‘Our prayers were answered': After 25 years of advocacy, a small Navajo community has water
The Navajo community of Westwater is pictured on Friday, April 25, 2025. (Kyle Dunphey/Utah News Dispatch)
Three weeks ago, the taps rumbled to life in Thomas Chee's home. For the first time in his life, water sputtered through his faucet.
'Oh, it was so beautiful,' said 47-year-old Chee on Friday. 'Boy, it just hit me. It hit hard, and I just broke down.'
Chee is one of the few dozen residents of Westwater, Utah, a small Navajo community in the southwest corner of the state that for years lacked water and electricity. Chee, who currently serves as the community president, has called Westwater home for his entire life.
He, along with his neighbors, have used outhouses, hauled water with tanks on the back of their trucks, relied on solar electricity and lit kerosene lamps. With his grandmother, Chee would often walk down to a spring in a ravine near his home to get drinking water.
Until now.
For 25 years, residents have been trying to get water. In March, Chee said, 'our prayers were answered.'
On Friday, Westwater residents celebrated alongside Utah Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson, Navajo Nation President Buu Nygren, Utah GOP Rep. Mike Kennedy and other lawmakers, bureaucrats and tribal leaders.
'As president, my priority has always been water, water, water,' said Nygren, who took office in 2023. 'I grew up without running water. I know what it's like to haul water. I know what it takes, it's tough, it's something that our kids and our relatives shouldn't be going through.'
Bringing water to Westwater was part of a larger, ongoing effort to expand access to water in Navajo communities. Estimates vary, but somewhere between 30% to 40% of homes on the Navajo Nation, the country's largest Indian reservation, lack running water. That's despite Lake Powell and the Colorado River, which supplies drinking water to 40 million people across seven states and Mexico, running along the northern border of the reservation.
But those communities are mostly rural, tucked away in some of the most remote parts of the lower 48 states. Westwater is not.
The same ravine where Chee and his family got their drinking water separates Westwater and Blanding, home to about 3,100 people. In minutes, a Westwater resident can get to Blanding's main street, which has a hospital, a grocery store, a city hall, bank, and a handful of cafes, shops and restaurants. Utah State University's campus in Blanding is visible from Westwater.
'I was shocked with how close this community was to Blanding,' Henderson told Utah News Dispatch Friday, describing her first visit to Westwater. 'This is a community right here, next to a city. So to me, this challenge was something that I felt was worth taking on.'
Expanding basic utilities to Westwater was less of a logistical issue — which is often the case for the remote communities that dot the Navajo Nation — and more of a jurisdictional issue.
The land has long been home to Navajo families, and was purchased by the Navajo Nation in 1986. However, it's 'fee simple' land, not reservation land, meaning the residents pay taxes to San Juan County. That's different from untaxed 'trust' land, which makes up most American reservations and is under full control of indigenous people.
For 25 years, as Westwater residents lobbied for access to water, they were stuck in jurisdictional limbo, caught between the Navajo Nation, the city, county, and state.
'No one really took ownership, no one took responsibility for the people out here. It wasn't really the tribe's responsibility, it wasn't the county, or the city's responsibility. So I decided it was the state's responsibility,' Henderson said.
Henderson, who gave Westwater a shoutout during her inaugural address earlier this year, said she made improving access to water and electricity a priority.
In 2020, the Utah Legislature appropriated $500,000 to electrify Westwater, matched by a $500,000 donation from The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Two years later, Westwater tied into Blanding's grid and lights flickered on in the 29 lots that make up the small community. That same year, Blanding struck a deal with the state of Utah, the Navajo Nation, the Navajo Tribal Utility Authority and San Juan County to bring culinary water to Westwater.
The Navajo Nation chipped in $5.5 million, and Utah state leaders allocated $3.5 million in American Rescue Plan funds, the $1.9 trillion economic stimulus package passed by Congress and signed by former President Joe Biden in 2021. Blanding city leaders changed its ordinances to allow for a well to be drilled, and a coalition of nonprofits, with help from the county, helped raise funds and coordinate the project.
State officials helped Blanding build an arsenic treatment plant and drill a new well near the spring that divides the city and Westwater. For the last couple years, crews have been building a pipeline into the community.
By late March, every Westwater resident had potable water flowing through their taps.
'This project is a testament to what can happen when people come together,' said Logan Monson, the former mayor of Blanding who now serves as a Republican lawmaker in the Utah House. 'It is my hope today that this water project will stand as a symbol, a symbol that every person matters. That every community deserves to be seen.'
