How much longer will the EU aid and abet torture?
I recently returned from a mission aboard the Ocean Viking, where I witnessed both the best and the worst of humanity.
Throughout four rescue operations in the central Mediterranean, we brought a total of 563 people to safety — people who, just days earlier, were enduring unimaginable horrors in Libya.
Their stories are not just heartbreaking — they are a damning indictment of a system built on cruelty, one that Europe has knowingly helped sustain.
Once rescued aboard the Ocean Viking, the visible shock and trauma that the migrants have been through are plain to see. Pictures: Fellipe Lopes
This is not new information. For years, Libya has been a waypoint for those fleeing war, poverty, or persecution, hoping to reach Europe. They arrive with dreams of freedom, but most are instead funnelled into a violent underworld of exploitation.
Entire criminal networks profit from the suffering of their victims. What's more appalling is that some of these perpetrators operate within or alongside state-sanctioned forces.
Listening to the survivors, one thing becomes crystal clear: what's happening in Libya is not a lawless fluke — it is an
Armed groups coerce them into calling their families to demand ransom, offering the simplest and cruellest ultimatum: 'No money, no freedom.'
The reality? Libya is not a safe place for people on the move. It is a place where human rights violations are committed in broad daylight: arbitrary detention, murder, rape, and enslavement.
The United Nations has already acknowledged as much in its 2018 report, 'Abuse Behind Bars', which documented systemic violence and slavery.
Still, the world — especially Europe — has done little to intervene.
Once in Libya, migrants are often captured by militias or organised groups who extort them, torture them, and force them to work under conditions of slavery. Furthermore, Libya faces accusations of crimes against humanity committed by security forces and armed militia groups.
The cruelty and brutality endured by thousands of people is staggering. Once rescued aboard the organisation's vessel, the visible shock and trauma etched on the survivors' faces speak volumes about what they've been through.
As a photojournalist, my aim is to build a genuine connection, offering a safe, respectful space where their stories can be shared and heard.
Over seven weeks onboard Ocean Viking, I keep asking myself the same question: how many more will need to die at sea or continue to be tortured in Libya for the European Union to do something about it?
EU money funding brutal system
Instead of working to dismantle this brutal system, the European Union continues to feed it. EU money trains and equips the Libyan Coast Guard, which intercepts migrant boats and returns people to the very conditions they fled.
'Lamunn' (who asked to use a pseudonym) says he tried several times to apply for visas in Germany, the Netherlands, and Italy, but he never received a response. Lamunn said not only was he forced to watch people being raped while in Libya, but he was also the subject of sexual abuse on several occasions.
One afternoon, after three days without drinking water, he asked for some water. However, because he didn't speak the local language, he was beaten. Lamunn used the word trauma to describe that time in Libya: "I would rather die at sea than spend another day in Libya."
Since 2014, more than 31,000 people have drowned in the Mediterranean — the deadliest sea migration route on Earth. Civilian rescue ships like the Ocean Viking are trying to fill the gap left by Europe's retreat from moral responsibility. But rather than support these life-saving missions, many are criminalised, blocked, or smeared.
This system thrives on our silence, and it's time that ended. Europe cannot claim to stand for human rights while directly funding the machinery of human suffering. We have the means to change this — to end the deals that empower abusers, to support safe migration routes, and to treat people fleeing danger with dignity and respect.
Rebecca, SOS Méditerranée medical team leader says: ''Part of my role onboard is not only to provide survivors with medical care but also to support them psychologically, whether it is through basic psychological first aid or through linking them to organisations on land more qualified to do the extensive support that is so often needed.
To see people withdraw into their minds, disassociating with the world around, as the only refuge they have left, is devastating. We do what we can whilst they are with us, if only to show that there is still kindness and a gentle touch.
"Over the past four years working onboard, I have witnessed countless survivors of the brutal conditions that are so prolific in Libya and along the migration pathways. The scars are not only present on the body, with unhealed wounds, extensive scarring, burns and other signs of torture, but also evident in the mind."
