The number of poor are falling in India; is it time to shift the poverty line now?
Last month, the World Bank released yet another set of poverty estimates for India and bang, bang. The hammer dropped. Extreme poverty is nearly dead. Just some 3.3 crore Indians are extremely poor as against 23 crore a decade ago.
According to the World Bank's Spring 2025 Poverty and Equity Brief, India has lifted 171 million out of extreme poverty. It also made strong gains in poverty reduction at the lower-middle-income level -- measured at $3.65 per day -- which fell from 61.8% to 28.1%, lifting 378 million out of poverty.
The latest estimates, coming in the backdrop of intense trade and terror tensions, sprinkle some much-needed stardust on the macroeconomic front.
Importantly, it allows the government to flash a V-sign as the numbers are in line with India's recent Household Consumption Expenditure Survey 2022-23, which too indicated that extreme poverty has been ripped out by the roots pegging poverty rate somewhere between 2.8 crore and 7 crore. The previous official poverty estimate in 2011 counted 26 crore, or 21.9% of the population as extremely poor.
Lastly, the estimates also conform with the 2020 IMF working paper by economists Dr Surjit Bhalla, Karan Bhasin and Arvind Virmani, which drew sharp criticism and praise for projecting poverty rate at 2.5%.
Meanwhile, according to the World Bank report, if the five most populous states including Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Bihar, West Bengal, and Madhya Pradesh accounted for 65% of India's extreme poor in 2011-12, they contributed to two-thirds of the overall decline in extreme poverty by 2022-23.
But hey, hold the jubilation.
Not all in the country are convinced that poverty has well and truly declined to the extent the statistics suggest and call for careful scrutiny. Critics counter that there's really no glory in telling people stuff they either don't believe or cannot accept as ground reality. They reason that in the absence of broad-based growth, there's no way of spinning the math to make poverty numbers look rosy and without growth, nothing can actually kill poverty. Not facts. Not figures. And certainly not a flock of forecasts.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Man from the south who breathed fire against the British empire
'If Indians join together and breathe hard enough, our breath will be enough to blow away the foreigners,' said Subramania Sivam, who called himself Swatanthiranandar, or one who delights in freedom The part of Marina Beach opposite Presidency College, today just another stretch of sand for walkers and vendors, was once christened 'Tilagar Thidal' by Subramania Sivam, in honour of his political guru, Bal Gangadhar Tilak. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now But who was Subramania Sivam, the relatively unsung freedom fighter who made the British nervous? Though Sivam spoke of himself as a wayfarer who had the opportunity of conducting the 'coronation of Swaraj' in Tirunelveli district, such was the incandescent power and incendiary impact of his Tamil speeches against British rule, that the colonial regime sought to stamp him out of existence. But is there an empire that can quell the spirit of a man who called himself Swatanthiranandar, or one who delights in freedom? Sivam (1884-1925) has been seen as an 'enigmatic ascetic' who, through his patriotic speeches, made Tirunelveli district in the deep south reverberate to the revolutionary frequency of West Bengal in the 'extremist' phase of the Indian freedom struggle. Sivam, sometimes referred to as Siva, was born in Oct 1884 in Batlagundu, a village known as the gateway to the Kodaikanal hills. He appeared to inherit his hardy physique and free-spirited nature from his father. In his early years, he was well cared for by his maternal grandfather, the village munsiff of nearby Ayyampalayam. But things changed when Sivam moved with his parents to Madurai for his secondary education. It was when the years of poverty began. The family later relocated to Trivandrum to benefit from the free dining hall (oottuppura) offered by the Travancore Samasthanam. As a strapping youth who was called a bayilvan (wrestler, fighter), Sivam also gained mastery over Tamil and English though he failed in his matriculation exams in a Coimbatore school. To an English teacher who liked to repeat, 'What I want is common sense', he is said to have replied, 'Exactly so, Sir', cheekily pointing to the alternate meaning of 'want' as lack. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Sivam got into bad company in his teens and gained the temporary infamy of being a brawler and bully. But in 1902, Sivam met Sadananda Swami at Trivandrum. The Swami, as Ramanatha Menon, had worked in the Kolar gold mines before becoming a Raja Yogi and Ayurvedic healer. Having taken refuge at Sadananda Swami's feet, Sivam remained with him like his shadow till Jan 12, 1907. It was as if the aimless ship of his life had finally found its anchorage in the presence of the saint who added Sivam to his name, symbolising union with the divine. Ironically, this would only be the beginning of the greatest challenges and extreme tribulations that Sivam would face in life. The speeches of Thakur Kahan Chandra Verma, an Arya Samaji speaker from Lahore, calling for uncompromising nationalism ignited a blaze of patriotism in Sivam's heart and he became a passionate speaker himself. 