd also voicing their disbelief.
the fact carey actually celebrated this catch!!?!? #WIvAUS pic.twitter.com/ZLTIyqClJY
— Long Live Test Cricket (@LongLiveTest) June 26, 2025
That old debate of whether Alex Carey was in control of the ball, and whether he was in control of his body. All down to interpretation, that beautiful word in every umpire’s textbook
— Bharat Sundaresan (@beastieboy07) June 26, 2025
'The emotions at the ground are a little bit high at the moment,' Blewett said.
'It appears as though it touches the ground.
'I agree with the sentiments of the West Indies dressing room that they feel like they've been on the wrong end of some of the calls today.'
Former West Indies spinner Samuel Badree continued: 'It's unfortunate, it really is unfortunate.'
Holdstock was thrown into the spotlight yet again during Australia's second innings when the West Indies reviewed an LBW decision against Cameorn Green, who was unbeaten on 14.
Slow-motion replays and Ultraedge suggested the ball may have brushed his pad before hitting the bat, but the West Australian survived the marginal chance — much to Sammy's disappointment.
Holdstock adjudicated that the noise on Ultraedge came from bat hitting back pad, but not everyone was convinced.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
31 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Ray Thomas and Shayne O'Cass analyse every race at Rosehill on Saturday
The Daily Telegraph racing editor Ray Thomas and form expert Shayne O'Cass debate the chances across 10 races at the McKell Cup meeting at Rosehill Gardens on Saturday. â– â– â– â– â– SUGGESTED BETS RAY'S BEST VALUE BET Race 7 No.3: HOPEFUL SHAYNO'S BEST Race 6 No.8: USEAPIN VALUE BET Race 7 No.6: MORMONA â– â– â– â– â– RACE 1: MIDWAY HCP (1300m) Ray Thomas: CRAFTY EAGLE (1) has improved steadily with each run this preparation and indicated he was close to top form again with a closing third to King Of Rouseau over this course and distance last start. He was forced back to the near the inside which wasn't the place to be last start and still ran on strongly. With the claim, he's not badly in at the weights and he's ready to win. MISS SPACEGIRL (11) and PRESIDES (7) are both very genuine and will be the mix, while HOW MUCH BETTER (10) was very good first-up and should improve. Shayne O'Cass: PRETTY TAVI (12) has a very famous seventh dam, none other than Chicquita who was a champion on and off the track, RT. He had quite good form in Victoria but was never what you call 'city class'. That's not the case now that he is in NSW, Hawkesbury to be precise. His three Midway runs, all of them very good. KHUMBILA (6) is ready, in fact is crying out for 1300m third-up. He has finally drawn a good alley and that could make all the difference. ROLLING MAGIC (2) has some solid formlines. King Of Roseau breaks the 532 day drought with a great win at Rosehill! ðŸ'¥ @djgibbons22 | @SnowdenRacing1 — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 14, 2025 RACE 2: TAB HIGHWAY (1500m) Thomas: I've got Brett Cavanough going 1-2 with NEW PHARAOH (5) and WARRIOR FOR PEACE (3), Shayno. New Pharaoh was trapped three-wide most of the way and still ran on strongly late to just miss a place over this trip late last month. New Pharaoh, who finished right alongside stablemate Warrior For Peace (third) last start meets his stablemate better at the weights and he's drawn to get the right run. Warrior For Peace is going to be hard to beat again. THINK LIKE PADDY (1) was competitive at Group 3 level in Brisbane last start and this is much easier. TO BE FRANK (8) is a chance at odds. O'Cass: RED RAGS TO BULLS (10) has contested two Highways prior to this, finishing third to Super Norwest in the first and fourth to the same horse here at Rosehill two weeks ago. If he is going to win one, probably this is the one. THINK LIKE PADDY (1) ticks all the boxes so let me just throw in a bit of trivia regarding the name, RT. He is by So You Think and was bred by Patrick Hogan (who used to call Sir Tristram – Paddy). This is Sir Patrick's amazing Gay Poss family. Thomas: Love your work, Shayno. In the third, I don't think there is much between PUNTIN (9) and TASORAAY (10). I'm leaning to Puntin after his good first-up effort when he was narrowly beaten at Canterbury. The step up to 1400m suits, he's very consistent and will be in the finish. Tasoraay might have gone too hard in