Woman had to beg to pay hefty Watercare bill in instalments after issue with faulty smart meter
Photo:
Nunnicha Supagrit
A Watercare customer says she had to beg to pay off a huge catch-up bill in instalments after a faulty smart meter gave her zero-use bills for months.
The issue stemmed from Watercare's smart meters, which it told
Checkpoint
more than
13,000 of were not working
.
The water supplier had known about problems with one type of smart meter since October last year, and the fault had so far affected about one third of the 40,000 meters installed since 2022.
Hamideh, from West Auckland's Henderson, told
Checkpoint,
she had complained to Watercare more than once about an issue with her smart meter which began in November last year, but while waiting for the issue to be fixed she was sent a bill to the amount of $219.
"It was shocking - I was not prepared for it."
She had lost her job a few months ago and knew she wouldn't be able to afford to pay off the bill in one go.
"I called Watercare and asked to pay in instalments and they said no, not possible. I explained I lost my job and was told that I should have saved for it."
After about 25 minutes on the phone, Hamideh said it was accepted she could pay in instalments.
"But there's still no reading on my water meter. I was quite pissed off when she told me I had to save for it.
"They told me the meter just stopped syncing data... they didn't communicate the problem with their customers. It's been seven months and no solution."
Watercare chief financial officer Angela Neeson told
Checkpoint
she was really sorry to hear about Hamideh's experience and said it needed resolving.
"That it's taken seven months to resolve does sound unusual."
Neeson said when Watercare realised there was an issue with the smart meters processes were put in place to identify when the meters started to become faulty.
"The process does take a couple of months because the first month of a zero read could just be someone on holiday or out of the house but after the second month we move the customer to a manual read," she said.
She acknowledged there was nothing on the Watercare website about the faulty meters and said Watercare had "been focused on liasing with the customers".
"We watch for month two to identify when there is potentially a faulty meter."
Watercare had now stopped installing that particular meter, Neeson confirmed but she did not give a timeline on how long it would take to replace the faulty ones.
"We will always look and how we can do better and we're considering whether we don't wait that one month after a zero read to investigate so that it shortens that period for customers.
"We are always looking at how we can do things better".
Neeson confirmed water bills would
increase 7.2 percent at the start of July
which she said reflected the cost of running the operations and becoming financially independent.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
New scheme aims to cut out supermarkets, source local produce
A new scheme aims to cut out supermarkets and get fruit and vegetables grown next door or down the road onto people's plates. A group of agencies in Wellington is working to produce direct from local growers and create an online platform where shoppers can bypass big mark-ups and eat seasonally too. The process starts at lush urban farm Kaicyle, tucked down a side street in inner-city Wellington. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Silverbeet, celery, baby carrots and spring onions line the garden surrounded by the industrial warehouses and carparks of Newtown. "It's winter so it's slow season but we grow all sorts of different things, but we try to grow things that people want," co-manager Ellie Clayton told Checkpoint. "At the moment we've got heaps of silverbeet, and just a great, cheap staple for people." The farm is one of several in the Wellington region participating in the pilot, co-ordinated by Wesley Community Action, Kaibosh food rescue and Health NZ - which aims to put local produce on people's plates at an affordable price. Growers in Kāpiti and Horowhenua are also part of the scheme. "It's great for local growers because it means we can just harvest what's needed and what's been ordered, and then we can get this really great fresh Kai that we are harvesting on a Thursday morning, and people can pick it up on the Thursday morning, and cook it for Thursday dinner," Clayton said. Co-manager Ellie Clayton. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Kaibosh Food Rescue Wellington city operations manager Luke Campbell said his team were "the wheels" of the operation. Drivers from food-rescue charity pick up the orders as part of their regular routes and deliver them to packing hubs around Wellington, the Wairarapa and the Kāpiti Coast. "We've got a mission of zero food poverty and zero food waste, and so anyway we can help facilitate that, that's what we do. "So connecting food, with the people that need it. Nobody wants to grow food or sell food or be part of food and see it go in the bin." Kaibosh Food Rescue Wellington city operations manager Luke Campbell. