I tried seven brands of salted butter and the difference was a major surprise
Little did I know that this seemingly simple taste test would push me to the limits of human endurance, writes Vita Molyneux. Until you've tasted seven distinct butters in a mere 30 minutes, you can't truly understand what the body is capable of.
By mid way, I was struggling. Maybe I was being too generous with my spreading, or perhaps it was the 23-degree heat in my bedroom, but I did not feel great.
I stared down at three more butters feeling my arteries beginning to clog. My head was spinning and I needed a drink of water and a lie down.
I needed a piece of fresh fruit, I needed a hug. Instead I took a deep breath, reminded myself that this is my job and I'm extremely lucky to have it, and cracked on.
By the end, I believe I had transcended. But the results were in and I have declared a winner - and a loser. All the butters were left out on my counter for an hour to achieve the perfect spreadability, reports the Express.
The seven salted butters I sampled were: All Things Butter, Lurpak Slightly Salted, Kerrygold, Anchor, Tesco own brand, Aldi Cowbelle and Lidl Dairy Manor.
Lurpak
This is a classic. It's my usual purchase, but I must confess, I rarely indulge in just bread and butter, so I most often use it in cooking.
I had high expectations but, to be honest, Lurpak left me somewhat disappointed. It tasted a bit oilier than I anticipated, and the salt was more subtle than I prefer.
However, the texture and spreadability were good. Overall, Lurpak scores OK.
Rating: 6/10.
All Things Butter
The colour of this was a stunning rich yellow.
When I sliced off the piece I was going to taste I was taken aback by its crumbly texture.
However, after softening, the butter was rich, creamy and indulgent with the perfect level of salt.
This butter tasted like luxury, and I loved it!
Rating: 9/10.
Aldi Cowbelle
This one had the best spreadability so far - it went on the bread perfectly and was the saltiest of the bunch. There was an aftertaste of the sea, but I like the sea, so that's fine.
It had a rich, golden colour, and almost had a hint of garlic about it (although that could be the chopping board). Really lovely.
Rating: 8/10.
Kerrygold
The spreadability was a little poor, but it didn't tear the bread, which is always a good sign. It had the most gorgeous colour of all the butters, a stunning yellowish gold - I suppose it's in the name.
However, it wasn't very salty at all, and the texture was pretty nondescript. Overall, OK.
Rating: 6/10.
Lidl Dairy Manor
This butter was nearly white, and quite salty, with a slightly bitter aftertaste.
It had top-notch spreadability and I favour the saltier ones, so this gets an extra point.
Rating: 7/10.
Tesco
Tesco's own brand was a real let down. It was overly oily and lacked flavour with no real salty tang.
Despite its spreadability and appealing colour, I can only award Tesco a modest score.
Rating: 4/10.
Anchor
The final hurdle!
The end was in sight. This butter had a pleasing texture and was rich and creamy, although not as salty as I might prefer - instead it had that peculiar garlic undertone like the Aldi butter.
But again, that could very well have been my wooden chopping board.
It was satisfactory, but nothing exceptional, so it receives an in-between score.
Rating: 5/10.
Final thoughts
All Things Butter clinched the title for the best butter, and sadly, Tesco's own brand needs to be cast aside.
But overwhelmingly, I learned a crucial lesson - too much of a good thing is indeed a real phenomenon.
