Five things to know about the St Catherine monastery in Egypt's Sinai
Following warnings from the authorities and Orthodox Church in Greece that the ruling threatens the monastery's status, a government delegation is travelling from Athens to Cairo on Wednesday to discuss the situation.
World's oldest monastery
The monastery was founded by Byzantine Emperor Justinian in the sixth century at the biblical site of the burning bush at the foot of Mount Sinai, where Moses was believed to have received the 10 commandments, according to the world's three major monotheistic religions.
It was named for Saint Catherine of Alexandria, whose remains are housed in the church, along with rare iconography and manuscripts.
It is headed by the Archbishop of Mount Sinai and Raithu, under the ecclesiastical jurisdiction of the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Jerusalem.
According to UNESCO, "the entire area is of immense spiritual significance" to Christianity, Islam and Judaism.
The organisation says the monastery is "the property of the Greek Orthodox Church and belongs to the Archdiocese of Sinai".
Ownership dispute
On Friday, an Egyptian appeals court ruled that the monastery "is entitled to use" the land and the archaeological religious sites dotting the area, all of which "the state owns as public property".
The ruling, only a brief of which has been published by Egyptian media, has drawn criticism from the Orthodox patriarchates in Athens, Jerusalem and Istanbul.
Archbishop Ieronymos, head of the Greek Orthodox church in Athens, warned the monastery's property could now be "seized and confiscated".
Egypt has defended the court ruling, saying it "consolidates" the site's sacred status.
President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi said Egypt was "fully committed to preserving the unique and sacred religious status of Saint Catherine's monastery", in a phone call with Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis.
Mitsotakis meanwhile emphasised the importance of "preserving the pilgrimage and Greek Orthodox character of the monastery".
The delegation from Athens is expected to lay out its position on Wednesday.
According to Greece's state news agency, that position "is supported by a UNESCO document, which proves that Egypt had acknowledged in writing since 2002 that the ownership of the land and buildings belongs to the Greek Orthodox Church and the Archdiocese of Sinai".
Megaproject
Construction began in March 2021 in the Saint Catherine area, which includes the eponymous town and a nature reserve, for a government megaproject known as the 'Great Transfiguration' of Saint Catherine.
The project aims to bring upwards of a million tourists a year to the serene mountain village.
Its many construction projects include an events hall, hundreds of hotel rooms and a new residential area housing hundreds of units.
Observers say the project has harmed the reserve's ecosystem and threatened both the monastery and the local community.
According to a report by World Heritage Watch, the project has "destroyed the integrity of this historical and biblical landscape".
UNESCO in 2023 requested that Egypt "halt the implementation of any further development projects", conduct an impact evaluation and develop a conservation plan.
The government, which is campaigning for former tourism and antiquities minister Khaled al-Enany to head UNESCO from October, said in January that 90 percent of the project was complete.
Visitors
The peaks and valleys around Saint Catherine attract large groups of hikers, peaking at 2,000 visitors to Mount Sinai in a single day last December, local authorities reported.
The area, 1.5 kilometres (one mile) above sea level, is particularly popular with both Egyptians and foreign tourists seeking a reprieve from overcrowded Red Sea resorts elsewhere in Sinai.
- Bedouin tribe -
The area is home to the Jabaliya tribe, whose name derives from the Arabic word for "mountain".
Said to be the descendants of the Roman soldiers who came to guard the monastery in its early days, they maintain a close connection to Saint Catherine, with many working as tour guides today.
For decades, they have been calling for better infrastructure, including reliable water supply, emergency services and telecommunications coverage to improve their work and daily life.