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Ten minutes away, volunteers are busy filling boxes of fresh fruit and vegetables. Wesley Community Action's co-ops co-ordinator Cory Hope was rummaging through some of the days offerings. "These are daikon radishes, so this is something we try to introduce because they actually grow really well, they're really healthy, and they're really versatile. "You can cook them, you can have them raw, I like to make a pickle out of them. [We've got] your classic kiwi fruit from up north, kūmara from up north as well." Hope said the social agency already had a co-op scheme which provided $15 boxes of produce to participants, and about six tonnes of produce was delivered to 1100 families each week. The new pilot - jointly organised by Wesley Community Action and Health NZ - allows shoppers to hop online, on a platform called Coshop, and buy what they want. Wesley Community Action's co-ops co-ordinator Cory Hope. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Local growers set their own prices, but Hope said the boxes run cheaper than the supermarkets with packing done by volunteers, and distribution done by the food rescue. "Most of the mahi is done by our fantastic volunteers, and we only charge a levy to cover administrative and freight costs. "That's it, there's no profit involved at all. So generally we run about 15 - 25 percent cheaper than the supermarkets," Hope said. According to Ministry of Health data from 2023-2024, one in four children live in households where food has run out often or sometimes. One in two Pacific and one in three Māori children were living in households where food ran out sometimes. 26 percent of children lived in households where they often or sometimes ate less because of lack of money. Hope said regional food resilience needed a boost - but it was hard for local growers to build a market channel for their goods, and currently difficult for people to access local produce at an affordable price. "They have an income, you might have a job, but it's tricky to make ends meet each week. So buying affordable access to fresh healthy kai, hopefully that will leave a few more dollars in people's pockets to spend on bills or something else." The pilot finishes at the end of August, but Hope said the goal was for the model to be replicated and expanded throughout the city. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
'Today is a good day': Government celebrates Reserve Bank's OCR cut
Cabinet Minister Louise Upston. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Cries of celebration from the government benches were heard at Parliament today, following the Reserve Bank's cut to the Official Cash Rate (OCR). "Today is a good day," Cabinet Minister Louise Upston exclaimed during General Debate. "We have good news for every New Zealand household and business that their mortgage rates are coming down." "Good news today," her colleague Chris Penk echoed. "Interest rates are coming down. The stimulatory effect for our New Zealand economy is going to be great." As expected, on Wednesday, the Reserve Bank cut its benchmark cash rate by 25 basis points to a three-year low of 3 percent and left the door open for further moves lower. The central bank said the economy had stalled in the past few months with households and businesses cautious because of rising prices, a soft labour market, and global uncertainty. It said underlying inflation pressures were expected to reach its target of around 2 percent, even though headline consumer inflation was edging higher to the top of its broader 1-3 percent band. The Prime Minister and Finance Minister called a media conference at Parliament to respond to the news on Wednesday afternoon, telling media the decision would provide more stimulus to the economy. Christopher Luxon said New Zealand had been through a difficult period, but the "road to recovery looks good." He said homeowners would have more money in their back pocket, and therefore, more money to spend. "We have about 40 percent of people in New Zealand that will be refinancing their mortgages in the next six months, so they will really start to feel the benefits of those lower interest rates transmitting through the economy, which is really fantastic news." Nicola Willis echoed the sentiment, saying: "what we want to see is people having the confidence to be spending in the economy and lower interest rates certainly support that." Willis said the Bank had also forecast more cuts to come. She acknowledged households would make their own decisions when it came to spending or saving, but both her and Luxon thought confidence would increase over time. "It's true that as unemployment is forecast to reduce and as growth is forecast to recover, that will support greater levels of confidence in the economy, and therefore it is likely that many households and businesses will think, yep, this is the time to start spending." Willis said it was "objective data" that said things are "absolutely getting better, and you should feel confident about that." She acknowledged people were still facing high prices at the supermarket, but said Foodstuffs and Woolworths had the "power in their hands" to ensure New Zealanders faced lower prices. "They can exercise it any day they like." Willis also took a swipe at the opposition and those who were critical of the state of the economy, saying "there's a choice" when it came to how the country spoke about the economy. "Do we talk ourselves into an ongoing funk, or do we