Eastern Cape teacher accused of beating learner with a hosepipe
The Eastern Cape Department of Education has issued a stern warning to teachers against using corporal punishment to discipline learners. This comes as a teacher from Zamokuhle Junior Secondary School in Matatiele is due back in court later this month, accused of beating a 12-year-old learner with a hosepipe.
The learner's mother, who asked that we not name her or her son, told GroundUp that her child returned from school with dark bruises on his buttocks on 19 May.
According to the learner, on the day of the incident, he and three other learners were washing their dishes after lunch, after the bell had rung for them to return to classes. He said a male teacher approached them and instructed them to follow him to the staff room to 'punish them' for being late to class.
'He took the hosepipe and hit my classmate three times on his hand. The second classmate was beaten three times on the bum. The third classmate was also beaten on bums seven times,' said the learner. 'I stopped counting at eight while he was beating me. I started feeling numb, I didn't cry anymore,' he said.
The learner said he returned to class and was in pain for the rest of the day. 'I wanted to go home but I didn't want to get in trouble again. The pain was unbearable, I was crying but trying to be strong at the same time,' he said.
His mother said she went to the school to report the matter, but she was snubbed by the other teachers. She then decided to open a case at the police station. The teacher has since apologised.
'To be honest I now feel sorry for him, I don't want him to lose his job,' said the mother.
When GroundUp contacted the school for comment, we were told by the person who answered the call that the teacher had resigned.
National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson Luxolo Tyali said the teacher faces charges relating to corporal punishment at the Maluti Magistrates Court. His next court appearance will be on 25 June.
Eastern Cape Department of Education spokesperson Vuyiseka Mboxela warned that corporal punishment is against the Constitution and the department's policies. She said she had asked the school for more details.
Equal Education Law Centre Attorney Ebrahiem Daniels said though it is illegal, corporal punishment continues in schools. He said the organisation gets reports of corporal punishment from across the country.
Daniels said there is a lack of training and support for teachers about other forms of discipline. 'Without the tools to manage classrooms constructively, some teachers continue to resort to physical punishment. Research consistently shows that corporal punishment is not only ineffective but also harmful.
'It is linked to increased aggression, anti-social behaviour, and long-term emotional harm. Rather than correcting behaviour, it reinforces the idea that violence is an acceptable way to solve problems,' said Daniels.
This article first appeared on GroundUp. Read the original article here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Children's rights and how to spot abuse
Children's rights and how to spot abuse As National Child Protection Week drew to a close on June 5, parents are urged to educate their children about their rights. National Child Protection Week is commemorated from May 29 to June 5. This year's theme was 'Working together in ending violence against children'. The week serves to raise awareness of the rights of children as articulated in the Constitution and the Children's Act (Act No. 38 of 2005). Under the act, each South African child is entitled to: – A name and nationality. – Family care or appropriate alternative care. – Basic nutrition, shelter, healthcare and social services. – Protection from neglect, maltreatment and abuse. – Protection from exploitative labour services, including work or services that are inappropriate. – Protection from being used in armed conflict and protection during times of armed conflict. Tshwane District Health Social Worker Agnes Mathebula says there are various signs of physical and emotional abuse that parents can look out for should they occur. 'We identify signs of abuse either physically or through looking at the behaviour of the child. Physically, you'll see things like bruises, fractures, cigarette burns and things like that, those aren't too difficult to identify. But the emotional abuse can be difficult to spot,' Mathebula says. Behavioural indicators may include fear of parents, alterations in behaviour, withdrawn or aggressive tendencies or academic difficulties. The Department of Social Development has a pilot 24-hour call centre dedicated to providing support and counselling to victims of gender-based violence: The toll-free number to call is 0800 428 428 (0800 GBV GBV) to speak to a social worker for assistance and counselling. Callers can also request a social worker from the Command Centre to contact them by dialling *120*7867# (free) from any cellphone. You can also get help at: Childline South Africa: 116 Child Welfare South Africa: 0861 4 CHILD (24453), 011 452-4110 or e-mail: info@ ALSO READ: Your ultimate weekend plans in Pretoria Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to bennittb@ or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading! Stay in the know. Download the Caxton Local News Network App Stay in the know. Download the Caxton Local News Network App here
Daily Maverick
21 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Health Funders Association launches latest legal challenge to NHI Act, calling legislation ‘unworkable'
The Health Funders Association is the sixth organisation to launch a legal challenge to the NHI Act, describing it as 'unaffordable, unworkable and unconstitutional'. The Health Funders Association (HFA), a nonprofit representing 20 medical schemes and three administrators in South Africa's private healthcare funding sector, has become the latest organisation to launch a legal challenge to the National Health Insurance Act. On Thursday, 5 June the HFA announced the challenge, which has been lodged in the Gauteng Division of the High Court in Pretoria. The organisation has said that while it supports the 'goal of universal health coverage', it considers the NHI Act to be 'unaffordable, unworkable and unconstitutional'. 'Litigation is not our preferred route but it is, under these circumstances, the responsible one to protect our economy and the future of healthcare in our country,' said NFA chief executive Thoneshan Naidoo. Unconstitutional and invalid In its legal challenge, the HFA argues that the NHI Act is procedurally and substantively flawed and will cause irreparable harm to the health system economy. It also seeks to show that: Section 33 of the NHI Act, which limits the role of medical schemes to providing complementary cover, infringes on section 27 of the Constitution regarding the right to access healthcare; The Act is not a 'reasonable measure' under section 27(2) of the Constitution, which stipulates that the government must take progressive, reasonable steps to realise access to care; and The Act unconstitutionally delegates legislative authority to the minister of health. Naidoo said that the relief sought by the HFA in the high court was for 'certain sections of the NHI Act be declared unconstitutional and invalid. Alternatively, the Act, in its entirety, to be declared unconstitutional and invalid.' There are already five legal challenges to the Act playing out in South Africa's courts, led by the South African Medical Association, the Board of Healthcare Funders, the Hospital Association of South Africa, the South African Private Practitioners Forum and the trade union Solidarity. 