The next time I'm offered such a decadent taste test, I am calling for reinforcements. sent twice daily to your inbox
Look for places near you
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
2 days ago
- The Sun
Gardening pro's 3 key jobs to do this weekend to stop rose black spot – including £3 bloom boost
WE love a rose in the UK - and traditionally our gardens are stuffed full of beautiful blooms that have been bred for thousands of years. But how frustrating is it when you spot the rose leaves going yellow and starting to fall - or the beautiful buds refuse to open and shrivel up instead? 3 3 Black spot is the nemesis of all rose-growers - a fungal disease that first appears as black spots on the roses' leaves. Then the leaf will start to yellow - and fall off - usually spreading further down the plant. And although it doesn't kill the rose - it can weaken it - making it susceptible to other pests and diseases. Spores can overwinter on fallen leaves - and then infects the soil and then the plant next year. Fight against it by making sure that all the fallen leaves are thrown away - not put on the compost. And make sure the rose is pruned to allow enough air to move through the branches. Although proper hard rose pruning is generally done in late winter or early Spring - a light prune now won't be a problem. Also - mulching over winter can help. And make sure you're watering the base rather than from the top of the leaves. Give your rose a dose of proper liquid rose feed - Westland do a decent high performance liquid plant food which helps build resistance to disease. You can get it at Tesco for £8.99. Or Temu is selling Doff Rose and Shrub Feed for £2.89 - which helps maintain healthy roses. Finally - try and choose roses that are resistant to blackspot. Everyone can spot the pot plants - but you have 20-20 vision & high IQ if you can find five red roses in just 19 seconds The general advice with roses is not to plant them in the same soil that a previous rose was in. It can - in extreme cases - cause replant disease - which is where the rose will struggle to grow. You may even find it dies. It's because the roots won't establish properly. But the RHS recommends that you line the planting hole with a cardboard box with a hole in the bottom. By the time the cardboard box has rotted into the soil, the roots will have established. But if you're fed up of black spot, powdery mildew and rose rosette diseases - then have you considered growing a wild rose instead? They might not be quite as extravagant and blingy as the cultivated varieties - but wild roses - known as 'Species Roses' in the catalogues - do a very good job of growing without any human intervention at all. In fact - they're the roses that all our bred roses originated from - and almost thrive on neglect. Charles Shi is in charge of the Wild Rose Garden at Kew - designed originally by Capability Brown in 1900. As part of it's restoration, he and his team travelled as far afield as China and Vietnam to bring back roses that are so new, they haven't been named yet. He told me: 'One of the great things is whilst they flower for a short amount of time - wild roses make up for that by being very resistant to disease. 'Even if they get smothered in aphids they're absolutely fine. 'They're also more hardy. And the early flowers are followed by hips if they're not deadheaded, which feed the birds over Winter. 'It's so important to conserve them - as they could have medicinal compounds that could cure cancer - we're discovering up to 100 compounds every year in our research - which are being used in medical trials. 'They also play a crucial role in ecological conservation by providing food and habitat for pollinators and wildlife.' Some of Charles' favourites include... Rosa Soulieana - which he's nicknamed The Sleeping Beauty Rose - as it's like the one in the book that surrounds the castle. Smells of Cinnamon and up to 4m high. Rosa hirtula - from the Hakone, Japan, at the foothills of Mt Fuji - The only rose with a tree-like habit, with beautiful spiky hips Rosa x odorata 'Mutabilis' A bushy shrub, about 1.8m in height, with purplish young foliage and almost thornless stems Rosa laevigata - has dinner-plate sized flowers.
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
I tried cheddar cheese from Lidl, M&S and more - best was £1 cheaper than Cathedral City
We put cheddar cheese to the test to find out which supermarket's own brand is best - and the results may surprise you. Cheddar cheese, a staple in my home and used for toasties, jacket potatoes and sandwiches, isn't the cheapest ingredient to purchase. Cathedral City is reportedly the nation's favourite cheese, with Pilgrims Choice not far behind, but you can get supermarket own-brand cheddar for less, and some even at half the price. We've always chosen Cathedral City in our house without trying any supermarket brands, so I was eager to see how they would compare. For this taste test, I purchased mature Cheddar blocks from Asda, Tesco, Aldi, Lidl, Sainsbury's, Morrisons, Waitrose and Marks and Spencer, as well as the two leading brands - Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice. Naively, I assumed all cheddar cheese tasted the same, but I couldn't have been more mistaken. I bought all the packets on the same day and allowed them to reach room temperature before taste testing. Cathedral City This was the only cheese that came in a resealable pack, which helped it stay somewhat fresh in