Now that the residents have water and electricity, leaders have high hopes for the small city.
'Moving forward, the Westwater community is not going to have those struggles, so that they can focus on some of the things that matter. What else can life provide you when you set yourself up,' Nygren said.
Chee, standing in the creek where he once helped his grandmother bring water back to their home, echoed the Navajo Nation president.
'I believe we will thrive. Life has gotten easier,' he said. 'We don't have to worry about hauling, or looking for water. I believe my community will be more productive.'
Chee spoke over the soft trickle of the spring, pausing as his eyes watered.
'For many years, we relied on this beautiful water right here. It sustained life. Sorry to be emotional, but water is a real precious resource,' he said. 'It's been a long time coming for my people to have this infrastructure.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Axios
40 minutes ago
- Axios
Behind the Curtain: A decades-in-the-making immigration war
President Trump undoubtedly stands on strong political ground, backed by most Americans, in cases where he's deporting convicted criminals. Now comes a new test, literally 40 years in the making: How comfortable are Americans with deporting millions of immigrants who paid taxes, built families and committed no crimes after coming here illegally? Why it matters: That's the heart of the standoff in LA, as well as the broader Trump effort to expel potentially millions of immigrants who broke the law to get here and then played by U.S. rules. "I said it from Day 1: If you're in the country illegally, you're not off the table," Tom Homan, Trump's border czar, told the N.Y. Times. "So, we're opening that aperture up." The backstory: Congress, going back to 1986, has sought and failed to find a pathway to citizenship for those who fit the precise description above. Many current GOP senators were among those seeking said solution. But concerns about border security and rewarding illegal behavior killed every effort. Now, Trump, Republicans, some Democrats and much of the U.S. public are supportive of mass deportation instead. An estimated 14 million unauthorized immigrants live here — many of them working and paying taxes. They often fill jobs other Americans won't do — hotels, construction sites, landscaping and child care. Expelling them would sink some businesses, slow services in many communities, and hit close to home for lots of U.S. citizens. Will public enthusiasm wane when this reality becomes clear? Trump and White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller are pushing to hit a target of 3,000 immigration arrests a day, as first reported by Axios' Brittany Gibson and Stef Kight. That's triple the number of daily arrests that agents were making in the early days of Trump's term, Axios found. The only way to pull that off is by casting wider nets beyond convicted criminals to larger worksites. So raids could rise sharply at factories, restaurants and Home Depots, where people living here illegally often gather to seek day labor on job sites. "Wait till you find out how many trillions we have to spend on illegal aliens," Miller wrote Tuesday in reply to a tweet by California Gov. Gavin Newsom about a Pentagon estimate that the National Guard deployment in LA will cost $134 million and last 60 days. The big picture: Accelerated deportations are a top personal priority for Trump, who relishes visibility for the raids. Amid the unrest in LA on Monday, Miller posted on X: "You can have all the other plans and budgets you want. If you don't fix migration, then nothing else can be fixed — or saved." White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson told us: "If you are present in the United States illegally, you will be deported. This is the promise President Trump made to the American people and the Administration is committed to keeping it." A CBS News/YouGov poll taken last week showed 54% approval of the Trump administration's program to deport immigrants illegally in the U.S. White House communications director Steven Cheung tweeted that finding and added: "And the approval number will be even higher after the national guard was sent to LA to beat back the violence this weekend." And MAGA media is egging the president on. Charlie Kirk, one of the most influential pro-Trump podcasters, tweeted Tuesday: "President Trump is getting more popular. Deportations are popular. We need more. ... America is demanding mass deportations." Asked for comment for this column, the Department of Homeland Security pointed us to the U.S. Customs and Border Protection's " CBP Home" app, which lets aliens notify the government of their intent to leave the country. "Tap 'Departing Traveler' to begin," the instructions say. "We are offering those in this country $1,000 and a free flight to leave the country and preserve the potential to return the right, legal way," DHS assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin told us. Under current law, those taking that option will be barred from coming back for either three or 10 years, or permanently, depending on how long they've been in the U.S. illegally. How it works: It's important to understand how people pay taxes even though they're here illegally: In 1996, the U.S. government created an alternative to the Social Security number for undocumented immigrants — the individual taxpayer identification number (ITIN). This allows people to pay taxes while being here illegally and awaiting a path to citizenship. Those people have been paying taxes, believing it would enhance their chances of getting citizenship. A portion of those taxes helps fund Social Security. Under that law, if they eventually get citizenship, those taxes will count toward their retirement. The amounts are substantial. Undocumented immigrants paid $96.7 billion in federal, state and local taxes in 2022, according to a tally by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy. More than a third of what they pay funds programs they can't even access. Now, those ITIN numbers could be used to track people down. Deportation fears triggered a decline in tax filings this year in some immigrant communities in the D.C. suburbs, the Washington Post found. That sets the stage for a humanitarian showdown unlike any witnessed in U.S. history: Trump is willing to use the U.S. military inside America to protect U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents during roundups. The bottom line: There's no clear mechanism to differentiate between someone who came here recently alone versus a father of three, whose wife and children are living here legally, and have been here paying taxes and committing no crimes for a decade. In the eyes of the current law, illegal is illegal. When TV explodes with images of burning cars and lawlessness, Trump wins. But what about families torn apart or longtime neighbors yanked from their homes and taken away in handcuffs? That's when America's rawest views of immigration will be revealed.