According to a United Nations report: 'Abuse Behind Bars: Arbitrary and Unlawful Detention in Libya' published in April 2018, there is systematic violence, slavery and sexual abuses towards migrants in Libya.
"Armed groups in Libya, including those affiliated with the state, hold thousands of people in prolonged arbitrary and unlawful detention, and submit them to torture and other human rights violations and abuses.''
The survivors aboard the Ocean Viking are not statistics. They are mothers, sons, daughters, and dreamers. And the only reason many of them are alive today is because civilians refused to look away.
This all system is designed to profit from people's lives, and its structural chain is located in several countries. In Libya, the authorities turn a blind eye to the systematic abuse of human rights. The European Union continues to fund the Libyan government and its actions to stop migration.
At sea, the EU funds and provides training for the Libyan Coast Guard, which has been accused numerous times of violent practices, obstructing search and rescue operations and bringing people on the move back to Libya to be placed in detention centres, restarting the cycle of abuse.
The question is: how much longer will Europe continue to do just that?
SOS Méditerranée is an international maritime and humanitarian organisation dedicated to saving lives at sea. It operates as a European network, with teams in Germany, France, Italy, and Switzerland. It is currently financing and operating the mission with the Ocean Viking, the search and rescue ship operating in the Central Mediterranean. Since 2016, SOS Méditerranée has assisted a total of 42,052 people at sea.
Fellipe Lopes is communications coordinator at SOS Méditerranée.
Read More
The Mick Clifford Podcast: Fintan Drury on the forgotten people of Gaza
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
an hour ago
- Agriland
12 EU member states want animal-sourced food names protected
12 EU member states have supported a call for the European Commission to introduce protections on traditional animal-sourced food names so they cannot be used on plant-based food labels. The delegation from the Czech Republic presented a paper on the issue at a meeting of agriculture ministers in the Council of the EU this week. The Czech paper was supported by 11 other member states, including Ireland. The document said that the food market in the EU is increasingly composed of products that consist only of plant-based ingredients and are similar in appearance, taste and consistency to products of animal origin. These plant-based foods are very often labelled with the names belonging to meat, eggs, honey, fish, and products made from them. However, the paper said that plant-based products differ substantially from food products of animal origin, particularly in terms of composition and nutritional value. The Czech submission said that it is 'essential' that foods which imitate, mimic or substitute foods of animal origin do not mislead the consumer by their labelling as to their true nature. Protection of names is already in place for products for the dairy sector. However, no other protection of food names is in place at EU level for other animal-sourced products, and some member states are considering the introduction of reserved names for other food of animal origin at national level. The member states involved in the paper are calling for 'harmonisation of legal protection' to be provided on food names. They are seeking a legislative proposal from the commission to protect the names of animal origin, providing them with similar protection that already exists for milk and dairy products. The pressure on the commission to protect names of animal-sourced food has been welcomed by the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association (ICMSA). ICMSA president Denis Drennan claimed that the inclusion of terms such a 'sausage' or 'burger' in vegetarian or vegan foods 'was deliberate and cynical'. He said that the 'hijakcing' of traditional meat and dairy terms 'actually constitutes an admissions by the corporations involved that they were unable to convince consumers other than by such camouflage'. 'Obviously, people are free to eat whatever they want but it is a matter of considerable irritation to farmers to see the very people and corporations who want to replace our naturally produced meat and dairy with their own non-meat and non-dairy products very deliberately using the terms that they know are generally understood to refer to traditional dairy and meat products,' Drennan said. 'They want to use our terminology and the acceptance borne of centuries that those terms have amongst the general public to effectively smuggle their own products past a sceptical public.' The ICMSA president said it is 'no longer tenable to allow non-dairy and non-meat products to advertise and promote themselves using terms and language associated with the traditional foods these vegetarian and vegan products are attempting to supplant'. 'It's self-evidently wrong that products that contain not a trace of meat are being sold as 'sausage' or 'burger' and being marketed in this disingenuous way. These corporations…are quite deliberately playing on people's desire for healthy, traditional, meat-based foodstuffs while actually substituting real meal ingredients with cheaper and more processed vegetable and plant-derived elements,' Drennan said.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Unbelievably cynical': farmers accuse vegan food producers of ‘hijacking' sausage and burger labels
