Study finds a steep decline in mothers' mental health
The surgeon general's report led the researchers behind the new study to begin analyzing data from nearly 200,000 mothers who participated in the National Survey of Children's Health, an annual survey of households with children up to age 17. Researchers found that 1 in 20 mothers reported her mental health was poor or fair in 2016; by 2023 the ratio was about 1 in 12. In contrast, 1 in 22 fathers surveyed reported fair or poor mental health in 2023.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
There are limitations to the study, which was cross-sectional, meaning it looked at snapshots in time but did not follow the same women year over year. It also relied on self-reporting. Still, the findings were not surprising to experts in the field of maternal mental health, who have been observing the decline in emotional well-being for years.
Advertisement
Dr. Tamar Gur, endowed director of the Soter Women's Health Research Program at Ohio State University, said that if nothing else, the new findings would help reassure the mothers she treats that they are not the only ones struggling.
'Now I have something I can point to when I'm seeing a patient and say, 'You're not alone in this,'' Gur, who was not involved in the study, said. 'This is happening nationally, and it's a real problem.'
The new study was not designed to address the question of why maternal mental health seems to be on the decline, but one of its authors, Jamie Daw, an assistant professor of health policy and management at the Mailman School of Public Health at Columbia University, has some theories.
Daw and others pointed to several factors that may have hurt maternal mental health over the past decade or so, including the high costs of housing, increasing child care costs, and soaring food prices, which can each put financial and emotional pressure on families.
Those stressors exist on top of longstanding concerns, including that women continue to carry a heavier burden at home and the continued lack of national paid parental leave.
Other experts pointed to the COVID-19 pandemic as a cause of the decline in mental health, but Daw said the drop predated the pandemic.
'This is about broader trends that extend beyond the pandemic,' Daw said, while acknowledging the pandemic had given declines in mental health a 'boost.'
Some mental health experts say the women they see in their practices continue to reel from the effects of the pandemic.
Advertisement
'We all got much more isolated during COVID,' said Dr. Catherine Birndorf, founder of the Motherhood Center of New York, who was not involved in the new study. 'I think coming out of it, people are still trying to figure out, 'Where are my supports?''
Crystal Schiller, director of the Center for Women's Mood Disorders at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, said that the past few years had been a 'perfect storm for women's mental health.'
'The stress of the pandemic kicked off a mental health crisis for many people that has never fully recovered, in large part because most Americans can't access high-quality mental health care,' she said.
The United States has long faced a shortage of therapists, and many of those who would benefit from therapy cannot afford it. Schiller and other experts also noted that mothers may face particular challenges in carving out time for therapy when they are balancing work and raising children.
While the new findings build on years of escalating warnings about the state of American mothers' mental well-being, experts said one potential bright spot from the new study was that it may reflect the fact that mothers had become more vocal about their mental health struggles and more comfortable disclosing them with friends, family members, and health care providers and on social media.
'I do think people are becoming more outspoken about what's happening to them,' Birndorf said.