Politico
an hour ago
- Politico
The leader of the opposition
Presented by With help from Eli Okun and Bethany Irvine On this morning's Playbook Podcast, Jack and Adam Wren discuss Gavin Newsom's emergence this week at the front of the anti-Trump pack … and why Saturday's grand military parade in D.C. may not be entirely comfortable viewing for either GOP grandees or military top brass. Good Wednesday morning. This is Jack Blanchard, more bleary-eyed than usual after last night's glammed-up party at the French Ambassador's place. But fear not: I stuck to sparkling water all night long, just for you guys … Playbook is a cruel mistress indeed. Let me know how I'm doing so far. BREAKING THIS MORNING: Elon says sorry. 'I regret some of my posts about President @realDonaldTrump last week. They went too far,' Elon Musk wrote on X at, erm, 3.04 a.m. this morning. It follows Musk's decision to delete some of his most egregious messages about Trump from last Thursday's blowup — yes, including the Jeffrey Epstein one — and marks the culmination of a pretty unprecedented climbdown, by Musk's standards. There's no sign of a response from the president as yet, but he'll surely be lapping it up. Popcorn at the ready: And if that's not enough theater for you, Trump — joined by the lesser-spotted Melania — will head to the Kennedy Center this evening for the opening night of 'Les Misérables.' Trump, of course, fired the arts center's entire board in February and appointed himself chair. And now — as luck would have it — his favorite musical's coming to town. Enhanced security will be in place all day, though whether that stops Trump getting the JD Vance treatment remains to be seen. Plot twist: For those who haven't seen it, 'Les Mis' follows a group of 19th-century king-hating revolutionaries who take to the streets against their authoritarian government, but ultimately see their hopes of change crushed. It's hard to see how it could have any real relevance today. In today's Playbook … — Newsom grabs his moment as hundreds of U.S. Marines hit the streets of LA. — Bessent heads to the Hill after trade breakthrough with China. — GOP senators huddle to discuss reconciliation tweaks. DRIVING THE DAY WATERSHED MOMENT: Hundreds of U.S. Marines will hit the streets of Los Angeles today as the Trump administration cranks up its pressure on the city's immigrant population. The 700 active-duty Marines sent to L.A. will join existing National Guard troops in 'protecting federal property and personnel,' a spokesperson for the U.S. Northern Command said this morning (per the NYT) — 'including providing security to ICE agents on their missions.' It follows a complaint from border czar Tom Homan that the LA protests have made it 'dangerous' for ICE officials to do their jobs. Mission creep: The anarchic and riotous scenes we saw in downtown Los Angeles on Sunday have actually largely dissipated — especially following Mayor Karen Bass' decision to impose an 8 p.m. curfew last night. But the troops Trump has deployed are going nowhere. Instead, official ICE pictures yesterday showed National Guard troops standing guard alongside ICE officers as they carried out raids on undocumented migrants across LA. (Bloomberg News confirmed this is happening). And it sounds like the newly deployed Marines will be asked to do the same. Let's be clear: These are precisely the sorts of scenes — U.S. troops assisting with immigration raids in liberal cities — that Dems have feared since Trump's election. They are also precisely the target of California Gov. Gavin Newsom's request for an emergency injunction against the way Trump is deploying military force in his state, per POLITICO's Kyle Cheney and Josh Gerstein. District Judge Charles Breyer — the Bill Clinton-appointed brother of former Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer — will hear that case tomorrow. It could be quite a moment. We need to talk about Gavin: Newsom, for his part, delivered a pretty extraordinary address to the nation last night, in which he sought to position himself as the leader of America's anti-Trump opposition. Speaking directly to camera in a crisp, eight-minute monologue, Newsom denounced Trump's aggressive deployment of ICE officers and military forces in LA — before raising his eyes to horizons far beyond his own state. 