Irish farmers have welcomed tentative moves by the European Parliament to restrict 'cynical' vegetarian and vegan food producers from using words such as sausage, burger and schnitzel to sell their products. The European Commission is drafting new rules covering EU-wide agriculture and MEPs are using the overhaul to lobby for changes to how vegetarian and vegan products are sold to customers. The 'hijacking' of traditional farming terms was 'deliberate and cynical' and could constitute 'a breach of any trade descriptions Act', said Irish Creamery and Milk Supplier's Association (ICMSA) president Denis Drennan. French MEP Céline Imart is proposing an amendment banning plant-based products being labelled with a long list of terms linked to animal products. READ MORE It is the latest salvo in the long-running battle involving farmers, their representatives, the commission and vegetarian food producers. The differing perspectives have also been aired at the European Court of Justice, which has ruled that plant-based foods can use terms traditionally associated with meat once consumers are not misled. [ Flip Burger takeaway review: are these the best veggie burgers in Dublin? Opens in new window ] The court has also ruled that non-dairy products cannot be described as milk and cheese. Farmers have continued to fight for the naming rights to certain products. Mr Drennan said the 'hijacking' of farming terms 'constituted an admission by the corporations involved that they were unable to convince consumers other than by such camouflage'. He said it was 'a matter of considerable irritation to farmers to see the very people and corporations who want to replace our naturally produced meat and dairy very deliberately using the terms they know are generally understood to refer to traditional dairy and meat products'. Oisín Coughlan, climate policy analyst and former chief executive of Friends of the Earth, expressed bafflement at the ICMSA's comments restricting vegan food producers from using words such as sausage or burger, and said any such move would be 'a step too far'. [ What's really in veggie burgers? Well, they aren't always made of veg Opens in new window ] 'Everyone knows that vegetarian sausages don't come from pigs and I don't see how a vegan sausage or veggie burger is damaging meat producers,' he said. 'It just communicates that if you don't want to eat meat there are equivalents available, and that seems fair to me.' Mr Drennan accused vegan food producers of wilfully trying 'to effectively 'smuggle' their own products past a sceptical public'. He suggested that plant-based food producers use terms such as sausage, burger and milk 'because they know that those terms already have a degree of acceptance'. [ The Irish Times view on food labelling: defending the sausage Opens in new window ] He claimed food producers 'simply appropriate the names of the very foods they're trying to replace and supplant'. 'It's unbelievably cynical and actually an admission that they know that they're unable to convince consumers by their own efforts or merits,' he said.
Irish Examiner
8 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
How much longer will the EU aid and abet torture?
I recently returned from a mission aboard the Ocean Viking, where I witnessed both the best and the worst of humanity. Throughout four rescue operations in the central Mediterranean, we brought a total of 563 people to safety — people who, just days earlier, were enduring unimaginable horrors in Libya. Their stories are not just heartbreaking — they are a damning indictment of a system built on cruelty, one that Europe has knowingly helped sustain. Once rescued aboard the Ocean Viking, the visible shock and trauma that the migrants have been through are plain to see. Pictures: Fellipe Lopes This is not new information. For years, Libya has been a waypoint for those fleeing war, poverty, or persecution, hoping to reach Europe. They arrive with dreams of freedom, but most are instead funnelled into a violent underworld of exploitation. Entire criminal networks profit from the suffering of their victims. What's more appalling is that some of these perpetrators operate within or alongside state-sanctioned forces. Listening to the survivors, one thing becomes crystal clear: what's happening in Libya is not a lawless fluke — it is an Armed groups coerce them into calling their families to demand ransom, offering the simplest and cruellest ultimatum: 'No money, no freedom.' The reality? Libya is not a safe place for people on the move. It is a place where human rights violations are committed in broad daylight: arbitrary detention, murder, rape, and enslavement. The United Nations has already acknowledged as much in its 2018 report, 'Abuse Behind