Australian car dealers lose again as court rules in favour of Mercedes-Benz
The Federal Court has dismissed an appeal, filed in 2024, against a judgement it handed down in 2023.
In that ruling, where it found in favour of Mercedes-Benz Australia Pacific over a majority (38 of 50) of its franchised dealers, the Court found dealers hadn't been misled about the agency move and that Mercedes-Benz hadn't engaged in unconscionable conduct.
The Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) said it's 'bitterly disappointed' by today's decision, particularly as it follows the Supreme Court of Victoria's ruling earlier this year which found General Motors didn't breach its agreement with Australian dealers when it axed the Holden brand in 2020.
Hundreds of new car deals are available through CarExpert right now. Get the experts on your side and score a great deal. Browse now. Supplied Credit: CarExpert
It's pushing for the Federal Government to introduce additional protections for automotive franchisees 'so that the blueprint created by this court decision is not used by others'.
'We welcome the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in this matter. Our focus continues to be on delivering luxury products and services for our valued customers around Australia,' said a spokesperson for Mercedes-Benz.
At the heart of the original case, which commenced in October 2021, was the compensation Mercedes-Benz offered to dealers, although Justice Beach indicated Australian franchise law may once again need to be revisited and potentially modified.
'Australian dealers have been fighting to stop Mercedes-Benz using their power over franchised dealers to force them into one-sided business relationships. Today's decision is a significant blow to that fight which will have detrimental effects on Australia's franchising sector,' said AADA CEO James Voortman. Supplied Credit: CarExpert
'In handing down today's decision, there is now a clear need to protect Australian franchisees against unfair treatment from franchisors to arbitrarily change business models with no compensation.
'The presiding Judge in the original court decision clearly articulated the need for further amendments to the Franchising Code to protect the investments dealers make in their businesses.
'Today's decision confirms that current laws in Australia do not adequately protect new car dealers against unfair conduct and particularly are not being supported against unfair decisions being made in head office overseas.
'It is imperative that the Federal Government moves at speed to implement the commitments it made in the election to protect franchisees against unfair contract terms and unfair trading practices.'
The move to an agency retail model resulted in Mercedes-Benz taking ownership of dealership stock, and removing the ability for customers and dealership staff to negotiate on prices – a change which dealers claimed would drive up prices of new models. Supplied Credit: CarExpert
At the time of the initial court action, the 38 dealers were pursuing approximately $650 million in compensation.
Mercedes-Benz isn't the only auto brand to switch to an agency model in Australia, with Honda also doing the same – also resulting in legal action from some of its dealers.
Like Honda, Mercedes-Benz experienced a sales downturn after the switch in January 2022.
Deliveries of vehicles from its Cars division fell from 28,348 in 2021 to 26,801 in 2022, before dropping again in 2023 to 24,315 and then 19,989 in 2024.
But there's light at the end of the tunnel, it would appear, with deliveries in the first half of 2025 up 15.9 per cent on the same period last year to 11,146 in total – its best first-half of a year since 2023.
MORE: Everything Mercedes-Benz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Peugeot and Fiat parent steal design boss back from Renault
After five years at rival Renault, Gilles Vidal will become head of design for European brands for Stellantis from October 1. There he will oversee the design of cars, SUVs and vans from Peugeot, Citroen, DS, Opel/Vauxhall, Fiat/Abarth, Alfa Romeo, and Lancia. He replaces his former boss Jean-Pierre Ploué, who will leave Stellantis. His return to Stellantis is the latest in a series of executive changes and appointment since Antonio Filosa took charge of the French-Italian-American automaker in late June. CarExpert can save you thousands on a new car. Click here to get a great deal. Supplied Credit: CarExpert Mr Vidal has been the Renault Group's head of design Gilles Vidal. During his relatively short tenure there he has overseen a number of key models and important changes. The Renault 5 EV concept, which debuted in 2021, was turned into the 2024 production model. This has been joined by the 4 E-Tech, another retro-flavoured all-electric model, and starting with the 2023 Rafale, a new design language has been rolled out across the Renault lineup. On top of this he also oversaw the introduction of a harder-edged style for Dacia, and the transformation of Alpine into a brand that also encompasses sporty electric SUVs. Supplied Credit: CarExpert No interim or long-term successor has been named for Mr Vidal. His departure sees the French automaker thrown into more chaos. In June, CEO Luca de Meo suddenly quit to lead