the fridge. It seemed different to the others immediately upon opening. There was moisture on the cheese that I wiped away with a piece of paper towel. The cheese sliced really nicely; however, it lacked the crumbly and sharp texture you expect from a mature cheddar. I was really surprised at how many supermarket versions I preferred over Cathedral City, so for £3.75, I don't think I'd be buying it again. Rating: 5/10 Pilgrims Choice Priced at £4.25, the most expensive of all, I had high expectations for this cheddar cheese. This one was uniquely shaped compared to the rest. It was cube-shaped rather than flat, which made it more convenient for grating, storing and cutting. It left me pondering why more cheeses aren't sold in this shape. The cheese had a pleasant crumbly texture, but the taste was a huge disappointment. I would likely say it was the worst of all of them. Rating: 3.5/10 Asda This £2.69 cheese from Asda tasted overly processed and rubbery - nothing like a mature cheddar cheese should be. It seemed more chewy rather than crumbly, and not to my liking at all. Rating: 2/10 Tesco Shaped just like the Pilgrims Choice cheese, Tesco's own brand version retails for £2.79 and is definitely on the mild side. It was actually quite bland and rubbery in texture. I don't think I would bother with it again, seeing as though some of the other supermarket brands of a similar price tasted better. Rating: 4/10 Morrisons Priced at £2.79, this cheese from Morrisons was creamy; however, it lacked a strong flavour. Similar to Tesco's own-brand cheese, I'd say this one is milder rather than mature. Rating: 5/10 Aldi Budget-friendly Aldi's Mature Cheddar costs £2.79 and was surprisingly one of my favourites of all the cheeses. This cheese was delicious. Crumbly and packed with flavour, this cheese was creamy and moreish. Rating: 9/10 Lidl The cheese from Lidl was quite creamy in texture but lacked flavour compared to a few of the other brands. Rating: 5/10 Sainsbury's The Sainsbury's mature cheddar retails for slightly higher than the previous supermarket-owned brands of cheese, as it costs £3.15. Unfortunately, I wasn't keen on this one as the texture felt excessively rich in the mouth, and it had a bitter aftertaste. Rating: 4/10 Waitrose A slightly salty taste from Waitrose, which I liked, and it was smooth and rich without being too overpowering. It's good value too. For £2.75, it's £1 cheaper than the market leader and even cheaper than most of the other own brands of cheeses. Rating: 9/10 Marks and Spencer M&S British Mature Cheddar, which costs £2.75, won me over. With a number five strength, I found it was really tangy and packed full of flavour. I loved that it had the right amount of creaminess to it. It not only tastes miles better than Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice, but it's far cheaper, and even cheaper than Lidl and Aldi, which was very surprising. Rating: 10/10 Overall verdict I was surprised to find that Cathedral City was definitely not my favourite. Instead, I preferred the M&S, with Waitrose and Aldi coming in at a tie for close second.
The Guardian
2 days ago
- The Guardian
Olive oil cake with orange slices and flaked almonds
This bake encapsulates summer. It's made with Tesco Finest extra virgin olive oil, produced by a family mill in southern Sicily, which makes the cake extra moist. It also adds a delicious layer of flavour and offers a healthier, dairy-free alternative to butter. In the summer, I want cake I can serve after barbecues with a ball of ice-cream. This easy recipe works really well for that. Simply boil an orange then blend it into a silky cake batter, and you'll have a deliciously light and fragrant cake where the citrus notes really come alive. And, of course, it's even better served with an indulgent scoop of Tesco Finest pistachio ice-cream or pistachio gelato, for a velvety and nutty flavour. Prep 15 min Cook 1 hr 30 min Serves 10 3 oranges 4 Tesco Finest free-range chestnut maran eggs 200ml Tesco Finest Sicilian extra virgin olive oil 70g Tesco Finest Greek yoghurt 200g caster sugar 100g ground almonds 200g self-raising flour 1 tsp baking powder ½ tsp fine sea salt 30g flaked almonds 2 tbsp icing sugar To serve Tesco Finest roasted pistachio ice-cream or Tesco Finest pistachio gelato Suggested wine pairingTesco Finest sauternes Heat the oven to 180C (160C fan)/350F/gas 4. Bring a pan of water to the boil. Add one whole, unpeeled orange and boil for 30 minutes. Once cooked, remove with a slotted spoon and leave to cool. Then quarter the orange and remove the pips. Blend the orange quarters, including the rind, in a blender then pour into a large mixing bowl. Line a deep springform cake tin with parchment. Peel and slice the remaining two oranges into 5mm thick rounds and arrange these on the bottom of the tin. To the mixing bowl, add the eggs, olive oil, yoghurt and caster sugar and whisk everything together. Add the ground almonds, flour, baking powder and salt and whisk briefly until combined. Pour the mix into the tin and bake for 55 minutes or until springy to the touch. Leave to cool, then turn out on to a serving plate and peel off the parchment. Toast the flaked almonds in a frying pan for 4-5 minutes, tossing a few times until golden brown. Scatter the cake with the toasted almonds and dust with the icing sugar. Serve in slices with the ice-cream or gelato. Shop the ingredients for this recipe on and discover how Tesco Finest can make your everyday taste better
