Dublin family linked to 26 previous personal injury claims face €150,000 legal bill
A Co Dublin family, already linked to 26 previous personal injury claims, now face a bill for legal costs of up to €150,000 after six separate new claims for damages totalling €360,000 against a motorist were thrown out by a judge Wednesday.
Frank Gaynor and his wife Sylvia, both aged 60, and four of their family, suspected of seeing 'what was coming down the track' at them in their latest cases, failed to appear in the Circuit Civil Court today.
Barrister Paul McMorrow told Judge Christopher Callan that none of the six, who allege they suffered whiplash injuries in a rear-ending traffic accident seven years ago, had turned up to advance their cases and had been earlier been directed by the court to decide whether they were going ahead with them or not.
Plumber and taxi driver Frank Gaynor and his wife, of Drishoge Manor, Oldtown, North County Dublin, had led objections in October last year to their solicitor being allowed to pull out of their case, due to a breach of trust, but have not been seen in the Circuit Civil Court since.
READ MORE
Their solicitor had felt unable to successfully challenge a full defence that had been entered by Allianz, insurers of motorist Brien Stenson, Carrs Mills, Donabate, Co Dublin, who the Gaynors were claiming had rear ended them.
Their daughters Nicole (35) and Jazmin (33), together with brothers Frank Junior (33) and Reece (21) had joined their parents in claims for up to €60,000 damages each arising from the accident near the Hilton Hotel on Malahide Road in April 2018.
Mr McMorrow, who appeared with Karen Cahill of Nathaniel Lacy solicitors, told the court that the defendant wanted all of the Gaynors to prove every single allegation they had made in their personal injury claims.
Counsel said that Mr Stenson and his insurers alleged that the extent of their injuries could not possibly have arisen from such a collision as had occurred.
He told the court that despite not having appointed new solicitors the family would be capable of representing themselves as they were well acquainted with legal proceedings having been linked to 26 previous claims.
'The defendant wishes to have a court order that these proceedings be brought to an end today,' Mr McMorrow said. 'The Gaynor family has been given a fair chance and had been advised they could appoint new solicitors but have not done so.'
Judge Callan said the court noted the cases had been set down for trial on May 7th last and there had been no appearance at that time nor again today when the case had been put in for mention to see whether or not they intended to proceed with the prosecution of their claims.
He dismissed every claim brought by the Gaynors and made orders for legal costs against each one of them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gardaí investigate death of man found injured at house in west Co Dublin
Gardaí are investigating the circumstances surrounding the death of a man in West Dublin. A man, who was in his 50s, was found injured at a house in Foxdene Drive, Balgaddy, Co Dublin shortly after 11pm on Wednesday. He was taken to Tallaght University Hospital where he was later pronounced dead. A Garda statement said the local coroner will be informed and a postmortem examination will be carried out. READ MORE The scene remains preserved pending a forensic examination. Gardaí are appealing to anyone who was in the vicinity of Foxdene Drive between 11pm and 12am and saw anything that may help them with their investigation to contact them at Lucan Garda station on (01) 6667300, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda station. Any road users or pedestrians who may have relevant camera footage are also asked to make it available.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Illegal peat harvesting is still taking place on a large scale, EPA report finds
Illegal commercial extraction of peat on a large scale continues to be widespread in Ireland, with a flourishing export trade worth €40 million a year, an EPA investigation has found. A total of 38 large-scale operations are engaged in illegal peat extraction in a sector that 'does not operate within planning or environmental laws', the report, published on Wednesday, concludes. 'Local authority enforcement performance in this area is patently inadequate,' it finds. The EPA has investigated 38 sites across seven counties – Offaly, Kildare, Laois, Westmeath, Roscommon, Longford and Sligo – where large-scale commercial peat extraction is being carried out without any of the necessary authorisations from local authorities. READ MORE The worst county was Westmeath, with eight illegal sites, followed by Tipperary and Roscommon with six each. [ Ireland worst in world for wetlands depletion over past 3 centuries, global study finds Opens in new window ] These illegal operations are contributing to an export trade of 300,000 tonnes of peat annually, valued at almost €40 million, the report says. The EPA has carried out 170 enforcement inspections between 2021 and 2024, including legal actions at District Court and High Court level against operations on areas greater than 50 hectares. These actions have resulted in cessation of illegal extractions on several peatlands, while a number of actions remain live before the courts. The products being extracted are milled peat used as compost and large sod peat – used in horticulture – as well as 'wet peat extracts' used in mushroom production. Dr Tom Ryan, director of the EPA Office of Environmental Enforcement, said: 'Operators engaged in unauthorised peat harvesting activities are in flagrant violation of environmental law. They are destroying our precious natural environments, and this needs to stop.' 'The environmental damage caused by large-scale peat extraction operating outside regulatory control is catastrophic for the environment,' Dr Ryan said. 