Whitehorse dam relicensing gets the OK, but with new terms and conditions
In a 66-page document issued this week, the decision bodies for the project — Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Transport Canada and the territorial government — agreed that the ongoing operation of the dam "will result in, or is likely to result in, significant adverse effects," primarily to chinook salmon, First Nations wellness, fish habitat, wetlands and heritage resources, among other things.
Yukon Energy submitted a proposal to the territory's assessment board in late 2023 to relicense the dam. Until then, the 67-year-old facility had never been scrutinized by the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Board (YESAB), which did not exist when the facility's licence last came up for renewal in 2000.
The relicensing application came at a time when Yukon River chinook salmon stocks have been in steady and dramatic decline. First Nations and environmentalists argue that the dam, by obstructing access to upstream spawning grounds, or even killing fish with its turbines, is a significant part of the problem.
YESAB's report, issued earlier this year, acknowledges those concerns.
"Adverse effects stemming from the project are likely to further deteriorate the already serious state of Yukon River chinook salmon and are likely to have much longer lasting effects," the report states, adding that examples could include the extinction of the species, loss of First Nations' ceremonies and transfer of traditional knowledge.
Yukon Energy's current licence for the dam was set to expire next month. YESAB suggested the 25-year renewal be approved and made 39 recommendations, many of them focused on fish and wildlife, and Indigenous land use.
Those recommendations include coming up with plans to redesign the dam's fish ladder and how to make it more effective, developing a system to monitor fish passage at the Lewes control structure upstream, and that Yukon Energy launch a study into how the dam has long affected how First Nations people who use the land in the project area.
Board's recommendations 'did not go far enough'
In their decision this week, the federal and territorial governments accept most of the board's assessment, and its recommendations.
However, they also modified some of YESAB's recommended terms and conditions for the licence, "to ensure significant adverse project effects and adverse effects to Aboriginal and treaty rights are adequately mitigated."
"The terms and conditions related to chinook salmon recommended by the [YESAB] Designated Office did not go far enough to ensure that measures to reduce impacts to chinook salmon would in fact be implemented, especially in the short-term," the decision document reads.
"Additionally, multiple terms and conditions did not provide clear objectives for plans or monitoring, or specific timelines for the development and implementation of these items."
The governments altered the terms and conditions related to chinook and First Nation wellness to better address those concerns. Part of that includes a requirement to develop a traditional knowledge framework and to include traditional knowledge "within all plans and studies for the life of the project."
Yukon Energy must also provide a schedule for when some of its plans and projects related to chinook salmon and First Nation wellness will be developed and implemented.
Other new conditions include a requirement for Yukon Energy to immediately "improve fish passage and reduce entrainment mortality" until a long-term plan to address those things is in place.
Yukon Energy must also begin an annual monitoring program to determine fish passage and mortality at the dam, provide cultural awareness training to all staff "that interact with salmon and traditional knowledge," and issue public reports annually about fish monitoring and mortality, among other things.
"With these modifications ... Decision Bodies are satisfied that project effects related to chinook salmon and First Nation wellness are sufficiently mitigated," the decision report reads.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
4 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Bolivia heads to a runoff after an election ends two decades of ruling party dominance
