
Justice Ramaswami, A 1989 Report & An Impeachment Proceeding: Ex-CAG Boss' Book Reveals Rot
As the Monsoon Session of Parliament begins on Monday, the Narendra Modi government is expected to start proceedings to impeach Allahabad High Court judge Yashwant Varma, from whose Delhi bungalow wads of currency notes were found. The likely proceedings bring back memories of a 1989 CAG report that led to impeachment proceedings against Justice V Ramaswami — a first in Indian Parliament where a judge faced the heat on the basis of a CAG report.
Amid the buzz over Varma's impeachment, former Director General of CAG P Sesh Kumar's book throws light on Justice Ramaswami's case in particular.
'The CAG report in 1989 played a pivotal role in the impeachment motion against Justice V Ramaswami, who was then serving at the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The report highlighted instances of financial misconduct and irregularities during Justice Ramaswami's tenure as the Chief Justice (CJ) of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. Specifically, it highlighted extravagant expenditures, unauthorised purchases and violations of financial norms," Kumar wrote in his new book 'CAG: What It Ought to Be Auditing'.
In his book, Kumar takes the reader to 1989, recalling the findings of the CAG: 'The CJ allegedly misused public funds on renovations and furnishings of his official residence and office. These included expensive items such as carpets, air conditioners and furniture without proper approvals. The audit revealed that approximately Rs 49 lakh was misused for unauthorised expenditures, including lavish renovations and purchases for his official residence and office. The report flagged the misuse of funds earmarked for judicial and administrative purposes, leading to significant financial impropriety."
The former CAG boss stressed in the book that while the top auditor of India 'submits audit reports based on the administrative control of the audited entity", which should have been the Governors of Punjab and Haryana, the findings involved matters of national importance for the attention of the Parliament of India, as they involved matters of judicial accountability.
In the case of Justice Ramaswami, the issue gained national attention and was examined at the parliamentary level, leading to the involvement of the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) of the Lok Sabha.
'Following the CAG revelations, 108 Lok Sabha MPs submitted a motion for impeachment against Justice Ramaswami, accusing him of 'proved misbehaviour' under Article 124(4) of the Constitution. It was the first-ever impeachment process initiated against a judge of the higher judiciary in India based on a CAG report. A three-member judicial committee was constituted under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, to investigate the allegations," he recalls.
The committee found Justice Ramaswami guilty of gross misconduct, corroborating the CAG report's findings, he added. 'In 1993, the impeachment motion was debated in the Lok Sabha. Despite the strong evidence presented, the motion failed because the ruling party abstained from voting. As a result, the impeachment motion fell short of the required two-thirds majority in the Lok Sabha," laments Kumar.
Justice Ramaswami was not impeached but resigned shortly afterwards, marking a controversial end to the episode.
'The case remains a landmark in Indian judicial history, highlighting both the importance of the CAG in exposing financial irregularities in the higher judiciary and the limitations of the impeachment process, particularly the role of political considerations in what is supposed to be a quasi-judicial procedure," he added in the book.
The Modi Sarkar has, over the last few weeks, reached out to key opposition leaders over the issue of impeaching Justice Varma and Kumar, without taking any names, made a scathing remark on the issue. 'Contrast this with the situation and sad spectacles of cash allegedly found to have been delivered to one judge at the residence (Haryana) and found burnt in the outhouse (New Delhi) of another judge of high courts—where nothing happened till recently when it appears to be heading towards an impeachment process or resignation."
Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated!
tags :
corruption Narendra Modi Yashwant Varma
view comments
First Published:
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New Indian Express
10 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Alleging irregularities in flower market leasing, AIADMK councillors walk out of Salem corpn meeting
SALEM: Alleging irregularities in the leasing process of the VOC Flower Market complex, AIADMK councillors led by party's leader of opposition in the council N Yadavamoorthy walked out of the Salem City Municipal Corporation's monthly council meeting, on Friday. The meeting was chaired by Mayor A Ramachandran, along with Deputy Mayor M Saradha Devi and Salem City Corporation Commissioner M Elangovan. The AIADMK councillors strongly opposed the corporation's move to lease the flower market shops directly to vendors. The complex, developed under the Smart City project under the AIADMK regime, was originally leased to a private party. After the private party withdrew from the contract, the corporation invited fresh tenders and decided to handle the leasing by itself. AIADMK councillors said the corporation is now demanding advance payments of up to Rs 8 lakh and monthly rents of up to Rs 20,000 from vendors. They argued that such high costs would be unaffordable for small flower sellers who have been operating at the market for decades.