front and was ambushed late by Don't Forget Jack last start. He will at his peak after two runs from a spell and will take running down. DON'T FORGET JACK (3) appreciated the solid tempo and overwhelmed his rivals with a fast finishing effort two weeks ago. If this race is run to suit, he will be hard to hold out again. NORTHERN EYES (2) is very genuine and deserves a win. O'Cass: I'm going with a horse than ran 11th of 12 at Randwick last Saturday – PRETTY POWERFUL (12). His run was best summed up by the stewards – 'began awkwardly, held up over the final 400m and, as a result, was unable to be fully tested'. And that's putting it mildly! Can't imagine the same thing happening this weekend with barrier 11 of 12. I've always been a fan of AGITA (11). This is a nice race for the son of Adelaide to resume in. KADAL (6) has finished on the podium at 15 of 21 starts. Deserves another win and is getting close too. Don't Forget Jack gets back to form with the perfect run at Rosehill! ðŸ'� @NockBraith | @ANeashamRacing — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 14, 2025 RACE 4: PRECISE AIR HCP (1400m) Thomas: WEEPING WOMAN (5) led for a long way only to be collared in the final few bounds by the very promising Sacred Rocks over 1300m here two weeks ago. She will be fitter after two runs from a spell and she gets any sort of control up front, she will be tough to catch. CAPTAIN AMELIA (1) has been improved by recent racing and is on the quick back-up after her solid effort when fourth as favourite at Randwick last week. She's worth another chance. CHANGING COLOURS (7) is very consistent but finds it hard to win. SUPER NORWEST (10) won a Highway last start and has each way claims. O'Cass: PANJATI (6) was a $500,000 yearling, not so much because she is a Pierro, but the fact that her third dam is the broodmare gem, Shantha's Choice, dam of Redoute's Choice, Manhattan Rain and Platinum Scissors. Gerald Ryan co-trains Pajanti, he also trained her handy mother, Crystal Flute. As for Pajanti, she can't get to 1400m fast enough. WEEPING WOMAN (5) has been a very costly conveyance at her two runs this time; but in her defence, she struck a Heavy 8 first-up then drew 12 of 12 the next time and was only beaten a neck. CHANGING COLOURS (7) hasn't missed a medal in eight starts. Thomas: LIVIN' THING (3) unleashed an impressive burst of acceleration to race away from his rivals at a Kensington midweek meeting last start. He's up in grace here but gets in well at the weights after the claim. MANAAJEM (13) was beaten as an odds-on favourite first-up at Warwick Farm but she's fitter and will improve on the drier track here. KING'S SECRET (5) has his chance when unplaced in a strong form race last start and he's also worth another chance. SOVEREIGN HILL (7) showed talent last season but is resuming off a long spell but he's trialling well. O'Cass: USEAPIN (8) is a Chris Waller-trained filly by one of his two Everest winners – Yes Yes Yes. She's won three of her nine starts, albeit at the NSW provincials but she has run some honourable races when tried in town against the likes of More Territories and Aeliana no less. She was never let loose in either trial so watch for market moves. RANTAN (6) had no luck at Gosford there on Cup day in what has turned out to be a very strong form race. SPYWIRE (1) is almost certainly the best horse in the race and I will be watching if they back him. Livin' Thing records an impressive win in Race 4 at Randwick Kensington. @JohnOSheaRacing — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 11, 2025 RACE 6: SCHWEPPES HCP (1500m) Thomas: MICKEY'S MEDAL (7) is in a rich vein of form although this is toughest test. He's won successive Rosehill 1500m races and is so genuine, he will be in the mix again. THUNDERLIPS (2) was held up for a run but when the gap came he burst through to score an impressive win. He's also racing in top form and carries weight well. SIR ARTIE (3) ran well first-up and can only improve. GREEN SHADOWS (1) ran a blinder in the Civic Stakes last week this easier race sets up well for him. O'Cass: I've got TESTATOR SILENS (5) to do the ultimate form reversal here, RT. He was rock solid in betting when third-up here two weeks ago but as it turned out, he never passed a horse. Nothing in the stewards' report to shed light on the poor performance so we just have to write it off to horses not being