This article originally appeared in
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
27 minutes ago
- The Hill
Blumenthal calls for firing of RFK Jr. ally over violent rhetoric
Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) is demanding Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr 'immediately' fire a key ally from his role as vaccine advisor on a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention panel due to 'escalating and violent' rhetoric in the wake of an attack on CDC headquarters. Blumenthal wrote a letter to Kennedy on Aug. 13 calling for him to fire Robert Malone from the CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). Blumenthal said Malone 'issued a meme-filled post' on his personal blog 'that included violent and threatening images that appeared to be directed at government officials.' Hours before a gunman attacked CDC headquarters, Malone uploaded a post to his personal blog that included an image of a revolver loaded with a single bullet and the words 'Five out of six scientists have proven that Russian roulette is harmless.' Less than 48 hours after the attack, another of Malone's blog posts included images of guns and meme with the words 'if you need a disarmed society to govern, you suck at governing.' On Aug. 8, a gunman opened fire on the CDC in Atlanta, killing a responding police officer. Officials said almost 500 shell casings were recovered, and about 200 struck six different facilities on the agency's campus. The alleged shooter was motivated by his distrust of the COVID-19 vaccine, according to law enforcement. Kennedy tapped Malone as one of eight hand-picked replacement members of the ACIP in June after firing the 17 sitting panelists. Malone is a former researcher who helped lay the groundwork for mRNA vaccine technology, but has since turned into a self-professed anti-vaxxer, COVID-19 skeptic and close advisor to Kennedy. ACIP is an influential panel that recommends which vaccines go on the childhood and adult schedules after reviewing safety data. If ACIP endorses a vaccine, insurers must cover it. 'Malone has displayed an unfathomable failure of judgment and heartlessness for the family of slain Officer Rose, and for the thousands of CDC staff on whom the work of ACIP depends,' Blumenthal wrote in the letter. 'Dr. Malone's escalating and violent rhetoric—including in the aftermath of this tragic incident—has no place on a panel responsible for determining immunization recommendations for children and adults throughout our country,' he continued, before calling on Kennedy to fire Malone immediately. Malone did not immediately respond to requests for comment. 'Sen. Blumenthal's demand is nothing more than virtue signaling,' an HHS spokesman told The Hill. 'Dr. Malone was selected for ACIP based on his long-standing scientific credentials and we are grateful to him for taking the call to serve. This is not a moment for the media or democratic lawmakers to exploit a tragedy for political gain.'
Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
Map Shows US States Where COVID Cases Are Rising
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. COVID-19 cases are rising in 31 states and "likely growing" in 14 others, according to the latest data from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The government agency, which coordinated the national response to the pandemic, said that 45 states were seeing high chances of increased COVID cases, five years after the pandemic began. Why It Matters Since the start of the pandemic, heath authorities have kept an eye on the number of cases across the world. While the development of a vaccine means that increased cases will no longer be met with the same lockdown policies, COVID cases are still a cause for concern, especially for the unvaccinated and immunocompromised. What To Know The number of states in which COVID cases appear to be growing has increased from 27 to 31 since August 5. Most significantly, the data shows that California switched from "likely growing" to "growing," meaning that the most populous state in the union is now measuring an increasing number of COVID cases. Other large population hubs, like Texas, New York and Florida, have stayed in the "growing" category. A majority of the U.S. population lives in a "growing" state. The only states to report no growth in COVID cases were Alaska, Maine, New Hampshire and North Dakota, along with Washington, D.C. A spokesperson for the CDC told Newsweek that "COVID-19 activity is increasing in many Mid-Atlantic, Southeast, Southern and West Coast states. The most recent genomic surveillance estimates indicated that the most common variants in the U.S. were NB. 1.8.1 and LP. 8.1 in late June. "Due to low numbers of sequences reported to CDC, precision in the most recent reporting period is low." What People Are Saying Dr. Steven Goldberg, a physician and chief medical officer at HealthTrackRx, told Newsweek: "The current rise in COVID-19 cases is likely multifactorial. Increased summer travel, indoor gatherings due to high temperatures, waning vaccine immunity and the emergence of immune-evasive Omicron subvariants like KP.3 and LB.1 all play a role. "Wastewater surveillance, along with anecdotal reports of increased COVID-19-related ER and urgent care visits, corroborate this increase." The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in a statement: "As of August 5, 2025, we estimate that COVID-19 infections are growing or likely growing in 45 states, declining or likely declining in 0 states, and not changing in 5 states." What Happens Next The CDC will continue to monitor any spread of COVID across the U.S.
