Chipman-area murder trial delayed over additional evidence
A trial for two people accused of murdering a New Brunswick man has been delayed over the need for lawyers to review newly disclosed evidence in the case.
Joshua McIsaac and Erica Blyth were supposed to go on trial on April 23 for first-degree murder in the death of Brandon Donelan..
However, on Wednesday, Court of King's Bench Justice Richard Petrie agreed to delay the trial to allow Crown and defence lawyers time to review additional evidence that has surfaced in the case.
"An adjournment of a trial of this magnitude is a big deal. It's something we try to avoid at all costs," said Crown prosecutor James McConnell, noting the impact on the victim's family.
"It's not something that we would raise lightly, but in order to have a fair trial, unfortunately, it's unavoidable."
Donelan's body was found in a wooded area between Minto and Chipman on March 31, 2022, about two months after he'd been reported as missing.
McIsaac and Blyth were jointly charged with first-degree murder, and six weeks had been set aside later this month for their jury trial.
McConnell agreed to review the new evidence and return to court on April 23 to provide it to defence lawyers for their own review.
A publication ban prevents CBC News from reporting on the nature of the evidence ahead of the trial.
Nathan Gorham, lawyer for McIsaac, and TJ Burke, lawyer for Blyth, both agreed to the delay, and confirmed their clients would waive their Charter right to be tried within a reasonable time.
Given the amount of new information that must be reviewed, both parties agreed not to schedule new trial dates until sometime after their next appearance.
McIsaac and Blyth appeared at the Burton courthouse in person for Wednesday's proceedings. The two have been in custody since being charged in June 2023.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
6 minutes ago
- CBC
B.C. mom picks up her son's ADHD medication, is given an opioid instead
A mother on Vancouver Island is warning people to double check their prescriptions after she was accidentally dispensed the powerful opioid hydromorphone instead of her son's regular ADHD medication. Comox, B.C., resident Sarah Paquin, 31, says she still shudders to think about what could have happened to her nine-year-old son had her husband not noticed the medication looked different before he gave it to him. "It was terrifying," Paquin said, standing in her front yard and playing with one of her three young boys. "One simple little mistake like that could have ended horribly." WATCH | 9-year-old dispensed opioid in pharmacy mix-up: Pharmacy mix-up leaves child with hydromorphone pills 15 hours ago Duration 1:58 A mother on Vancouver Island is warning people to check their prescriptions very carefully after a close call for their son. As Maryse Zeidler reports, she and her husband found that their pharmacy accidentally dispensed the wrong medication. Paquin says she didn't think too much of it when she went to pick up her son Declan's medication last week and the staff member at her local Shoppers Drug Mart pharmacy didn't check her ID or take out the prescription from the bag. The next day, her husband was about to give Declan his medication when he saw the pills were a different colour and shape than normal. Her husband looked at the bottle and noticed the prescription was for someone else, and that it was for five milligrams of hydromorphone. Right away he returned the pills to the pharmacy. "Immediately your mind goes to the worst case scenario," Paquin said. "The results could have been catastrophic and it just makes my heart sink to think about what could have happened." Hydromorphone is a powerful opioid that is two to eight times stronger than morphine and is often used to treat acute pain or chronic cancer pain. According to the Mayo Clinic, it can cause serious unwanted effects or fatal overdose in children. Human error CBC News reached out to Loblaws, the company that owns Shoppers Drug Mart. In a written statement, the company said the incident was a case of "human error" that never should have happened. "We have controls in place to minimize risks like this — where the patient was handed the wrong prescription bag — and the associate will review these with employees to avoid a similar situation in the future," the company said. Paquin says she has since heard from the pharmacist, who was very apologetic. She says he acknowledged that steps were missed and standards were dropped, and told her the employee who dispensed the medication has been suspended pending an internal investigation. Asking for accountability Despite his reassurances, Paquin has filed a complaint with the College of Pharmacists of B.C. "The pharmacy needs to take responsibility, be held accountable for what happened," she said. In an email, the college told CBC News it takes these types of errors very seriously. "We have legal requirements in the Health Professions Act bylaws in place to prevent these occurrences, including mandatory standards for prescription preparation to ensure accuracy of the prescription product and consultations for all prescriptions, to make sure clients understand their medication, how to take it properly, and address any questions," the college said. As part of pharmacists' consultation with clients, they are required to confirm the person's identity, name and the strength and purpose of the drug, it added. In 2023-24, the college says it received a total of 990 concerns through its intake process. Of those, 54 became formal complaints and investigations, 16 of which were medication related. Paquin decided to share her ordeal on social media, to warn others to check their prescription before taking it. "It's scary that it happened to us, but I'm also in a way kind of thankful that it happened to us and we caught it because it could have been given to somebody who didn't notice and got hurt," she said.