'This isn't just about protests here in Los Angeles,' Newsom told America. 'This is about all of us. This is about you. California may be first, but it clearly will not end here. Other states are next. Democracy is next. Democracy is under assault before our eyes.' Going viral: The video is getting plenty of love from Dems online — hitting more than a million views on the MeidasTouch YouTube channel inside three hours last night. And it was on the front pages of both the NYT and WaPo early this morning. 'I for one am very happy to see somebody that isn't afraid to speak up,' Ana Navarro told CNN. 'I have been so thirsty for somebody that is not cowardly, bending the knee and selling out to Donald Trump as he does all of this to America.' Even the WSJ describes Newsom as 'the leader of the opposition.' This is all fascinating stuff for kremlinologists of the fledgling 2028 Democratic race. Playbook noted yesterday that politicians aligning themselves with anti-ICE protesters may be taking on political risk come a general election, but Newsom is playing a different game right now — and playing it well. He even leaned into Trump's threat to have him arrested, spying the same political opportunity enjoyed by Trump himself in 2023. (POLITICO's Jeremy White and Melanie Mason take a closer look at Newsom's leadership prospects here.) White House pushback: Trump has yet to respond directly to Newsom's video, but it was striking to see the White House comms operation move into overdrive last night. White House comms director Steven Cheung and his deputy Alex Pfeiffer were both going predictably hard at Newsom on X, as was the White House's Rapid Response account. Stephen Miller did not hold back. Trump's pal Jon Voight published a blistering video response. Others in MAGA world simply mocked Newsom for the technical glitches that wrecked the initial live broadcast. But but but: It's worth noting Team Newsom is giving as good as it gets, mimicking the ways Trump has successfully deployed social media over recent years. We're seeing rapid response pushback; caustic humor, deeply mocking tones. And again — plenty of online Dems are lapping it up. WaPo's Tatum Hunter has more on that. Taking it offline: Trump, predictably, now appears to be considering other ways to punish California, including cutting federal education funds (per POLITICO's Rebecca Carballo and colleagues) and killing its nation-leading vehicle emissions standards (per POLITICO's Alex Nieves.) First in Playbook: This all comes ahead of Trump's big military parade in D.C. on Saturday, and the split-screen scenes in Los Angeles and Washington 'underscore how Trump is leveraging his role as commander-in-chief in a much clearer and more urgent way than he did during his first term — embodying the image of a strong military commander that he has long admired in other foreign leaders, allies and adversaries alike,' POLITICO's Megan Messerly and colleagues write this morning. The heartburn: NYT's Helene Cooper reports some military leaders are feeling a little uncomfortable about the whole thing, now that troops are literally being deployed on U.S. streets to help quell protests. Even GOP Hill members are squirming: POLITICO surveyed 50 GOP lawmakers, and only seven said they planned to stay in Washington this weekend for the festivities. Also uncomfortable viewing: U.S. troops booing and jeering Trump's rivals during yesterday's presidential speech at Fort Bragg. Watch the clip IT'S THE ECONOMY, STUPID INFLATION NATION: The monthly Consumer Price Index data for May comes out at 8:30 a.m., the latest measure of whether Trump's trade wars are driving up costs for Americans. Economists predict a tick up to 2.9 percent inflation annually and 0.3 percent month to month, reflecting a moderate impact from tariffs, Bloomberg's Mark Niquette reports. Trading places: Fresh off a plane from London, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent will appear before the House Ways & Means Committee at 10 a.m. and a Senate Appropriations subcommittee at 4 p.m., where he'll likely provide a download from the latest U.S.