Tim Watson labels Harley Reid childish and unprofessional after copping 13th fine from AFL
No player in the AFL has conceded more free kicks in 2025 than the brash former No.1 pick amid suggestions his behaviour is going unchecked at the battling Eagles.
Reid, 20, and in just his second season, copped a $6250 fine for tripping Port Adelaide's Travis Boak during the third quarter of Sunday's loss during which the rising star had a running battle with fellow former No.1 pick Jason Horne-Francis and gave away six free kicks.
The fine was the largest fine available to the match review officer and took the total Reid has been fined to $26,250, including $15,000 this season.
Watson, who made his AFL debut as a 15-year-old in 1977, lashed Reid's behaviour and said there shouldn't be an out clause because of his age.
'As a young man we've been a little bit gentle on him and his behaviours out there on the field,' Watson said.
'He's now given away more free kicks than any other player in the game.
'I think it's time to deliver some hard truths to Harley Reid, and I don't know whether or not they've gone softly because they're fearful that he's going to turn around and want to go home or whatever it might be.
'But I think his behaviours are childish, and they're unprofessional, and they're undisciplined.
'It appears like there's been this soft touch that's been applied to him. I just don't think that you can tolerate the way that he behaves on the footy field any longer.
'Who else in the game is behaving like that as a 20-year-old. You name one player that's behaving like Harley Reid, is behaving regularly on the football field in the game right now.
'So why do we tolerate it? We're like, 'Oh, he's young'. Every guy that steps into the game is young, they're 18 or 19-year-olds.
'I'm understanding of young people making mistakes, but this is just a pattern of behaviour now that hasn't been modified, hasn't been controlled, and is still hurting his team.'
Watson questioned the quality of the Eagles' leadership under first-year coach Andrew McQualter and whether Reid was getting away with his behaviour because club officials feared he would leave.
'The behaviours that you walk past are the behaviours you accept in any form of life,' Watson told SEN.
'Do you think that every other player that's playing there at the West Coast Eagles at the moment aren't looking at him sideways and thinking, 'Hang on a minute, how come this bloke gets away with it? How come we tolerate this? The coach is telling us all this and all of a sudden we've got this other guy here and different rules apply to him'.
'It's ugly behaviours that he's displaying out there on the football field, and I think it's hurting him and it's hurting the West Coast Eagles as they try to build a young team too.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘Not good enough': Footage exposes Nick Daicos' horror lapse
Essendon legend Matthew Lloyd has called out Nick Daicos over a costly defensive lapse on Saturday night. The Crows secured a nailbiting three-point win over Collingwood, 9.5 (59) to 8.8 (56), to clinch a top two spot on the ladder. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. But with a little over nine minutes left on the clock and the Crows holding a two-point advantage, Daicos slipped up. As both sides awaited a boundary throw in deep inside Adelaide's forward 50, Daicos moved clear of his opponent James Peatling. The 22-year-old positioned himself in clear air in front of Darcy Cameron, but it quickly went pear-shaped. The throw from the boundary umpire fell short as Cameron stuck his left boot at the ball, which trickled off the side of his boot and ended up in the hands of Peatling who was all alone. The 24-year-old midfielder collected the ball and snapped to extend the Crows' lead out to eight points. The final quarter moment was highlighted by Crows great Rory Sloane, who said Daicos failed to put a body on his rival when it was needed most. 'This was the only breakdown for the Pies the entire game and it came at a crucial time,' Sloane said on Channel 9's Sunday Footy Show. 'Your job at a D50 stoppage is to go man first, defend first and then worry about the ball. 'Nick's too far away from Peatling, who picks that ball up and kicks the snap. 'I know why Daicos did it, he's reading this play (and) it dropped short. He's thinking Cameron might take it and give the handball. 'But that was a huge error.' Lloyd doubled down and said the mistake couldn't be forgiven. 'That's not good enough. 'I'm not cutting anyone slack in that regard. You have to have body contact. 'What is Nick doing there? You must grab a player. Peatling is sitting there saying all my Christmases have come at once, there's no-one on me. 'So whether it fell short or it didn't you must be locked on D50, there should be no spare players.' The moment came after Daicos raised eyebrows earlier in the contest when he was awarded a contentious free kick. The Collingwood superstar was going toe-to-toe with Adelaide's Brodie Smith when he drew the umpire's whistle. The push and shove between the pair kicked off when Daicos planted a forceful right hand into Smith's chest only for the Crows veteran to respond with a left shove and then a right to the chest. It was Smith's final blow however that left Daicos hunched over on the turf grabbing his chest as the whistle blew to award the free kick.