Politico
3 hours ago
- Politico
The MAHA wave
Driving the Day IN THE STATES — Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s Make America Healthy Again campaign to combat chronic disease is reshaping state legislatures, with hundreds of bills introduced this year echoing his agenda in both red and blue states, POLITICO's Amanda Chu reports. A POLITICO analysis of state legislatures found more than 130 pieces of legislation aimed at limiting access to ultraprocessed foods and improving nutrition, over 60 measures restricting the use of pesticides and other chemicals and more than 130 measures expanding vaccine exemptions or prohibiting mandates were introduced this year. Lawmakers also introduced dozens of bills to promote the use of psychedelics, authorize sales of raw milk and the antiparasitic drug ivermectin and ban the fluoridation of drinking water. The advances seen in state capitols, often considered laboratories for federal rulemaking, offer a glimpse into how a Kennedy-run Department of Health and Human Services might turn MAHA priorities into regulation. The White House is set to release a final MAHA report, which will include recommendations to fight chronic disease. Details: POLITICO tracked nearly 900 measures on MAHA-aligned subjects that were introduced in 50 states this year — a 45 percent increase from the previous year and measures introduced in 2023 among the four states that meet every two years. Measures ranged from banning the use of food dyes to limiting children's access to social media over mental health concerns to restricting the use of mRNA, the technology behind the Pfizer and Moderna Covid-19 vaccines. The surge in state activity underscores the growing political clout of the MAHA base, which cuts across party lines, and offers MAHA supporters a chance to secure policy wins outside a White House navigating competing interests. Following intense pressure from agricultural lobbyists, the Trump administration assured farm groups earlier this summer that the final MAHA report would include no new policy around pesticide use despite linking the chemical to cancer in a May draft report. Bipartisan appeal? Blue states New York and New Jersey led the country in the number of MAHA-aligned measures introduced this year, followed by Republican-led Texas. While some topics, like ending vaccine mandates, were predominantly backed by one party, a few themes had bipartisan traction: Roughly a third of measures to improve nutrition and restrict food additives were sponsored by at least one member of each party this year. 'We see so much state activity. … It's bipartisan. They're tapping into something that most Americans know intuitively. MAHA will persist when Kennedy is gone in the future,' said Joel White, a Republican health care strategist and founder of Horizon Government Affairs, a Washington lobbying firm. WELCOME TO THURSDAY PULSE. Adults in the U.S. are drinking less and worrying more about alcohol's health effects, according to new numbers from Gallup. Send your tips, scoops and feedback to khooper@ and sgardner@ and follow along @kelhoops and @sophie_gardnerj. At the White House PRASAD BACKSTORY — White House chief of staff Susie Wiles advocated to bring back the FDA's top vaccine regulator, Dr. Vinay Prasad, after he was pushed out following social media attacks from MAGA influencer Laura Loomer, POLITICO's David Lim, Dasha Burns and Tim Röhn report. Wiles' decision to advocate on Prasad's behalf, as described to POLITICO by two senior administration officials granted anonymity to discuss sensitive details, came after pleas from both Prasad's boss, FDA Commissioner Marty Makary, and Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. They insisted that Prasad is part of Kennedy's broader Make America Healthy Again movement to combat chronic diseases and integral to the Trump coalition. Loomer did not respond immediately to a request for comment. The FDA referred questions to the White House. 'Secretary Kennedy and the entire HHS team are doing a terrific job as they deliver on President Trump's mandate to Make America Healthy Again,' White House spokesperson Kush Desai said. 'Scores of prominent restaurant chains and food brands dropping artificial ingredients from our food supply and historic reforms at the FDA to fast-track lifesaving drugs and treatments prove that the entire HHS team is delivering for the American people.' Background: President Donald Trump forced Prasad out of his FDA job less than two weeks earlier after the Cambridge, Massachusetts, pharmaceutical manufacturer Sarepta Therapeutics, joined by GOP allies and Loomer, sought his ouster. He abruptly returned last week. Read the full story here. DRUG STOCKPILE EO — President Donald Trump issued an executive order Wednesday aimed at bolstering the domestic supply of drugs by ordering his health department to fill a drug-ingredient stockpile he established during his first term, POLITICO's Lauren Gardner reports. The directive builds on the