Progress thwarted by educational inequities
WESTERN SUBURBS
Re ″ Young tradies like Dylan and western suburbs professionals have this in common ″, 15/8. Congratulations to Dylan D'Emanuele for his perseverance and determination to enter a trade, assisted by Youth Projects. It certainly shouldn't be so hard for young people to gain a foothold in their own society.
Two adverse factors have primary responsibility for this. First, the Victorian government lost the plot in closing around 120 technical secondary schools, expecting high schools to somehow cater for academic and non-academic students, and ″warehouse″ unemployed youth to keep them off the streets.
I'd previously observed teachers in a now-closed technical school in the inner-west, witnessing how engaged students were in mechanical, construction and myriad other tasks, supplemented by classes in basic skills.
The students who flourish in technical schools need those educational opportunities to learn skilled trades which can take them straight into work.
The second major factor disadvantaging today's youth is the exportation of entry level work to cheaper labour countries. Those jobs used to go to school-leavers after Year 10.
High levels of youth unemployment are inevitably detrimental to those young people and to the society as a whole.
Barbara Chapman, South Yarra
New insights needed
Accolades to The Age for co-presenting the upcoming 'West of Melbourne Summit', and its continuing advocacy by their journalists for people living in the west side of Melbourne.
The spoken word cannot be ignored. New insights are desperately needed. Both sides of Victorian parliament need to listen.
Addressing the various needs of people choosing to live and raise their children in the west could address problems facing the inner city Melbourne congestion.
Christine Baker, Rosanna
Melbourne infrastructure delays have history
My heart goes out to those folk in the west who pine for improved transport infrastructure. I can only hope they do better than their brethren in Doncaster.
Soon after World War II ended, it was proposed to extend tram route 48 from North Balwyn to Doncaster, thereby servicing the residents of housing replacing the fast-disappearing orchards.
Successive political parties seeking to retain or reclaim the state's treasury benches eagerly supported the proposal. As is the fate of certain current infrastructure proposals, once elected, assorted reasons for deferment were trotted out.
The latest is that the hill to Doncaster Shoppingtown is too steep to enable disabled access. Any suggestion that the route be extended further to Box Hill via Tram Road, thereby looping the city with a significant chunk of the eastern suburbs, can only be described as a figment in the imagination of those living there.
(By contrast, Australia's first electric tram service existed in Doncaster from 1889 to 1896 when Victoria was a colony!)
Jim Lamborn, Doncaster
THE FORUM
Buried report
As reported by The Age this week, the government has refused to make the outcome of the 2022 Property Market Review″ public. According to both Premier Jacinta Allan and Consumer Affairs Minister Nick Staikos, the review is 'a cabinet document from the last term of government' and therefore does not have to be made public. What nonsense!
Like many others, I responded to a personal invitation to provide a written submission to the review. My comprehensive submission subsequently included, again by invitation, a one-hour presentation to the Nous Group who were commissioned to conduct the review for the government.
My submission concentrated on the need for auction rules to be reformed to stamp out the insidious practice of underquoting. This can be achieved by introducing a simple, new, easily policed rule that would require agents to publish their vendors' reserve prices in all auction advertising.
The REIV this week has finally agreed, after 20 years' resistance and following exposure of underquoting by The Age, that vendors' reserve prices should be advertised before auctions and it has also called for the review to be made public.
There's something very concerning about why the review is not being made public. Why should anybody spend valuable hours of their time preparing well-researched submissions on important issues of wide public interest, only for their input to be buried?
John Keating, real estate agent and auctioneer, Woodend
Rebalance tax system
The articles ' We've worked hard ... but it's not enough ' (14/8) and ' Spender calls for new income tax system ' (14/8), highlight the gross unfairness of our tax system.
Work, not property investment, should be rewarded by governments. Current property investor tax breaks are inequitable and they elevate house prices, further disadvantaging prospective homeowners.
It's time for Labor to rebalance our tax system and give younger generations a fair go.
Lyn Shiells, Glen Iris
Bendigo festival no-show
Re: ″ Authors ditch Bendigo festival over freedom of speech concerns ″, (15/8). As a Bendigo resident, the Bendigo Writers Festival is an annual event on my calendar.