News.com.au
4 hours ago
- News.com.au
Daly Cherry-Evans responds to Roosters' backflip rumours
Manly skipper Daly Cherry-Evans says he's handling the firestorm around his playing future 'as best as he can', conceding a finals series in his last season at the Sea Eagles is now unlikely. The Sea Eagles' 26-12 loss to the Tigers on Sunday essentially eliminates them from finals contention. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. It's a disappointing scenario for Manly, who have lost four games in a row to fall out of the eight. Cherry-Evans cut a dejected figure on the field at full time and in the Sea Eagles' post-game press conference. 'We're now hoping to make the finals which is where you don't want to be,' the Manly skipper said. 'I don't know if toll is the right word, but after the game there is a bit to process. I've got a lot of love for this place so obviously wanted to finish with a finals campaign but that's really unlikely. The realisation of that is why I looked so disappointed after the game.' Cherry-Evans was then asked by a journalist if the outside noise around his future has affected him. The star half is expected to join the Roosters next season although nothing has been made official. Given Cherry-Evans' up-and-down form, combined with the recent red-hot run of the Roosters and their halfback Sam Walker, it has led to speculation the Chooks might have a case of buyer's remorse. In addition, it was reported earlier in the week that Cherry-Evans' Roosters deal hasn't been registered by the NRL yet. 'Just to be clear so I can differentiate, I'm definitely not happy with losing four in a row,' Cherry-Evans said. 'Everything else to be honest with you, I'm doing the best I can and feeling like I can hold my head up high.' Manly coach Anthony Seibold didn't want to make excuses for what he labelled a 'massive step back'. However, he noted his team's injury crisis, with seven first choice forwards all unavailable. 'We've come off the back of a really tough month of footy where we've played three of the top four teams, which has taken a fair bit of juice out of us,' he said. 'We were entrenched in the finals so the last month has been really disappointing for us. 'We're missing some of our bigger bodies and we were beaten up the middle today. 'Seven of what we potentially thought would be first choice forwards unavailable at present, but our group today, we beat Melbourne a month ago. Same group of players. So injuries are not an excuse. 'We were way off today but we lost the battle in the middle. I can bulls**t you but that's where we lost it.'
The Advertiser
4 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Plenty of son shine as Bulldogs blast lowly Eagles
Depending on your outlook, it was either a glorious endorsement of the AFL's father-son rule, or the damning indictment of why the system needs changing. Western Bulldogs star Sam Darcy (dad Luke, 226 games) handballed to Tom Liberatore (dad Tony, 283 games), who passed to debutant Jordan Croft (dad Matthew, 186 games), who took a great mark and kicked his first goal on debut. With Rhylee West (dad Scott, 324 games) also busy in attack, the Bulldogs thrashed wooden spooners West Coast by 94 points on Sunday at Marvel Stadium. The 19.12 (126) to 4.8 (32) win left the Bulldogs eighth on the ladder and sets up a massive clash next Sunday against Fremantle at the same venue. If Gold Coast win at least one of their two games in round 24 as expected, the loser of the Bulldogs-Dockers clash will miss the finals. So the Bulldogs and Fremantle effectively start their finals series next Sunday, with coach Luke Beveridge noting they had to beat GWS this time last year to make the eight. "It (the West Coast win) is a promising day on a number of fronts ... for both clubs, (next Sunday) is a big day," Beveridge said. "It was a mixture tonight - our stoppage strength wasn't really on show, but our offence and defensive elements were pretty good." There is plenty of ongoing commentary about the father-son rule, which the AFL has decided against changing. St Kilda in particular have been vocal in saying it skews the draft too much. Under the rule, the Bulldogs had easy access to Liberatore, Darcy, West and now Croft because their fathers played at least 100 games for the club. "It's a beautiful thing. Family in footy, it's something special," Beveridge said. "It doesn't matter what I say, because people will say 'well, you're going to say that'. "I'm hoping they protect it." Much of the pre-game chat had been around how many goals Darcy would kick, and he looked ready for a day out with the first two of the game in the opening 11 minutes. But Croft then lit up the second term, first taking a great mark. His kick from 50m was marked on the goal line by teammate Aaron Naughton, who duly converted. Two minutes later the three father-sons combined for Croft's first AFL goal, with Matthew celebrating in the stands. Croft kicked another goal in the second term as the Bulldogs romped to a 56-point lead at the main break. Lachie McNeil was hurt in a third-term collision and subbed out with a hip injury. Darcy, West, Naughton and Sam Davidson all kicked three goals, while captain Marcus Bontempelli added two among his 31 disposals and 10 clearances in another best-afield performance. The season cannot end quickly enough for the last-placed Eagles. Jamie Cripps' final-term goal meant they avoided their lowest score at Marvel Stadium, by just two points. But it was their lowest score and biggest losing margin this season. "We just couldn't quite stop any of their scoring and we clearly couldn't score - pretty big parts of footy," said Eagles coach Andrew McQualter. Eagles star Liam Baker worked his backside off in defence. Young key forward Jobe Shanahan looks likely, but his finishing let him down and he kicked three behinds. Depending on your outlook, it was either a glorious endorsement of the AFL's father-son rule, or the damning indictment of why the system needs changing. Western Bulldogs star Sam Darcy (dad Luke, 226 games) handballed