look ahead and recognize that things will get better?" she said. She said she was conscious households listened to "merchants of misery" and opposition "doomsayers" every day who talked down the New Zealand economy. "Now is not the time to be talking down the New Zealand economy," Willis said. "The data doesn't lie. The Reserve Bank are independent. They are not political." Following the OCR cut, the right-leaning Taxpayers' Union warned the coalition government not to rest on its laurels and to cut in its "reckless spending". Willis shot back, pointing to the Reserve Bank's indication that the government's decisions were making a difference. "I'd encourage the Taxpayers' Union to read the monetary policy statement report, because it explicitly calls out ... that in the medium term, the fact that the government is reducing spending as a share of GDP will reduce inflation pressure. "So it's not just us saying, guys, that our fiscal choices are reducing inflationary pressure and supporting lower interest rates. The Reserve Bank are explicitly calling that out." She said the Taxpayers' Union might think it's a good idea to cut support to Kiwi families who need it, to stop investing in schools and hospitals: "I disagree." ACT leader and Associate Finance Minister David Seymour said the cut would help mortgage holders, borrowers and businesses. "There are lots of people who want this whole thing just to go faster but there are no shortcuts." ACT would have gone further in cutting public expenditure, he said. Seymour said that could amount to $7b or $8b in cuts every year, in line with the alternative budgets ACT released while in opposition. "That sounds like a lot of money, when you consider that the government's currently spending $142b what we're really talking about is about a 5 percent reduction and I still think that's necessary." Unemployment was about where it was forecast to be a couple of years ago, he said, and if the government stayed the course with keeping spending under control the situation would improve. The Greens said some people would welcome the cut, but the Reserve Bank's decision wouldn't help those people being left behind by government decisions, which were leading to an increase in poverty and homelessness. "While the OCR cut will provide some relief for those with a mortgage, the number of New Zealanders left out in the cold continues to grow under Luxon's decisions. "Reports out today show families being forced to choose between unsafe boarding houses, or living on the street," said Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick. Swarbrick said monetary policy was a blunt instrument, "it is fiscal policy - that is, the government's choices on tax and spend - which dictates who wins and who loses in our economy." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Homeless people ordered to leave church grounds by Christchurch Council have 'nowhere to go'
A group of homeless people living on a church's grounds in Christchurch will have nowhere to go if the city council moves against the impromptu encampment, advocates say. About ten people call a carpark at Holy Trinity Avonside home. The Christchurch City Council has issued an abatement notice "requiring the property to cease being used, or allowed to be used, as a campground". The council would consider further action if nothing changed by Friday. But church community workers said the group, who lived in tents, busses and - in one case - a shed, had complex circumstances that led to their living situation. But, most importantly, they had nowhere else to go. The carpark at Holy Trinity Avonside. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Community worker River Rain said a trust - Te Puna Ora - was being established to take over the work of the church. "We're not a campground and we're very clear on the fact that camping is something you do as a leisure activity - that's not what's happening here. We are meeting a need for people who don't have anywhere else to go," Rain said. The church first allowed freedom campers to use the carpark, but increasingly it was the homeless who were turning up for help and a place to stay. Rain said he hoped the church - and the trust that would takeover its work - could find a "creative solution" with the help of the council. But those who now called the carpark home said they had few options left. Will Kenneally was one of those living in the carpark. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Will Kenneally had been living at the carpark for about six months. He had health issues which prevented him working and about a year ago was attacked. Kenneally's head was stomped on, fracturing his skull and breaking his nose and a tooth. He felt safe staying at the church - the first time he had felt that way in a long time. "Now I can actually go to sleep and I don't have to worry about someone pounding on the window at three in the morning trying to hustle me or take things off me or trying to take the van off me," he said. A couple of the tents set up in the church grounds. