Teen died after police rush to her flat, but could not be saved due to 'frustrating' delay
Police were delayed in entering the flat of an 18-year-old woman who later died in hospital, an inquest has heard.
Alex Duce was found by officers on the afternoon of September 11, 2022, at her second-floor flat in Newport, Wales, and died days later, Newport Coroners' Court was told. Alex, a care home worker and beauty student at Ebbw Vale College, was described as "popular" with "many friends."
Hours before she was found, her mother reported her missing, saying a video call the previous evening had shown nothing unusual and that her disappearance was out of character. PC Michael Lammert attended the flat alone earlier that day. He was told by Alex's mother that she had been struggling with her mental health and had self-harmed around five weeks earlier.
Gwent Police classified her as "medium" risk. In his notes, PC Lammert recorded that Alex neither drank alcohol nor used drugs and did not pose a danger to others, Wales Online reports. "All that I had was that there had been a previous incident where she had taken an overdose and that there were concerns she might do it again," PC Lammert told the inquest. "There was no immediacy. If there was a clear message relaying she was contemplating suicide then that would definitely have been a higher risk."
Shortly before 11am, PC Lammert knocked on Alex's door and tried nearby flats, but there was no answer. A close friend told him she "does this from time to time," which he understood to mean she sometimes shuts herself off from family and friends.
At this stage, police did not have sufficient evidence to force entry under section 17 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act. PC Lammert then returned to Ebbw Vale station to trace people linked to Alex, including her foster family and a social worker, who said she sometimes struggled to maintain connections but was not considered particularly vulnerable.
He was diverted to a higher-priority incident before being sent back to the Castle Street flat around 4pm, accompanied by PC Lauren Smith. Reports said several of Alex's loved ones were outside, banging on the door.
PC Smith, trained in forced entry, had to assess whether to break in. Finding the necessary method of entry kit, which includes a hooligan bar and battering ram, proved difficult; it took about 30 minutes to locate the kit in another police vehicle. She described such delays as "frustrating," as at the time, only one kit was available per station.
When they reached the flat, PC Smith was unaware of Alex's previous self-harm incidents. "That information was never made available to me," she told the coroner. "The sense of urgency increased while I was there as I gained more information." She said that had she known about the suicide risk earlier, she "might have changed approach."
After a neighbour reported hearing footsteps and a "loud bang" from Alex's flat that afternoon, PC Smith decided to force entry just before 5pm. Using a battering ram five times, officers gained access and found Alex dead in her room. They believed she had recently lost consciousness and immediately began CPR while calling for backup and paramedics.
PC Ethan O'Sullivan arrived at 5.03pm with a defibrillator and continued resuscitation until paramedics arrived. Alex, showing signs of life, was taken to Prince Charles Hospital in Merthyr Tydfil for advanced life support. She remained on life support until it was switched off on 16 September. The inquest continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
5 hours ago
- Scotsman
Alex Salmond's widow to push ahead with suing Scottish Government
A family friend said claims in Nicola Sturgeon's memoir has strengthened Moira Salmond's resolve Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Alex Salmond's widow is to push ahead with the former first minister's legal action against the Scottish Government. Moira has reportedly appointed a KC, two junior counsel and a lead investigator to pursue the case. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Sunday Mail said criticism of Mr Salmond in Nicola Sturgeon's new memoir had strengthened her resolve. Alex Salmond's widow Moira during the public memorial service for the former first minister in 2024 | PA A family friend told the paper: "Moira is upset and angered by the continued attempts to smear Alex in the book – much of which is ridiculous and inaccurate. It has only strengthened her resolve to make sure that the full truth comes out and that Alex's name is cleared.' They added: 'Her case against the Scottish Government is now live, the legal team is in place, the finance in place and this will be going ahead, no question of that. Alex may not be here to defend himself but his family are determined to stand up to those who continue to attack him. 'There is an adjustment period ongoing until September where updates can be made by either side to their paperwork, it takes time but the ball is rolling. Anyone who thinks this is just going to go away is wrong.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Salmond was in the process of suing the Scottish Government over its botched handling of sexual harassment claims made against him when he died last year. In November 2023, he warned a 'day of reckoning' was coming and named Nicola Sturgeon and ex-permanent secretary Leslie Evans in the case, accusing both of 'misfeasance', or the wrongful exercise of lawful authority. In her memoir, Ms Sturgeon dismissed claims of a 'conspiracy' against her predecessor. 'Right up to the moment he died, Alex was accusing me, and others, or being part of a conspiracy against him,' she wrote. 'He was trying to rewrite history; to supplant the truth with an alternative reality. I cannot let that stand unchallenged.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Salmond was cleared of multiple sexual assault charges following a trial at the High Court in Edinburgh in 2020. He previously won a legal case against the Scottish Government over its handling of complaints against him. However, Ms Sturgeon said a picture had emerged during Mr Salmond's trial 'of behaviour towards women that, on occasion, had been inappropriate', and said she felt 'he would have rather destroyed the SNP than see it succeed without him'. Ms Sturgeon wrote: 'Alex's claims of conspiracy and betrayal were the cries of a man who was not prepared to look honestly at himself in the mirror, and that is why, ultimately, my greatest regret might be for him. He died without reckoning with himself.' Moira, 88, previously spoke out about attacks on her late husband. "Attacks by the living on the dead will seem to many as deeply unfair,' she said in a statement in January. 'My wish, and sincere hope, is that these attacks will now stop.