According to World Heritage Watch, they are currently outnumbered by the thousands of labourers building the megaproject.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
13 hours ago
- LeMonde
In Pompeii, new evidence shows signs of life post-eruption
Archaeologists have discovered new evidence pointing to the reoccupation of Pompeii following the 79 AD eruption of Mount Vesuvius that left the city in ruins, the directors of the famous site said Wednesday, August 6. Despite the massive destruction suffered by Pompeii, an ancient Roman city home to more than 20,000 people before the eruption, some survivors who could not afford to start a new life elsewhere are believed to have returned to live in the devastated area. Archaeologists believe they were joined by others looking for a place to settle and hoping to find valuable items left by Pompeii's earlier residents in the rubble. "Judging by the archaeological data, it must have been an informal settlement where people lived in precarious conditions, without the infrastructure and services typical of a Roman city," before the area was completely abandoned in the fifth century, they said in a statement. While some life returned to the upper floors of the old houses, the former ground floors were converted into cellars with ovens and mills. 15 to 20% of population died in eruption "Thanks to the new excavations, the picture is now clearer: post-79 Pompeii reemerges, more than a city, a precarious and grey agglomeration, a kind of camp, a favela among the still recognizable ruins of the Pompeii that once was," said Gabriel Zuchtriegel, director of the site. Archaeologists estimate that 15 to 20% of Pompeii's population died in the eruption, mostly from thermal shock as a giant cloud of gases and ash covered the city. Evidence that the site was reoccupied had been detected in the past, but in the rush to access Pompeii's colourful frescoes and still-intact homes, "the faint traces of the site's reoccupation were literally removed and often swept away without any documentation". "The momentous episode of the city's destruction in 79 AD has monopolised the memory," said Zuchtriegel. Volcanic ash then buried the Roman city, perfectly preserving the homes, public buildings, objects and even the people until its discovery in the late 16th century. A UNESCO World Heritage Site, Pompeii is Italy's second most-visited tourist spot after the Colosseum in Rome, with some 4.17 million visitors last year. It covers a total area of approximately 22 hectares (54.4 acres), a third of which is still buried under ash.
Euronews
3 days ago
- Euronews
UN special representative to Cyprus departs with peace talks in limbo
The UN Secretary General's Special Representative for Cyprus on Monday had his last meeting with the President of Cyprus, Nikos Christodoulides. The Canadian Colin Stewart is retiring from his position as Special Representative. Upon his departure, he expressed his disappointment over the attitude of both the Greek and Turkish Cypriot leaders in formal discussions on the Cyprus issue. Cyprus has been divided since 1974, when a Greek-backed coup triggered a Turkish military intervention. The Republic of Cyprus which encompasses the southern two-thirds of the island, is internationally recognised and an EU member state, while the breakaway entity in northern Cyprus remains recognised only by Turkey. The UN has maintained a peacekeeping force in Cyprus since 1964. "A fundamental requirement is the will to find common ground, and that is different from trying to win or trying to impose your point of view," Stewart said. "One thing I found disappointing was how little they (the two sides) had in common, compared to the official views of the two sides." Stewart added that "people in Cyprus have a lot in common" and "don't have any problems with each other." He said that "millions of people a year" pass through the crossing points from north to south and vice versa, "but what is required is the will to find a solution that is mutually acceptable." Director of President Christodoulides' Press Office Victor Papadopoulos openly disagreed with Stewart's view, saying "I cannot say that we share such assessments. We are all bound by UN resolutions, and UN representatives are bound by UN and UN Security Council resolutions." "Everyone knows," he added, "that Ankara holds the 'key'." Turkish Cypriot leader Ersin Tatar says Stewart 'undermined' impartiality Turkish Cypriot leader Ersin Tatar lashed out at previous statements gave to local media, which he said was "incompatible with the impartiality of the UN's mission." The UN representative had told Cypriot newspaper Phileleftheros that "first of all, there are not many people in the north who take a two-state solution seriously." "There is no scenario under which the north will turn into an independent state recognised by the international community. That is not going to happen,' he continued. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has repeatedly promoted the idea, urging the international community to recognise the island's division. Tatar reacted by saying "The Turkish Cypriot side will remember [Stewart] as an official who, during his term, failed to fulfil his responsibility to increase trust between the two sides, undermined the perception of impartiality on some critical issues and, in particular, failed to show the necessary sensitivity to the legitimate humanitarian demands of our people." 'The Turkish Cypriot side has repeatedly and clearly demonstrated its will for a solution. This vision is shaped by the reality of two separate peoples, two separate democracies, and two separate states in Cyprus. A lasting and just solution in Cyprus is only possible by taking the current reality as a basis,' Tatar added. It is not yet known who will replace Colin Stewart in his now vacant role.
