Speaking For Gaza Not Patriotism: Bombay HC Rejects CPI(M) Plea For Protest On Palestine Issue
A division bench of Justices Ravindra Ghuge and Gautam Ankhad stated that speaking for Gaza and Palestine is not patriotism and asked the petitioner to instead raise voices for causes within India.
The bench also questioned why the petitioner does not focus on issues in their own country.
"Our country has several issues to deal with... We don't want anything like this. I am sorry to say, you are all short-sighted... You are looking at Gaza and Palestine... Why don't you do something for our own country? Be patriots... Speaking for Gaza and Palestine is not patriotism... Speak up for the causes in our own country... Practice what you preach..." Live Law quoted Justice Ghuge as saying.
The bench also expressed curiosity about why the party wants to protest something happening thousands of miles away rather than issues within India.
"We are curious... You have no issues with respect to our own country... something productive for our own country... They are fighting 1,000s of miles away, and you are showing concern for Palestine, Gaza, etc. You can take up social and local issues like flooding, drainage getting blocked, illegal parking... Why aren't you protesting such issues?" Live Law quoted Justice Ghuge as saying.
The bench asked the petitioner, "Do we have so much time to hear such a case when hundreds of cases of our citizens are listed?"
"Do we have so much time to spend hearing such a matter when we have hundreds of cases of our citizens listed? Are these not our constitutional issues?" Live Law quoted Justice Ghuge as saying.
Thousands of people in Gaza have lost their lives due to Israel's ground offensive and air strikes, which commenced in October 2023 as a reaction to Hamas' attacks on Israeli cities.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
'Aid must be permitted to reach people': Barack Obama voices concern over Gaza; calls for action to 'stop preventable starvation'
Former US President Barack Obama (AP photo) Former US President Barack Obama on Monday urged immediate action to prevent what he called the "preventable" starvation unfolding in Gaza, referring to the situation caused by the war that erupted between Israel and Hamas on October 7, 2023. "While a lasting resolution to the crisis in Gaza must involve a return of all hostages and a cessation of Israel's military operations, these articles underscore the immediate need for action to be taken to prevent the travesty of innocent people dying of preventable starvation," Obama posted on X, alongside links to two New York Times articles. "Aid must be permitted to reach people in Gaza. There is no justification for keeping food and water away from civilian families," he added in a follow-up post. Meanwhile, Israel's military on Sunday announced a "tactical pause" in fighting amid mounting concerns over starvation in the region. US President Trump, responding to reporters' questions about the images of starving children in Gaza, accused Hamas of diverting aid. "When I see the children and when I see, especially over the last couple of weeks people are stealing the food, they're stealing the money, they're stealing the money for the food. They're stealing weapons, they're stealing everything," said Trump. "It's a mess, that whole place is a mess. The Gaza Strip, you know it was given many years ago so they could have peace. That didn't work out too well," he added. The Israeli military has stated there is no evidence that Hamas has systematically stolen humanitarian aid. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu defended Israel's handling of aid, saying limited humanitarian access has been permitted -- provided it doesn't bolster Hamas or endanger hostages. "We've done this so far," Netanyahu said, according to The Jerusalem Post. "But the UN is spreading lies and falsehoods about Israel. They say we don't allow humanitarian supplies in, yet we do. There are secure corridors. They've always existed, but now it's official. No more excuses."
News18
an hour ago
- News18
'Prevent Dying Of Starvation': Barack Obama Calls For 'Immediate Action' Amid Gaza Crisis
Last Updated: Former US President Barack Obama has emphasised that aid must be allowed to reach people in Gaza as 'there's no justification for keeping food and water away from civilians.' Former US President Barack Obama has reacted to the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict for the first time and called for 'immediate action". Taking to X, Obama said, 'While a lasting resolution to the crisis in Gaza must involve a return of all hostages and a cessation of Israel's military operations, these articles underscore the immediate need for action to be taken to prevent the travesty of innocent people dying of preventable starvation." He further stressed that aid 'must be permitted" to reach people in Gaza, adding that 'there is no justification for keeping food and water away from civilian families." His remark came as the World Health Organisation has reported a sharp rise in malnutrition and disease, with a large portion of Gaza's 2 million residents now starving, as reported by AP. Experts have also raised an alarm over the worsening situation and warned that Gaza is nearing famine. Amid the concerns over rising hunger in Gaza, the Israeli military on Sunday started a limited halt in fighting in three populated areas. This also comes as Israel has faced massive backlash for the 21-month-long war. The military said it would begin a 'tactical pause" in Gaza City, Deir al-Balah and Muwasi, three areas of the territory with large populations, to 'increase the scale of humanitarian aid" entering the territory. The pause begins every day at 10:00 am to 8:00 pm local time until further notice, starting Sunday, according to a report by AP. Meanwhile, several recent images from Gaza being widely shared online show emaciated children. Israel says it is prepared to end the war if Hamas surrenders, disarms, and goes into exile, something the group has refused to agree to. Israel has allowed in around 4,500 trucks for the UN and other aid groups to distribute since May. However, according to the UN, the average of 69 trucks a day is far lower than the 500 to 600 trucks Gaza needs in a day. The UN says it has been unable to distribute much of the aid because hungry crowds and gangs take most of it from its arriving trucks. view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Houthis Vow To Target All Ships Trading With Israel, Urge Nations To Cut Ties Over Gaza Blockade
Yemen's Houthi rebels have announced a new escalation, threatening to target any commercial vessels connected to Israeli ports regardless of their country of origin. This campaign, focused on the strategic Bab el Mandeb Strait, aims to show solidarity with Palestinians in Gaza. The Houthis have already attacked over 100 ships, sunk multiple vessels, and launched missiles at Israel, prompting fierce retaliatory strikes. International shipping faces increasing peril, while diplomatic efforts seek to stave off further conflict and protect key global trade routes.#RedSeaCrisis #HouthiAttacks #GlobalShipping #IsraelGaza #MiddleEastNews #MaritimeSecurity #BreakingNews #Ceasefire Read More
