Starmer's pledge on Palestinian state ‘grotesque,' says campaign group
Keir Starmer pledged to recognize a Palestinian state in September if Israel fails to reach a ceasefire with Hamas, among other conditions.
Placing the Palestinian right to self-determination 'within the context of Israel's actions' is 'shameful,' the PSC said in a statement, adding that it is an 'inalienable right' that should be recognized regardless of Israel's conduct.
Starmer's apparent shift, which followed in French President Emmanuel Macron's footsteps, 'came in part because of intense pressure from the British public, expressed in the huge protest movement that has persevered over many months,' the PSC said.
Since the beginning of the Gaza war in October 2023, the PSC and a host of other campaign groups have led regular protest marches through British cities.
The protests have swelled in size amid mounting public anger over Israel's conduct in Gaza, as well as the UK government's perceived reluctance to take action against it.
Protesters have focused on British ties to Israel and its military, waging boycott campaigns against companies with ties to the Israel Defense Forces.
'Every British MP and government official is also aware of the fact that British-exported weapons are being used by the Israeli military in its brutality against Palestinian civilians and complete devastation of the Gaza Strip's infrastructure,' the PSC said.
'British politicians are now bemoaning the images of horror, but continuing to act as partners in Israel's genocide by maintaining trade with Israel, including in weapons and other military items, and by implementing limited sanctions on a few individual ministers, as though Israel's genocide is being engineered and carried out by a 'few bad apples.''
The PSC condemned Starmer's move this week as 'grotesque,' and one that tells Palestinians: 'State recognition may come, but only if and when many, many more of you are dead.'
Rather than representing a turning point, his decision is 'simply more of the same,' the PSC said, describing the pledge as having been 'added to the package of collusion and complicity with genocide.'
It called on the government to take immediate steps and 'everything in their power' to secure an unconditional ceasefire in Gaza. The UK must also place a comprehensive weapons embargo on Israel, the PSC demanded.
'Keir Starmer claims support for the Palestinian right to self-determination while ensuring that Israel has all the means it needs to eradicate the Palestinian people and annex their land,' it said.
'The British public will not be fooled into holding out hope for the possibility of a symbolic gesture granted by the British government in September.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
15 minutes ago
- Arab News
Why the delay in judging Israeli war crimes?
The Israeli human rights organization B'Tselem released a comprehensive report on July 27 describing the Israeli war on Gaza as genocide. However, the delay in publishing such an indictment is troubling and adds to an existing problem of politically motivated decision-making processes that have, in their own right, prolonged Israeli war crimes. The report accused Israel of committing genocide, a conclusion reached after a detailed analysis of the military campaign's intent, the systematic destruction of civilian life, and the government-engineered famine. This finding is significant because it adds to the massive body of legal and testimonial evidence affirming the Palestinian position that Israel's actions in Gaza constitute a genocide. Moreover, the fact that B'Tselem is an Israeli organization is doubly important. It represents an insider's indictment of the horrific massacres and the government-engineered famine in Gaza, directly challenging the baseless argument that accusing Israel of genocide is an act of antisemitism. Western media were particularly interested in this finding, even though numerous firsthand Palestinian reports and investigations are often ignored or downplayed. This double standard continues to feed into a chronic media problem in its perception of Palestine and Israel. Claims by Palestinians of Israeli war crimes have historically been ignored by mainstream media or academia. Whether the Zionist militia's massacre of Tantura in 1948, the actual number of Palestinians and Lebanese killed in the massacres of Sabra and Shatila in Lebanon in 1982, or the events resulting in the Jenin massacre in the West Bank in 2002, the media has frequently ignored the Palestinian account. It often gains a degree of validation only if it is backed by Israeli or Western voices. The latest B'Tselem report is no exception. But another question must be asked: Why did it take almost two years for B'Tselem to reach such an obvious conclusion? Israeli rights groups, in particular, have far greater access to the conduct of the Israeli army, the statements of politicians, and Hebrew media coverage than any other entity. Such a conclusion, therefore, should have been reached in a matter of two months, not two years. This kind of intentional delay has so far defined the position of many international institutions, organizations, and individuals whose moral authority would have helped Palestinians establish the facts of the genocide globally much earlier. For example, despite the International Court of Justice's historic ruling on Jan. 26, 2024, that determined there are plausible grounds for South Africa's accusation of Israel of committing genocide, the court is still unable, or unwilling, to produce a conclusive ruling. A definitive ruling would have put significant pressure on Israel to end its mass killing in Gaza. Instead, for now, the ICJ expects Israel to investigate itself — a highly unrealistic expectation at a time when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu promises his extremist ministers that Israel will encourage the ethnic cleansing of Gaza. The same indictment of intentional and politicized delays can be attributed to the International Criminal Court. While it issued arrest warrants for Netanyahu and his former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant on Nov. 21, 2024, no concrete action has been taken. Instead, it is Karim Khan, the ICC's chief prosecutor, who finds himself attacked by the US government and media for having the courage to follow through on the investigation. Individuals, too, especially those who have been associated with 'revolutionary' politics — the likes of Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Sen. Bernie Sanders, among others — have been reluctant to act. On March 22, 2024, Ocasio-Cortez refused to use the term genocide in Gaza, going as far as claiming that while she saw an 'unfolding genocide,' she was not yet ready to use the term herself. Sanders, on the other hand, who has spoken out repeatedly and strongly against Netanyahu, describing him in an interview with CNN on July 31 as a 'disgusting liar,' has had repeated moral lapses since the start of the war. When the term genocide was used by many far less 'radical' politicians, Sanders doubled down during a lecture at a university in Ireland. He said that the word genocide 'makes him queasy,' and he urged people to be 'careful about it.' Delays born of political calculation and fear of retribution have given Israel the critical space it needed to carry out its genocide. Dr. Ramzy Baroud These are not simply lost opportunities or instances of moral equivocation; they have had a profound and direct impact on Israel's behavior. The timely intervention of governments, international institutions, high courts, media, and human rights groups would have fundamentally changed the dynamics of the war. Such collective pressure could have forced Israel and its allies to end the war, potentially saving thousands of lives. Delays born of political calculation and fear of retribution have given Israel the critical space it needed to carry out its genocide. Israel is actively exploiting this lack of legal and moral clarity to persist in its mass slaughter of Palestinians. This must change. The Palestinian perspective, their suffering, and their truths must be respected and honored without needing validation from Israeli or other sources. The Palestinian voice and their rights must be truly centered, not as an academic cliche or political jargon, but as an undeniable, everyday reality. As for those who have delayed their verdict regarding the Israeli genocide, no rationale can possibly absolve them. They will be judged by history, and by the desperate pleas of Gaza's mothers and fathers, who tried and failed to save their children from the Israeli killing machine and the world's collective silence or inaction.
