Club World Cup refs to wear eye-level cameras but it's what FIFA won't show that's most telling
FILE - Referee Ricardo De Burgos Bengoetxea watches the VAR during the Spanish Copa del Rey final soccer match between Barcelona and Real Madrid at Estadio de La Cartuja stadium in Seville, Spain, Saturday, April 26, 2025. (AP Photo/Jose Breton, file)
soccer
By JAMES ROBSON
Referees at the Club World Cup will wear eye-level cameras to finally allow fans to see exactly what the officials are looking at during a soccer match.
Well... not quite.
FIFA has announced the innovation will be implemented at its newly-expanded tournament, which kicks off in Miami on Saturday. But on closer inspection, the technology appears to be more about improving the experience for television viewers than improving the game.
For instance, only 'non-controversial' images will be shown during the match. FIFA has not specified what that means, but don't look for goal-scoring incidents and potential red cards to be included.
The camera will be attached to the referee's earpiece.
'It is a trial,' Pierluigi Collina, chairman of the FIFA referees committee, said Wednesday. "What will be the future? We will see.
'We have said that we want to, let's say, offer a new experience to TV viewers. We want to show something, let's say, entertaining. I don't think that we always need to think of the controversial or potentially controversial incidents on the field of play.'
Footage will be checked before being broadcast, rather than shown live.
FIFA says the refcam view could be used to show unique angles of goals scored and offer different perspectives of the game that normal cameras cannot see. But if restricted to that, it would appear to be a missed opportunity in a sport that is increasingly using advances in technology to improve the accuracy and transparency of decision-making.
Another innovation at the Club World Cup — a month-long tournament staged in the United States and featuring 32 of the best soccer teams in the world — is to show footage being reviewed by VAR for the first time on big screens inside the stadium. In theory, the refcam would make referees more accountable for their decisions by allowing fans to see exactly what the official saw before making a call.
But it is not even clear how much it would be used to help VAR.
While Collina said all footage would be available to the VAR, he questioned how useful the refcam would be in such circumstances.
'Honestly, can you believe that a camera position just besides the referee's eyes can see something that the referee's eyes cannot see? Honestly, I think it's difficult to believe,' he said.
FIFA, itself, has made clear where it believes the footage would be of most use, saying the test was designed to 'explore whether the new camera angle can improve the experience for those watching on television and online by showcasing the referee's perspective.'
It added that the tests would be used to make guidelines for future use.
'Step by step' Collina said. "We need to do something new and the simpler the better."
FIFA also announced a clampdown on time wasting by goalkeepers at the Club World Cup.
Previous rules specified keepers can't hold onto the ball for longer than six seconds, but Collina said that was frequently being flouted.
The time limit has now been extended to eight seconds, but referees will be much stricter in enforcement.
The referee will also count down from five seconds with their hand to indicate the time remaining. If a keeper holds onto the ball for longer than eight seconds, a corner kick will be awarded to the opposition, rather than an indirect free kick, which was the previous punishment.
© Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Times
8 hours ago
- Japan Times
FIFA President Gianni Infantino hails Club World Cup as start of 'new era'
FIFA President Gianni Infantino says the Club World Cup, which kicks off on Saturday, marks a historic "new era" for the game, comparing it to the first World Cup held in 1930. Infantino, who sat down for an interview, also took aim at critics of FIFA's ticketing policy and said that skeptics who questioned the need for the tournament would quickly change their minds. The 32-team competition, featuring clubs from around the globe, gets underway with Inter Miami facing Egyptian club Al Ahly at Hard Rock Stadium. "It starts a new era of football, a new era of club football," Infantino said. "A little bit like when, in 1930, the first World Cup, right, started." "Everyone today speaks about the very first World Cup. That's why it's also, this World Cup here is historic." The first World Cup was held in Uruguay in 1930, and Infantino noted that only European and South American teams took part, adding that the Club World Cup would give clubs from outside of soccer's traditional heartlands a chance to play on the global stage. "We want to be inclusive," he said. "We want to give opportunities to clubs from all over the world. "It's really to globalize football, to make it truly, truly global. Because when you scratch the surface, we say it's the No. 1 sport in the world, and it is, but then the elite is very concentrated in very few clubs, in very few countries." The Swiss official, who was general secretary of European body UEFA before taking the helm at FIFA in 2016, said that the club tournament also offered chances to players from over 80 countries. "Countries who would never have a chance to play in a World Cup are suddenly part of a World Cup, and they feel to be part of it, the fans of these players and of these clubs," added Infantino, who noted several great players of the past who never played in a World Cup. "A very good friend of mine is George Weah ... former legend, great player, Ballon d'Or winner, only African player who ever won the Ballon d'Or, by the way. He never played in a World Cup. He would have been playing in a Club World Cup and made not only his club and also his country