Parents of Millsap ISD students file lawsuit over abuse of special-needs kids
The parents, Carissa Cornelius, Vanessa Garcia and Whitney Price, are suing Millsap ISD over alleged physical and mental abuse their children endured in their school's special education classrooms, according to the lawsuit filed Tuesday in the Northern Texas U.S. District Court.
Named as defendants along with the school district are former superintendent Mari Edith Martin, Millsap Elementary School principal Roxie Carter, and Jennifer Dale and Paxton Bean, the two educators who were accused of abusing the kids.
Martin, Dale and Bean also face criminal charges and were arrested earlier this year.
The parents are suing on a total of nine counts. Against the school district, these include:
Failure to train
Failure to supervise
Violation of the right to bodily integrity
Discrimination and other violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act
Violation of the Rehabilitation Act
Dale and Bean are also being sued on five counts, including:
Violation of the right to bodily integrity
Discrimination in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act
Assault
Battery
Negligent discipline
The parents claim that the school district did not provide Bean and Dale with training on proper discipline, crisis prevention or positive behavioral techniques specific to children with special needs. They were still assigned to work in a special education classroom, the lawsuit says. The parents also say that the school did not supervise how its teachers interacted with and disciplined students with special needs.
The lawsuit alleges that Millsap ISD, Bean and Dale violated the children's right to bodily integrity 'as they were subject to physical and mental assault by state actors.' It also states that all three discriminated against the students for their disabilities.
Finally, the two teachers are accused of assault, battery and negligent discipline, according to the lawsuit.
'By all accounts, these children are beautiful, bright, and deserved the world. Instead, they were treated like animals; physically and verbally abused, and subject to sexual denigration by their teachers,' the lawsuit states.
Millsap ISD has not yet responded to a request for comment on the lawsuit. Attorneys for the other defendants are not listed in the court documents and could not immediately be reached for comment.
The school came under fire after a video showing Dale and Bean appearing to hit a child went viral, the Star-Telegram previously reported.
The video, taken on Feb. 19, shows Dale swinging at Alex Cornelius, a 10-year-old boy who has autism and is non-verbal, and Bean yelling and throwing a toy at him, according to court documents.
A teaching assistant filmed the incident without the two teachers' knowledge and reported it to Martin the same day, according to the complaint.
Cornelius shared the allegations and the video on Facebook on March 10. Along with the alleged abuse displayed in the video, Cornelius also told the Star-Telegram that her son was showered at the school without her consent and that the teachers called him names and made comments about his genitalia.
Martin, according to her arrest warrant, contacted a law firm for an external investigation. She did not file a report with the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services or the Parker County Sheriff's Office, both of which are required by state law.
Martin reported allegations involving Dale to the Texas Education Agency on Feb. 28. A report including allegations against Bean was filed on March 3.
Texas state law requires that suspected abuse be reported within 48 hours.
Cornelius said she was not made aware of the allegations until the teaching assistant brought the video to her. The Sheriff's Office told the Star-Telegram that it first became aware of the allegations on March 4, when Cornelius reported the abuse to them.
The Parker County Sheriff's Office discovered at least two other students — the children of the other plaintiffs — who experienced abuse from Bean and Dale, according to arrest warrant affidavits.
Whitney Price, another plaintiff in the lawsuit, told police that on Jan. 16, school staff told her that her 8-year-old son had gotten a bloody nose from running into a wall. When police read the nurse's log, Bean had said that the boy threw a fit and hit his nose on either a wall or her arm. Price said her son told her that Bean had punched him in the nose.
Victoria Garcia, the third plaintiff in the lawsuit, said that her 6-year-old daughter was another victim. According to the affidavits, a teacher's aide heard Dale call the girl a vulgar name and tell her that she wanted to 'put her hands around the child's neck and squeeze.'
Both teachers and Martin were arrested in March. Martin was charged with a felony of failure to report with the intent to conceal. Dale was charged with official oppression, a Class A misdemeanor, and Bean was charged with official oppression and injury to a child with intentional bodily injury, a third-degree felony.
Martin resigned from her position as superintendent without severance pay in March.
All three women were released on bond, the Star-Telegram reported.
The initial TEA report from Martin did not include Bean's name, according to the lawsuit. Bean is the daughter of Carter, the Millsap Elementary principal.