Kering, a luxury brand conglomerate that owns Gucci, Yves Saint Laurent, Balenciaga and others. Renault has appointed chief financial officer Duncan Minto as interim boss, but a full-time replacement has yet to be found. Prior to leading the Renault Group's design operations, Mr Vidal had spent all of his working life at Group PSA, the then-parent of Peugeot and Citroen. He joined Citroen in 1996 after graduating from the Art Centre College of Design in Vevey, Switzerland. He ascended through the ranks, working on both interior and exterior design, and managing the development of the first-generation Citroen C4 and C4 Picasso (above). Supplied Credit: CarExpert Mr Vidal was appointed as the Peugeot's brand chief designer in 2010, where he helped to craft a sportier and more modern image for the marque. Highlights include the 2013 Peugeot 308, the second-generation 508 launched in 2018, and the 3008 revealed in 2016. He also oversaw the introduction of the iCockpit interior design theme, which blends aircraft inspiration with the company's latest infotainment systems. MORE: Everything Peugeot
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
US President Donald Trump flags 20 per cent tariff ‘for the world', warns Australia of tougher trade barriers
US President Donald Trump has warned that the minimum tariff the United States imposes on its trading partners, including Australia—could soon double. Speaking at a press conference in Scotland, Mr Trump said he was planning a new universal tariff 'for the world.' Asked just how high it would go, he replied: 'I would say it'll be somewhere in the 15 to 20 per cent range. I just want to be nice. Probably one of those two numbers.' Currently, most US trading partners, Australia included, face America's 10 per cent 'baseline' tariff. In April, Mr Trump announced even higher 'reciprocal' tariffs for certain countries, but those increases were put on hold to allow negotiations on new trade agreements. Australia was not subject to the higher 'reciprocal' rate, but Mr Trump's latest comments suggest local exporters could be affected by the proposed global hike. 'We're going to be setting a tariff for, essentially, the rest of the world,' Mr Trump told reporters. 'That's what they're going to pay if they want to do business in the United States, because you can't sit down and make 200 deals.' Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has argued that the longstanding Australia-US free trade agreement and Australia's trade deficit with the US should exempt Australian imports from any new tariffs. Yet American officials continue to raise concerns about 'non-tariff barriers' to doing business, including laws requiring tech firms to pay for news content and rules governing the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme. In April, Mr Trump also took aim at Australia's biosecurity restrictions barring US beef imports, measures that the federal government has since agreed to lift. Mr Trump, who has vowed to end decades of US trade deficits by imposing tariffs on nearly all trading partners, has already announced higher rates of up to 50 per cent on some countries - including Brazil - starting on Friday. The announcements have spurred feverish negotiations by a host of countries seeking lower tariff rates including India, Pakistan, Canada and Thailand among others. The US president on Sunday clinched a huge trade deal with the European Union that includes a 15 per cent tariff on most EU goods, $US600 billion ($A920 billion) of investments in the US by European firms and $US750 billion in energy purchases over the next three years. That followed a $US550-billion deal with Japan last week and smaller agreements with the United Kingdom, Indonesia and Vietnam. Other talks are ongoing, including with India, but prospects have dimmed for many more agreements before Friday - Mr Trump's deadline for deals before higher rates take effect. Mr Trump has repeatedly said he favours straightforward tariff rates over complex negotiations. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said on Monday trade talks with the US were at an intense phase, conceding that his country was still hoping to walk away with a tariff rate below the 35 per cent announced by Mr Trump on some Canadian imports. Mr Carney conceded this month that Canada - which sends 75 per cent of its exports to the United States - would likely have to accept some tariffs. US and Chinese economic officials met in Stockholm on Monday for more than five hours of talks aimed at resolving longstanding economic disputes, seeking to extend a truce on tariffs by three months. US Treasury Chief Scott Bessent was part of a negotiating team that arrived at Rosenbad, the Swedish prime minister's office in central Stockholm, in the early afternoon. China's Vice Premier He Lifeng was also seen at the venue. China is facing an August 12 deadline to reach a durable tariff agreement with Trump's administration, after the two governments reached preliminary deals in May and June to end weeks of escalating tit-for-tat tariffs and a cut-off of rare earth minerals. Negotiators from the two sides were seen exiting the office about 8pm and did not stop to speak with reporters. The discussions are expected to resume on Tuesday. Mr Trump touched on the talks during a wide-ranging press conference with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Scotland. 'I'd love to see China open up their country,' Mr Trump said. Without an agreement, global supply chains could face renewed turmoil from US duties snapping back to triple-digit levels that would amount to a bilateral trade embargo. Trade analysts said another 90-day extension of a tariff and export control truce struck in mid-May between China and the United States was likely. - with AAP