-China trade talks. And Bessent has good news to share: The two sides announced last night that negotiators had struck a deal for a framework to restore their May trade truce, per the FT. It still awaits sign-off from Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, but you can expect markets to react positively this morning. Watching brief: Bloomberg's Saleha Mohsin and colleagues report that more and more Trump advisers want him to tap Bessent as the next Fed chair, despite the denials. Devil in the details: We're still waiting for specifics on this new U.S.-China deal — but if the U.S. has agreed to dial back some tech export controls, Bloomberg notes, Beijing would see that as a win. Indeed, analysts say that China's effective use of rare earths as leverage illustrates how the 'Trump administration underestimated Beijing's ability to withstand the pain of tariffs,' WaPo's Katrina Northrop writes. Trump won't enjoy reading that. In better news for Trump: The president landed a significant victory last night as an appeals court lifted a ruling that had blocked the president's sweeping 'Liberation Day' tariffs, per Reuters. The court said Trump can enforce the levies while litigation on the merits proceeds. Arguments aren't scheduled until the end of July. And it's not just China: Negotiators are also close to a deal with Mexico that would remove some U.S. tariffs on steel, Bloomberg's Joe Deaux and Eric Martin scooped. MEANWHILE ON THE HILL RECONCILABLE DIFFERENCES: Senate Republicans will meet behind closed doors this afternoon to get the latest information on their 'big, beautiful bill' from committee chairs who have not yet released their portions of the bill text. Senate Agriculture Chair John Boozman (R-Ark.) will brief members on a plan to reduce the House's SNAP cuts, forcing costs for food aid onto states at a lower rate than the House passed, POLITICO's Meredith Lee Hill and Grace Yarrow report. But on the flip side, Sen. Jim Justice ( warns that foisting SNAP costs onto state capitals could cost Republicans control of Congress, Grace reports. (Check out our colleagues on Inside Congress for more on the GOP's latest megabill casualties.) First in Playbook: Fear of those very changes — and other budgetary hits to states from the bill — is prompting several Democratic-led states to consider special sessions later this year to address the fallout, POLITICO's Jordan Wolman reports. Major fiscal changes and cuts could be in the offing. ELSEWHERE IN CONGRESS: It's a busy day on the Hill, with Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, Joint Chiefs of Staff Chair Gen. Dan 'Razin' Caine, HUD Secretary Scott Turner and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum all testifying in addition to Bessent. FAA Administrator-designate Bryan Bedford will be up for his confirmation hearing, and the Senate will have a procedural vote at noon on Billy Long's nomination for IRS commissioner. Swamp watch: Rep. Mark Green's (R-Tenn.) surprise announcement on Monday that he'll resign from Congress came while he was in Guyana, missing House votes, NOTUS' Reese Gorman reports. Though Green hasn't specified his next steps in the private sector, he's already been pitching people on … investment opportunities in Guyana. What a world. Gerontocracy watch: 87-year-old Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton (D-D.C.) told reporters she's running for election again after 18 terms — only for her office to suddenly introduce some wiggle room after a noisy outcry, POLITICO's Nick Wu reports. … 76-year-old Rep. Kweisi Mfume's (D-Md.) is hoping to benefit from seniority as he seeks the House Oversight ranking member spot, Nick and colleagues report. … And while we're doing elderly politicians, former White House aides Neera Tanden, Anthony Bernal, Ashley Williams and Annie Tomasini have agreed to testify before House Oversight as it investigates former President Joe Biden's abilities in office, per POLITICO's Hailey Fuchs. Half of D.C. will be tuning in for that. BEST OF THE REST CLIMATE FILES: EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin is due to announce a major pollution-prevention rollback at 2 p.m., Bloomberg's Ari Natter and Jennifer Dlouhy scooped. The agency's latest deregulatory moves will unwind Biden-era rules that forced power plants to curb emissions. ABOUT LAST NIGHT: Frontrunners Jack Ciattarelli and Rep. Mikie