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon The church had also provided the support he needed to heal. The idea of the council closing the site down was terrifying. "If you're cruel, you only hurt your own soul. But if you're kind, you will heal many souls. That's how I see it," Kenneally said. "Thoughtless words can destroy many hearts, but wisely spoken words will heal many hearts, and they're going out of their way to be cruel. "I only have to walk from there to there and I'm in a church - that makes a really big difference... When you have that emotional support, it means a lot more than even having a bed, in my eyes." Christina Karaitiana had been living in the carpark for about three months with her partner, who was currently in hospital. Christina Karaitiana had been at the carpark for about three months. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Karaitiana also had health problems, including a pacemaker. "There's a lot of people not even helping us, but ever since we've been at this Holy Trinity Church, the people here have been really great - supportive. They've been really wonderful," she said. She feared what would have happened to herself and her partner if they had not had a bus to sleep in over winter. "Out on the street in the cold," Karaitiana said, when asked where she would be without Holy Trinity. "We could have ended up really cold, having pneumonia. We could've even died. If it wasn't for this place, we wouldn't be here." Alastair Linfoot, who would serve as a trustee for Te Puna Ora, said he understood what those staying at the church were going through. Alastair Linfoot would serve a trustee for Te Puna Ora. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon "A year ago I was in a similar position to these guys - living in my car," he said. "So it's relatable - it means a lot to me because I had people help me and people gave me hope and now I'm a full time student, doing really well, living in a house and hope for the future. I want to be able to help and pass on that hope through what... the workers here are doing." His experience demonstrated how precarious many people's lives were. "We're all just one, might not even be a bad, decision away from being homeless or living in our cars," Linfoot said. "It's really tough out there. We have people living out in tents who work full-time jobs, families living in cars that can't survive because of the cost of living. It's kind of atrocious really." One of the concerns raised about high concentrations of homeless people was crime. But Bryan Gilchrist, another trustee, said the work of the church was dispelling that myth. Bryan Gilchrist was a trustee at the church. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon "My office overlooks the carpark next to Beverly Park and for so long it was home to the unhoused and to freedom campers and I would witness drug deals, altercations, so much littering. It was mind boggling. Even when council posted the no camping notice it still occurred, it still transpired," he said. "Then these folks came into the picture and offered them a space here and ... it feels like it has changed the landscape for this area and for the better. "They have provided a community for these folks. A reason to be, a reason to do something, a reason to get up. They provide food, they provide the shelter, they provide that community support that these folks really lack when they are unhoused and that mahi has been terrific to observe." Iain MacInnes, another community worker at the church, said they had worked to build relationships with other community service providers so they could help those staying at the site with their physical and mental health, access to employment and, ultimately, housing. Iain MacInnes, a community worker at the church. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Some who had stayed at the carpark had now found permanent homes, he said. But for those living at the church at present, it was about building a sense of community and belonging, MacInnes said. The advocates agreed homelessness was increasing. River Rain said they were guided by the church's principles. River Rain said she couldn't turn her back on those in need. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon "My boss - the vicar - is very motivated by a verse in Matthew that talks about Jesus commanding us to feed the hungry, welcome the stranger, clothe the naked, and care for the sick, and at the core of our work that's what we felt called to do," he said. "At this point we've gotten to know the people, we've gotten to know the stories and we've gotten to know the need. And I don't see any way that I could turn my back on that." A Christchurch City Council spokesperson said an abatement notice had been issued. "Council has issued an Abatement Notice requiring the property to cease being used, or allowed to be used, as a campground. The compliance date is 5pm on 22 August 2025. If the notice is not complied with, further enforcement action will be considered," the spokesperson said. "As the compliance date has not yet been reached, we are unable to comment on the outcome at this stage. "Staff continue to liaise with community organisations who support the homeless community and currently contract Christchurch City Mission to deliver on-the-street outreach workers. "Council recognises the need for a citywide strategy including community providers to deliver a collective process to address the issue and is in the early stages of planning this." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