'If we Indians join together and breathe hard enough, our breath will be enough to blow away the foreigners,' he would tell his audience. When the Travancore Samasthanam expelled him from the realm, he moved into Cochin and finally to Tirunelveli district, walking all the way while spreading the message of Swarajya in villages and towns through his fearless, frank and fery speeches. It was at this time that V O Chidambaram Pillai, by then the most influential leader in the south of the extremist faction of the Congress, and native entrepreneur who had founded the Swadeshi Steam Navigation Company to compete with British business interests, experienced the electrifying quality of Sivam's oratory and co-opted him in his nationalistic campaigns. Together, they mobilised labourers of the Coral Textile Mills in Tuticorin and won concessions for them from their British masters in Feb 1908. After the duo disregarded a ban and held a public meeting and procession on March 9 to mark the release of Bipin Chandra Pal who was incarcerated for refusing to divulge the identity of the writers of 'seditious' articles in his 'Bandemataram', district collector L M Wynch and his impetuous subordinate Robert Ashe had them arrested on charges of sedition, leading to large-scale riots in Tirunelveli. Curiously, while the first accused (Sivam) got 10 years transportation, the second accused (VOC) got a double transportation for life (transportation meaning being locked up in the brutal Cellular Jail in the Andaman Islands). Appeals got the transportation part scored out but they languished in jail for more than four years. The jail terms and the harshness of prison conditions reserved for them, wrecked their lives. Sivam was struck with leprosy. But his wife Meenakshi, to whom he had been married when he was 15, got to meet him in prison, and asked him for the means by which she could lead her life. He wrote his spiritual masterpiece 'Sachidananda Sivam' for her, the book being a guide for the higher life of divine seeking. After his release on Nov 2, 1912, he started the monthly 'Gnanabanu' with his wife as publisher. Meenakshi, however, died of tuberculosis on May 15, 1915, aged 27. For ten more years, Sivam trudged on despite his worsening health, training youth in nation building activities, and planning to build a temple to Bharatha Matha in Papparapatti, now in Dharmapuri district, where stands a memorial for this selfless and fearless patriot, who perhaps is the first great Tamil orator in modern times to capture the imagination of the masses. (The writer is a journalist and author) Email your feedback to
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
Defeated in Field, Now Field Marshal: BJP MP Ravi Shankar Takes Dig At Pakistan For Promoting Asim Munir
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MP Ravi Shankar Prasad, who is leading the all-party delegation in the United Kingdom, ridiculed Pakistan for promoting Chief of Army Staff General Asim Munir to Field Marshal despite recent military and strategic failures during Operation Sindoor, saying that despite Munir's defeat in the field, he was promoted. In May this year, Pakistan government promoted Army Chief General Asim Munir to the rank of field marshal for his role during Operation Sindoor. Addressing the Indian diaspora in London on Sunday, Prasad said that Pakistan's problem lies in its lack of democracy, as unelected and unaccountable military leaders have consistently seized power. "What is the problem of Pakistan? The problem with Pakistan is that it is not a democratic country. 'Muhammad Ali Jinnah ne banaya Pakistan, wo ban gaya Generals ki dukaan, that is the situation of Pakistan. The second thing, very important, is people, leaders make the country. There, Pakistan armed forces have made a country for themselves, unelectable, not accountable, not popular sanction, but they seized power. Ayub Khan field marshal for 10 years. Mr Yahya Khan for seven and a half years, Mr Zia ul Haq for eleven years, General Musharraf for nine years… Now you have Munir, General, who was defeated in the field but became a field marshal. That is the whole scenario," ANI quoted Prasad as saying. Accusing Pakistan of sheltering terrorists, Prasad pointed out that the 9/11 mastermind Osama bin Laden was caught in Pakistan. He added that the terrorists who hijacked the plane to rescue Masood Azhar have also been killed in Pakistan, along with Masood Azhar's two brothers, brothers-in-law, and sisters during Operation Sindoor. "9/11 in America, a gentleman known as Osama bin Laden, where was he caught? You know it very well, in Pakistan, who unleashed the entire mayhem of Al-Qaeda and the attack in New York. You remember that Daniel Pearl, the journalist, many journalists are sitting here and watching, it was slit and you'll be happy to know the terrorist who slit his neck has been slit by the missiles of India in this attack. The terrorists who hijacked the plane to rescue Masood Azhar had also been killed, and Masood Azhar's two brothers, brother-in-laws, and sisters have all been killed. Why are we here? We are here to tell the world terrorism is a global cancer," he said. He stressed that India has always sought peace with Pakistan and has never been the aggressor, but has only responded to threats by Pakistan. "India and Pakistan have fought four conventional wars, many distinguished Indians sitting here in the front, they have seen those times. 48 First War, 65 Second War, 71 Third War, when Bangladesh was created, 99 the Kargil War. These are four conventional wars. Remember one thing, my dear fellow Indians, India was never the aggressor, India only responded. The second thing you all need to understand, we are not against the people of Pakistan, they are fine. All governments, be it the Congress or the BJP or Jawaharlal Nehru or Lal Bahadur Shastri or Indira Gandhi or Dr Manmohan Singh or Atal Bihari Vajpayee, everyone tried to have a peaceful dialogue with them. What happened? Terrorism,' Prasad said. The Indian delegation, led by Ravi Shankar Prasad, arrived in London on Saturday (local time) as part of India's global outreach program to convey the country's firm stance against terrorism. The delegation includes BJP MP Daggubati Purandeswari, Samik Bhattacharya, Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Priyanka Chaturvedi, Congress MPs Ghulam Ali Khatana and Amar Singh, former Union Minister MJ Akbar, and former Ambassador Pankaj Saran. The delegation On April 22, twenty-six innocent people were killed and several others were injured in a terror attack by Pakistan-sponsored terrorists in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam. Indian Armed Forces launched Operation Sindoor on May 7 in response to the terror attack, targeting nine terror infrastructure sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir, leading to the death of over 100 terrorists affiliated with terror outfits like the Jaish-e-Mohammed, Lashkar-e-Taiba and Hizbul Mujahideen.