Sherrill easily secured the respective Republican and Democratic gubernatorial nominations in New Jersey, teeing up one of this year's marquee elections, as POLITICO's Matt Friedman breaks down. It'll be a crucial test of the electorate's mood during Trump's second term, especially as the typically blue state has looked purpler of late: Ciattarelli fell 3 points short of beating incumbent Phil Murphy in 2021, and Kamala Harris bested Trump by only 6 last year. TRAIL MIX: Hannah Pingree became the latest Democrat to jump into the Maine gubernatorial race, per the Portland Press Herald's Randy Billings. The former state House speaker is also the daughter of Rep. Chellie Pingree. … And Mike Bloomberg swung his support behind Andrew Cuomo, which could give the NYC mayoral frontrunner a significant boost, the NY Post's Carl Campanile and Craig McCarthy report. MONUMENTAL NEWS: The Justice Department put out a legal opinion, overturning guidance from 1938, to say that the president can unilaterally abolish entire national monuments created by previous presidents, WaPo's Jake Spring reports. If Trump goes there, it 'would take the administration into untested legal territory.' BILL OF HEALTH: HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a longtime anti-vaccine activist who has made several anti-vaccine moves since taking over the health agency, said he wouldn't bring in anti-vaxxers to replace the important advisory committee he fired, per Bloomberg. MEDIAWATCH: ABC News said longtime correspondent Terry Moran's contract won't be renewed after he blasted Stephen Miller on social media as 'a man who is richly endowed with the capacity for hatred,' per WaPo. WHISTLIN' DIXIE: 'Trump reverses Army base names in latest DEI purge,' by POLITICO's Jack Detsch and Paul McLeary TALK OF THE TOWN Jeanne Shaheen's staff had to figure out how to navigate an 8-foot-tall stuffed moose — and a bear nearly as tall — through the Capitol. Bill Nye showed a Men's Health reporter legions of texts Robert F. Kennedy Jr. sent him a while back filled with anti-vaccine conspiracy theories. SPORTS BLINK — The Congressional Baseball Game takes place at 7:05 p.m. at Nats Park tonight. Republicans enter with a four-year winning streak — including a 31-11 rout last year. It'll air on Fox Sports 1, with commentary from Kevin Corke and Chad Pergram. PLAYBOOK ARTS SECTION — 'Smithsonian to Conduct Wide Content Review Requested by Trump,' by WSJ's Natalie Andrews and colleagues: 'The content review is a victory for the White House as Trump extends his reach to the country's cultural institutions. PLAYBOOK METRO SECTION — House Republicans are no closer to fixing the billion-dollar hole they blew in the city's budget … but they are passing bills this week to repeal a D.C. law that allows non-citizens to vote in local elections, NYT's Michael Gold reports. OUT AND ABOUT — French Ambassador Laurent Bili, Steve Clemons, Heather Podesta, Kellyanne Conway and Cory Gardner hosted the fourth edition of Amethyste at Bili's residence last night. SPOTTED: Sens. Deb Fischer (R-Neb.), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), Dave McCormick (R-Pa.) and Dina Powell McCormick, Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) and John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.), Reps. Mike Turner (R-Ohio), Lizzie Fletcher (D-Texas) and Gabe Amo (D-R.I.), Del. Stacey Plaskett (D-U.S. Virgin Islands), Joe and Gayle Manchin, Vince Haley, CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz, NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya, Kiron Skinner, Justin Fanelli, Paul Dabbar, Omar Vargas, Faryar Shirzad, Teresa Carlson, Nick Carr, Dante Disparte, Riaz Valani, Joe Bartlett, Ludovic Hood, Sarah Rogers, Alex Wong, Joe Hack, Hogan Gidley, Morgan Ortagus, Sébastien Fagart, Belgian Ambassador Frédéric Bernard, Japanese Ambassador Shigeo Yamada, Roy Blunt, Dan Knight, John Hudson, Kaitlan Collins, Josh Dawsey, Tammy Haddad, Gloria Dittus, Daniel Cruise, Vincent Voci, Michael Wilner, Matthew Mazonkey, Garrett Haake, Tyler Pager, Juleanna Glover, Michael Shepard, Goli Sheikholeslami, Dafna Linzer, Michael Froman, Douglas Rediker and Heidi Crebo-Rediker, Tomicah Tillemann and Susan Blumenthal. — The Shakespeare Theatre Company's annual Will on the