Restaurateur fights to protect synagogue from bulldozer
Describing the incident as very disturbing, Shek wrote to municipal commissioner Bhushan Gagrani on Monday, calling for immediate action against the alleged illegal activity at the Magen David Synagogue in Byculla, a Grade 2A heritage site belonging to the Baghdadi Jewish community. 'This synagogue… has been a vital part of my life, and many other prominent Jews who once lived in Byculla but are now settled abroad.'
For Shek, this battle is deeply personal. Raised in the street next to the synagogue, he was a part of very fabric of the city's Jewish community, and went on to become a pioneering restaurateur in Mumbai.
On Sunday, Shek says he was shocked to find portions of the synagogue's interior being bulldozed, including large supporting pillars and the women's gallery. The labour contractor present fled when confronted. When Shek left, he was allegedly assaulted by the synagogue's trustees and the workers, who also tried to snatch his phone to delete footage he had recorded. The situation escalated, prompting the on-site police to escort Shek to the police station, where his statement was recorded.
In his letter to Gagrani, Shek also raised concerns about the alleged misuse of a nearby children's school playground, which the synagogue trust is believed to have converted into a paved wedding venue without legal, civic or other permissions. 'I sincerely urge you to use your authority to halt these illegal activities and take legal action against those responsible,' he said.
Solomon Sopher, chairperson of the Sir Jacob Sassoon Charity Trust, which administers the synagogue, has issued a strong rebuttal. Sopher told HT that the Magen David Synagogue was built 170 years ago, and had recently exhibited signs of structural deterioration. The trust had engaged noted conservation architect Abha Narain Lambha – whose firm had restored the Keneseth Eliyahoo Synagogue in Kala Ghoda in 2019 – to prepare a restoration plan. According to Lambha's proposal, such a plan would cost ₹9.7 crore, a sum the trust could ill-afford.
Due to challenges in securing external funding, particularly during the Covid-19 pandemic and in the absence of FCRA (permission for foreign remittances), the trust opted to undertake basic emergency repairs, Sopher said. These included strengthening beams and columns, and preventing water seepage ahead of the monsoon. This interim work, overseen by an architect, a structural engineer and a contractor, was funded by the trust, he added.
During these repairs, a deteriorating wooden beam collapsed along with a portion of a balcony, highlighting the fragile state of the synagogue's ageing wooden structure, Sopher said. He denied all accusations made by Shek, particularly the claim that the synagogue or its adjoining land is being considered for sale.
Sopher reiterated the trust's commitment to restoring the Magen David Synagogue to its original splendour and resuming full religious services. Until then, all weekday and Shabbath services are being conducted at the Keneseth Eliyahoo Synagogue. 'We will not be misled by false propaganda by parties with hidden agendas,' Sopher remarked.
'They assaulted me and are now trying to shift blame. I had no reason to attack anyone,' Shek told HT, referring to Sopher's allegations that Shek had allegedly forced entry into the synagogue and assaulted two staff members, and obstructed the management team. 'The police have seen footage clearly showing them assaulting me, even in front of officers.'
He added, 'They lack the necessary permissions and used a quote from a well-known architect without hiring her. Now, they plan to use cheap labour and misuse trust funds to cover the costs.'
Conservation architect Abha Narain Lambah told HT that in 2021, her firm was paid ₹2 lakh to prepare a preliminary assessment report to support fundraising efforts. 'Our report identified the building as a Grade 2A heritage structure, which means that any intervention requires prior heritage permissions. We also estimated that around ₹9 crore would be needed to complete the restoration.
'Over the past four years, we were never given any formal appointment to begin work or take on the project. We were told repeatedly that there were no funds available. Now, Sopher has appointed a contractor without consulting me, and he is solely responsible for that decision. I would never have allowed any roof repairs without thorough due diligence and the necessary clearances from the heritage committee. Even temporary works require proper permissions,' she added.
Lambah said she was appalled at the damage to the synagogue. 'It's like visiting a doctor for a consultation and, four years later, deciding to perform your own surgery from a quack just to save money,' she added.