Bean is now working at another school in Waxahachie, according to the lawsuit. Carter wrote a recommendation letter for her position there.
Millsap ISD has since approved a policy disallowing employees from evaluating, hiring or working with immediate family members on the same campus.
The parents are asking for a jury trial and compensation for medical expenses, physical impairment and pain, and mental anguish, leaving it up to a jury to decide the exact amount of damages, the complaint stated.
Cornelius told the Star-Telegram on Wednesday that she is now permanently homeschooling her son, Alex. 'We now have no trust in anyone when it comes to our children,' Cornelius said.
She described how her son now experiences a lot of anxiety, and he will wake up in the morning afraid that he will go back to school. She said both she and her son are now in therapy.
'It's not about the money,' Cornelius said about the lawsuit. 'It's about holding them accountable for what they did.'
Cornelius believes that more laws need to be passed for the safety of students, including having cameras in every special needs classroom and requiring that teachers undergo a psychiatric evaluation during the hiring process. 'I think that until that, and until we start holding teachers accountable for their actions, then nothing is ever going to change,' she said.
Cornelius said she hopes that this lawsuit gets the children justice and shows Millsap ISD, as well as other schools, that they can not mess with their children.
'Our kids may not be able to talk, but we sure can,' Cornelius said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
16 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Video of Merrillville woman's arrest by Lake County Sheriff's Department shows excessive force before miscarriage, lawyer says
A Merrillville woman's lawyer said recently released bodycam footage backs up her accusations that Lake County Sheriff's deputies forcibly pulled her from a vehicle during an arrest despite knowing she was pregnant. Three months later, she had a miscarriage. I'm '(expletive) pregnant,' Shikeia Randolph, 31, yells just before two officers pull her from a red Chevrolet Trailblazer, according to video obtained by the Post-Tribune through a public records request. A federal lawsuit accusing the officers of excessive force was filed two months ago in the U.S. District Court in Hammond. It alleges that a 3:24 a.m. traffic stop on June 5, 2023 was 'pretextual' — for an issue with a license plate cover, then a school truancy warrant — and quickly spiraled out of control. The video from an officer's dashboard camera appears to show, as she is arrested, the two officers turn her on her stomach as one pins her down to handcuff her hands behind her back. Randolph previously told the Post-Tribune she had just stopped for milk at a 24-hour gas station in Gary near Ridge Road and Grant Street with her four kids in the vehicle. She was supposed to drop them off at her mother's house, then head to her early shift as a receptionist at the Gary Housing Authority. Officer Peter Hamady, who pulled her over, is named with the sheriff's department in the lawsuit. His lawyer Casey McCloskey declined comment. In a federal filing on Aug. 7, McCloskey formally denied the accusations against Hamady, saying in part that his actions were 'objectively reasonable' and protected by 'qualified immunity.' Some of Randolph's claims could fall outside of a two-year statute of limitations, he wrote. McCloskey argued because Randolph refused to get out of her SUV, she forced cops to go after her, according to court documents. She disputed this, in interviews with the Post-Tribune. On the way to booking, Randolph tells Hamady the truancy case in Merrillville Town Court was for taking her daughter repeatedly to school a little late when she was in pain from just having another baby, according to footage recorded inside Hamady's police car. He appears to soften. 'I didn't know they had warrants for that,' he said in the footage. In an interview, Matthew Custardo, Randolph's lawyer in the federal lawsuit, argued the use of force was unjustified, even if she was arguing with the cops. 'She was confused why she was being pulled over,' he said. 'She's scared. She has every reason to be a little concerned about what's going on. She's standing up for herself, certainly.' According to the nearly 40-minute bodycam video, police officers tell her to call someone to pick up the kids, so they don't have to call child protective services. Originally, Randolph said she thought it might have been a warrant for an old driving while suspended case. 'Call CPS for what?' she responds in the video. 'A warrant for a suspended license?' 'It's not for that,' Hamady tells her in the footage. After she asks again, he says it's for truancy. 'Listen, you have a warrant,' Hamady said in the video. 'You're lucky I don't have you cuffed out of the car right now. You wanna go that route?' In the video, she accuses Hamady of pulling out of a nearby parking lot before she passed him. 'Ma'am, I was behind you,' he responded in the footage. At least three other officers are in view. 'I'm taking you to court,' she the phone, Randolph tells her mother the '(expletive) police' pulled her over as she asked her to get her kids, according to the video. She asks officers to wait until her mother arrives. 'I guess they are going to take me to jail,' she said over the phone in the footage. Randolph said in a previous interview with the Post-Tribune that the encounter appeared to escalate when she rolled up her window slightly to hear what her mom was saying. The arrest happens within about 12 minutes into the footage. As officers open her car door and grab her arm, Randolph's children can be heard crying in the back seat. 