Teen dad shook crying baby until newborn had brain damage - then blamed the dog
A young dad shook his crying baby until the newborn had irreparable brain damage and had the audacity to blame the family dog.
Dafydd Rutherford's shaking led his weeks-old infant to suffer multiple brain bleeds that have had life-long and devastating consequences, Swansea Crown Court heard. The court was told how Rutherford confessed to shaking his baby out of frustration and said it was not done to harm the child but was done instead to "stop the baby crying."
His defence lawyers said the offence was a result of "immaturity, impulsivity, and recklessness", stating that Rutherford, who was a teenager at the time, "simply wasn't ready for a child." Head scans revealed the baby suffered bleeding on the brain, which led to the involvement of police and social services.
The court heard how the infant was rushed to the paediatric care unit at the University Hospital of Wales, in Cardiff. MRI scans showed bleeding on both sides of the brain around the spinal cord as well as damage to the brain due to being deprived of oxygen, Wales Online reported.
Rutherford initially denied having caused the injuries to his child and claimed the dog knocked over the baby's basket. The defendant then admitted he had become frustrated with the dog barking and the baby crying before confessing to shaking the infant "three or four times."
An impact statement from the baby's relatives read to the court described having felt as though they were "torn apart" while the defendant remained silent. They added that by failing to tell doctors, Rutherford had "chosen to help himself rather than help his [child.]"
Rutherford, 22, previously admitted inflicting grievous bodily harm when he appeared for sentencing. Stuart John representing Rutherford, told the court that his client recognised he has inflicted "irreparable damage" upon his infant child as well as the entire family.
He added the crime came from a place of "immaturity, impulsivity, and recklessness" and said the defendant would be haunted by his actions for the rest of his life.
He said at the time of the incident he was a teenager who was "not ready for a child." Judge Catherine Richards told Rutherford that the baby had only been weeks old when he inflicted "devastating" injuries.
She said the defendant initially refused to take responsibility for the injuries before confessing he became frustrated by the dog and baby, resulting in him losing his temper.
Following a reduction for his guilty plea, Rutherford received a 28-month prison sentence. He will serve up to half of the term before being released on licence to complete the remainder in his community.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
10 hours ago
- Daily Record
Married care worker guilty of inciting boy at children's home into sexual relationship
Lindy Leah 'fell in love' with a teenage boy living at the children's home where she worked as deputy manager. A care worker has been found guilty of inciting a teenage boy at the children's home where she worked into a sexual relationship. Lindy Leah, 44, was said to have "fallen in love" with the youngster, who lived at the St Helens home where she was deputy manager. Liverpool Crown Court heard she wore inappropriate and revealing outfits around him and sent a string of WhatsApp messages including one asking him "for a love bite" and another encouraging him to go missing so they could have a drug-fuelled "night away". Leah, of Capesthorne Road, Orford, Warrington, denied any wrongdoing, claiming she saw herself as a "mother figure" to the boy as his key worker, reports Wales Online. However, a jury found her guilty of being a person in a position of trust who caused or incited a child to engage in sexual activity. The jury of six men and six women returned their verdicts after deliberating yesterday morning, August 8. Leah was remanded in custody until sentencing next month. Jurors were told Leah bombarded the boy with messages, at one point telling him she was "proper paranoid" that she had "lost him to a slag" before adding: "If you never met me then your life would be better. I miss you so much. All I want is for me and you to have a night away from everyone, just us. So if I wake up from these tablets and wine, then we will." Leah then went on to add: "Do you wanna go MSC [missing from care]? I love you so much. Can I book somewhere for me and you on Friday? Red and silky with some balloons and flake." Graham Pickavance, prosecuting, told the court that "balloons" was a "colloquial term" for the class C drug nitrous oxide. In a further message, Leah said to the teen: "Just listened to a song and it made me cry. Stupid love songs. It made me think of you, then it made me cry. I won't be listening to that again." A former colleague of Leah's, who the ECHO has chosen not to name for legal reasons, was also called to give evidence. Appearing from behind a screen in the witness box, she recalled an incident during her first shift at the home and said: "As I went into one of the staff bedrooms, she was in there, Lindy Leah and the young person. "The young person was laying across the bed with Lindy Leah in the bedroom. I couldn't believe my eyes [The boy ] was on his phone, as if it was normal. "I was just dismayed. I couldn't believe what I was seeing. I knew the protocol of a young person being in a member of staff's bedroom. It was not supposed to happen, full stop. I tried to speak to Lindy Leah to say it was inappropriate. She told me he's always in there, he looks comfortable and no one else has a problem. I was very concerned." The witness described Leah's behaviour as "unnaturally friendly and excitable". She said: "It was like you haven't seen