Chch employer sentenced after falsely stating worker was visiting relative
New Zealand Immigration (NZI) said the employer, Ava Young, pleaded guilty to two charges of providing false or misleading information to Immigration New Zealand, and one charge of aiding and abetting the breach of visa conditions.
Young had recruited a Thai national from overseas, and facilitated her entry into the country on a visitor visa.
For the job and the visa, Young charged the individual NZ$7500 – a debt she owed to Young. Despite this, NZI said the individual never held a visa allowing her to work in New Zealand.
After the employee arrived in Auckland in March 2024, she was informed by Young she would be living and working there. Young then took photos of the individual to advertise her services from the premises which Young managed.
ADVERTISEMENT
NZI said later the same day, the individual then received a message from Young which said a client was coming to see her.
"The message was an appointment for the individual to have sex with a client and included the time, cost and duration of the service," NZI said.
The individual was charged a 35% fee on her earnings, along with rent and expenses. Young also kept a schedule of the debt, which NZI said she would "regularly send" to the individual.
At the direction of Young, the individual provided massage and sex services at various Auckland addresses until June 2024, when she stopped working for Young after clearing her debt.
An investigation was launched by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) after receiving a complaint which said a female Thai national was breaching her visa conditions and was being "forced to work in a massage parlour and provide sexual services to clients".
Six search warrants were carried out across Auckland and Christchurch, resulting in Young's arrest.
NZI general manager of immigration investigations and compliance, Steve Watson, said the case "represents a serious breach of trust and responsibility".
ADVERTISEMENT
'Their actions compromised the integrity of New Zealand's immigration system.
'The individual arrived in New Zealand expecting legitimate work opportunities, but was instead misled and treated in a manner that was both unlawful and deeply unfair."
The court determined the offending was serious, but applied sentencing discounts for an early guilty plea, previous good character, and also took account of the defendant's personal circumstances.
It determined a non-custodial sentence with strict conditions would still hold Young accountable.
Young was then sentenced to four months' home detention.
'The individual arrived in New Zealand expecting legitimate work opportunities, but was instead misled and treated in a manner that was both unlawful and deeply unfair," Watson said.
'Immigration New Zealand remains committed to identifying, investigating, and holding to account those who take advantage of others for personal gain."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
07-08-2025
- NZ Herald
Thai prosecutors indict 23 over Bangkok high-rise collapse in earthquake
Thai prosecutors indicted 23 people and firms on Thursday, in a case linked to the deadly collapse of a Bangkok high-rise in an earthquake. The 30-storey tower crumbled seconds after a 7.7-magnitude earthquake hit Myanmar on March 28 this year, killing thousands in Thailand's war-torn neighbour. The tower, meant to
NZ Herald
02-08-2025
- NZ Herald
NZ passport fraud: Man gets record sentence for 25-year identity deception
Alam's 45-year-old wife, Taj Parvin Shilpi, who was sentenced to 12 months' home detention, was 'fully aware' of the fraud, Judge Winter said, as they were cousins who had lived in the same village growing up. The Te Atatū couple have a 21-year-old son, a university student who was 'entirely blameless', said Judge Winter, having arrived with his mother as a 4-year-old in 2008. He became a citizen as the child of a New Zealander. Alam went on to become president of the Bangladesh Association of New Zealand Inc (BANZI), where he helped up to 80 people applying for passports. Bangladesh had no consulate in New Zealand and Alam, through BANZI, had helped with paperwork, passports and stamps. There was no suggestion any of those passports were false. The judge was asked to take Alam's work in helping others into account as community service when looking at whether the sentence could be discounted. Judge Winter said it was a 'form of arrogance' that someone who was illegally in the country, and who had standing in the Bengali community, was dealing with other people's passports. He refused to reduce Alam's sentence for that, or for him being of good character. Alam's age and true identity remain unknown, but he is believed to be the 50-year-old older brother of John Alam, who lives in the US. How he adopted his brother's identity and came to possess the Bangladeshi passport that got him to New Zealand is unclear, but authorities found he lived in Japan in the 1990s before returning home and setting off for Auckland. He became a taxi driver and entered a 'marriage of convenience' with a New Zealand woman – they separated shortly after he got his residency. Alam told a jury earlier this year that they split because of differences over her 'lifestyle' but claimed that it was a genuine partnership. Having become a citizen, married Shilpi and had a son, he could still not complete his fraud, as Immigration New Zealand initially rejected her visa application because of discrepancies in the interviews staff had with the husband and wife. But Shilpi arrived in 2008 on the first of a number of visas – her application for residence was rejected as her health was deemed too poor. Alam had also tried to get his mother a visitor visa, but that too had been declined. Shilpi, who suffers from hypertension and diabetes, was 'aware that he was not the person who he claimed to be, and was aware from the very beginning', said Judge Winter. The jury had not believed her version that the couple did not meet until after his New Zealand marriage failed. Immigration New Zealand welcomed the record prison sentence and said it was a complex investigation that took six years to complete. Shilpi has only been on temporary visas and her last visitor visa has expired. Alam's case will be referred to Internal Affairs, which is in charge of passports and citizenship. - RNZ