Hill event last night included participation by Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.), Reps. Gabe Amo (D-R.I.), Sydney Kamlager-Dove (D-Calif.) and Dina Titus (D-Nev.), D.C. Council Chair Phil Mendelson, D.C. Councilmember Brooke Pinto, Aaron Myers, Grover Norquist, Holly Twyford, Renea Brown, Marla Allard, Olivia Beavers, Rich Edson, Steven Clemons, James Hohmann, Simon Godwin and emcee Mike Evans. Also SPOTTED: Carol Danko, Angela Lee Gieras, Neal Higgins, Victoria Hamscho, Karishma Shah Page, Alexa Verveer, LeeAnn Petersen, Andrea LaMontagne, Kathleen Coulombe, Michael Sinacore, Ryan Alcorn, Scott Gelbman, Joe Harris, Nick Sanders, James Sonne, Blake Major, Evan Williams, Cheyenne Hopkins, John Donnelly and Ana Delgado. — The Barbara Bush Foundation for Family Literacy marked the recent centennial of her birth with a celebration of reading last night at Vinegar Hill in Arundel, Maine — part of a three-day commemoration of the former first lady in Kennebunkport. The night included keynotes from bestselling authors Claire Lombardo, Dani Shapiro and Chris Whitaker, a video message from Jenna Bush Hager and a conversation with former staffers led by Jean Becker. Also SPOTTED: Doro Bush Koch, George Dvorsky, Ellie Sosa, Neil and Maria Bush, Margaret Bush, Marshall Bush, Andy Card, Shawn Gorman, Mark Lashier, Andrew Mueller, Kristan and Kyle Nevins, Anita McBride, Andrew Roberts and Tom Collamore. WHITE HOUSE ARRIVAL LOUNGE — Wayne Wall has been named senior director for the Middle East at the NSC, which is starting to staff up after a major purge, Axios' Barak Ravid reports. He previously was at the Defense Intelligence Agency. TRANSITIONS — Sabrina Singh is joining Seven Letter as a partner. She most recently was deputy press secretary at the Defense Department, and is a Kamala Harris alum. … Karina Lubell will be a partner at Brunswick Group. She previously led the competition policy and advocacy section at DOJ's Antitrust Division. … Ashley Moir has launched Ashley Moir Media, a PR company with booking services, media training and comms strategy. She most recently was director of national broadcast operations at Deploy/US and is a former senior booker at Fox News. … … Gopal Das Varma is now a VP at Cornerstone Research. He previously was VP at Charles River Associates and is a DOJ Antitrust Division alum. … Allison Rivera will be VP for government and industry affairs at the National Grain and Feed Association. She most recently was executive director of government affairs at the National Cattlemen's Beef Association. … Daniel Harder is now a senior government affairs adviser at Mayer Brown. He previously was director of government affairs and public policy at Biogen. WEEKEND WEDDING — John Hagner, partner at Workbench Strategy, and Adam Koehler, professional learning facilitator at World Savvy, got married Saturday in Minneapolis. They met online three years ago. Pic WELCOME TO THE WORLD — Derek Robertson, a reporter for POLITICO's Digital Future Daily and contributor to POLITICO Magazine, and Rachel Greer, associate director of records and archives at the ACLU, recently welcomed Margaret Hope Robertson. HAPPY BIRTHDAY: CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz … David Cohen … Jennifer Rubin … Kim Oates of the House Radio/TV Gallery … Disney's Lucas Acosta … Eric Lieberman … J Street's Jeremy Ben-Ami … Greta Van Susteren … Lindsey Williams Drath … Cesar Gonzalez of Rep. Mario Diaz-Balart's (R-Fla.) office … Jamal Brown … Mike Schoenfeld … Tad Devine of Devine Mulvey Longabaugh … Lorissa Bounds … Kristen Thomaselli ... Mary Kate Cunningham … Marty Kearns of Netcentric Campaigns … POLITICO's Meg Myer … Emily Dobler Siddiqi … former Rep. Mike Conaway (R-Texas) … Ryan Bugas … former South Dakota Gov. Dennis Daugaard … Wendy Teramoto … CNN's Morgan Rimmer … Will Rahn … Sofia Jones of the House Agriculture Committee … Jonathan Martinez of Haleon … Tamar Epps of the National Head Start Association … Amy Barrera of Senate Majority Leader John Thune's office Did someone forward this email to you? Sign up here. Send Playbookers tips to playbook@ or text us on Signal here. Playbook couldn't happen without our editor Zack Stanton, deputy editor Garrett Ross and Playbook Podcast producer Callan Tansill-Suddath.