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
How do you de-risk from outliving your savings?
In today's world a nagging question for many Indians is, Will I have enough money to last through retirement? It's a valid worry. Life expectancy, already about 72.5 years, is expected to cross 85 by the end of this century. At the same time, healthcare costs are rising. And inflation? That's silently eroding the value of our money year after year. A recent survey showed nearly 4 out of 10 working Indians fear they might outlive their savings. So, what can you do? Long retirement years If you retire at 60 and live till 85-90, retirement can easily last 25-30 years. That's almost equal to your working life. Let's say you plan to spend ₹50,000 a month in retirement or ₹6 lakh a year. Over 30 years it's ₹1.8 crore without accounting for inflation. Now add inflation at, say, 6%. That ₹50,000 monthly budget could become ₹1.6 lakh in 20 years. And that's why you need more than a 'big enough' retirement corpus. You need a strategy that helps your income keep up with rising costs. Let's look at some key risks which can erode your wealth. Think ₹1 crore is enough? At 6% inflation, the real value of that corpus halves in 12 years. To counter the effects of inflation, you should keep a portion of savings invested in inflation-beating assets that invest in equity market. Unit-Linked Pension Plans are specifically designed to help you build a retirement corpus which helps generate guaranteed income after retirement. These plans work best if you start investing early. A ULIP Pension Plan has two phases: Accumulation phase and payout phase. During working years, you accumulate a big corpus by investing regularly and earning market-linked returns on the investments. And when you retire, you can withdraw a certain portion (up to 60%) of corpus tax-free and also get regular guaranteed income from balance amount. A great feature is you can invest in a mix of equity and debt funds and switch between them. So you can stay equity-heavy in accumulation phase for faster growth and when nearing retirement you can remain debt-heavy to preserve capital. Medical inflation Healthcare costs in India are rising by 12–14% annually. This problem has a simple solution: health insurance. A comprehensive health insurance policy with lifetime renewability can ensure you won't have to dip into savings for any medical emergency. You must also explore topping up your insurance plan. Longevity risk If you've planned finances to last till 80 but live till 90, you could run out of money. The guaranteed regular income from Pension ULIPs on maturity ensures you get income for life irrespective of age. Withdrawals Pulling out big chunks for lifestyle expenses or emergencies early in retirement can put strain on future needs. Unit Linked Pension Plans ensure at least 40% of corpus is set aside to give you guaranteed return for life, thus securing your retirement. Thus, Pension ULIPs help you to counter these risks by providing the flexibility of partial withdrawals allowed for specific life events while the discipline of ensuring 40% of corpus is always set aside to give you guaranteed returns for life ensures you never run out of money. The rest can be withdrawn tax-free under Section 10 (10A) and Clause 23AAB of Income Tax Act, 1961 You can also consider National Pension Scheme (NPS), a government-backed plan which allows up to 75% of contributions to be invested in market-linked instruments with balance in safer debt options. Once you hit 60, at least 40% of the corpus goes into an annuity, giving a steady, guaranteed income for life. A checklist Figure out how much monthly income you need to live a comfortable life post retirement. Then use the 4% rule to arrive at the corpus size. For example, if you need ₹50,000 every month, then you need a corpus of ₹1.5 crore. But if you are expecting to retire after a decade or two, you need to adjust this number for inflation. Rupee cost averaging Markets go up and down. But over time, consistent investing pays off. By consistently investing in unit linked pension plans you ensure you earn higher number of units when markets fall and lower number of units when markets rise. This helps grow your corpus irrespective of market conditions. That's rupee cost averaging. So start early, stay consistent and let compounding do its magic. Investing early Starting to invest early helps save more and investments get time to grow. With right planning, retirement can be one of the most rewarding chapters of your life. (The writer is head, Investments,
