Health NZ apologises: Whangārei Hospital patient starved 16 hours a day for six days waiting for surgery
Over the next few days, it became more painful, making walking difficult.
On June 9, Emsley's GP thought she had gout and prescribed a steroid treatment.
Despite the steroids, she felt very unwell and, the next morning, was so mumbled and confused when talking to her daughter on the phone, her daughter called an ambulance.
Emsley was rushed to Whangārei Hospital with low blood pressure, difficulty breathing, a high temperature and confusion. It took all day for her to be stabilised with intravenous fluids, antibiotics and pain killers.
'My toe was pulsating with pain - it was like a red hot poker and I was almost screaming in pain.'
Heather Emsley, 66, is still batting the infection in her toe and believes the delay for surgery prolonged her recovery. Photo / Denise Piper
Once stabilised, Emsley was admitted to a ward, where doctors began trying to diagnose her illness, including her being prepared on and off for surgery.
An ultrasound eventually identified a problematic pin, inserted into her toe about 25 years ago as a treatment for her rheumatoid arthritis.
'Somewhere along the line, bacteria decided to hone in on that one pin and cause a major infection, which then went through my body.'
A specialist decided Emsley needed surgery to remove the pin and debridement of the wound to clear the infection.
The wait for surgery meant she was unable to eat or drink anything from 2am until about 6pm, however, her operation did not proceed.
This happened for six consecutive days, causing Emsley stress and emotional strain.
Emsley said her situation highlighted the hospital's staff shortage, and poor communication between the theatre and her ward.
Despite breaking down in tears one day, it was another day before Emsley got her surgery, about 7.45pm on June 22.
She was later told she should have had surgery within 24 hours, not the 140 hours she waited.
'It wasn't the right process - it was cruel and, from my point of view, Third World. It's just not something you expect from a modern hospital.'
Emsley's fight against her infection continued after her surgery, including on-going intravenous antibiotics and wound treatment.
She was discharged from hospital on July 2 but still walks with a moonboot and walking stick.
Health NZ Te Tai Tokerau group director of operations Alex Pimm says some patients expecting surgery need to be deferred for more urgent cases. Photo / Denise Piper
Emsley and her daughter made formal complaints about her treatment, in the hope no other patient would have to go through the same torturous wait.
'I would like to see that no other patient goes through what I went through, in terms of having to wait so long and having to be starved, basically, for that length of time.'
Emsley received a six-page response, with Health NZ apologising for her treatment and outlining plans for improvement. It confirmed someone in her category should have surgery within six to 24 hours.
'It sounds like, by us complaining, it helped them look into what's wrong,' she said.
Alex Pimm told the Northern Advocate: 'We have empathy for Ms Emsley on her health journey and are sorry for her experience at Whangārei Hospital'.
However, Pimm said the acute theatre list is prioritised based on patient need and clinical urgency.
'Unfortunately, this means that on occasion some patients who were expecting surgery are deferred to enable somebody with a more urgent condition to receive treatment.'
Pimm did not answer questions about whether strike action also caused delays, instead encouraging patients to talk with the hospital directly if they have any questions or concerns.
Denise Piper is a news reporter for the Northern Advocate, focusing on health and business. She has more than 20 years in journalism and is passionate about covering stories that make a difference.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
More help needed to tackle dengue
Acting Director of Health, Tagaloa Dr Robert Thomsen, says the number of dengue cases is likely to peak in the next three weeks before easing off.
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Health NZ scrambles for parking at Whangārei Hospital as complaints soar
Patients, visitors and staff have to drive around and around the Whangārei Hospital campus to get a park, resulting in a spike in complaints. Photo / Denise Piper Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. Patients, visitors and staff have to drive around and around the Whangārei Hospital campus to get a park, resulting in a spike in complaints. Photo / Denise Piper A year's worth of complaints about the lack of car parking at Whangārei Hospital was received by Health New Zealand Te Whatu Ora in just one month, as tensions rise about the lack of available spaces. Now Health NZ is scrambling to get new parks in place before more construction starts on the hospital rebuild, fearing more patients will miss appointments and staff morale will drop if it does nothing. In May, the Northern Advocate highlighted how patients were missing appointments and staff were having to arrive hours before their shifts, because of the parking problems. While demand for parking at the hospital has always been high, work on the $35 million child health unit, Tira Ora, has exacerbated the problem by removing 123 parks. Now information released under the Official Information Act shows how the lack of parking is having an impact, with complaints soaring in 2025.
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Wood smoke, traffic fumes polluting Christchurch's air
Professor Simon Hales (left) says much of Christchurch's air pollution problem, particularly in winter, can be traced back to home heating. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Recently the air quality in parts of Canterbury has been rated 'unhealthy' using the air quality index (AQI), which measures high levels of particulate matter in the air. But what does poor air quality actually mean for our health? University of Otago environmental epidemiologist Professor Simon Hales told RNZ's Nights the source of the pollution, particularly in winter, is generally home heating. "The reason why it's a problem in winter is because in Christchurch there is a kind of, the city is somewhat bowl-shaped with the Port Hills on one side, and there tends to be sort of a very calm night with the temperature inversion, which is a bit like having a lid on the city. So all the smoke that comes out of people's chimneys is trapped, and that's what leads to the very high level." Hales said Christchurch's air quality had improved since he lived there 30 years ago, but still needed to improve further. "The World Health Organization (WHO) has a guideline level for the daily level of PM2.5 fine particle pollution, and that's 15 micrograms per cubic metre," he said. "About 15 percent of the days over the past five years have been over that guideline level. And in the last three months, about 43 days." That means, in the last three months, Christchurch's air has had over the WHO-recommended daily level of particle matter in its air about 47 percent of the time. "There is also an annual guideline which is five micrograms per cubic meter. And in fact the annual average PM 2.5 in Christchurch has been about nine micrograms per cubic meter, so nearly double the WHO guidelines," Hales said. While polluted air was unlikely to noticeably affect young and fit people, those with chronic diseases, particularly heart and lung related, might notice their symptoms getting worse temporarily. However, the short-term effects were only part of health impact, he said. "Over weeks and months of exposure, it's making people who are currently healthy gradually less healthy. So it's actually inducing disease or worsening disease in people who otherwise would would have been healthy. And this relates particularly to heart disease and lung disease, but there's an increasing number of different diseases that we're realising are related to air pollution exposure." And it's not just woodsmoke leading to the poor air quality. Nitrogen dioxide, which comes mainly from road traffic, is also a big issue, Hales said. "In fact, we recently did a study which suggested that the N-O-2 was actually more of a problem in terms of its overall health impact, causing over 2000 premature deaths per year." The same study, published in 2021, revealed about 1000 deaths relating to particles mainly from home heating. The main solution was to switch to cleaner fuels, Hales said. That should not be a problem for a wealthy country like New Zealand, which had abundant hydropower resources, he said. A similar shift was needed in regards to transport. "We need to change the modes by which we get about mostly. "We still use personal cars, mostly fossil fuel-powered cars, and we need to switch both to clean vehicles, EVs for example, but also we need to switch the mode so that people are not relying so much on personal cars, but also using public transport and active transport, so walking and cycling." New Zealand had mixed results when it came to the WHO's guidelines, Hales said. "If you look in global terms, then New Zealand is doing pretty well. We're not meeting all of the guidelines all of the time, but we are getting close and in many places we do meet the guidelines for most of the time, so that's something that many countries can't say. "On the other hand, I think we need to be doing more. We need to have more incentives for the kind of policies that I was suggesting before." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