Montreal Gazette
3 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Man accused of McGill ghetto murder references synchronicity, quantum physics during testimony
Montreal Crime By François Pelletier continued his very confusing testimony Thursday in the trial where he is accused of stabbing Romane Bonnier to death in the McGill Ghetto in front of several stunned witnesses more than three years ago. Pelletier, 39, is acting as his own lawyer in the case at the Montreal courthouse, where he is charged with first-degree murder. On Wednesday, he made an opening statement to the jury during which he bluntly admitted he killed the 24-year-old woman by stabbing her 26 times. After he delivered the opening statement, he was sworn in and began to testify in his own defence. Without the aid of a lawyer, he set off on what has been a very long monologue. No one is asking Pelletier questions and while he told the jury he wants to explain what happened to Bonnier before they decide his fate, his testimony has been full of asides about things like what songs he was listening to after Bonnier agreed to let him be her roommate and he became obsessed with her. 'Let's just say there are many layers to this reality we are living,' he told the jury at one point. He said he was listening to Radiohead's Creep, Chris Isaak's Wicked Game and a song called Sunspots by Nine Inch Nails. '(Sunspots) is a rather powerful song,' he said, Besides the songs, Pelletier referenced synchronicity and quantum physics and claimed both were involved in his attraction to Bonnier. He also made references to his mental health, which led prosecutor Marianna Ferrero to object twice. Superior Court Justice François Dadour sustained both of the objections, a sign that Pelletier is not supposed to refer to his mental health. On Wednesday, Pelletier told the jury he would have preferred that a psychiatric evaluation on his mental health had been part of the evidence. Ferrero later made another objection when she noted that Pelletier has used the word 'f--k' many times while testifying. The Crown's theory is that, during 2021, Bonnier placed an ad seeking a roommate to share the rent on an apartment she was already living in. Pelletier replied to the ad and Bonnier agreed to let him live with her. They had a brief relationship, but Bonnier eventually put an end to it. Pelletier was unable to accept the breakup and texted Bonnier frequently. The Crown alleges that on Oct. 19, 2021, he staked out her workplace, a store owned by her parents, and followed her after she left before he stabbed her to death. 'She was a sophisticated schemer,' Pelletier said Thursday morning while claiming, as he does often, that Bonnier sometimes dressed in a way to attract him. 'She was dressed to kill. She was dressed to kill me,' Pelletier said during another part of his testimony. 'She was wearing a red dress that I remember to this day.'
Global News
19 hours ago
- Global News
Lawyer who attacked 80-year-old with knife in Deep Cove pleads guilty
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook A North Vancouver lawyer who attacked an 80-year-old man with a knife in Deep Cove last year has pleaded guilty to multiple charges. Alexander Currie admitted to attacking the senior on May 25, 2024, slashing his motorcycle helmet and narrowly missing causing him serious injury. On Wednesday, he entered guilty pleas to assault with a weapon, uttering threats and mischief. Currie had initially been charged with attempted murder. 0:56 Knife-wielding North Vancouver man facing charges after Deep Cove incident The court heard that he was having a manic episode at the time of the attack. Currie has a history of mental illness, but hadn't suffered an episode in 17 years. Story continues below advertisement The knife attack victim read a statement to the court, describing it as terrifying, after which Currie apologized for the trauma he'd caused. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The Crown and defence made a joint submission to the court, calling for a conditional discharge and citing Currie's lack of a criminal record and his determination to rebuild his life. The judge will hand down the sentence on June 13th. With files from Rumina Daya
