Music teacher who rejected transgender students' chosen names can sue Indiana school
The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the Brownsburg school district near Indianapolis did not show that letting John Kluge refer to the students only by last name impeded its mission to create a safe and inclusive learning environment.
Tuesday's 2-1 decision by the Chicago-based appeals court reversed an April 2024 ruling by an Indianapolis trial judge, and returned the case to her. The appeals court ruled against Kluge in an earlier stage of the case in 2023.
Lawyers for the school district did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Kluge said his Christian religious beliefs barred him from using students' preferred names and pronouns.
Brownsburg High School at first let him use last names, "like a sports coach" as he put it.
But it stopped after students and other faculty complained, and told Kluge to use first names or be fired.
Kluge decided to resign, and sued under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits workplace discrimination based on religion or religious practices.
Writing for Tuesday's majority, Circuit Judge Michael Brennan cited a 2023 U.S. Supreme Court decision that broadened workplace protections for religious workers.
Brennan said Brownsburg did not show that Kluge subjected transgender students to "increased stigmatization" solely by using last names, or that doing so caused emotional distress and imposed an undue hardship on its educational mission.
"Brownsburg has not carried its burden to show undisputed facts of a serious disruption to the learning environment," wrote Brennan, who was appointed to the bench by Republican President Donald Trump.
Circuit Judge Ilana Rovner, an appointee of former Republican President George H.W. Bush, dissented, saying the school "did what it could" to accommodate Kluge's religious beliefs, rescinding the accommodation only when it proved harmful.
She also accused the majority of improperly making jurors a "super-personnel department" that could second-guess employers' good-faith decision making.
Kluge was represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian legal group.
ADF senior legal counsel David Cortman said he looked forward to proving at trial that Brownsburg discriminated against Kluge by deciding his religious views "couldn't be tolerated."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
a minute ago
- The Independent
FEMA abruptly disbands youth advisory council, but students say their climate advocacy won't stop
After a few frightening incidents seeing family and friends collapse in Phoenix 's grueling heat, Ashton Dolce, 17, began to wonder why his country's leaders were not doing more to keep people safe from climate change. 'I was just dumbfounded," Dolce said. He became active in his hometown, organizing rallies and petitions to raise awareness about extreme heat and calling for the Federal Emergency Management Agency to make such conditions eligible for major disaster declarations. Just before his senior year of high school in 2024, Dolce got the chance to really make his concerns heard: He became one of 15 students across the United States selected to join the FEMA Youth Preparedness Council, a 13-year-old program for young people to learn about and become ambassadors for disaster preparedness. 'It was this really cool opportunity to get involved with FEMA and to actually have a specified seat at the table where we could develop resources by and for youth,' Dolce said. Then came signs of trouble. On Jan. 16, the young people were told by email that a culminating summit in the nation's capital this summer was canceled. By February, the students stopped hearing from their advisers. Meetings ceased. After months of silence, the students got an email Aug. 1 saying the program would be terminated early. 'We were putting so much time and effort into this space," he said, "and now it's fully gutted.' FEMA took action to ensure it was 'lean' In an email to students reviewed by The Associated Press, the agency said the move was intended "to ensure FEMA is a lean, deployable disaster force that is ready to support states as they take the lead in preparedness and disaster response.' The council's dissolution, though dwarfed in size by other cuts, reflects the fallout from the chaotic changes at the agency charged with managing the federal response to disasters. Since the start of Republican President Donald Trump 's second term, his administration has reduced FEMA staff by thousands, delayed crucial emergency trainings, discontinued certain survivor outreach efforts and canceled programs worth billions of dollars. Dolce said ignoring students undermines resilience, too. 