Claire Wright, Jess Hill, Thomas Mayo and Randa Abdel-Fattah are the very writers and thinkers I would be attending to hear, in expectation of respectful, intelligent, informed and balanced perspectives.
I congratulate them on taking such a principled stance in withdrawing from a public forum which curtails their ability to do this, even though it means no writers' festival in Bendigo for me this year.
Michelle Goldsmith, Eaglehawk
AI flooding zone
Two years ago, I was offered a free trial for one of the artificial intelligence (AI) content generation platforms. I tried it and immediately cancelled my subscription. Even then, I could see the dangers of this technology. The information delivered by the platform on the topic I gave it was just good enough to provide a viable alternative mechanism for busy professionals to generate documents. But it also contained numerous errors and pieces of misinformation.
My colleagues laughed at my concerns. 'People will check the content and correct any errors before they use it,' they told me.
And perhaps, initially they did. My concern was that after a while, everyone would just assume the information is correct and not bother to check any more. The content is so quickly and easily produced, it would eventually 'flood the zone' and drown out the work produced through careful research and due consideration.
Fast-forward two years and we read that defence lawyers filed error-filled AI-generated documents with the Victorian Supreme Court (15/8). The lawyers were too busy to check the materials before they filed them and the prosecutors didn't bother checking either.
Heaven help us if AI is the future of our society.
Donna Cohen, Southbank
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Courier-Mail
2 hours ago
- Courier-Mail
Revealed: How Australia's new EV tax rollout will work
Don't miss out on the headlines from National. Followed categories will be added to My News. EXCLUSIVE Australia's new tax on electric vehicle drivers is set to kick off with a trial period for trucks before it stings cars. can reveal that the Albanese Government is looking at a staged rollout to test the proposed new EV tax and trucks will be the first cab off the rank. It is also interested in a new road user charge that sends price signals on the best time to be on the road, or the freeway. Over time, it could replace petrol taxes and apply to all cars based on distance travelled and when cars and trucks are on the road to tackle congestion. Don't miss a ding! Get all the latest Australian news as it happens — download the app direct to your phone. Free ride for EVs nearly over The free ride enjoyed by drivers of electric vehicles is coming to a close with Treasurer Jim Chalmers and state governments finalising plans for a new road-user charge. All Australian motorists who buy petrol and diesel at the bowser pay 51.6 cents a litre in fuel excise. But drivers of EV vehicles pay nothing. 'The status quo won't be sustainable over the next decade or two,'' Treasurer Jim Chalmers told 'As more and more people get off petrol cars and into EVs we've got to make sure that the tax arrangements support investment in roads. 'But we're in no rush, changes of this nature will be made, because the status quo won't work in 10 or 20 years.' Treasurer Jim Chalmers has shared some details of the government's plan. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman The Treasurer says roads won't keep up without a new system for charging users, with potholes like these in Sydney this week becoming more common. Picture: Richard Dobson The Treasurer made no secret of his support for a road user charge before the election, but favours a staged rollout of the changes. Based on a planned NSW road user scheme, a national rollout will depend on your mileage but might cost between $300 and $400 a year. Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas said that electric vehicles are 'heavier and do more damage to the road network as a consequence than do internal combustion engine vehicles'. 'By giving drivers a clear signal about the cost of infrastructure, they would have an incentive to use it more efficiently,' the Productivity Commission report said. How does fuel excise work? The current rate of fuel excise is 51.6 cents in excise for every litre of fuel purchased. For a typical household with a car running on petrol, the tax costs more than $1200 a year. But the flat sales tax isn't paid by drivers of pure electric vehicles, who simply need to plug in their cars to recharge. While registration and driver's licence fees go to state and territory governments, fuel excise is collected by the federal government. Australian motorists paid an estimated $15.71 billion in net fuel excise in 2023-24, and are expected to pay $67.6 billion over the four years to 2026-27. However, governments have long-warned that a road-user charge will be required to fill the gap in the budget left by declining revenue from the fuel excise, as the petrol and diesel engines in new cars consume less fuel and Australians adopt hybrid and electric cars. Chinese tech to change EVs Rapid charging tech promised by China's CATL could put electric cars in top gear, as David McCowen reports. Video Player is loading. Play Video This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Text Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Caption Area Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Drop shadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. X Learn More Loaded : 37.82% 0:00 00:00 / 00:00 Close Modal Dialog This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button. 