Strategic Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients Reserve that Trump established in 2020 during the Covid-19 pandemic when shortages of medical supplies and devices hampered the pandemic response. The U.S. relies largely on China, India and the European Union for APIs, particularly those that go into commonly used generic medicines like antibiotics and chemotherapies that are manufactured on low margins. Details: The order directs the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response — the HHS agency that focuses on emergency readiness — to develop a list of 'approximately' 26 drugs considered critical to domestic health and security interests. It calls for an accounting of available funding that can be used to open the stockpile and to secure and maintain a six-month supply of active pharmaceutical ingredients needed to make the critical drugs. In Congress PRO MEDICAID CUTS — An influential group of Republicans has invited a key proponent of slashing Medicaid to brief congressional aides as the GOP mulls a potential second reconciliation bill, POLITICO's Benjamin Guggenheim and Meredith Lee Hill report. Brian Blase, president of the conservative think tank Paragon Health Institute, is set to address staff Thursday at a briefing on health care reform hosted by the Republican Study Committee, according to an invitation obtained by POLITICO. Blase was allied with conservative hard-liners earlier this year in pushing for significant cuts to Medicaid in the first GOP package. He was the initial author of a letter arguing for 'structural' changes to the program that Rep. Chip Roy (R-Texas) and 19 other hard-right members later sent to their House Republican colleagues. Details: An RSC spokesperson declined to comment on Thursday's briefing. But a person granted anonymity to discuss plans in advance said the meeting is set to cover enhanced tax credits for Affordable Care Act health insurance premiums, which are due to expire at the end of the year, as well as rules governing the percentage of Medicaid expenditures covered by the federal government and reimbursed to states. Not unprecedented: The RSC, composed of 189 House conservatives, has been a key force pushing for a follow-on to President Donald Trump's 'big, beautiful bill' that was signed into law last month. The group has invited several conservative experts to address staffers in recent weeks, though it has yet to endorse any specific health care policies for any forthcoming package. Those staff-level meetings continue as House GOP leaders try to plot a way forward amid skepticism over whether another sprawling domestic policy bill is even possible, given the difficulties Republicans had coming to an agreement on the first bill. Looking forward: It's still unclear what health topics a possible second package would address. Some House GOP factions are discussing further slashing Medicaid as well as possibly targeting Medicare funding. AROUND THE AGENCIES MAHA REPORT TIMELINE — The White House told several agricultural industry representatives to expect the latest Make America Healthy Again report to be publicly released in September, according to two people familiar with the conversation, POLITICO's Grace Yarrow reports. Some farm groups were recently invited to the White House and given 20 to 30 minutes to view a hard copy of a draft strategy report, said the two people, who were granted anonymity to share private details. The draft report that groups have seen is roughly 15 pages and has only 'light' mentions of pesticides, one of the two people said. But given that officials plan to wait for weeks before publishing the report, anything could change. Farm groups are crossing their fingers that the MAHA Commission won't scale up plans last minute to crack down on pesticides. 'If the ag community felt like they'd had some success in mitigating some of the worst language, or even taking some of that stuff out, an extra month may not feel like an opportunity,' said one of the people. 'It actually might feel like a bigger risk, because if they're already comfortable with where it sits now, what does an extra month mean?' 'On the other side, the MAHA folks are going to be pushing for more aggressive policy solutions across the board,' the person added. 'Maybe it would have been better for it to just pop out as it is.' Buckle up: Behind the scenes, the White House is taking extra time to review the policy recommendations to 'make sure it's not fucked up like last time,' as one person familiar with the process told our Dasha Burns, referencing the first error-riddled report from the MAHA Commission earlier this year. An HHS official told our Playbook colleagues that 'the team at the White House and HHS is ensuring that whatever is in the report is the best possible product for the American people. If they need more time, they need more time.' WHAT WE'RE READING The New York Times' Roni Caryn Rabin and Irena Hwang report on the Trump administration halting research related to racial and socio-economic disparities.