The Hill
an hour ago
- The Hill
GOP backs Trump on LA, but there's skepticism over deploying Marines
Republican senators support President Trump's crackdown on people protesting his administration's work to deport thousands of migrants, but they are uncertain about the Pentagon's deployment of 700 active-duty Marines to California. The Trump White House appears confident that a showdown with California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) over illegal immigration is good politics for the president. But some GOP lawmakers are worried about the prospect of street clashes spreading to other cities and of Trump invoking the Insurrection Act of 1807 to get the active-duty military more involved in responding to mass protests. There's no GOP opposition to a tough response to street protests. Senate Appropriations Committee Chair Susan Collins (R-Maine), who is up for reelection next year in a state Trump lost to Biden, said 'the violence that we're witnessing against law enforcement, ICE officers in L.A.' and the property damage is 'completely unacceptable and does call for a strong response. But she warned that 'sending in active-duty troops to deal with domestic law enforcement issues raises very serious concerns.' 'I do not agree with the president's decision to do that,' she said, before pivoting to support for Trump's decision to call in the National Guard without the consent of local officials. 'I think calling up the National Guard, which has experience in dealing with domestic disasters, whether man-made or weather-related, does make sense,' Collins said. 'But I do not think that sending in active-duty Marines is a good idea. 'I think it puts them in a very difficult position,' she added. Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), a member of the Armed Services Committee, said he hopes 'cooler heads prevail' on both sides of the political spectrum as the administration continues operations to deport migrants. Rounds said he doesn't want to see street clashes and property destruction play out in other cities. 'Hopefully it does not occur and hopefully cooler heads prevail all the way around,' he said. 'The challenge … is you've got individuals that are creating a scene when [Immigration and Customs Enforcement] is coming in and doing their job.' Senate Armed Services Committee Chair Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) and Sen. Deb Fischer (R-Neb.), a senior member of the Armed Services panel, declined to comment on the deployment of Marines. A poll of 4,309 U.S. adults by YouGov found that only 34 percent of Americans approved of Trump deploying Marines to Los Angeles, while 47 percent disapproved. Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) on Tuesday defended Trump's decision to deploy 4,000 members of the California National Guard to help maintain the peace in Los Angeles, but he distanced himself from the decision to mobilize active-duty Marines, telling reporters he didn't know Trump's precise authority for doing so. 'I don't know the particulars on what authorities exist there, but my assumption is that the administration has been looking carefully at what he can and can't do under the law. Obviously, the 1798 Act is available to them if they choose to exercise it,' Thune told reporters. That's a reference to the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, which authorizes the president during a declared war, invasion or predatory incursion to detain and deport citizens of an enemy nation. Thune argued Trump was justified in mobilizing the National Guard because local authorities failed to contain property destruction and the threat of violence. 'In this case, at least there were clear just failures on the part of state and local officials, which is why I think it required the president to take a federal response,' he said. 'There was a security situation out there that needed to be addressed, and I think ultimately, the president's objective is to keep people safe,' he said. Newsom accused Trump of 'intentionally causing chaos' by mobilizing troops, and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass (D) said the move was 'completely unnecessary' because the Los Angeles Police Department was 'well equipped' to handle protests.' Trump's deployment of active-duty troops is raising questions on Capitol Hill about whether he will invoke the Insurrection Act of 1807. The president cited the law in January as potential authority to obtain complete operational control of the southern border, if necessary. White House aides drafted a proclamation during Trump's first term in 2020 to invoke the Insurrection Act in case Trump wanted to deploy active-duty troops to Washington, D.C., to respond to protests over the murder of George Floyd earlier that year. The president decided not to, despite calls by Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.), who wrote in a New York Times op-ed to 'send in the troops.' Gen. Eric Smith, the commandant of the Marine Corps, told Republican senators Tuesday morning that the 700 Marines Trump deployed would be limited to guarding federal properties and had training in crowd control. He said active-duty soldiers would not have arrest authority. Rounds told The Hill that Smith informed members of the Armed Services panel that Trump was operating under Title 10 of the United States Code, which includes the statutes often referred to as the Insurrection Act, according to the Brennan Center for Justice. 'They are there just as if they were on any other sovereign mission at an embassy anyplace else around the world. They have been trained in crowd control, but their mission is to protect other entities that are federal in nature, meaning buildings or other members of the military,' Rounds said. He said the National Guard troops — in contrast to the Marines — 'are federally activated' and 'members of the armed services under Title 10 rather than Title 32,' referring to the transfer of the California National Guard from Newsom to Trump. 'That was not part of the discussion,' he said of the Insurrection Act. 'I know it's available to him,' referring to Trump, 'but right now it's not necessary.' Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) claimed that the Democratic officials in California and Los Angeles 'seem not to be very concerned with controlling the violence' and 'in some ways are defiant of federal law' by refusing to work with federal officials to deport migrants who are living in the country illegally. He said 'my preference would be to have local, not national' law enforcement and troops handle local protests but warned that waiting too long to send in the National Guard could allow protests to spiral out of control, like they did in some cities during summer 2020 after Floyd's murder.