00:26 SUBSCRIBER ONLY Chinese tech to change EVs China's... more CATL could put electric cars in top gear, as David McCowen reports. Rapid charging tech promised by... more ... more A road user charge is needed to fill the gap left by the decreasingly profitable fuel excise. Picture: NewsWire / Nicholas Eagar What does the AAA say? The Australian Automobile Association (AAA) is calling for a national approach to road-user charging but wants a guarantee the revenue will be earmarked for road upgrades. The AAA backs a distance-based road-user charging as a fairer and more equitable way to fund land transport infrastructure. The 2024 federal budget forecasted a reduction in fuel excise receipts by $470 million over four years from 2024-25. Roadblocks to reform Currently, New South Wales is the only state with firm plans to introduce a road-user charge from 2027 or when EVs reach 30 per cent of new car sales. Plug-in hybrid EVs will be charged a fixed 80 per cent proportion of the full road-user charge to reflect their vehicle type. Western Australia has also stated an intention to implement a road-user charge. Meanwhile, Victoria's electric vehicle levy had to be scrapped following a ruling from the High Court. Our road infrastructure must be maintained as heavier EVs do increasing damage. Picture: Alan Barber Two Victorian electric car owners launched a legal challenge on the basis the tax was not legal as it was an excise that only a federal government could impose. They won, with the High Court upholding the legal challenge. There have been several false starts to enshrine a road-user charge including in South Australia, where the former Liberal Government planned to introduce a charge for plug-in electric and other zero emission vehicles, which included a fixed component and a variable charge based on distance travelled. It was later pushed back to 2027 due to a backlash before the legislation was ultimately repealed. 'Gold standard' for reform Some experts argue the gold standard for reform is a variable rate that factors in the vehicle's mass, distance travelled, location, and time of day. But there's a big barrier to the Commonwealth imposing those charges because the Constitution prohibits it from imposing taxes that discriminate between states or parts of states. State governments could impose those levies, but as the experience of the Victorian Government underlines, it is legally complex. Originally published as How the Albanese Government plans to revolutionise the taxes you pay for driving a car
Sky News AU
3 hours ago
- Sky News AU
‘Karen Syndrome': Melbourne Lord Mayor suggests fines for walking on wrong side of footpath in huge case of 'nanny state overreach'
Fresh off banning e-scooters, Melbourne's Lord Mayor is now floating the idea of a crackdown on pedestrians who walk on the wrong side of the footpath. Lord Mayor Nick Reece took to the pages of The Age on Friday to complain about the state of 'pedestrian etiquette' on Melbourne's streets. In a piece spanning almost 800 words, Mr Reece complained about people walking too fast, people walking too slow, and 'people drifting diagonally like bishops on a chessboard'. Melbourne's Lord Mayor suggested fines could be used against people who failed to walk on the left of the footpath, while people who use their phones while crossing the road could have them confiscated. 'Foot-traffic numbers are soaring in the city again, and the new metro stations are about to deliver half a million more people every week – it's time we took action,' Mr Reece wrote. 'Given the chaos on our footpaths, perhaps it is time for less carrot and more stick. Less suggestion and more compulsion, in the form of a new keep-left law.' Mayor Reece also took aim at the 'generation of zombies' always staring at their mobile phones or taking selfies, suggesting Melbourne should follow Honolulu in fining people who used their mobiles while crossing the street. 'Victoria has a road rule that bans phone use while driving. What about the same for pedestrians crossing the road? Perhaps we could seize offenders' phones for a day? For many, that would be harsher than a fine,' he said. The suggestion was condemned by Brian Marlow from grassroots activist group CitizenGO, who said the Lord Mayor 'must be suffering form an acute case of Karen Syndrome'. 'Only someone fully embedded in the taxpayer-funded Karen Industrial Complex could look at Melbourne's foot traffic and decide what we really need is more laws telling grown adults where to walk,' he said. 'This is Australia. We believe in freedom. Freedom to walk where we please, not shuffle along in government-approved single-file lines like schoolkids on excursion. 'We don't take kindly to being scolded by Big Brother in a high-vis vest, especially not from a bloke who clearly fancies himself the self-appointed hall monitor of the CBD. 'Maybe next he'll be issuing citations for failing to smile politely at a tram driver.' Mr Marlow said the proposal to regulate how people walk on the footpath perfectly encapsulated 'nanny-state overreach'. 'Reece's fetish for micromanaging public space isn't leadership,' he said. 'It is authoritarianism masquerading as civic virtue. And let's be clear: it is not about safety. It is about control. It is the same mindset that put health bureaucrats in charge of your freedoms during COVID.' In finishing his op-ed, Mayor Reece called for Melbourne's to 'return order to our footpaths'. 'If we want to remain a beautiful walking city, then we need to brush up on our pedestrianising skills… Stay calm. Be kind. Keep left. Or we may need the strong arm of the law to fix things,'' he said.
