Fraudster ordered to pay back illegally obtained money to SARS
Mphephu was accused of defrauding the South African Revenue Services, which led to SARS suffering a loss of R1 070 000 during the 2013/2014 income tax financial year returns.
According to Lieutenant Colonel Magonseni Nkosi (provincial spokesperson of the Hawks), Mphephu intentionally filed fraudulent tax returns for six Transnet employees. After investigations were conducted, it was discovered that he added false information on medical tax certificate returns without members' knowledge.
The matter was then reported to the Hawks Serious Commercial Crimes Investigation unit based in Middelburg for further investigations.
Mphephu was charged with Contravention of the Tax Administration Act.
Charges were also laid against the six Transnet employees, but were later withdrawn.
He was sentenced to eight years' imprisonment or pay a R200 000 fine.
Mphephu was ordered to pay R70 000 of the fine immediately, and the remaining amount to be paid in instalments of R2 500 by the seventh day of each month, from September 2025.
He was further ordered to pay R50 000 to the Criminal Assets Recovery Account before August 28.
Three years of his sentence was suspended for five years, on the condition that he is not convicted of a similar offence.
The media statement that was sent out said that SARS managed to recover some of the money from Mphephu and his six co-accused.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
7 hours ago
- The Citizen
Videos: How a TikTok video saved a former golf prodigy from Pretoria streets
More than a year ago, a viral TikTok video of a Pretoria man begging at a Lynnwood traffic light touched thousands of hearts. According to Pretoria Rekord, that man was Jaco Niemand (40), a former South African golf champion who had been trapped in addiction and living on the streets for nearly 15 years. The video sparked an outpouring of support, setting Niemand on a path of recovery that has brought him further than he ever thought possible. His love for golf began when he was just four years old. By the age of nine, he had become the South African champion over 3km in his age group — a promising young sportsman with dreams of making it big. After school, he pursued his studies in golf, confident of a bright future in the sport. The vicious cycle of addiction During his university years, Niemand's life took a darker turn. Introduced to drugs, he soon found himself partying hard, making a lot of money, and numbing his emotions with cocaine. Over time, he moved on to Cat, heroin, and finally, nyaope. 'I started using to suppress pain I didn't want to deal with,' he says. 'As men, we're never really taught how to handle our emotions.' The more he used, the more his life unraveled. Eventually, he lost everything — his possessions, his career prospects, and his home. His addiction demanded up to R2 500 a day, with each fix costing around R250. 'It's a vicious cycle — the more your conscience bothers you, the more you use to silence it,' he explains. A second chance By the time photographer Albert Bredenhann met him in Lynnwood, Niemand was gaunt, desperate, and dangerously close to death. That day, Bredenhann gave him R100 — money Niemand admits he used to buy drugs. But the real turning point came the next day, when Bredenhann returned, took him for coffee, and drove him directly to a rehabilitation centre, stopping to buy him clothes along the way because Niemand had nothing. 'When I saw Jaco and heard his story, I knew he didn't belong on the streets,' Bredenhann says. 'I wanted people to see that those on the streets are human beings with dreams and hope.' At the rehab centre, Niemand broke down under a hot shower — his first in months. 'On the streets, lice take over your body. That shower felt like washing off my old life,' he says. This wasn't his first attempt at sobriety. Niemand had tried seven times before, relapsing six times. 'In the beginning, I stayed clean for Albert — I didn't want to disappoint him. But after six weeks, I realised I had to do it for myself.' One of his hardest moments in recovery was apologising to his twin brother, who had driven every month to beg him to go to rehab. 'I wasn't ready before. Timing is everything.' Rediscovering his passion Now 20kg heavier, Niemand is healthier, happier, and rediscovering his passions. Most days, he can be found on the golf course — the place he says feels most like home. 'Golf has been my passion since I was four. It's part of who I am, and I still dream of a future in it.' He also cherishes life's simplest joys. 'One of my proudest moments after rehab was making my first plate of food for myself — spaghetti bolognese,' he smiles. Niemand and Bredenhann are now close friends, often sharing a braai together. For Bredenhann, the reward is seeing Niemand thrive. 'When we took him to rehab, he had nothing. That's where support really matters.' Niemand hopes his story will inspire others still trapped on the streets or in addiction. 'Drugs kill you from the inside out. All you think about is your next fix. But you can break free — you just can't do it alone.' Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel. Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal. Read original story on