proud." Infantino dismissed concerns that the tournament added to schedule congestion but acknowledged that some fans were yet to be sure of the value of the tournament, saying that would quickly change. "I believe, I'm convinced that, you know, as soon as the ball starts rolling, the whole world will realize what is happening here," he said. "It's something special." Reports of low ticket sales for some games have led to criticism of FIFA's use of a 'dynamic pricing' model, increasingly common in the United States, which allows for prices to rise and fall according to demand. But Infantino defended the approach and the decision to offer heavy discounts to students in Miami. "I'm a positive person generally, but they criticize FIFA if the prices are too high, then they criticize FIFA if the prices are too low. "Then they criticize FIFA if we make ticketing promotions with students. Students! I mean, when I was a student, and I didn't have money, I would have loved FIFA to come to me and say, you want to come and watch a World Cup match?" "We don't want to see empty stadiums. I believe the stadiums will be pretty full." The FIFA president said that the tournament, which secured a global broadcasting deal with DAZN reported to be worth $1 billion, was already an economic success and stressed that all the money generated from commercial deals would be put back into the game. Asked how he would judge whether the tournament had been a success, Infantino said he would feel it in his "heart" but said he was confident. "In terms of inclusivity, in terms of economy, in terms of fan interest, you take all of these criteria, we'll speak again at the end of the Club World Cup, but already now, I (feel positive), when I look at the number of tickets sold, and I look at the TV rights," he said, noting that the games will be available on DAZN's streams for free. "Tell me one top competition today, where you can watch football for free?" he asked. The Club World Cup has also been caught up in the fierce debates in the U.S. over immigration control with games being held near Los Angeles, the scene of violent clashes between protestors and immigration officers. "Security for me and for us is a top priority, always," Infantino said. "So when something is happening, like in Los Angeles we are obviously monitoring the situation, we are in constant contact with the authorities, we want fans to go in games in a safe environment."
Kyodo News
a day ago
- Kyodo News
Football: Urawa to represent J-League at revamped Club World Cup
KYODO NEWS - 14 hours ago - 10:01 | Sports, All Urawa Reds will fly the flag as Japan's sole representative at the new 32-team Club World Cup kicking off Saturday in the United States, where hefty bonuses await the winner of each match, let alone the entire month-long tournament. Earning entry via their 2022-23 Asian Champions League triumph, Reds fittingly became Japan's inaugural entry in the overhauled event as winners of three continental titles, more than any other Japanese club. Qualification has already earned them $9.55 million and any group-stage win will net a further $2 million, with that amount to be split between the two sides in the event of a draw. The prize-money balloons from the round of 16 onward, with the eventual winners pocketing some $125 million in total. The competition will feature continental champions from 2021 to 2024, as well as teams with a high standing in their respective confederations' club rankings during the period, with a maximum of two clubs from any country. "The 32 best club teams in the world will determine, for the first time in history, which club, which team, is the best," FIFA President Gianni Infantino said. The tournament's addition to an already congested footballing calendar raised eyebrows, especially for European clubs who have just wrapped up their draining domestic seasons, but it represents an invaluable opportunity for Urawa to square off with some of the world's top sides. The draw has placed them in a tough but intriguing Group E featuring Argentina's River Plate, led by 17-year-old wonderkid Franco Mastantuono, Italian giants Inter Milan, who made this year's UEFA Champions League final, and Mexican powerhouse Monterrey. "I want Urawa to show they can more than compete with anyone on the world stage," former Japan captain and Urawa player Makoto Hasebe said in a video message in March as the trophy was exhibited at their Saitama Stadium. Prior to the latest alteration, the Toyota Cup pitted European and South American champions in a one-off decider in Japan before it was expanded to the previous edition of the Club World Cup in 2005, contested by six continental champions and a side from the host nation. Urawa's best outing to date in the tournament came in 2007 when the Asian champions lost 1-0 to Kaka-inspired AC Milan in the semifinals but beat Etoile Sahel of Tunisia in the third-place match 4-2 on penalties following a 2-2 draw. Recently crowned European champions Paris Saint-Germain join Real Madrid, Manchester City and Bayern Munich as favorites to lift the new trophy, while the spotlight will fall on 38-year-old Lionel Messi after his Inter Miami claimed the host's slot. Urawa arrive in the United States on the back of a decent domestic season so far, sitting third and six points off the top midway through the J1 campaign, having played two games more than leaders Kashima Antlers. Kashima, the 2018 ACL winners, incidentally had the best run at the Club World Cup two years earlier as host representative, reaching the final where they lost 4-2 in extra time to Real Madrid, a feat that Urawa goalkeeper Shusaku Nishikawa hopes his team can emulate. "In order to tell the world how wonderful the J-League is, we need to produce a good result," said the veteran who is set to play in the Club World Cup for the fourth time. "Earning at least a point in the opener is the most important thing and we want to focus on that (for now)."
