Abolishing Ofwat and compulsory water meters - key recommendations from landmark report into 'broken' water industry
The report, which includes 88 recommendations, suggests a new single integrated regulator to replace existing water watchdogs, mandatory water metering, and a social tariff for vulnerable customers.
The ability to block companies being taken over and the creation of eight new regional water authorities, with another for all of Wales to deliver local priorities, has also been suggested.
The review, the largest into the water industry since privatisation in the 1980s, was undertaken by Sir Jon Cunliffe, a career civil servant and former deputy governor of the Bank of England who oversaw the biggest clean-up of Britain's banking system in the wake of the financial crash.
He was coaxed out of retirement by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to lead the Independent Water Commission.
Final recommendations of the commission have been published on Monday morning to clean up the sector and improve public confidence, as bills rise 36% over the next five years. Here are its nine key recommendations:
• Single integrated water regulators - a single water regulator in England and a single water regulator in Wales. In England, this would replace Ofwat, the Drinking Water Inspectorate and water-environment related functions from the Environment Agency and Natural England. In Wales, Ofwat's economic responsibilities would be integrated into Natural Resources Wales.
It's hoped this will solve the "fragmented and overlapping" regulation, and more stable regulation will improve investor confidence. Communications regulator Ofcom was given as an example of how combining five existing regulators into one worked.
• Eight new regional water system planning authorities in England and one national authority in Wales to be responsible for water investment plans reflecting local priorities and streamlining the planning processes.
The new authorities would be independent, made up of representatives from local councils, public health officials, environmental advocates, agricultural voices and consumers. The aim is they could direct funding and ensure accountability from all sectors impacting water.
• Greater consumer protection - this includes upgrading the consumer body Consumer Council for Water, into an Ombudsman for Water to give stronger protection to customers and a clearer route to resolving complaints. Advocacy duties are to be transferred to Citizens Advice.
• Stronger environmental regulation, including compulsory water meters. Also proposed by Sir Jon are changes to wholesale tariffs for industrial users and greater water reuse and rainwater harvesting schemes. A new long-term, legally binding target for the water environment was suggested.
• Oversight of companies via the ability to block changes in ownership of water businesses when they are not seen to be prioritising the long-term interests of the company and its customers, and the addition of "public benefit" clauses in water company licences.
To boost company financial resilience, as the UK's biggest provider, Thames Water struggles to remain in private ownership, the commission has recommended minimum financial requirements, like banks are subject to. This could mean utilities hold a certain amount of cash. It's hoped this will, in turn, make companies more appealing to potential investors.
• The public health element of water has been recognised, and senior public health representation has been recommended for regional water planning authorities, as have new laws to address pollutants like forever chemicals and microplastics.
• Fundamental reset of economic regulation - including changes to ensure companies are investing in and maintaining assets to help attract long-term, low-risk investment. A "supervisory" approach has been recommended to intervene before things like pollution occur, rather than penalising the businesses after the event.
• Clear strategic direction - a long-term, 25-year national water strategy should be published by the UK and Welsh governments, with ministerial priorities given to water firms every five years.
• Infrastructure and asset health reforms - companies should also be required to map and assess their assets and resilience.
Nationalisation of the water industry was not in the Independent Water Commission's terms of reference and so was not considered.
How has the report been received?
In a speech responding to Sir Jon's report, Mr Reed is set to describe the water industry as "broken" and welcome the commission's recommendations to ensure "the failures of the past can never happen again".
The water industry lobby group Water UK said "fundamental change has been long overdue".
"These recommendations should establish the foundations to secure our water supplies, support economic growth and end sewage entering our rivers and seas," a spokesperson said.
"The Independent Water Commission has written a comprehensive, detailed review of the whole sector, with many wide-ranging and ambitious recommendations.
"Crucially, it is now up to government to decide which recommendations it will adopt, and in what way, but the commission's work marks a significant step forward."
Campaign group Surfers Against Sewage said the report "utterly fails to prioritise public benefit over private profit".
"This is not transformational reform, this is putting lipstick on a pig - and you can bet the champagne is flowing in water company boardrooms across the land," said its chief executive, Giles Bristow.
"Only one path forward remains: a full, systemic transformation that ends the ruthless pursuit of profit and puts the public good at the heart of our water services," he said.