The Citizen
8 hours ago
- The Citizen
Sars fights on, as illicit trade ‘devastates' SA's fiscus
Criminals must know they are in the tax man's sights. The South African economy loses billions of rands to tax evasion and illicit financial flows annually, but the South African Revenue Service (Sars) continues to wage its battle against tax fraud. In 2020, Business Leadership South Africa estimated that the country lost around R250 million daily as a direct result of illicit trade. In 2022, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development estimated that South Africa was losing $3.5 billion to $5 billion (R62 billion to R88.8 billion) a year, or more than 1% of its GDP, to illicit financial flows. In a statement on its website at the end of last year, Sars said it was determined to act on tax crime in SA and it wanted those committing this crimes to know that they are firmly in its sights. ALSO READ: SA loses R30 billion in revenue due to illicit trade in cigarettes and liquor Real threat Sars notes that the impact of activities within the illicit economy is enormous and poses a real threat to the country. It quotes the United Nations, which stated that 'money flowing to organised crime outstripped all the money that the developing countries could devote to long-term development'. A large number of illicit cigarettes are consumed in South Africa every year. 'That means we lose excise revenue every year. That sort of revenue would build quite a few more schools, roads and houses which we need,' says Sars. Moneyweb recently reported that cheap cigarettes, sometimes selling for around R5 per packet of 20 in the market, translate into an estimated R28 billion loss to the fiscus annually. Or put differently, around R100 million each working day. ALSO READ: Illicit tobacco sales a drag on excise tax collections A win for Sars One recent success for Sars was a high court confirmation of a preservation order against several entities associated with Amalgamated Tobacco Manufacturing. In June this year, the Durban High Court issued its judgment in an application by Sars for the confirmation of a preservation order against two entities, Plus0 (read PlusZero) and Dodo, after a provisional preservation order was granted against 20 respondents in February this year. The matter pertains to a Sars investigation into a 'co-ordinated scheme of tax evasion' and the potential dissipation of assets. The two entities wanted the preservation order to be discharged completely. Plus0 and Dodo were placed in the hands of a curator bonis following the execution of the preservation order in March this year. Tax Justice SA last week issued a statement welcoming the confirmation of the preservation order. Its founder, Yusuf Abramjee, said the order will allow Sars to continue securing assets while investigating more than R96 million in suspicious financial transfers involving the Pietermaritzburg-based cigarette maker. ALSO READ: SA losing nearly R30bn to illicit cigarettes as Sars tools face delays, says Godongwana Robust powers 'This case demonstrates exactly why Sars needs robust investigative powers and why the illicit tobacco trade continues to devastate our fiscus,' Abramjee said. 'When a court finds a tobacco manufacturer has a case to answer over millions in under-declared income, it confirms what we've been saying for years – the industry is riddled with tax dodgers who are bleeding the country dry.' Sars says on its website that every South African can help stem the growth of the illicit economy by refusing to buy counterfeit goods or contraband cigarettes, and by reporting poaching incidents to Sars, the police, and the Department of Environmental Affairs. They are also encouraged to report informal trade in precious stones. Sars said it is taking specific actions, including: Increased supervision of cigarettes exported via warehouses; Improving the manual tracking of cigarettes in transit through South Africa; Working with tobacco industry experts to develop a way of detecting illicit cigarettes; and Conducting more retail inspections. ALSO READ: South Africans smoked 37 billion cigarettes in 2023, but only 13 billion were taxed Research firm Ipsos conducted a study commissioned by British American Tobacco into the cheapest purchase prices in the cigarette market. The study indicated that almost 70% of 4 812 retailers approached in their mystery shopper research sold cigarettes below R20 per pack. The minimum collectable tax (MCT) for a packet of 20 cigarettes is R26.22 (R22.80 for excise duties and R3.42 for Vat). Ipsos found that cigarettes sold for less than MCT have reached record-high levels in 2025, at 76.6% up from 27% in 2022. The hotspots for cheap cigarettes sold by retailers in SA are the Eastern, Northern and Western Cape as well as North West province. Purchases at R26.22 and below occurred at more than 80% of the retail stores sampled in these provinces. Moneyweb is awaiting a response from Sars regarding the impact of its actions over the past six months. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Civil wife vs ‘customary wife': Widow's legal fight over late husband's R1.6m pension hits another delay