Japan Times
a day ago
- Japan Times
Expanded Club World Cup set to have far-reaching impact on global soccer
FIFA's expanded Club World Cup, which gets underway in the United States this weekend, is a controversial addition to the global soccer calendar, and one that could have a far-reaching impact on the sport in the years to come. The 32-team tournament, with $1 billion dollars in prize money on offer, has been crammed into an already overloaded schedule leading to concerns it will push elite players to breaking point. It also threatens to upset the balance of domestic and continental club competitions, giving competing teams huge financial advantages over rivals. Consider the leading clubs in Europe, which is sending 12 teams including Champions League winners Paris Saint-Germain, Real Madrid, Manchester City and Chelsea. The chances are high that some will go deep into the Club World Cup, with a maximum of seven games to be played up to the July 13 final. The riches on offer are extraordinary, up to a possible $125 million for the top-performing European team. "The Club World Cup model affects the ecosystem of national leagues, especially in Europe," Javier Tebas, the president of Spain's La Liga, told radio station Cadena Cope. But while the likes of Liverpool and Barcelona will not be in the United States, and will thus miss out on the cash prizes, they will be able to give players a much-needed rest. "I think it will have a huge impact, and it will give Liverpool and Arsenal a huge advantage in the next season to not be there," said England manager Thomas Tuchel when asked about the consequences for the Premier League. Those clubs are already among the world's wealthiest without taking into account the sums being lavished by FIFA, but what about teams elsewhere? It will become harder for clubs in South Africa to challenge Mamelodi Sundowns once they leave with a guaranteed minimum of almost $10 million — the equivalent of the prize money for winning nine domestic titles. The amateurs of Auckland City were already dominate in Oceania before being handed $3.5 million just as an appearance fee. But if taking part will be perhaps the ultimate career highlight for their players, it just adds to the demands on those at top clubs. The introduction of the competition was met with opposition in Europe, and global players union FIFPro has warned that the wellbeing of many of its members is being threatened by the huge workload they face. Portugal midfielder Vitinha has played 52 matches for PSG this season, including the Champions League final win over Inter Milan on May 31. There have also been eight games for Portugal, including the Nations League final last week. Now he is off to the United States with PSG, with potentially no holiday until mid-July. The next French season is then due to start in mid-August, at the same time as the Premier League and La Liga. Then at the end of next season, Vitinha should be back in North America with Portugal at the expanded 48-team World Cup. Such demands on leading stars are why player unions in Europe last year raised the threat of strike action in a bid to cut down on the number of matches. "The problem is the accumulation of excessively long and intense seasons back to back," said Maheta Molango, chief executive of England's Professional Footballers' Association. "Players don't think just about the summer, they think about how they are not going to have a holiday for the foreseeable future." Meanwhile, domestic leagues do not see why they should change to accommodate FIFA's new tournament. "International organizations and especially FIFA have increased the number of matches they organize, so now we have a calendar that is beyond saturation," said Mathieu Moreuil of the Premier League. Other competitions are being devalued because the Club World Cup is taking place at the same time, like the CONCACAF Gold Cup, also being played in the United States. U.S. coach Mauricio Pochettino is unable to call on leading players like Weston McKennie and Timothy Weah because they are at the Club World Cup with Juventus. "That is the circumstance that we have and we need to adapt," said Pochettino, a former PSG coach who may disagree with the view of Luis Enrique, currently in charge of the French side. "I think it is an incredible competition," he remarked looking ahead to the Club World Cup.