NZ Herald
29-07-2025
- NZ Herald
Conservationists warn over Thailand's growing captive lion population
'It's absolute madness,' said Tom Taylor, chief operating officer of conservation group Wildlife Friends Foundation Thailand. 'It's terrifying to imagine, if the laws aren't changed, what the situation is going to be in 10 years.' The boom is fuelled by social media, where owners like Tharnuwarht post light-hearted content and glamour shots with lions. 'I wanted to show people ... that lions can actually bond well with humans,' he said, insisting he plays regularly with his pets. He entered Big George's enclosure tentatively though, spending just a few minutes being batted by the tawny striped liger's hefty paws before retreating behind a fence. Since 2022, Thai law has required owners to register and microchip lions, and inform authorities before moving them. But there are no breeding caps, few enclosure or welfare requirements, and no controls on liger or tigon hybrids. Births of protected native species like tigers must be reported within 24 hours. Lion owners have 60 days. 'That is a huge window,' said Taylor. 'What could be done with a litter of cubs in those 60 days? Anything.' Illicit trade Taylor and his colleagues have tracked the rise in lion ownership with on-site visits and by trawling social media. They recorded around 130 in 2018, and nearly 450 by 2024. But nearly 350 more lions they encountered were 'lost to follow-up' after their whereabouts could not be confirmed for a year. That could indicate unreported deaths, an animal removed from display or 'worst-case scenarios', said Taylor. 'We have interviewed traders [in the region] who have given us prices for live and dead lions and have told us they can take them over the border.' As a vulnerable species, lions and their parts can only be sold internationally with so-called Cites permits. But there is circumstantial evidence of illicit trade, several experts told AFP, speaking on condition of anonymity to avoid angering authorities. Media reports and social media have documented lions, including cubs, in Cambodia multiple times in recent years, though Cites shows no registered imports since 2003. There is also growing evidence that captive lion numbers in Laos exceed Cites import licences. In Thailand, meanwhile, imports of lion parts like bones, skins and teeth have dropped in recent years, though demand remains, raising questions about how parts are now being sourced. Thai trader Pathamawadee Janpithak started in the crocodile business, but pivoted to lions as prices for the reptiles declined. 'It gradually became a full-fledged business that I couldn't step away from,' the gregarious 32-year-old told AFP in front of a row of caged cubs. She sells 1-month-olds for around 500,000 baht (US$15,500 or $25,900), down from a peak of 800,000 baht ($41,200) as breeding operations like hers increase supply. Captive lions are generally fed around 2kg of chicken carcasses a day, and can produce litters of two to six cubs, once or twice a year. Pathamawadee's three facilities house around 80 lions, from a stately full-maned 9-year-old to a sickly pair of 8-day-olds being bottle-fed around the clock. They are white because of a genetic mutation, and the smaller pool of white lions means inbreeding and sickness are common. Sometimes wrongly considered a 'threatened' subspecies, they are popular in Thailand, but a month-old white cub being reared alongside the newborns has been sick almost since birth. It has attracted no buyers so far and will be unbreedable, Pathamawadee said. Thailand's captive lion population has exploded in recent years, with nearly 500 registered individuals in zoos, breeding farms, petting cafes and homes. Photo / Lillian Suwanrumpha, AFP She lamented the increasing difficulty of finding buyers willing to comply with ownership rules. 'In the past, people could just put down money and walk away with a lion ... Everything has become more complicated.' Legal review Pathamawadee sells around half of the 90 cubs she breeds each year, often to other breeders, who are increasingly opening 'lion cafes' where customers pose with and pet young lions. Outside Chiang Mai, a handler roused a cub from a nap to play with a group of squealing Chinese tourists. Staff let AFP film the interaction, but like all lion cafes contacted, declined interviews. Pathamawadee no longer sells to cafes, which tend to offload cubs within weeks as they grow. She said several were returned to her traumatised and no longer suitable for breeding. The growing lion population is a problem for Thailand's Department of National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation (DNP), admitted wildlife protection director Sadudee Punpugdee. 'But private ownership has existed for a long time ... so we're taking a gradual approach,' he told AFP. That includes limiting lion imports so breeders are forced to rely on the domestic population. 'With inbreeding on the rise, the quality of the lions is also declining and we believe that demand will decrease as a result,' Sadudee said. Already stretched authorities face difficult choices on enforcing regulations, as confiscated animals become their responsibility, said Penthai Siriwat, illegal wildlife trade specialist at WWF Thailand. 'There is a great deal of deliberation before intervening ... considering the substantial costs,' she told AFP. Owners like Tharnuwarht often evoke conservation to justify their pets, but Thailand's captive lions will never live in the wild. Two-year-olds Khanom and Khanun live in a DNP sanctuary after being confiscated from a cafe and private owner over improper paperwork. They could survive another decade or more, and require specialised keepers, food, and care. Sanctuary chief vet Natanon Panpeth treads carefully while discussing the lion trade, warning only that the 'wellbeing of the animals should always come first'. Big cat ownership has been banned in the United States and the United Arab Emirates in recent years, and Thailand's wildlife rules are soon up for review. Sadudee is hopeful some provisions may be tightened, though a ban is unlikely for now. He has his own advice for would-be owners: 'Wild animals belong in the wild. There are plenty of other animals we can keep as pets.' -Agence France-Presse