"We welcome Sir Jon's calls for a national strategy, enshrining public health objectives in law and regional water planning. But we won't be taken for fools - abolishing Ofwat and replacing it with a shinier regulator won't stop sewage dumping or profiteering if the finance and ownership structures stay the same."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
a minute ago
- The Independent
Gordon Brown: Raise gambling taxes to fund abolition of benefit cap
Gordon Brown has warned that Britain is experiencing its worst poverty in over half a century, urging Sir Keir Starmer to abolish the two-child benefit cap. The former prime minister proposed funding the abolition of the cap, which would cost £3.2 billion, through reforms to gambling taxes. Mr Brown supported a report by The Institute For Public Policy Research (IPPR) suggesting that increased gambling taxes could lift around half a million children out of poverty. The two-child benefit cap, introduced by George Osborne, restricts benefit claims for third or subsequent children born after April 2017. The Betting and Gaming Council has criticised the proposed tax increases, arguing they are 'economically reckless' and could push consumers towards unregulated black markets.
The Independent
a minute ago
- The Independent
Average tracker mortgage borrower set to see £29 fall in monthly payments
The average homeowner on a tracker mortgage will see nearly £29 shaved off their monthly payments, following the quarter point cut in the Bank of England base rate, according to industry figures. Banking and finance industry body UK Finance calculated that the reduction in the base rate on Thursday, from 4.25% to 4%, will mean the typical mortgage holder on a deal that directly tracks the base rate will pay £28.97 per month less, based on the average balance outstanding. Over a year, this adds up to a reduction of nearly £350 (£347.64). Those on a standard variable rate (SVR) deal could see their monthly mortgage payments reduce by £13.87 on average, adding up to an annual saving of £166.44 – provided the lender passes on the base rate cut in full. Borrowers often end up on an SVR when their initial deal ends and the rate is set by individual lenders but often follows movements in the base rate. Homeowners on fixed-rate mortgages will see no immediate change, although thousands are due to remortgage in the months ahead. Around 900,000 fixed-rate mortgage deals are due to expire in the second half of 2025, according to UK Finance's figures, with 1.6 million fixed deals having ended or being due to end across the whole of the year. Charles Roe, director of mortgages at UK Finance, said: 'Today's rate cut by the Bank of England takes us back to where we were just over two years ago when rates were last at 4%. 'While most mortgage holders are on fixed-rate deals, the cut will be welcomed by those on tracker or variable rate mortgages. This rate reduction should also help new mortgage applicants, as affordability and overall borrowing costs could improve.' Nicholas Mendes, mortgage technical manager at John Charcol said: 'Mortgage rates have been edging lower in recent weeks, helped by falling swap rates and a fresh price war among lenders. 'Many banks are off their annual targets, particularly on the purchase side, so they're sharpening rates to compete for remortgage business instead. That's why we've started to see a handful of five and two-year fixed rates priced below 3.8%, even as inflation remains above target.' He said that for those borrowers 'rolling off sub-2% pandemic-era deals this year, the gap between old and new repayments is still significant, but it's narrowing. The payment shock is nowhere near what we were seeing 12 to 18 months ago.' Mr Mendes added: 'For anyone approaching the end of their current mortgage deal, it makes sense to start the process around four to six months before it expires, depending on your lender. 'That gives you time to consider both a product transfer with your existing lender and the option of remortgaging to a new one. Most lenders will allow you to secure a rate early, which means that if the market moves against you and rates rise, you are protected. 'If rates fall, there is often the opportunity to switch to a lower deal before completion, either with the same lender or a different one, provided you have kept an eye on fees, timelines and any cancellation clauses.' Matt Smith, a mortgage expert at Rightmove, said: 'Lenders have been competing for business in a market which has the largest supply of homes for sale in a decade. 'A combination of rate cuts and changes to buyer affordability criteria are helping many home movers to responsibly borrow more towards the home that they want. 'The market expects there will be one more (Bank of England base rate) cut before the end of the year, with an outside chance of two. Any further cuts would likely see this cycle repeat again, with lenders using it as an opportunity to reduce rates a little more. 