to Tom Liberatore (dad Tony, 283 games), who passed to debutant Jordan Croft (dad Matthew, 186 games), who took a great mark and kicked his first goal on debut. With Rhylee West (dad Scott, 324 games) also busy in attack, the Bulldogs thrashed wooden spooners West Coast by 94 points on Sunday at Marvel Stadium. The 19.12 (126) to 4.8 (32) win left the Bulldogs eighth on the ladder and sets up a massive clash next Sunday against Fremantle at the same venue. If Gold Coast win at least one of their two games in round 24 as expected, the loser of the Bulldogs-Dockers clash will miss the finals. So the Bulldogs and Fremantle effectively start their finals series next Sunday, with coach Luke Beveridge noting they had to beat GWS this time last year to make the eight. "It (the West Coast win) is a promising day on a number of fronts ... for both clubs, (next Sunday) is a big day," Beveridge said. "It was a mixture tonight - our stoppage strength wasn't really on show, but our offence and defensive elements were pretty good." There is plenty of ongoing commentary about the father-son rule, which the AFL has decided against changing. St Kilda in particular have been vocal in saying it skews the draft too much. Under the rule, the Bulldogs had easy access to Liberatore, Darcy, West and now Croft because their fathers played at least 100 games for the club. "It's a beautiful thing. Family in footy, it's something special," Beveridge said. "It doesn't matter what I say, because people will say 'well, you're going to say that'. "I'm hoping they protect it." Much of the pre-game chat had been around how many goals Darcy would kick, and he looked ready for a day out with the first two of the game in the opening 11 minutes. But Croft then lit up the second term, first taking a great mark. His kick from 50m was marked on the goal line by teammate Aaron Naughton, who duly converted. Two minutes later the three father-sons combined for Croft's first AFL goal, with Matthew celebrating in the stands. Croft kicked another goal in the second term as the Bulldogs romped to a 56-point lead at the main break. Lachie McNeil was hurt in a third-term collision and subbed out with a hip injury. Darcy, West, Naughton and Sam Davidson all kicked three goals, while captain Marcus Bontempelli added two among his 31 disposals and 10 clearances in another best-afield performance. The season cannot end quickly enough for the last-placed Eagles. Jamie Cripps' final-term goal meant they avoided their lowest score at Marvel Stadium, by just two points. But it was their lowest score and biggest losing margin this season. "We just couldn't quite stop any of their scoring and we clearly couldn't score - pretty big parts of footy," said Eagles coach Andrew McQualter. Eagles star Liam Baker worked his backside off in defence. Young key forward Jobe Shanahan looks likely, but his finishing let him down and he kicked three behinds. Depending on your outlook, it was either a glorious endorsement of the AFL's father-son rule, or the damning indictment of why the system needs changing. Western Bulldogs star Sam Darcy (dad Luke, 226 games) handballed to Tom Liberatore (dad Tony, 283 games), who passed to debutant Jordan Croft (dad Matthew, 186 games), who took a great mark and kicked his first goal on debut. With Rhylee West (dad Scott, 324 games) also busy in attack, the Bulldogs thrashed wooden spooners West Coast by 94 points on Sunday at Marvel Stadium. The 19.12 (126) to 4.8 (32) win left the Bulldogs eighth on the ladder and sets up a massive clash next Sunday against Fremantle at the same venue. If Gold Coast win at least one of their two games in round 24 as expected, the loser of the Bulldogs-Dockers clash will miss the finals. So the Bulldogs and Fremantle effectively start their finals series next Sunday, with coach Luke Beveridge noting they had to beat GWS this time last year to make the eight. "It (the West Coast win) is a promising day on a number of fronts ... for both clubs, (next Sunday) is a big day," Beveridge said. "It was a mixture tonight - our stoppage strength wasn't really on show, but our offence and defensive elements were pretty good." There is plenty of ongoing commentary about the father-son rule, which the AFL has decided against changing. St Kilda in particular have been vocal in saying it skews the draft too much. Under the rule, the Bulldogs had easy access to Liberatore, Darcy, West and now Croft because their fathers played at least 100 games for the club. "It's a beautiful thing. Family in footy, it's something special," Beveridge said. "It doesn't matter what I say, because people will say 'well, you're going to say that'. "I'm hoping they protect it." Much of the pre-game chat had been around how many goals Darcy would kick, and he looked ready for a day out with the first two of the game in the opening 11 minutes. But Croft then lit up the second term, first taking a great mark. His kick from 50m was marked on the goal line by teammate Aaron Naughton, who duly converted. Two minutes later the three father-sons combined for Croft's first AFL goal, with Matthew celebrating in the stands. Croft kicked another goal in the second term as the Bulldogs romped to a 56-point lead at the main break. Lachie McNeil was hurt in a third-term collision and subbed out with a hip injury. Darcy, West, Naughton and Sam Davidson all kicked three goals, while captain Marcus Bontempelli added two among his 31 disposals and 10 clearances in another best-afield performance. The season cannot end quickly enough for the last-placed Eagles. Jamie Cripps' final-term goal meant they avoided their lowest score at Marvel Stadium, by just two points. But it was their lowest score and biggest losing margin this season. "We just couldn't quite stop any of their scoring and we clearly couldn't score - pretty big parts of footy," said Eagles coach Andrew McQualter. Eagles star Liam Baker worked his backside off in defence. Young key forward Jobe Shanahan looks likely, but his finishing let him down and he kicked three behinds.