machines. Me? I do think the 4kg reduction in weight will help. THUNDERLIPS (2) deserves so much praise for that win at Randwick last start. GREEN SHADOWS (1) is all but pitched in here with 57kg. Thomas: HOPEFUL (3) hasn't won a race for over three years but this might be his chance. He stuck to his task in the Winter Cup last start to finish a close third and if he can repeat that effort, he will go close to winning. CASUAL CONNECTION (8) won well at Randwick then led for a long way under a big weight before his close second to Tympanist at Kensington. He drops 5kg and rates highly although the wetter the better for him. BACIO DEL MIST (10) got too far back in the Winter Cup but her effort tin the Lord Mayor's Cup two starts back indicates she can be competitive here. ALEGRON (2) has been struggling this campaign but if anywhere near his best, he would win this race. O'Cass: MORMONA (6) has been on my radar since before and after he resumed in the Lord Mayors Cup where he ran an eye-catching seventh of 14. He followed that up with a sixth of 14 in the Winter Cup up against a fair few of this weekend's Stayers Cup rivals. By the way, this race should be 3200m if you ask me! I agree with HOPEFUL (3) – he's certainly overdue for another win. The one thing you know about CASUAL CONNECTION (8), he will stay the trip. What a finish at Rosehill! Sir Lucan fights off Bear On The Loose to win the Listed Winter Cup! â�'ï¸� — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 14, 2025 RACE 8: ASAHI SUPER DRY HCP (1800m) Thomas: FEDERER (12) went back to the inside which was inferior going early in the straight then was guided back out wider before he ran eighth to Thunderlips at Randwick when resuming. There were excuses for his last start effort and he did show considerable potential when last in work. PIGGYBACK (10) can give trainer Ciaron Maher a stable quinella. She's racing well and wasn't disgraced when a close third to Shohisha in a slowly run race at Randwick last start. Drawn to get the right run and will be very competitive. PURE ALPHA (9) and MISTERKIPCHOGE (15) haven't been far away in recent starts and find themselves in a winnable race. O'Cass: I was moderately keen on LENAPE VIBE (14) second-up but few were as he drifted from $51 to $61. Maybe he was run short, RT, but there is no doubt that he should have finished closer than he did. Take note he comes back from 2000m to 1800m but I'm mindful that he is one for one at the track and trip. KALZALARK (13) has raced himself into peak fitness now and gets to 1800m off his best run this time in. I can see where you are coming from with Federer. He will be fitter for his 'second serve'. Thomas: ELAMAZ (3) is a stakes winner in France who has not missed a top two finish in seven starts, winning four. He makes his Australian debut off three barrier trials where he has shown tactical speed. Promising and this is not a strong race. LOCH EAGLE (2) charged home to win over the Randwick mile course last start and he has won up to 1800m before. This is his first attempt at 2000m but the way he attacked the line last start suggests this is the right time to test his stamina reserves. ADELAIDE RIVER (1) did run fourth in the Caulfield Stakes at weight-for-age last sprint and is resuming off two slashing trial wins. He's very talented and looks to have returned in great order. GLORY DAZE (6) is racing in good form. O'Cass: ADELAIDE RIVER (1) boasts an absolutely fascinating CV. He is a son of Australia who won the English and Irish Derbies, just like his own father Galileo did. Adelaide River didn't win them but he ran in the English and Irish Derbies (second) as well as the French classic (which he ran second in as well). All we can say about the present day is that he is trialling like he is back in business. BELVEDERE BOYS (5) is two for two at the track and distance including a big win in the Country Classic. Thomas: LIBERTY STATE (10) resumed with a dominant win at Rosehill, unleashing from back in the field with a powerful finishing surge. She's a smart mare building a good record and she is protecting a perfect second-up record. LADY EXTREME (13) broke through for a deserved confidence-boosting win when resuming at Rosehill and she could got right on with it now. SNACK BAR (12) has had a few chances but can't be overlooked and UNSTOPABULL (9) ran well for third in a good form race last start. O'Cass: UNSTOPABULL (9) has a commendable overall record of 12 podium finishes from 20 starts and four of them are wins. I would venture to say a few of those eight placings could have been wins but for his pattern and/or circumstances beyond the horse's control. This is more or less his trip, RT, and with Jeff Penza on from a wide gate, it could be down the middle and over the top. FLYING DESTINY (5) has massive excuses for the first-up last at Canterbury when wide throughout being the gist. Drawn three this time. Liberty State returns after a spell with a big win in the last at Rosehill, and that's a double to @djgibbons22! 