'This is your last warning,' one of the officers said in the video. 'We don't want your kids to see this.' 'You already freaked my kids out,' she said. 'Get out of the (expletive) car,' one officer stated in the footage. I'm '(expletive) pregnant,' she yells just before two officers pull her from the vehicle after she tried to cling to the steering wheel in the video. 'Let me go! Get off of me! Please get off of me! Somebody help me!' After she is handcuffed on the ground, a police dog is seen in the background of the dashboard camera footage. Randolph's white shoes are scattered nearby. 'I'm trying to help you out here,' one officer tells her in the video. Randolph was charged with resisting law enforcement two months later. Hamady's account in court documents makes no mention of her pregnancy. During the ride to booking at the Lake County Jail, they talk at length about her decision to have a fifth child, according to footage inside the police car. Her fiancé wanted one last child, she said. When Hamady asks how far along she is on the video, she responds she's nearly 12 weeks pregnant. 'Well, congrats to you,' he said in the video. Hamady stated in the footage that her bond should be $400. It's 'not Friday, so it's a good thing,' he tells her in the video. 'I'll make sure they keep you updated.' He asks if she's comfortable as late-'90s era music plays over the radio, the footage shows, before they chat about where she is planning to get married. Do you 'want the window open back there, or are you good?' he asks in the video. Since police insisted on towing her red Chevrolet Trailblazer, Randolph's mother had to take four kids back in a cramped sedan, a situation that was not likely 'legally safe,' Custardo said. Randolph's lawsuit alleged her arrest suggested a 'broader pattern' in the Lake County Sheriff's Department, including 'inadequate training,' 'insufficient supervision' and a 'failure to implement effective accountability measures,' according to court documents. The Lake County Sheriff's Department refused to answer questions related to the incident, including what kind of de-escalation training its officers receive at various stages in their careers. Hamady joined the department in 2022, according to court filings. Sheriff Oscar Martinez Jr. declined comment through a spokeswoman, who said he could not discuss pending litigation. Watching the video with her mother was 'very emotional,' Randolph said in an Aug. 5 interview, especially hearing her kids crying in the video's background. She refused to let her 12-year-old daughter view it. 'I feel better now that I've seen it,' Randolph said. 'It matches the exact story I've been telling for so long.' There's been some 'expected' backlash online after a pair of articles in local newspapers, Randolph said. She was there trying to protect herself and her Williams, her criminal public defender, said she did remember parts of the case in retrospect, and confirmed she tried to get the bodycam from the Lake County Sheriff's Department 'multiple times' since the case was filed in August 2023. Court filings show one discovery request for the body cam was made as late as October 2024. The only reason not to turn it over was if they 'didn't want me to see something,' she said. Randolph was tired of repeatedly coming to court for a slow-moving case, Williams said. She told her client that she could fight to get the bodycam footage, or take a pretrial diversion to get rid of the case in a year. 'It's common to get slow discovery (evidence) when you're requesting bodycams,' Williams said, adding that some police departments are worse than others, but she's had 'good experience' with the sheriff's department in the past. Randolph's case is scheduled for a pretrial diversion hearing on Aug. 15. However, an automatic court filing on Aug. 11 appears to show there may be a snag. Court filings show Randolph, her fiancé and sister were charged June 26 with resisting law enforcement in Hobart. Hobart Police Cpl. Christopher Sipes wrote that Randolph and her fiancé got his attention around 1:30 a.m. May 25 on Main Street for ignoring a 'pedestrian signal.' , Randolph said they were out that night celebrating her fiancé's birthday. As End Zone let out across the street, a crowd, including the half-dozen in her group, were migrating to the other bar, Randolph said. At least two officers were there, as someone behind them yelled something about the guy handcuffed on the ground getting arrested nearby. The officer thought her fiancé said something, she said. Sipes wrote he and the other officer followed them into Cagney's. 'Bulls jersey, stop right there,' the other officer said to Randolph's fiancé, according to court records. As they got to the bar, Randolph said an officer grabbed her arm from behind. According to court documents, when the officer asked for identification, the couple 'ignored' him and said they 'didn't do anything.' Randolph 'stepped in front' of officers to block them from her fiance. As the cops went to arrest them just inside the bar's entrance, the crowd 'became aggressive,' the officer wrote. During a 'struggle' as she was being handcuffed, Randolph's black strapless top fell down, exposing her breasts, records state. Randolph said in an interview she tried to turn away for some privacy, because there were a 'million people standing around.' Once she stood up, an officer wrote, he pulled her top back up, records state. She denied she got in their way or refused to give her identification card. The officer was bigger than her, and it didn't make sense that she could overpower him. The whole incident was 'very unfortunate,' her lawyer Patrick Young said Aug. 7, adding he's working with prosecutors to resolve the case.