'With our knowledge, skills and experience of the funding industry… we bring an understanding of what the flaws are [in the NHI Act], what path we're on and alternative solutions. We don't view ourselves in opposition, but as part of completing the solution,' Naidoo told Daily Maverick. He noted that the HFA had engaged with the NHI through public participation processes before it was signed into law, in an attempt to work collaboratively with stakeholders. 'We are a part of Busa [Business Unity South Africa]… and while we go ahead with this legal challenge, we are hoping that through Busa… and that ongoing engagement with the president, it can lead to some amicable solution,' Naidoo said. Health Department spokesperson Foster Mohale said the department would study the HFA's application once it had received it and 'respond accordingly through the legal channels'. Independent study Part of the reason the HFA's legal challenge was launched more than a year after the NHI Act was signed into law was to allow time to research the potential impact of the legislation, said Naidoo. The organisation commissioned an independent economic analysis by consultancy firm Genesis Analytics. 'The Genesis analysis assesses various potential efficiency savings under NHI compared to the current system. For modelling purposes, savings are assumed to be as high as 45% of private sector cost levels. The report demonstrates that even under the most optimistic assumptions, it is not possible to raise the funds required for NHI,' the HFA said. 'For NHI to fund a level of care equivalent to what medical scheme members currently receive, as government has indicated is the intention, the Genesis model shows that personal income tax would need to increase by 2.2 times (a 115% increase in tax) from the current average rate of 21% to an average of 46% of income.' The Genensis model considered a scenario of pooling existing healthcare expenditure in the private and public sectors to support NHI. Its finding was that to enable this, personal income tax would need to increase by 1.5 times its current rate (a 47% increase in tax), from its average of 21% to 31%, according to the HFA. The report stated that medical scheme members would face a 43% reduction in the level of healthcare services relative to what they currently receive. When breaking down who would be affected by the potential decline in services under the NHI, Naidoo said the Genesis analysis showed that more than 68% of medical scheme members were black, Indian or coloured, with up to 83% earning less than R37,500 per month. 'There's often a misconception that medical schemes are for the wealthy and the elite. But if 83% are earning less than R40,000, it means this is actually your economic engine of South Africa. This is your workforce,' Naidoo said. Another finding of the study was that an additional 282,000 healthcare professionals would be needed to achieve the same level of care and access under the NHI than is currently experienced through medical schemes. 'Every year, we only get about 3,600 new medical graduates. Qualifications take between nine to 13 years… so the targets are decades away,' Naidoo said. Pursuing meaningful reform Naidoo said the HFA was not seeking to preserve the status quo, since it believed meaningful reform was essential to improve affordability, quality and access in healthcare. 'We remain committed to working with government and stakeholders to design a more inclusive, financially viable and constitutionally sound [system],' he said. 'Almost all successful [universal healthcare coverage] models, whether it's in high-income, middle-income or even low-income countries, involve strong public-private sector collaboration… Rather than sidelining the private sector, these systems leverage its capacity, innovation and infrastructure to expand access, improve efficiency and enhance quality of care.' The HFA has proposed a 'hybrid funding model' that involves the NHI fund and medical schemes operating 'in tandem'. It argues that this system would preserve individuals' 'freedom to choose supplementary private cover'. 'Public resources are focused on those most in need, while regulated competition supports innovation, efficiency and cost control,' it said. 'The proposed model offers a common benefit package with built-in cross-subsidisation to ensure equitable access for vulnerable populations. Grounded in a strong primary healthcare foundation, the model reflects international best practice and is especially relevant for middle-income countries like South Africa.' Other organisations have proposed alternative models to the NHI fund, including the Universal Healthcare Access Coalition, made up of the South African Medical Association, the Progressive Health Forum and the South African Private Practitioners Forum. Naidoo noted that a 'common thread' in many of these healthcare reform proposals was the emphasis placed on 'multifund, multipayer systems' rather than a single-fund monopoly. DM
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Meyiwa trial judge offside
It is deeply concerning that Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng, presiding over the high-profile Senzo Meyiwa murder trial, made a racially charged remark broadcast live, says the writer. In a country still navigating the painful legacy of racial division, those entrusted with upholding the Constitution must be held to the highest standards of impartiality, professionalism, and respect. It is deeply concerning that Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng, presiding over the high-profile Senzo Meyiwa murder trial, made a racially charged remark broadcast live. The frustrated judge said 'This is what happens in a South Africa run by Blacks. A White advocate will never have the gall to ask me that,' in response to a formal request by Advocate Charles Mnisi, who had advised the court that he would be unavailable on Monday due to participation in Sunday's Comrades Marathon. While the judge's frustration over delays in this long-running and emotionally charged trial may be understandable, resorting to racially divisive language is entirely unacceptable. It undermines the integrity of the judiciary and risks inflaming already fragile race relations in South Africa. Decorum in court is not just about the behaviour of lawyers and attendees, it begins with the conduct of the bench. Judges must embody the fairness and dignity they expect from others. These comments fall far short of that standard. The trial of those accused of murdering Orlando Pirates and Bafana Bafana captain Senzo Meyiwa, a national tragedy, must be conducted with the utmost seriousness and integrity. We call on the Judicial Service Commission to urgently review these remarks and reaffirm the principle that justice must be administered without fear, favour, or prejudice. Brett Herron, GOOD Secretary-General