LA PAZ, Bolivia (AP) — Bolivia's presidential vote is headed to an unprecedented runoff after Sunday's election ended over two decades of ruling party dominance in the Andean nation. A centrist, Sen. Rodrigo Paz, drew more votes than the front-runners, although not enough to secure an outright victory, early results showed. Paz, a former mayor who has sought to soften the edges of the opposition's push for austerity to rescue Bolivia from a looming economic collapse, will face off against former President Jorge 'Tuto' Quiroga, who finished second. Bolivia holds the presidential runoff — its first since its 1982 return to democracy — on Oct. 19. 'This economic model must change,' Paz declared to crowds who cheered and chanted, 'Renewal!' Paz's campaign had gained unexpected traction as he teamed up with Edman Lara, a social media savvy ex-police captain with evangelical backing whose supporters see him as someone willing to stand up to corruption in the security forces. With over 91% of the ballots counted Sunday, Paz received 32.8% of the votes cast. Quiroga secured 26.4%. Candidates needed to surpass 50%, or 40% with a 10-point margin of victory, to avoid a runoff. Quiroga congratulated Paz on his lead. 'What happened is unprecedented,' he said. 'Bolivia told the world that we want to live in a free nation.' An establishment confronts its demise The results delivered a blow to Bolivia's Movement Toward Socialism, or MAS, party, which has governed almost uninterrupted since its founder, charismatic ex-President Evo Morales, rose to power as part of the 'pink tide' of leaders who swept into office across Latin America during the commodities boom of the early 2000s. The official MAS candidate, Eduardo del Castillo, finished sixth with 3.2% of the vote. A candidate considered to be the party's best hope, 36-year-old Senate president Andrónico Rodríguez, captured 8% of the vote. During his almost 14 years in power, Morales expanded the rights of the country's Indigenous majority, defended coca growers against U.S.-backed eradication programs and poured natural gas profits into social programs. But the maverick leader's increasingly high-handed attempts to prolong his presidency — along with allegations of sexual relations with underage girls — soured public opinion against him. Discontent turned into outrage as Bolivia's once-stable economy imploded under Morales' protégé-turned-rival, President Luis Arce. Annual inflation rate has soared from 2% less than two years ago to 25% as of last month. A scarcity of fuel has paralyzed the country. A shortage of U.S. dollars needed to pay for essential imports like wheat has crippled the economy. As the crisis accelerated, MAS leaders traded blame. A power struggle between Morales and Arce fractured the bloc and handed the opposition its first real shot at victory in decades, even as its uncharismatic candidates failed to unite. Morales' supports heed calls to vote null Blocked from running by a court ruling on term limits, Morales has been holed up in his stronghold of Chapare for months evading an arrest warrant for allegedly impregnating a 15-year-old girl while president. He has branded Rodríguez a traitor for competing and encouraged his supporters to register their anger at his exclusion by casting null-and-void ballots. His followers appeared to heed his call: An unusually high proportion of votes, 19%, were deemed invalid. Usually the share of blank and null votes doesn't exceed 6%. Voting even in the restive jungle largely passed peacefully, authorities said, with only minor disruptions. A dynamite stick went off near the school where Rodríguez planned to cast his ballot in Chapare. When he arrived hours later, pro-Morales crowds assaulted him with bottles and rocks as he voted. Whisked away by guards, Rodríguez later called it a 'difficult moment.' A centrist takes a surprise lead The win for Paz came as a shock to a nation that had been conditioned by weeks of opinion polls to expect that the leading contenders, Quiroga and businessman Samuel Doria Medina, would capture the top two spots. Paz has sought to distance himself from pledges by Quiroga and Doria Medina to sell Bolivia's abundant lithium reserves to foreign companies and turn to the International Monetary Fund for billions of dollars of loans. But he has also launched blistering attacks on the MAS party and its economic model. 'I want to congratulate the people because this is a sign of change,' Paz said. New face, old roots Despite their grand promises, Doria Medina and Quiroga struggled to stir up voter excitement. Bolivians associate them both with the U.S.-backed neoliberal administrations that Morales repudiated when he stormed to office in 2006, declaring an end to Bolivia's 20-year experiment with free-market capitalism. 'If they couldn't govern well before, what makes us think they'll do it now?' asked Yaitzel Poma, 30, as she celebrated in the capital of La Paz. 'We have to learn from the past to make better choices.' Bolivia faces a return to belt-tightening. After years of alignment with world powers like China and Russia, it seems set to reconcile with the United States. Paz supporters have described the former mayor Bolivia's southern town of Tarija as a fresh face with new ideas. But Paz, too, has deep ties to Bolivia's old political elite. The 57-year-old lawmaker is the son of former President Jaime Paz Zamora, who began his political career as a co-founder of the Revolutionary Left Movement, a party persecuted under the bloody military dictatorship of Hugo Banzer in the 1970s. 'What we're doing is moving back in time,' said Kathryn Ledebur, director of the Andean Information Network, a Bolivian research group. 'This is not a new actor with dynamic policies.'