The Hill
2 days ago
- The Hill
New Orleans mayor indicted on federal corruption charges
New Orleans Mayor Latoya Cantrell (D) was indicted on federal charges Friday after an alleged affair with a local police officer. Cantrell, the city's first female mayor, is accused of engaging in a romantic relationship with Jeffrey Paul Vappie II, a police officer in the executive protection unit. Court documents allege she orchestrated out-of-state trips to maximize their opportunities to engage in 'personal activities' that cost the City of New Orleans over $70,000 in addition to travel expenses for Cantrell. Prosecutors say both Cantrell and Vappie were warned about misconduct in 2022. The Democratic mayor is in her final term as the city's leader and is now charged with making false statements and false declarations before a grand jury, conspiracy to obstruct justice and conspiracy to commit wire fraud. 'Aware their conduct violated rules, policies, and criminal laws, Cantrell and Vappir attempted to distract and impede inquiries and investigations, including a federal grand jury investigation, about the true nature and circumstances of their relationship and their scheme to defraud,' the indictment reads. 'They did this by using an encrypted messaging platform, intimidating and punishing subordinates, lying to colleagues and advisors, making false public pronouncements, harassing a o colleagues and advisors, making false public pronouncements, harassing a private individual who took pictures of them in public together, deleting electronic evidence, making false statements to federal law enforcement agents, authoring an affidavit signed under oath and penalty of perjury containing false information, and testifying falsely while under oath before a federal grand jury,' it continues. Cantrell will face charges in the U.S. District Court's Eastern District of Louisiana. This is a sad day for the people of New Orleans,' said Monet Brignac, a spokesperson for City Council President JP Morrell told The Associated Press. 'Our thoughts and prayers are with the Cantrell family as they navigate through this difficult time.' Cantrell previously alleged she was targeted as a Black woman and faced 'very disrespectful, insulting, in some cases kind of unimaginable' treatment, according to the AP.
NBC News
2 days ago
- NBC News
New Orleans Mayor LaToya Cantrell indicted after federal corruption investigation
New Orleans Mayor LaToya Cantrell has been charged after a corruption investigation and is accused of defrauding the city while trying to keep her romantic relationship with a police officer a secret, federal prosecutors said Friday. Cantrell is charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to obstruct justice, making false statements and false declaration before a grand jury, according to a federal indictment filed Friday in the U.S. District Court in the Eastern District of Louisiana. Shortly after news broke of the allegations, a lawyer for Cantrell told NBC News they had not yet seen the indictment and had no comment. Prosecutors allege that Cantrell was in a romantic relationship with Jeffrey Paul Vappie II, who served as a member of the Executive Protection Unit on occasions from May 2021 to April 2024. 'To hide their relations from detection and to maximize their time together, Cantrell and Vappie exploited their public positions to develop and implement a scheme to defraud the city of New Orleans and the New Orleans Police Department by engaging in personal activities while Vappie claimed to be on duty and was paid for,' the indictment states. New Orleans City Council President JP Morrell on Friday offered prayers for Cantrell and her family. 'Our office is aware of the indictment that was filed today,' Morrell said in a statement. 'This is a sad day for the people of New Orleans. Our thoughts and prayers are with the Cantrell family as they navigate through this difficult time." Cantrell, a Democrat, is serving her last term as mayor and is set to leave office in January. She is a Democrat and the city's first female mayor in its 300-year history. Her second term has been turbulent and she survived a recall effort in 2022.