The Herald Scotland
5 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Moira Salmond resumes legal action over harassment case
Finance for the revived case — which originally sought around £3 million in damages and loss of earnings — has been secured, with wealthy supporters of Mr Salmond understood to be backing the proceedings. READ MORE The case accuses ministers of misfeasance — the wrongful exercise of lawful authority. Before his sudden death from a heart attack in North Macedonia last October, Mr Salmond had warned of a 'day of reckoning'. 'Attacks by the living on the dead will seem to many as deeply unfair.' (Image: PA) A family friend told the Sunday Mail: 'Moira is upset and angered by the continued attempts to smear Alex in the book — much of which is ridiculous and inaccurate. It has only strengthened her resolve to make sure that the full truth comes out and that Alex's name is cleared.' They added: 'Her case against the Scottish Government is now live, the legal team is in place, the finance in place and this will be going ahead, no question of that. Alex may not be here to defend himself but his family are determined to stand up to those who continue to attack him. 'There is an adjustment period ongoing until September where updates can be made by either side to their paperwork. It takes time, but the ball is rolling. Anyone who thinks this is just going to go away is wrong.' Ms Salmond has also previously urged for restraint. 'Attacks by the living on the dead will seem to many as deeply unfair,' she said in January. 'My wish, and sincere hope, is that these attacks will now stop.' The book, in which Ms Sturgeon denies a conspiracy to bring down her predecessor, but paints a damning portrait of him as a bully and a drunk, has prompted angry responses from Mr Salmond's family. His niece, Christina Hendry, branded Frankly "distasteful" and "cruel." She told the Scottish Sun on Sunday: '[Nicola Sturgeon] is using his name for relevance, to promote her book, to earn money — she could have said these things in the past few years. 'She has chosen to wait until he is no longer here to defend himself. It's left to the family to deal with this and there's an element of cowardice to that.' She added: 'My uncle spent his career bigging up Scotland and looking to the future — looking to make change for the better. 'He did not spend his time cashing in on others' legacy or using their name or dragging their name through the dirt.' Ms Hendry added: 'Many people are struggling to understand why she would do this and why she would have such disregard for the family and their feelings. 'Not once have I seen her mention any thought to the family and what they're going through with these headlines about my uncle. 'There's a question of jealousy and bitterness — she was not able to achieve the same and her political career does not have the same legacy as his.' Asked if she believed Ms Sturgeon was cashing in on her infamous fall-out with her uncle, Ms Hendry replied: 'Yes. I can't see any other reason. 'It seems quite a coincidence that the time she is saying this is the time she is selling her book.' Asked if she believed Ms Sturgeon was cashing in on her infamous fall-out with her uncle, Ms Hendry replied: 'Yes. I can't see any other reason. 'It seems quite a coincidence that the time she is saying this is the time she is selling her book.' Ms Hendry said Ms Sturgeon's actions were dissapointing (Image: Supplied) In the memoir, Ms Sturgeon claims Mr Salmond had not read the SNP's 650-page white paper on independence and left her to write much of it alone. She describes her 'cold fury' when he jetted to China, vowing to read the document on the plane, which she believed 'would not survive contact with the first glass of in-flight champagne'. READ MORE She also alleges he was 'implacably opposed' to gay marriage, tolerated rumours of 'consensual affairs' during his marriage, and 'failed to show contrition' for 'inappropriate' behaviour towards women. She suggests he may even have leaked news of the government investigation into him in 2018 to cast himself as a victim — a claim dismissed by his allies. Mr Salmond was acquitted of 13 charges of sexual assault, including attempted rape, at the High Court in 2020. A separate judicial review that year found the Scottish Government's investigation into him had been 'tainted by apparent bias', awarding him more than £500,000 in legal costs. Kenny MacAskill, Mr Salmond's successor as Alba leader, also condemned the memoir, saying: 'What has been published plumbs even lower depths than we ever imagined. Sturgeon has shown she is without honour.'