🥳 @HawkesRacing | @aus_turf_club — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) May 31, 2025
News.com.au
31 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Peter Snowden says promising mare Tashi is due for some luck in Group 1 Tatt's Tiara at Eagle Farm
Leading Sydney trainer Peter Snowden reckons his promising mare Tashi is due for some luck in Saturday's Group 1 Tatt's Tiara at Eagle Farm. The five-year-old mare has been agonisingly close to victories in her last three races, with the widest margin in those runner-up finishes being just half a length. Tashi goes into the $700,000 Tatt's Tiara (1400m) for fillies and mares as a $7.50 chance behind only the Chris Waller -trained Firestorm ($4.20) and Floozie ($4.40), who has won four straight races. 'She's been unlucky all right,' Snowden said about the daughter of Sebring. 'She's been racing really well but three times she's been beaten by a short half-head. 'It's been horrendous. She has been up for a really long time but I can't see any signs in her that she's had enough or she's tired. 'Her work has been great during the week and she looks in good order so hopefully there's one more peak performance in her. 'I'd love to see her win the Tatt's Tiara, that'd be fantastic.' Tashi has been remarkably consistent lately but the stats sheet still reads zero wins since she saluted in a Benchmark 88 (1200m) at Randwick in early March last year. Since that victory, she has finished runner-up five times from 12 races, including the last three. Another photo in the Listed Helen Coughlan Stakes at Eagle Farm with Zaszou getting there by a whisker! ðŸ'¸ @pstokesracing @Brown_ethan8 @BrisRacingClub — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 7, 2025 The mare has gone close in last month's Group 3 Hawkesbury Crown (1300m) won by City Of Lights, the Listed Helen Coughlan Stakes (1200m) at Eagle Farm claimed by Zaszou and the Group 2 Dane Ripper Stakes (1300m) two weeks ago when she charged home to almost beat Floozie. To compound Snowden's bad fortune this Queensland Winter Carnival, the appropriately named Need Some Luck narrowly missed out in the Listed Hinkler Handicap (1200m) at Eagle Farm and Media World was beaten by less than a quarter of a length in the Group 3 Fred Best Classic (1350m) at Doomben. 'We're hitting the crossbar all the time so we're due to get one between the posts,' he said. Meanwhile, punters have loaded up on the Kris Lees-trained Infancy, who has shortened this week from $35 to $19 in betting markets for the Tatt's Tiara, the final Group 1 of this season. The four-year-old mare has drawn the carpark with barrier 21 but Lees said it was 'not a big concern' for the backmarker. 'She gets back anyway and she's probably a better horse when she gets to the outside,' he said. 'I'd prefer a better gate but it's far from the end of the world. 'Floozie's the one to beat. She's a mare in form and you have to respect that but it's a typical mares' race – there's a stack of chances and she's one of them.' However, Infancy must pass a race-day vet check to take her place in the Group 1 after showing signs of lameness on Friday. Infancy won the Group 2 Sapphires Stakes (1200m) first-up at Randwick in April at odds of $21, beating star sprinters Commemorative and Lady Laguna. She then finished fifth in her next two 1200m races – on a bottomless track in the Listed ATC Trophy on the Gold Coast last month and in the Helen Coughlan Stakes three weeks ago when she couldn't find much room. Fairytale mare Adiella, trained by Toowoomba hobby trainer John Dann, will not take her place in the Group 1 Tatt's Tiara. Dann said the mare, who won a $500,000 race last start and was a $21 chance in the Tatt's Tiara, had banged her back leg and would be sent for a spell.