Bars', which documented systemic violence and slavery. Still, the world — especially Europe — has done little to intervene. Once in Libya, migrants are often captured by militias or organised groups who extort them, torture them, and force them to work under conditions of slavery. Furthermore, Libya faces accusations of crimes against humanity committed by security forces and armed militia groups. The cruelty and brutality endured by thousands of people is staggering. Once rescued aboard the organisation's vessel, the visible shock and trauma etched on the survivors' faces speak volumes about what they've been through. As a photojournalist, my aim is to build a genuine connection, offering a safe, respectful space where their stories can be shared and heard. Over seven weeks onboard Ocean Viking, I keep asking myself the same question: how many more will need to die at sea or continue to be tortured in Libya for the European Union to do something about it? EU money funding brutal system Instead of working to dismantle this brutal system, the European Union continues to feed it. EU money trains and equips the Libyan Coast Guard, which intercepts migrant boats and returns people to the very conditions they fled. 'Lamunn' (who asked to use a pseudonym) says he tried several times to apply for visas in Germany, the Netherlands, and Italy, but he never received a response. Lamunn said not only was he forced to watch people being raped while in Libya, but he was also the subject of sexual abuse on several occasions. One afternoon, after three days without drinking water, he asked for some water. However, because he didn't speak the local language, he was beaten. Lamunn used the word trauma to describe that time in Libya: "I would rather die at sea than spend another day in Libya." Since 2014, more than 31,000 people have drowned in the Mediterranean — the deadliest sea migration route on Earth. Civilian rescue ships like the Ocean Viking are trying to fill the gap left by Europe's retreat from moral responsibility. But rather than support these life-saving missions, many are criminalised, blocked, or smeared. This system thrives on our silence, and it's time that ended. Europe cannot claim to stand for human rights while directly funding the machinery of human suffering. We have the means to change this — to end the deals that empower abusers, to support safe migration routes, and to treat people fleeing danger with dignity and respect. Rebecca, SOS Méditerranée medical team leader says: ''Part of my role onboard is not only to provide survivors with medical care but also to support them psychologically, whether it is through basic psychological first aid or through linking them to organisations on land more qualified to do the extensive support that is so often needed. To see people withdraw into their minds, disassociating with the world around, as the only refuge they have left, is devastating. We do what we can whilst they are with us, if only to show that there is still kindness and a gentle touch. "Over the past four years working onboard, I have witnessed countless survivors of the brutal conditions that are so prolific in Libya and along the migration pathways. The scars are not only present on the body, with unhealed wounds, extensive scarring, burns and other signs of torture, but also evident in the mind." According to a United Nations report: 'Abuse Behind Bars: Arbitrary and Unlawful Detention in Libya' published in April 2018, there is systematic violence, slavery and sexual abuses towards migrants in Libya. "Armed groups in Libya, including those affiliated with the state, hold thousands of people in prolonged arbitrary and unlawful detention, and submit them to torture and other human rights violations and abuses.'' The survivors aboard the Ocean Viking are not statistics. They are mothers, sons, daughters, and dreamers. And the only reason many of them are alive today is because civilians refused to look away. This all system is designed to profit from people's lives, and its structural chain is located in several countries. In Libya, the authorities turn a blind eye to the systematic abuse of human rights. The European Union continues to fund the Libyan government and its actions to stop migration. At sea, the EU funds and provides training for the Libyan Coast Guard, which has been accused numerous times of violent practices, obstructing search and rescue operations and bringing people on the move back to Libya to be placed in detention centres, restarting the cycle of abuse. The question is: how much longer will Europe continue to do just that? SOS Méditerranée is an international maritime and humanitarian organisation dedicated to saving lives at sea. It operates as a European network, with teams in Germany, France, Italy, and Switzerland. It is currently financing and operating the mission with the Ocean Viking, the search and rescue ship operating in the Central Mediterranean. Since 2016, SOS Méditerranée has assisted a total of 42,052 people at sea. Fellipe Lopes is communications coordinator at SOS Méditerranée. Read More The Mick Clifford Podcast: Fintan Drury on the forgotten people of Gaza