Al Arabiya
an hour ago
- Al Arabiya
Israel kills dozens in Gaza; Kremlin awaits Trump envoy ahead of sanctions deadline
In this episode of W News, presented by Leigh-Ann Gerrans, we report on the ongoing war in Gaza, where health officials say at least 40 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli gunfire and airstrikes, including 10 who were seeking aid. We also cover the Kremlin's statement that it expects 'important' talks later this week with US President Donald Trump's special envoy, Steve Witkoff, ahead of Trump's looming deadline to impose new sanctions on Russia unless it makes progress toward a peace deal in Ukraine. Guests: Moshe Elad – Middle East specialist Ahmed Fattouh – Fatah spokesperson Dasha Chernyshova – Correspondent Ander Antikov – Political analyst
Arab News
2 hours ago
- Arab News
Israeli PM says to brief army on Gaza war plan
JERUSALEM: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu promised Monday to update Israel's Gaza war plan, a day before a UN Security Council meeting on the fate of hostages still held in the Palestinian a cabinet meeting nearly 22 months into the war, the Israeli leader told ministers that later in the week he would instruct the military on how 'to achieve the three war objectives we have set.'Netanyahu's announcement comes as he faces increasing pressure to return the remaining hostages in Gaza, as well as mounting international calls to address the dire food situation in the Gaza — backed by the United States and Panama — is preparing to convene a UN Security Council meeting on Tuesday to highlight the fate of the the weekly cabinet meeting, Netanyahu reiterated that Israel's three war goals remain 'the defeat of the enemy, the release of our hostages and the promise that Gaza will no longer pose a threat to Israel.'His statement came after hundreds of retired Israeli security chiefs wrote to US President Donald Trump to urge him to convince Netanyahu to end the Minister Gideon Saar said ahead of the UN session in New York that 'the world must put an end to the phenomenon of kidnapping civilians. It must be front and center on the world stage.'Of the 251 hostages seized during Hamas's October 2023 attack on Israel, 49 are still held in the Palestinian territory, including 27 the Israeli military says are UN session was called after Palestinian militant groups published last week three videos showing hostages Rom Braslavski and Evyatar David appearing weak and emaciated, causing deep shock and distress in said he had asked the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) to provide food and medical treatment to the Israeli armed wing said it was willing to allow access to the hostages in exchange for opening aid corridors into all of Gaza, where UN-mandated experts have warned famine was ICRC said in a statement it was 'appalled by the harrowing videos' and reiterated its 'call to be granted access to the hostages.'Netanyahu's government has faced repeated accusations by relatives of hostages and other critics of not doing enough to rescue the captives.'Netanyahu is leading Israel and the hostages to ruin,' said the Hostages and Missing Families Forum campaign group.'For 22 months, the public has been sold the illusion that military pressure and intense fighting will bring the hostages back.'The truth must be said: expanding the war endangers the lives of the hostages, who are already in immediate mortal danger.'Mediation efforts led by Qatar, Egypt and the United States have failed to secure a of retired Israeli security officials including former heads of intelligence agencies have urged US President Donald Trump to pressure their own government to end the war.'It is our professional judgment that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel,' the former officials wrote in an open letter shared with the media on war 'is leading the State of Israel to lose its security and identity,' said Ami Ayalon, former director of the Shin Bet security service, in a video released to accompany the letter argued that the Israeli military 'has long accomplished the two objectives that could be achieved by force: dismantling Hamas's military formations and governance.''The third, and most important, can only be achieved through a deal: bringing all the hostages home,' it October 2023 attack that sparked the war resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, mostly civilians, according to a tally of official campaign in Gaza has killed at least 60,933 people, also mostly civilians, according to figures from the Hamas-run territory's health ministry, which are deemed reliable by the civil defense agency said Israeli fire on Monday killed at least 19 Palestinians, including nine who were waiting to collect food aid from a site in central Gaza City, Umm Osama Imad was mourning a relative she said was killed while trying to reach an aid distribution point.'We are starving... He went to bring flour for his family,' she said. 'The flour is stained with blood. We don't want the flour anymore. Enough!'Further south, in Deir el-Balah, Abdullah Abu Musa told AFP his daughter and her family were killed in an Israeli the attack on 'young children,' he said that 'perhaps the world will wake up — but it never will.'