Acting on Shek's complaint, the BMC's building and factories department of C Ward visited the synagogue on Tuesday and pasted a stop-work notice as they had received no permissions or plans for any alterations to the structure.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
‘2.27 lakh transactions using single account': CAG flags Rs 59.32-cr excess in Covid-time benefit transfers in Karnataka
A report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General (CAG) of India tabled in the Karnataka Assembly on Wednesday flagged some payments made to beneficiaries in the state during the first wave of the Covid pandemic. The CAG has found that Rs 59.32 crore was paid in excess, while 2,195 beneficiaries could not be verified. The Karnataka Building and Other Construction Welfare Board provided details of around 16.46 lakh beneficiaries to whom aid to the tune of Rs 823.12 crore was provided using direct benefit transfer during the pandemic. 'An analysis of the data provided by the Board revealed that 2,27,231 transactions were conducted multiple times using the same bank account number,' the report noted. Further, 1,08,5689 beneficiaries received benefits multiple times through various payment methods. The CAG audit identified repetitive transactions resulting in excess payments amounting to Rs 59.32 crore. The CAG report on the board said that due to incomplete data provided by the Government, the genuineness of payments amounting to Rs 1.1 crore could not be verified. Irregularities that took place during the Covid pandemic are the subject of an ongoing investigation by the Justice Michael D'Cunha Commission, which has submitted two interim reports related to the procurement of various goods and services and the distribution of benefits during the pandemic. The CAG report also highlighted the registration of ineligible people as construction workers. The CAG scrutinised randomly selected 399 applicants for registration and renewal of beneficiaries available. Its report observed that 'employment certificate furnished along with the applications did not contain the details of employment but were accepted by the Registering Officer'. Tailors, clerks, weavers, and people pursuing some other occupations were registered as construction workers and availed of the benefits, the report said.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Ludhiana: 5 months after love marriage, 19-year-old woman ends life
Five months after solemnising love marriage, a 19-year-old woman ended her life by hanging herself from a ceiling fan in her rented accommodation in Mahavir Jain Colony on August 15. The Tibba police booked her husband for abetment to suicide. It is alleged that her husband used to thrash her in an inebriated condition. The sub-inspector added that the mother of the victim alleged that the husband of her daughter was an acute drinker and he used to thrash her in an inebriated condition. (HT Photo) The FIR has been registered on the statement of the victim's mother. The complainant stated that the family lives in Bihar. Her daughter had eloped with the accused in March this year and later they solemnised marriage against the will of the families. The couple started living in a rented accommodation in Mahavir Jain Colony in Ludhiana. Sub-inspector Kulwinder Singh, who is investigating the case, stated that the woman died by suicide on August 15. The police traced her family members and informed her about her death. The sub-inspector added that the mother of the victim alleged that the husband of her daughter was an acute drinker and he used to thrash her in an inebriated condition. Further, the sub-inspector added that an FIR under Section 108 of the BNS has been registered against the accused. A hunt is on for the arrest of the accused.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Ludhiana: Man duped, jailed in UK, deported; agent booked
A 23-year-old youth from Baba Nand Singh Nagar had to spend 15 days in a jail in England besides enduring a severe mental trauma after being sent abroad on forged documents, police officials have said. Stranded abroad, the victim managed to survive for about a month in a hotel at his own expense. (HT Photo) The victim, Manpreet Singh, was later deported to India where his family claims to have spent lakhs of rupees on legal help and medical treatment. According to the police, the accused has been identified as Shauki, a resident of Rurka village in Jalandhar. He allegedly collected ₹10.5 lakh from the victim's family, promising to arrange a work permit in England. Manpreet's father Pyara Singh, a retired insurance employee, said the money paid to the accused came from his retirement benefits. He alleged that his own brother (victim's uncle) had introduced them to Shauki, who convinced the family with claims of successfully sending several villagers abroad. The accused arranged for Manpreet's travel in October 2024. 'My son reached England on October 22, but the very next day his tourist visa expired. Since all the documents were fake and the email IDs were also controlled by the agent, my son didn't realise it,' said Pyara Singh. Stranded abroad, Manpreet managed to survive for about a month in a hotel at his own expense. In November, British authorities caught him during verification checks, found his documents fake and lodged him in jail for 15 days. Spent lakhs on rescue and treatment The distraught father said he immediately hired a lawyer in England at his own expense, spending nearly ₹5 lakh to secure his son's release, apart from another ₹1 lakh on his return ticket. 'My son returned alive. But the ordeal left him deeply disturbed,' he said. Back home, Manpreet slipped into depression and had to be admitted to the DMC Hospital for nearly a month, with the family spending another ₹1.5 lakh on treatment. The victim alleged that when he confronted his uncle about the money, he was first assured of repayment. 'Later, he flatly refused to return the money,' Manpreet said. After that the family lodged a complaint with the police in March. Following investigation, the Sadar police registered a case under Section 318(4) of the BNS and Section 24 of the Immigration Act against Shauki and launched a search for his arrest. Officials said the case highlights the dangers of trusting unscrupulous travel agents who exploit families with dreams of sending their children abroad. 'We are investigating the matter and the accused will be brought to justice,' said ASI Davinder Singh, who is investigating the case.