Economic Times
10 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Indian-origin hospital worker filmed 13,000 people in bathrooms
Indian-origin hospital worker filmed thousands in bathrooms Sanjai Syamaprasad, a 48-year-old hospital worker of Indian origin based in Long Island, has pleaded guilty to secretly recording patients and staff, up to 13,000 individuals, using a hidden camera disguised as a smoke detector in restrooms. Despite the serious nature of the crime, Syamaprasad was sentenced to five years of probation, avoiding jail time after entering a guilty plea, said a ToI a Brooklyn resident and father, had worked as a sleep technician at various sleep disorder facilities. Initially, he pleaded not guilty to five counts of unlawful surveillance and two counts of tampering with evidence, but later changed his plea. The case came to light when coworkers caught him watching bathroom footage on his phone during a shift. He was subsequently fired from his position at Northwell Sleep Disorders in 2023. According to CBS News, investigators recovered over 300 videos, which captured the body parts of numerous individuals. However, charges were filed for only five victims, including a child, due to challenges in identifying all those discovered that Syamaprasad had installed Velcro dots in nine restrooms, which allowed him to mount the concealed camera in locations where it could capture footage of both the toilet and the County District Attorney Anne Donnelly expressed strong disagreement with the outcome, having recommended one to three years in prison for each count.'My reaction to five years probation is disappointment and disgust — this case deserved jail time,' Donnelly said. 'What he did, the number of people he exposed — over 300 plus videos we have — and you treat that with probation? I think it's wrong and that's why I was recommending upstate jail time.'She added: "This was a massive, massive violation of people's privacy and rights," warning that the plea deal sends the wrong to officials, Syamaprasad worked overnight shifts at the Northwell Sleep Disorders Center in Manhasset between July 2023 and April 2024, during which time he recorded thousands of patients and coworkers—some on multiple occasions. Investigators believe he may have purchased his first covert recording device as early as August 2022. With inputs from ToI (Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates) Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Paid less than plumbers? The real story of freshers' salaries at Infy, TCS. Can medicines inject the vitamins Amazon is missing? Can victims of Jane Street scam be compensated by investor protection funds? We prefer to have idle pilots than grounded planes: Akasa CFO on losses, funding hiccups, Boeing What if Tata Motors buys Iveco's truck unit? Will it propel or drag like JLR? How private ARCs are losing out to a govt-backed firm dealing in bad loans Stock picks of the week: 5 stocks with consistent score improvement and return potential of 13 to 45% in 1 year Short-term valuation headwinds? Yes. Long-term growth potential intact? Yes. Which 'Yes' is more relevant? F&O Radar| Deploy Bull Call Spread in Nifty to gain from a 'buy-on-dips' stance


Hindustan Times
10 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Indian-origin entrepreneur who served chai to PM Modi, PM Starmer opens up about his ‘surreal day'
Akhil Patel, a London-based Indian-origin founder of a tea company who served chai to PM Modi and PM Starmer during the Indian leader's recent visit to the UK, has opened up about his 'surreal experience.' In an Instagram post, he recalled how he felt once he saw the world leaders walking towards his stall to have tea instead of coffee. Indian-origin entrepreneur Akhil Patel serving tea to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Prime Minister Keir Starmer. (X/@narendramodi, X/amala_chai) 'A quick recap of a surreal day. Yesterday, I was invited by @10downingstreet to serve chai at Chequers — to @narendramodi , @keirstarmer, and Indian & UK ministers. Can we just take a moment to realise how mad that is?' the entrepreneur posted on his company Amala Chai's official Instagram page. 'There I was, in the UK Prime Minister's house, serving masala chai — and not one person wanted coffee,' he continued. 'From one chaiwala to another, that was a special day. Right… I'm getting off the internet now to make a cup of chai,' he added. Who is Akhil Patel? A London School of Economics graduate, Patel started his career as a data analyst. However, he shifted his career from corporate employee to entrepreneur in 2019 after founding Amala Chai. He started his company after being inspired by his grandmother and her love for tea. The company claims to procure all the materials it sells directly from 'small family farms in Assam and Kerala.' PM Modi's recent UK visit: In a statement, India's Ministry of External Affairs said, 'During his official visit to the United Kingdom from 23-24 July 2025, Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi met today with the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, Rt. Hon. Sir Keir Starmer. On arrival at the UK Prime Minister's country residence at Chequers in Buckinghamshire, he was warmly received by Prime Minister Starmer. The two leaders held a one-on-one meeting as well as delegation level talks.'