'It bodes well for the second half of this year, with further mortgage rate reductions and stable prices likely to encourage more activity.' Mark Manning, managing director of Northern Estate Agencies Group said: 'Today's rate reduction will help to settle people's nerves and ensure the property market remains buoyant.' Rachel Springall, a finance expert at said: 'The continuation of falling mortgage rates will instil a sense of confidence among borrowers.' She added: 'Lenders have also been relaxing stress tests to further support mortgage customers.' Ms Springall added: 'In positive news, swap rates have been edging downwards once again in recent days, which will give lenders more scope to reduce fixed mortgage rates.' She said: 'There remains a clear financial gain for borrowers to shift from a variable rate mortgage onto a cheaper fixed rate, as a typical mortgage borrower being charged the current average standard variable rate of 7.42% would be paying £372 more per month, compared to a typical two-year fixed rate.' Moneyfacts' calculation was based on a £250,000 mortgage, being repaid over a 25-year term. Ms Springall also said that base rate reductions 'will spell further misery for savers'. She said: 'It is essential that savers do not wait around for too long to snap up the top rates on the market, particularly if they use their pots to supplement their monthly income.' According to the average easy-access savings rate on the market in August is 2.68%, down from 3.15% in the same month a year ago. The average easy-access Isa on the market in August offers 2.90% in interest, down from 3.36% a year earlier, the financial information website said. Thomas Lambert, a financial planner at wealth manager Quilter said: 'Cash savings rates have been among the few beneficiaries of the Bank's earlier rate hikes, but they are now under pressure as expectations shift. 'Banks and building societies are typically quick to respond to rate cuts, particularly on easy-access accounts, meaning the top rates may start to slip. 'Fixed-rate savings products may hold up for a little longer as institutions manage existing funding strategies, but the overall trend is clear. Those looking to make the most of their savings may want to consider locking in rates now, while they remain relatively high. 'The broader challenge is that many savings rates are once again falling below inflation, and the erosion of real returns is becoming an issue for households trying to preserve the value of their money. 'Diversification, including a considered approach to investing, may be needed to maintain purchasing power over time.' The value of investments can go down as well as up. Jenny Ross, editor of Which? Money, said: 'If you're a saver, now is the time to take stock of your accounts. Banks will likely be swift to cut the interest paid on variable rate accounts, so shop around to make sure your money is working as hard for you as it can.'
The Independent
a minute ago
- The Independent
Interest rates cut to 4% as UK inflation picks up
UK interest rates have been cut to their lowest level since March 2023, despite the Bank of England predicting a sharp rise in inflation amid accelerating food prices. The central bank chose to reduce interest rates to 4% from 4.25%, pointing towards a recent fall in wage inflation and reduced uncertainty over the impact of US tariffs. The cut came after the Bank's nine-person rate-setting committee was forced to take a second vote for the first time in its history. The Bank's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) initially saw four of its committee vote for the 0.25 percentage point reduction, four vote to keep rates at 4.25% and one, Alan Taylor, vote for a 0.5 percentage point cut. Governor Andrew Bailey then led a second vote, when Mr Taylor gave his backing for a cut to 4%, providing a majority of five to four. Mr Bailey said: 'We've cut interest rates today, but it was a finely balanced decision. 'Interest rates are still on a downward path, but any future rate cuts will need to be made gradually and carefully.' Lower interest rates will be welcomed by Chancellor Rachel Reeves, and the move is likely to reduce the Government debt payment costs. It comes after warnings from the NIESR think tank that the Chancellor may need to find a further £40 billion through tax rises or spending cuts in her autumn Budget in order to balance the state finances. Firms were already hit by significant tax and wage cost increases in April after Ms Reeves' first Budget. In its fresh report, the Bank of England warned that UK businesses said increased national insurance contribution payments and uncertainty caused by the tax rise have 'weighed on growth'. Nevertheless, the Bank raised its economic growth forecast for this year, predicting that GDP (gross domestic product) will grow by 1.25% in 2025, up from its previous estimate of 1%. It comes despite latest figures from the Office for National Statistics showing that the economy contracted in both April and May. Bank officials indicated that the economy is still likely to have grown by 0.1% over the second quarter, and predicted this will pick up further through the year amid hopes that reduced interest rates will encourage spending. Meanwhile, inflation is expected to accelerate in the coming months, putting more pressure on household budgets. Consumer price index (CPI) inflation is now on track to peak at 4% in September, surpassing previous guidance that it would peak at 3.5%. The increased cost of living is largely being driven by higher energy and food prices, according to the Bank. Food prices have jumped in recent months, with the cost of beef, chocolate and coffee all accelerating. The inflation reading for September could also be influential as it is typically used to decide how much benefits increase the following year and is also one aspect of the pension triple lock. The triple lock means that pensions will rise by the highest of the September inflation reading, wage inflation for the month, or 2.5%. Inflation will remain higher than previously expected for the next two years. The Bank said inflation is now on track to drop down to the 2% target rate set by the Government in 2027. On Thursday, the Bank also said it now had increased clarity over the potential impact of US President Donald Trump's tariff regime compared with its previous report in May. It said tariffs will now drag down UK economic growth by 0.2 percentage points, down from 0.3, after the Government's trade agreement with the US.