The Australian
4 hours ago
- The Australian
Japan's emperor expresses 'deep remorse' 80 years after WWII
Tens of thousands of people braved blazing heat to pay their respects at a controversial Japanese shrine on Friday, as Emperor Naruhito spoke of his "deep remorse" on the 80th anniversary of the nation's World War II surrender. Two cabinet ministers were among the visitors to the Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo, which honours 2.5 million mostly Japanese soldiers who perished since the late 19th century but also enshrines convicted war criminals. Trips to the shrine by government officials have angered countries that suffered Japanese military atrocities, particularly China and South Korea. Naruhito said he felt "a deep and renewed sense of sorrow" in a sombre speech alongside Empress Masako in an indoor arena in the centre of the Japanese capital, where the national flag flew at half-mast outside. "My thoughts are with the numerous people who lost their precious lives in the last war and their bereaved families," the 65-year-old said. "Reflecting on our past and bearing in mind the feelings of deep remorse, I earnestly hope that the ravages of war will never again be repeated." Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba also addressed the ceremony, pledging "to uphold the painful memories of war... passing them down across generations, and pursue actions toward lasting peace". Ishiba, a political moderate, sent a customary offering to Yasukuni, according to Kyodo news. No Japanese prime minister has visited the shrine since 2013, when a trip by then-premier Shinzo Abe sparked fury in Beijing and Seoul, and a rare diplomatic rebuke from close ally the United States. China's foreign ministry said an official had made "solemn representations" with Japan's embassy in Beijing over Friday's visit, according to an online statement. - Reflection, wrongdoings - With temperatures above 30C in the picturesque grounds around the shrine, there was a sea of umbrellas as people tried to shelter from the sun. At least two people became unwell in the heat and were forced to seek help. Takashi Eguchi, a 53-year-old graphic designer from Tokyo, told AFP Yasukuni served as an accessible place in the heart of the city for ordinary people to reflect on the nation's history. "We live in a moment when wars have broken out or are likely to break out in various places," he said. "So I came here to look back at what Japan has done, including its failures." Another visitor, who gave only his surname Harada, came dressed in a Japanese imperial army uniform to honour the sacrifice of the war dead. "I know the time will come when war veterans will no longer be with us. I wanted to do my part to continue their legacy," said the 39-year-old from the central prefecture of Nagano. "You have to look at all aspects of wars. Good things and bad things happened." Agriculture minister Shinjiro Koizumi, seen as a potential future prime minister, paid a visit to the shrine in the early morning, as he does annually on August 15. He was followed later by another cabinet member, finance minister Katsunobu Kato. Ishiba's chief political rival Sanae Takaichi -- who leads the nationalist wing of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party -- was also there, as were members of the "Japanese first" Sanseito party that made strong gains in July's upper house election with its "anti-globalist" drive. Naruhito, Masako and their daughter Princess Aiko are due to visit Nagasaki next month to meet survivors of the devastating atomic bomb and honour the war dead in what is reportedly the emperor's first trip there since he acceded to the throne in 2019. hih-nf-tmo-aph-mya/reb/sco