'It results in destruction of vital ecosystems for biodiversity, loss of important carbon sinks ... and decimation of an irreplaceable cultural and scientific amenity and resource.' Peat extraction is subject to several legal restrictions in Ireland, and many sites have not received the required permissions. Photograph: EPA Bord na Móna was an excellent example of appropriate engagement with environmental regulations working, he said, including compliance with EPA licensing requirements, minimising of negative environmental impacts of peat harvesting, and securing of the rehabilitation of harvested peatlands. Local authorities have primary responsibility for regulating all commercial peat extraction. The EPA said it will continue to use its powers to ensure local authorities fully implement and enforce environmental requirements. The report notes appropriate regulation of peat harvesting can provide important protections for the environment. Bord na Móna had lawfully operated nine different peatland complexes across 11 counties under EPA licence until 2020, when these operations ceased. In accordance with their licence conditions and with support of the Peatlands Climate Action Scheme, Bord na Móna is engaged in rehabilitation of those peatlands, with almost 19,000 hectares rehabilitated by the end of 2024, 'bringing them back to life, allowing nature to take its course and the peatlands to flourish again', the report states. [ Turf cutters warn of confrontational scenes after EU Commission move Opens in new window ] The EPA has gathered evidence of expensive machinery, complex drainage systems, extensive rows and stacks of cut peat and, in some cases, large warehouses on sites. Large-scale commercial peat extraction can only take place if it is granted planning permission. In some cases, an EPA licence is also required. For peat extraction from on an area greater than 50Ha, extraction needs an EPA integrated pollution control licence as well as planning permission and an environmental impact assessment (EIA). There is a ban on the commercial sale of peat for solid fuel heating and restriction of peat-cutting for other purposes, such as horticulture. Environmental groups have highlighted that very few, if any, plots have the required permits or would be eligible for them because they would fail at the EIA stage. Peat extraction was targeted for phase-out on environmental and public health grounds, as turf-burning causes air pollution and bog-stripping undermines the natural environment.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Minister concerned 44% of women are dissatisfied with initial Garda response to abuse
The Minister for Justice has expressed concern that 44 per cent of women surveyed by Women's Aid were not satisfied with their initial engagement with gardaí over domestic abuse. Jim O'Callaghan stressed, however, that the majority of women found gardaí to be helpful. He said gardaí are being continually trained on this issue. The Minister said work continues within his department to create a register of domestic abusers. He is increasing funding for issues to ensure abusers, rather than victims, are the ones to leave the family home. Mr O'Callaghan was taking questions in the Dáil, where the Women's Aid annual report dominated. The report revealed the agency last year received the highest number of domestic abuse complaints in its 50-year history, with an increase in all forms of abuse. READ MORE Women's Aid highlighted concern about An Garda Síochána's 'inconsistent' response to more than 65,000 such contacts it received last year. Labour leader Ivana Bacik said there is a suite of laws dealing with domestic abuse, but these are all 'ineffective if the first line of defence, the gardaí, are not implementing them adequately'. She said, 'We've heard from survivors who were dismissed or not taken seriously. That failure doesn't just erode trust, it puts lives at risk.' Mr O'Callaghan said 'the majority had a positive experience'. He said 'women I have spoken to who come into contact with gardaí who have had training in domestic violence have a very positive narrative'. But he believes it is more 'an issue for men and boys than it is for women, because regrettably, my sex are the sex that perpetrate this violence against women'. [ Shocking domestic violence data adds further urgency to new strategy Opens in new window ] He said pornography must be having an 'extraordinary impact on young men 'because it presents women in a very submissive, malleable manner'. 'Not all the solutions are through the criminal justice system,' he said. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald said the report made for 'grim reading'. All the statistics 'are going in the wrong direction, and Women's Aid says that this is only the tip of the iceberg '. 'Behind these statistics are real women and their children, real lives shattered. The report reflects that Government must do a far better job to achieve zero tolerance of violence against women.' She also pointed to the lack of refuge spaces and asked why women should have to leave their home rather than the abuser. The Minister agreed it should not be the 'first port of call' when a woman is abused to seek to find her another place to live. 'The response should be: 'How can we get the abuser out of the home?'' He said there are mechanisms, including barring and safety orders, which he is committed to properly funding. Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon said 'social media is supercharging' violence against women. He said the algorithms 'are rewarding misogyny, disinformation and abuse because it keeps people scrolling and it keeps the companies making money'. Mr Gannon called on the Government to 'regulate these recommender algorithms'. [ Highest number of domestic violence disclosures in 50 years is 'just tip of iceberg', says Women's Aid Opens in new window ] The Minister said this issue cannot be solved through domestic legislation, but requires 'an EU response'. At the launch of the report on Wednesday, Women's Aid chief executive Sarah Benson said domestic violence is endemic in society, but the 'single greatest risk structure is being born female'. She said people in Ireland have been talking about the issue 'more than ever' over the last few years. As it becomes 'increasingly destigmatised', victims and survivors 'will rightly reach out for support'. It is important this momentum continues to recognise the prevalence of domestic violence in Ireland and to reduce the number of people affected by it, she said.