BBC News
17 hours ago
- BBC News
Treasure hunters stealing from Wales' historical sites
As darkness falls in one corner of Wales, police officers begin their hunt for treasure thieves - a crime that would sound like fantasy if it wasn't for the Gwent Police's patch, the hills are littered with ancient forts and Roman remains - and have become a regular target for those hoping to unearth rare artefacts for the black investigators are left with nothing but a hole in the ground - with little idea of what has been stolen or its value - though some looted treasures have been worth as it is nicknamed, is now seen as a genuine threat to the nation's heritage. PC Dan Counsell had never heard of the term nighthawking before he took a call in September was told locals of an ancient village near Chepstow had awoken to find more than 50 holes mysteriously dug among the gravestones of their churchyard. Residents were horrified and newspaper headlines spoke of "grave robbers."PC Counsell understood the upset - many of his own family members, including grandparents, were buried truth the robbers weren't interested in the dead, but the artefacts that may be buried beyond them, deep into the it became a Christian church about 700 years ago, there were Romans here. Among the holes, some dug on top of the graves themselves, were discarded bits of old metal - a telltale sign that those practising in the "darker underbelly" of metal detecting had been in the archaeological community as nighthawkers, they use the cover of darkness to access sites they have no legal right to disturb in the hope of unearthing do it for the thrill of building their own private collection, others are thought to smuggle items abroad in the hopes of selling them to the highest not uncommon for illicit finds to appear on online auction and police point out this is a small number of people in an otherwise hugely respectful community of metal detectorists. In one of the most recent high-profile cases, two men from south Wales were found guilty of stealing a hoard of Viking gold from Herefordshire worth £3m - most of it has never been PC Counsell's first case in the graveyard, he began looking out for the two years his team had uncovered 23 suspected incidents in the force's patch - a 600 sq mile (1,550 sq km) corner of south-east Wales peppered with imposing castles, ancient hill forts and Roman ruins. Reports of people in fields at night and mysterious holes being discovered has all led PC Counsell's team to uncover cases of said one of the most worrying things was that most targeted Scheduled Monuments - a term used in the UK to describe archaeological areas of great national importance. Cadw, the authority charged with protecting Wales' 4,000-plus protected ancient sites, said it saw 10 to 20 nighthawking incidents each year, but that the nature of it meant was very likely often relies on an eagle-eyed member of the public spotting an unusual hole in the ground and deciding to report it to police, rather than discounting it as the work of a badger or rabbit. Dr Jonathan Berry, Cadw's senior inspector of ancient monuments and archaeology, said sometimes there were innocent explanations, like hobbyists not understanding the rules. Others, however, were motivated by "greed", with elements of organised crime."In terms of where these things go, that's kind of murky, but very often finds are sold on things like online auction houses, antiques centres, things like that," he said."It could also just be private networks, social media. You can find items of significant rarity and value can be out of the country and in other collections very quickly." According to police, often the sites targeted are remote, treacherous even, and reminiscent of an Indiana Jones expedition - minus the booby site PC Counsell takes us to, a series of standing stones, is through dense woodland, up a steep mountain track - even in a 4x4 with a trained police driver it's a hairy think treasure hunters could be making the journey in the pitch-black sounds fanciful and yet this site has fallen victim to nighthawking multiple times."Clearly their remoteness is attractive to potential criminals. They see these sites as being safe in terms of not being disturbed or apprehended."In an attempt to even the odds, the rural crime team has been using thermal imaging cameras attached to drones and binoculars capable of picking out suspected treasure thieves on a pitch-black mountain that helped them catch a suspected nighthawker hiding behind a pile of manure after his footprints on the fresh dung heap shone up on thermal imaging."It's a really hard crime to detect," said PC Counsell."Yet on at least six to eight occasions we've discovered people illegally metal detecting." None of those caught so far have been the ones accessing Wales' legally protected ancient sites, but Gwent Police hopes the frequent night patrols and new technology will get results."The sadness around it all is that these are scheduled ancient monuments for a reason - because they are recognised as being of national historical importance," said PC Counsell."If something is removed that we are unaware of, it could be really important, we just don't know. "Once that item is gone it's gone forever. It's having a big impact on the nation's heritage." When somebody finds something that could be treasure, they have a legal obligation to declare are not allowed to keep it, but if they followed the rules and unearthed it from land they had permission to be on - then they will be paid a share of its value once it's bought by a sees experts such as Sian Iles, a curator at the National Museum of Wales, brought in to give their verdict on whether any potential item meets the threshold for are several steps, but loosely speaking an item should be "old and gold".In Wales the general threshold is more than 300 years old and made up of at least 10% precious metal."Every treasure find helps us to build a picture about the decisions people in Wales were making in that time period, about their fashions or their beliefs," said Ms Iles. The senior curator of Medieval and later archaeology said the number of finds being declared to the National Museum had been going up year-on-year since Iles and her colleagues assess about 70 potential pieces of treasure each year and believe the vast majority of metal detectorists are doing the right thing and wanted their finds to be used to help recently helped assess a silver thimble found in a field in Flintshire by metal detectorists which was then declared added: "Even the smallest object can really bring in important information about people in the past."