CBC
9 hours ago
- CBC
Ginoogaming First Nation's chief calls renaming of Indian Road a 'starting point'
Chief Sheri Taylor of Ginoogaming First Nation says the renaming of Indian Road in Longlac, Ont., is a good start, but there's a long way to go when it comes to reconciliation between the Municipality of Greenstone and nearby First Nations. Greenstone's municipal council passed a bylaw approving the road's new name last week. Taylor says she was first approached about the proposed change last summer, and turned to her community's council of elders and knowledge keepers for input. "Behind all that was that it simply just can't be a name change to a road; it has to be more done in the spirit of reconciliation," Taylor said. "What comes with that? The responsibility on the behalf of the municipality in regards to the way a lot of the historical and the systematic issues and racism that our people have felt over the years." Ginoogaming's council came up with the name Nishnabe Miikena, which translates from Ojibway to Nishnabe, or Anishinaabe, Road. "Anishinaabe refers to our people, the Ojibway people, the first people, the good people," said Taylor. The Municipality of Greenstone, located within the Thunder Bay district in northwestern Ontario, includes a number of smaller communities, such as Geraldton, Longlac and Nakina. It covers an area of over 3,100 square kilometres along the Trans-Canada Highway. It's located on the traditional territories of several First Nations, including Animbigoo Zaagi'igan Anishinaabek, Aroland, Biinjitiwaabik Zaaging Anishinaabek, Bingwi Neyaashi Anishinaabek, Ginoogaming and Long Lake #58. While she gives credit to the municipality for acknowledging the importance of a more appropriate road name, Taylor said it's also necessary to recognize the historic tensions caused by towns being "developed in our homelands." A road renaming project is part of Greenstone's official Reconciliation Action Plan. In a report to council, the municipality's chief administrative officer said the new name "recognizes the historical intent of the naming of Indian Road (to recognize those with Indigenous heritage in the region) while also being more culturally appropriate." The bylaw approving the name change will come into effect Oct. 1 "to allow for ordering of signs, notice, and event planning." During the Aug. 11 municipal council meeting, Coun. Elaine Mannisto of the Longlac ward said she's received "explosive comments" from those who live on Indian Road that oppose the change. "One of the comments they made was that they all received letters asking about this initially and that they didn't agree to a name change, and now the proposal is to change the name," Mannisto said. However, Taylor said this kind of response "comes from a lack of knowing the history." "It comes from a lack of not understanding where we come from, too, so there's a lot of work that has to be done." It comes from a lack of not understanding where we come from, too, so there's a lot of work that has to be done. - Chief Sheri Taylor, Ginoogaming First Nation "There's many examples of the old systematic discrimination that has happened to our people, one of them being the Indian Act," she said. "There's residential schools, Indian day schools, Sixties Scoop, there's overrepresentation in the child welfare system, there's incarceration rates." One way to address these inequalities is by promoting economic development within the area's First Nations, she said. "Our people, First Nations people, have contributed enormously to the economic growth of Greenstone, and that doesn't seem to be recognized," said Taylor. "I think as they move along, those types of things need to be recognized — that our people have made major contributions to what Greenstone is today."
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Blocked from Bolivia's election, ex-leader Morales not sure how to respond to threats of arrest
LAUCA Ñ, Bolivia (AP) — Bolivia's charismatic, long-serving ex-President Evo Morales told The Associated Press on Saturday that he didn't know what to do about threats by the right-wing presidential candidates to arrest him if they came to power. From his stronghold in Bolivia's tropics of Chapare, where he has been holed up for months under the protection of die-hard supporters, he repeated his call for voters to deface their ballots in Sunday's high-stakes elections in defiance of the race from which he is barred due to a contentious constitutional court ruling. 'What are we going to do? Not even I know,' he said in response to questions about how he would respond if either of the right-wing front-runners, multimillionaire businessman Samuel Doria Medina and former president Jorge 'Tuto' Quiroga, wins the presidential election and fulfills their threats to arrest him. 'I am in the crosshairs of of the right-wing empire.' Morales, 65, was charged last year with human trafficking and accused of impregnating a 15-year-old girl when he was president. While he has not outright denied having sexual relations with the underage girl, he has described the charges as politically motivated. A judge issued the arrest order as he and his former finance minister, President Luis Arce, bickered over the control of their long-dominant Movement Toward Socialism Party. As a result of their bitter power struggle, the party splintered. With the Bolivian economy undergoing its worst crisis in around four decades, the implosion of the MAS party has given the right-wing opposition its best shot at winning at the ballot box since Morales first came to power in 2006. 'Look, it's an election without legality, without legitimacy …. without the Indigenous movement, without the popular movement,' Morales, Bolivia's first Indigenous president, contended in his interview with the AP at his political organization's headquarters, where he broadcasts a weekly radio show. The null-and-void vote, he said, 'isn't just a vote for our political movement.' 'It's a protest vote, a vote of anger.' He insulted Doria Medina and Quiroga, who have both run for president three times before, losing at least twice to Morales, as 'eternal losers.' Citing widespread voter disillusionment with the options, he expressed confidence that the election outcome would reveal an unusually high proportion of invalid votes. 'No one is going to win. It will be the spoiled vote, which is Evo's vote,' he said, speaking in third person.