Euronews
4 days ago
- Euronews
How a Ukrainian NGO is preserving everyday medieval life
St. Sophia's Cathedral, one of eight UNESCO world heritage sites in Ukraine, is one of the few surviving buildings from the Kyivan Rus era and one of the most important Christian shrines in all of Europe. Built in the 11th century, it preserves not only the high art of the time period, but also remnants of everyday medieval life. Namely, 7,500 inscriptions - including notes, names, prayers, and drawings - left by ordinary inhabitants of Kyiv. 'The walls of St. Sophia's Cathedral have preserved not only thousand year-old mosaics and frescoes, recognized as masterpieces of medieval art, but also thousands of inscriptions and drawings that visitors etched over centuries,' Vyacheslav Kornienko, Deputy General Director for Scientific Work of the Sofia National Reserve, said in a press release obtained by Euronews. 'These graffiti are a vast archive of invaluable historical records, offering us a glimpse into various aspects of life in those times,' he added. The project comes at a particularly crucial time for the fight to preserve and defend Ukrainian heritage and cultural identity. In 2024, Unesco published a list of 343 cultural sites verified to have suffered damage since the beginning of the Russian invasion. In July of this year, a Russian drone attack on Odessa damaged UNESCO-protected landmarks, such as Prymorskyi Boulevard and the Pryvoz Market, both part of the historic city center. Geared at appealing to young people and following the growing trend of digitally preserving cultural heritage, the so-called 'Graffiti Chronicles' aim to preserve the history of everyday people and highlight Ukrainian resilience. 'Since I first saw these symbols in 2021, I was fascinated by what they could tell us about our past. It was incredible to think that ordinary people like us stood in front of these walls and wrote their fears, dreams, and wishes, the same way we can stand and look at them now, a thousand years later,' Agatha Gorski, co-founder of the shadows project, said in the press release. 'Our team wanted to find a way to bring these unique and important pieces of history out of the shadows, inviting Ukrainians to discover for themselves what these hidden gems can tell us about our heritage,' she added. At the next stage of the project, QR codes will be installed next to the graffiti on the walls of the cathedral museum, allowing visitors to access the digital archive and additional information about the works from their phones. 'They do everything possible to strip us of our historical memory' For Ukrainians, now in the third year of full-scale war, the ability to digitize their history and culture has become relevant as ever. 'Digitized documents, objects of material heritage, and cultural monuments help preserve their memory in the form of a digital copy, even when the original no longer exists,' Dr. Vyacheslav Kornienko said in an interview with Euronews. 'This has become especially relevant for us during the war, as Russian aggressors deliberately destroy cultural sites and loot museums - in other words they do everything possible to strip us of our historical memory,' he added. While the process of digitally archiving cultural artefacts and documents is an important step, he admitted that more work is needed to complete the preservation process and avoid the loss of cultural heritage and historical memory. 'I believe that the best option is to combine both: digital copies should be created separately (like a deposit for safekeeping), but these copies should then serve as the basis for scholarly research, including monographs, catalogs, and articles that feature these heritage items,' he told Euronews. The digital versions of the graffiti at St. Sophia's Cathedral are not simply scans or photos, but rather 3D visualizations of it, preserved in video format. They also include information about the symbols and their meaning which was not previously available in English. Fighting Russian misinformation For Ukrainians, preserving cultural heritage, even from the Medieval era, can help to fight disinformation in the modern day. This includes disinformation spread by Russia in order to justify its invasion, such as the narrative that Russia and Ukraine were one during the Kyivan Rus period. 'I think this topic of the Kyivan Rus is a highly contested aspect and one that is a huge part of Russia's disinformation operations and how it tries to weaponize culture,' Agatha Gorski, who grew up across from St. Sophia's, said in an interview with Euronews. 'This is one of the first things that Putin said before the invasion, one of the key arguments, [he said in a speech that] Russia and Ukraine are one people,' she added. 'He very often likes to use this claim and go back into the times of the Kievan Rus, and use it to justify the invasion, and to justify the fact that Ukraine is not an independent nation, so for me, it was really important to also take this time period, because it's super crucial to us, and super crucial to our knowledge gaps, to fill that in,' she added. More than this, the lives of people from centuries ago can also serve as a symbol in an of itself for the resilience of the Ukrainian people and their culture, something that the Shadows Project has seeked to emphasize in this project, as well as in their other work. 'For me, any kind of history starts with people. In people's everyday lives and in experiences because this is really what can tell us the most. This is also again kind of the parallel for me with the shadows project where for us like we really try to tell the stories of people and we try to really make history accessible, make history alive, and tell it through the experiences of others,' Gorski told Euronews.