'This field needs young people and we are pushing young people out,' he said. "The administration is basically just giving young people the middle finger on climate change.' Larger federal programs related to youth and climate are also in turmoil. In April, the administration slashed funding to AmeriCorps, the 30-year-old federal agency for volunteer service. As a result, 2,000 members of the National Civilian Community Corps, who commonly aid in disaster recovery, left their program early. FEMA did not respond to questions about why it shut down the youth council. In an email bulletin last week, the agency said it would not recruit 'until further notice.' The council was created for students in grades 8 to 11 to 'bring together young leaders who are interested in supporting disaster preparedness and making a difference in their communities,' according to FEMA's website. Disinvesting in youth training could undermine efforts to prepare and respond to more frequent and severe climate disasters, said Chris Reynolds, a retired lieutenant colonel and emergency preparedness liaison officer in the U.S. Air Force. 'It's a missed opportunity for the talent pipeline,' said Reynolds, now vice president and dean of academic outreach at American Public University System. 'I'm 45-plus years as an emergency manager in my field. Where's that next cadre going to come from?' Some speak of a trickle-down effect The administration's goal of diminishing the federal role in disaster response and putting more responsibility on states to handle disaster response and recovery could mean local communities need even more expertise in emergency management. 'You eliminate the participation of not just your next generation of emergency managers, but your next generation of community leaders, which I think is just a terrible mistake,' said Monica Sanders, professor in Georgetown University's Emergency and Disaster Management Program and its Law Center. Sanders said young people had as much knowledge to share with FEMA as the agency did with them. 'In a lot of cultures, young people do the preparedness work, the organizing of mutual aid, online campaigning, reuniting and finding people in ways that traditional emergency management just isn't able to do,' she said. 'For FEMA to lose access to that knowledge base is just really unfortunate.' Sughan Sriganesh, a rising high school senior from Syosset, New York, said he joined the council to further his work on resilience and climate literacy in schools. 'I thought it was a way that I could amplify the issues that I was passionate about," he said. Sriganesh said he got a lot out of the program while it lasted. He and Dolce were in the same small group working on a community project to disseminate preparedness resources to farmers. They created a pamphlet with information on what to do before and after a disaster. Even after FEMA staff stopped reaching out, Sriganesh and some of his peers kept meeting. They decided to finish the project and are seeking ways to distribute their pamphlet themselves. 'It's a testament to why we were chosen in the first place as youth preparedness members," Sriganesh said. "We were able to adapt and be resilient no matter what was going on.'
The Independent
a minute ago
- The Independent
Trump's approval ratings drop with Republicans as he deals with Epstein fallout and tariff concerns
President Donald Trump's approval ratings with Republicans have dropped as he handles fallout from the so-called 'Epstein Files', and concerns about rising prices linked to his global tariffs. A new poll this week, from YouGov and The Economist, revealed 13 percent of Republicans disapproved of the president, with 83 percent approving. The poll was conducted among 1,577 adults across the U.S. This number had increased from May when a similar poll found that 9 percent of that group disapproved of the president. A YouGov/Economist poll, taken on January 26- 28, days after Trump returned to the White House, revealed only a 5 percent disapproval rate among right-leaning Americans. The president's slowly but surely declining approval rating, even among his own supporters, may indicate that his loyal MAGA base is faltering. Specifically, Trump's approval rating with right-leaning Americans has declined on issues including personal trust and the economy. In June, inflation rose to 2.7 percent. Job growth slowed down last month with just 73,000 jobs added to the economy, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The unemployment rate rose to 4.2 percent, but remains historically low. Trump fired head of the bureau, Erika McEntarfer, after the surprisingly weak jobs report, claiming without evidence that the numbers had been rigged. On Monday, he appointed conservative economist E.J. Antoni to the role. The president is seeing inflation rise even as he promised that it would end on the first day of his second stint in the White House. "Starting on day one, we will end inflation and make America affordable again, to bring down the prices of all goods," he said at an election rally last August. Trump's sagging approval rating among his own supporters also comes amid concerns about his tariff policy. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick predicted that monthly revenue would reach $50 billion due to the new taxes on imports - however, JP Morgan warned that the costs will ultimately be passed onto consumers in the form of higher prices. Trump's economic approval rating with Republicans dropped from 90 percent in January to 79 percent this month. When it comes to inflation, his approval rating went from 84 percent to 72 percent. While the vast majority of Republicans and right-leaning Americans still support the president, the polling trends indicate that economic worries may be eating into that support. Voters' views on Trump's trustworthiness also took a hit. Between the January poll and the latest survey, Republicans who think the president is untrustworthy went from 7 to 14 percent. One major issue that has caused ruptures in the MAGA base is the Trump administration's handling of the investigation into deceased sex offender, Jeffrey Epstein. Many conservatives, along with Democrats, were outraged by a July 6 memo from the Department of Justice and FBI which concluded that Epstein died by suicide and that there was no 'client list' of high-profile figures involved in his alleged sex trafficking scheme. Attorney General Pam Bondi had earlier insinuated there was a client list sitting on her desk, and that much more information was to be revealed in the investigation. Trump reacted to the uproar by telling his supporters to move on from Epstein. In the weeks following the DOJ memo, the Wall Street Journal published a bombshell story about Trump sending Epstein, his onetime friend, a 'bawdy' birthday sketch in 2003 which reportedly read: 'Happy Birthday — and may every day be another wonderful secret.' The president denied creating the card, and filed a $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the WSJ and its owner Rupert Murdoch. Subsequent reporting also revealed that Trump was informed by Bondi in May that his name appeared in the Epstein files, along with many other high-profile people. Last month Trump denied Bondi had told him that he appears in the Epstein files. The president has never been formally accused or charged with a crime in connection with Epstein. And the issue is unlikely to disappear. Representatives Ro Khanna, a California Democrat, and Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican, are planning to bring Epstein survivors to the Capitol for a press conference on September 3 when the House returns from recess.
Daily Mail
2 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Gavin Newsom channels his best inner Trump with theatrical parody that RALLIES demoralized Democrats
California Gov. Gavin Newsom is being celebrated by leaderless Democrats after adopting Donald Trump 's unique social media style to mock the president. Newsom announced on Tuesday that California would redraw its congressional districts after Trump ignored the governor's letter urging him to call off redistricting in red states. 'DONALD 'TACO' TRUMP, AS MANY CALL HIM, 'MISSED' THE DEADLINE!!! CALIFORNIA WILL NOW DRAW NEW, MORE 'BEAUTIFUL MAPS,' THEY WILL BE HISTORIC AS THEY WILL END THE TRUMP PRESIDENCY (DEMS TAKE BACK THE HOUSE!),' wrote Newsom's press office on X. The post is meant to mimic the unique cadence and colorful language Trump uses to write his messages on Truth Social in blaring all-caps font. 'BIG PRESS CONFERENCE THIS WEEK WITH POWERFUL DEMS AND GAVIN NEWSOM — YOUR FAVORITE GOVERNOR — THAT WILL BE DEVASTATING FOR 'MAGA.' THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER! — GN.' Newsom wrote a letter to Trump on Monday demanding Trump order GOP-dominated states, including Texas, halt their efforts to redraw congressional districts. The governor told Trump he's 'playing with fire' before promising 'California can neutralize any gains you hope to make.' Newsom's office gave Trump until Tuesday evening to respond to the letter. The crude-Trumpian all-caps language of the tweet invoked celebration from Democrats who have been leaderless and searching for a fighter following their 2024 election drubbing. 'Love him or hate him, you've got to admit he's the fiercest fighter right now,' wrote X user @ML3democrats in a tweet that received over 57,000 likes. 'He terrifies Trump.' 'Gavin Newsom is so good at this,' Majid M. Padellan told his 1.3 million followers on X while attaching a screenshot of Newsom's tweet. Popular Democratic activist Brian Krassenstein praised Newsom on X, stating, 'Holy CRAP. Gavin Newsom is good at this game!' 'HA: Gavin Newsom just announced, in a way MAGA will understand, that California is moving forward with redrawing their maps after Trump failed to meet the deadline to stand down,' Harry Sisson commented. 'Go for it, Newsom!' Ahead of the 2026 midterm elections, Trump and Republican congressional leadership are urging several Republican-led states to redraw their districts to help create more opportunities for the GOP. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott responded earlier this week to Newsom's threats to neutralize any Republican gains. The Texas leader vowed to remove up to 10 of the 12 Democratic seats in the Lone Star State. Meanwhile, Democratic Texas lawmakers have fled to Illinois and New York to block a quorum over a vote for redistricting. If California moves forward with mid-decade redistricting, Newsom has promised to eliminate up to five GOP-held seats.