Tshifhiwa Shembry Mutsila has been embroiled in a legal battle with the Municipal Gratuity Fund for 10 years. After a decade-long legal battle, a widow will have to wait at least another three months to find out whether she is entitled to her late husband's full R1.6 million pension. Tshifhiwa Shembry Mutsila has been in and out of court since 2015, after another woman, Dipuo Masete, claimed she was also married to the deceased under customary law and financially dependent on him. Husband's death sparks battle over R1.6 million pension Mutsila married Takalani Emmanuel Mutsila in December 2003 in a civil marriage. The couple had five children. Takalani, who worked for the Ba Phalaborwa Municipality in Limpopo, died in December 2012 in a workplace accident. His dependants were entitled to R1 614 434.86 under Section 37C of the Pension Funds Act. However, Masete lodged a claim with the Municipal Gratuity Fund (MGF), saying she and her two children had been named beneficiaries in the deceased's life policy and that he made regular payments into her bank account. ALSO READ: Councils take pension billions Although Mutsila disputed the claim, the MGF board in April 2014 decided to split the death benefit -awarding Mutsila and her five children 47.5%, and Masete and her two children 52.5%. A private investigator hired by Mutsila later found that Masete was married to Malema Joseph Mphafudi under customary law and that he was the biological father of her two children. This revelation sparked a custody battle brought by Mphafudi against Masete in the Limpopo High Court. Masete did not dispute these findings. Adjudicator's ruling In May 2014, Mutsila challenged the MGF's decision with the Pension Funds Adjudicator. While the adjudicator invited both the fund and Masete to respond, the MGF requested a delay until the custody matter was finalised. The adjudicator subsequently found that the MGF had not properly identified the deceased's dependants and set aside the decision in September 2014. The fund was instructed to conduct a proper investigation and make an equitable distribution of the death benefit within three weeks of the custody case's conclusion. READ MORE: Thousands denied pensions as employers fail to pay The MGF, however, approached the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria in April 2015 to overturn the adjudicator's decision. That application was dismissed in June 2018, and its appeal was rejected in November 2021. The high court found that the fund had distributed the pension before properly identifying dependants. SCA reversal Despite the earlier losses, the MGF was granted a special appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA). It argued that the adjudicator lacked jurisdiction and that Mutsila should have lodged her complaint directly with the fund under section 30A(1) of the Pension Funds Act before approaching the adjudicator. The MGF also contended it had not been heard before the adjudicator made a determination. In July 2023, the SCA ruled in favour of the fund, finding the adjudicator had not given it the opportunity to respond to Mutsila's complaint. The court also highlighted that Masete's factual dependency had not been challenged. ConCourt judgment Mutsila then escalated the matter to the Constitutional Court (ConCourt), where the appeal was heard in November 2024. Former MGF CEO Marthinus Jacobsohn argued before the apex court that the finding that Masete and her two children had been supported by the deceased was 'both rational and sound'. Judge Leona Theron, however, pointed out that the fund did not know about Masete's marriage to Mphafudi at the time of its decision and had failed to conduct a proper investigation within the 12-month period from the death of a member. 'The fund was not aware that he was the biological father of her children, that he was still alive, and that he could support the children financially. 'The only fact mentioned in the fund's founding affidavit filed in the high court and annexures attached thereto is that Ms Masete declared dependency on the deceased in the amount of R2 000. 'There is no evidence that the fund carried out any investigations to determine for itself or confirm this declared dependency. 'There is no allegation in the documents attached by the fund to its founding affidavit to the effect that the deceased either maintained Ms Masete's children, paid for their school fees and clothing, or provided them with shelter,' the judgment, delivered on 8 August 2025, reads. Theron also pointed out that Mutsila had not demonstrated exceptional circumstances warranting the ConCourt to replace the fund's decision with a new order. She, therefore, ruled that the case be sent back to the MGF for a new investigation as the dispute stemmed from their 'flawed decision'. 'It is important to note that the outcome of the custody proceedings between Ms Masete and Mr Mphafudi have no bearing on the order of this court,' Theron added. The ConCourt upheld Mutsila's appeal and ordered the MGF to make a fresh determination within three months of the judgment. The fund was also ordered to pay Mutsila's legal costs. NOW READ: This is what a divorce will do to your pension fund