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Trump threatens to double Australia's tariff to 20 per cent
US President Donald Trump has warned that the minimum tariff the United States imposes on its trading partners, including Australia—could soon double. Speaking at a press conference in Scotland, Mr Trump said he was planning a new universal tariff 'for the world.' Asked just how high it would go, he replied: 'I would say it'll be somewhere in the 15 to 20 per cent range. I just want to be nice. Probably one of those two numbers.' Currently, most US trading partners, Australia included, face America's 10 per cent 'baseline' tariff. In April, Mr Trump announced even higher 'reciprocal' tariffs for certain countries, but those increases were put on hold to allow negotiations on new trade agreements. Australia was not subject to the higher 'reciprocal' rate, but Mr Trump's latest comments suggest local exporters could be affected by the proposed global hike. 'We're going to be setting a tariff for, essentially, the rest of the world,' Mr Trump told reporters. 'That's what they're going to pay if they want to do business in the United States, because you can't sit down and make 200 deals.' Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has argued that the longstanding Australia-US free trade agreement and Australia's trade deficit with the US should exempt Australian imports from any new tariffs. Yet American officials continue to raise concerns about 'non-tariff barriers' to doing business, including laws requiring tech firms to pay for news content and rules governing the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme. In April, Mr Trump also took aim at Australia's biosecurity restrictions barring US beef imports, measures that the federal government has since agreed to lift. Mr Trump, who has vowed to end decades of US trade deficits by imposing tariffs on nearly all trading partners, has already announced higher rates of up to 50 per cent on some countries - including Brazil - starting on Friday. The announcements have spurred feverish negotiations by a host of countries seeking lower tariff rates including India, Pakistan, Canada and Thailand among others. The US president on Sunday clinched a huge trade deal with the European Union that includes a 15 per cent tariff on most EU goods, $US600 billion ($A920 billion) of investments in the US by European firms and $US750 billion in energy purchases over the next three years. If you'd like to view this content, please adjust your . To find out more about how we use cookies, please see our Cookie Guide. That followed a $US550-billion deal with Japan last week and smaller agreements with the United Kingdom, Indonesia and Vietnam. Other talks are ongoing, including with India, but prospects have dimmed for many more agreements before Friday - Mr Trump's deadline for deals before higher rates take effect. Mr Trump has repeatedly said he favours straightforward tariff rates over complex negotiations. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said on Monday trade talks with the US were at an intense phase, conceding that his country was still hoping to walk away with a tariff rate below the 35 per cent announced by Mr Trump on some Canadian imports. Mr Carney conceded this month that Canada - which sends 75 per cent of its exports to the United States - would likely have to accept some tariffs. US and Chinese economic officials met in Stockholm on Monday for more than five hours of talks aimed at resolving longstanding economic disputes, seeking to extend a truce on tariffs by three months. US Treasury Chief Scott Bessent was part of a negotiating team that arrived at Rosenbad, the Swedish prime minister's office in central Stockholm, in the early afternoon. China's Vice Premier He Lifeng was also seen at the venue. China is facing an August 12 deadline to reach a durable tariff agreement with Trump's administration, after the two governments reached preliminary deals in May and June to end weeks of escalating tit-for-tat tariffs and a cut-off of rare earth minerals. Negotiators from the two sides were seen exiting the office about 8pm and did not stop to speak with reporters. The discussions are expected to resume on Tuesday. Mr Trump touched on the talks during a wide-ranging press conference with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Scotland. 'I'd love to see China open up their country,' Mr Trump said. Without an agreement, global supply chains could face renewed turmoil from US duties snapping back to triple-digit levels that would amount to a bilateral trade embargo. Trade analysts said another 90-day extension of a tariff and export control truce struck in mid-May between China and the United States was likely. - with AAP