News.com.au
31 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Former Hall of Fame trainer takes aim at integrity officials in fight to resume training career
Former Hall of Fame greyhound trainer and convicted live baiter Ron Ball issued a stinging broadside to Queensland Racing Integrity Commission (QRIC) officials in a last-ditch attempt to return to the industry this week. Ball, who prepared the great Flying Amy during his six-decade training career, fronted the Queensland Racing Appeals Panel on Thursday in a bid to have a ten-year disqualification overturned. 83-year-old Ball was handed a life-ban for live baiting in 2015 before the penalty was sensationally slashed to 10-years on appeal, opening the door for a potential 2025 return to the training fold. • PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW! But in the lead up to the decade long ban expiring last month, QRIC officials disqualified Ball for a further 10-years, after he was found to be on the property and handling greyhounds of his partner and then licenced person Serena Lawrance back in October, 2022. 'They call themselves QRIC but it should just be QRC because the I stands for integrity and they don't have any,' Ball blasted at Thursday's appeal hearing. 'I served my 10 year punishment and when I go to make inquiries about reapplying for my licence, a matter from 2022 gets raised and dealt with without any communication with me at all. 'It just suits a narrative to keep me out of the industry. I believe I'm being discriminated and victimised against, it's unjust and excessive.' Ball went on to raise uncontested evidence from an internal QRIC review in 2022 after his partner Serena Lawrance's initial 18-month disqualification for allowing Ball onto her property was extended to 30 months. 'In that review, the body cameras worn by the QRIC inspectors were provided where they said words to the effect of 'she's not as fat as you said she was' as Serena was going to open the gate for them,' Ball said. When Panel Chair Kerry O'Brien quizzed Ball on the relevance of that to this appeal, Ball said that 'it spoke to the way they've been treated.' In response to Ball's representations, QRIC's legal representatives argued that stewards were well within their rights to impose the further penalty under Greyhounds Australasia (GA) Rule 179. The rule allows for the recommencement of a penalty if a person is found to have breached the rules while disqualified. 'Mr Ball failed to comply with the conditions of his warning off period,' QRIC's legal team said. 'If Mr Ball had welfare concerns about the greyhounds he should have raised those concerns with QRIC in the first instance. 'But instead Mr Ball chose to breach GA rule 178 which serves as a serious regulatory tool to safeguard the industry. 'He has demonstrated a pattern of non-compliance with the rules.' In return, Judge O'Brien said he was 'troubled' by the way in which the penalty had been handed down. 'Generally there would be a charge, submissions and the chance to respond before reaching a conclusion,' Judge O'Brien said. 'I accept there must be a consequence but there has been no charge issued in respect to rule 179 and no inquiry held. 'It was just concluded that Mr. Ball would be given 10 years.' The Appeals Panel said it was also reasonable for Mr Ball to accept correspondence from QRIC in April, 2024 that he would be free to reapply for his licence in 2025. 'Mr Ball isn't a lawyer,' Judge O'Brien said. 'In that correspondence there's no hint of a further breach and he has read the letter as any reasonable person would.' The Appeals Panel has reserved their decision until July 7.