a friend for a long time and you get excited. It was like that continually. It was like he was her best friend. It was so unprofessional." Asked whether she also had "concerns about the way she dressed" in work, the witness replied: "Almost every time I was working with her, absolutely. Her physical appearance, she always wore revealing clothes that were not suitable for a care home and for a member of staff looking after young people. "There was one type of suit she had, different colour of bodysuits. It's like a Lycra, all in one. It's skin tight. You could see she wasn't wearing a bra, you could see when she was wearing a thong and you could tell when she wasn't wearing either." The carer described one occasion where the boy was present in a staff room, saying: "Lindy, went 'oo, [ boy's name], look, I've got no knickers, I've just had a shower and forgot to bring clean knickers'. She pulled her suit up. You could see the outline of her vagina. She went 'oo, look, you can even see my nipples as well'. He was laughing." The woman went on to recount another incident where she had been painting one of the residents' bedrooms, saying of this: "Lindy opened the door and leant through. On her breast, she got some paint on her jumper. "There was a long corridor. She looked out and said, '[ boy's name], I've got paint on my top' and pulled her jumper off to reveal a cami top. She went 'oo, look' and started wobbling her belly and breasts to him." The witness was then questioned over a holiday which apparently Leah went on in order to celebrate her 25th wedding anniversary, but said of this: "She did not want to go. She said she didn't love her husband and only married him for his money, her son is a spoiled brat. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. "She said to her daughter on her phone, I just wish she'd die. She said she didn't want to go because she'd miss [the boy ]." When Leah was interviewd by detectives after concerns came to light, she "denied any improper behaviour". When Leah was released on bail under conditions not to contact the boy, the two were spotted together weeks later beside a white Audi car at Walton Hall and Gardens in Warrington by a fellow care worker. In her evidence, Leah was asked by her counsel Rebecca Filletti asked what training she had received prior to taking on the job. She told the court: "In my interview, I told them I was a mother. My training was based on being a mum. "I seen the kids as my children. I wanted to show them how kids thrive with a good mother around them. That's the only way I knew to be. We tried to make it as homely as possible. That's what we wanted for the children, to make it as much as a home environment as we could. "I just took on this role of his mother. I really seen him as my son, my kid. I adored him. We were little besties. We were a little team. "It was incredibly naïve and unprofessional of me to behave like that. I just got incredibly emotionally involved and looked at him like a son. He seemed so unloved by everyone around him. He just didn't have a relationship with his family. He had no one. He seen me as his mother. I took on that role and really looked out for him." Speaking of the incident regarding the paint on her jumper, Leah said: "I don't recall it. [Her colleague] was painting, so it could have happened. I would have took my jumper off. I always wear vest tops under my clothes. I wouldn't have been wiggling my body around to anybody." In relation to the accusation concerning the bodysuit, Leah added: "Never. I do believe, if there was other staff present, somebody would have said something. I would never do that." When referred to a series of stays at caravan parks in Cheshire and North Wales with the boy, Leah stated: "It was organised professionally, through the company. It was a school holiday. He wouldn't go camping. He agreed to do this. He wanted to go for steak, he wanted to do something nice." When probed about her WhatsApp messages with the boy, she added: "I'd been drinking. It was unprofessional, and I shouldn't have been messaging [the boy ]. "I wanted to take him away, get him away from the things he was doing, the people he was around. I wanted him to have a nice night away and have some food, just getting away from all the things he was doing, just me and him. "I thought it was best he went with me, so he could be himself. Just to get him away and let him be a kid. I was just trying to look out for him. I didn't mean to say missing from care. I'd been drinking all day. I didn't need to take him from care." Of the "red and silky with some balloons and flake" message, Leah said: "I was joking. I have a dry sense of humour. He knows how I felt about drugs. I meant wine. I was being silly, dramatic. He knows I'm joking. I was making fun of balloons, is it nitrous oxide?" Leah also denied taking drugs with the boy, and when asked whether there was "any intention for this trip to be sexual", replied: "Absolutely not. No." Having been shown a picture which was recovered from her phone and showed the teen holding a balloon in his mouth, she told jurors: "[The boy ] doesn't particularly like his teeth. That's the only picture he would let me take, of him blowing up a balloon." Ms Filletti went on to ask, "in general terms, what do you think of those messages?". Leah replied: "I think they're completely unprofessional and inappropriate. I think I acted on fear. I think I was acting like a mother, or we were friends. "[The boy ] didn't have anybody that cared about him. He was so alone. He just attached himself to me. I'm just a really loving person. I just loved him and really looked out for him. I thought he was my son. I thought he was my little friend. I had such an emotional, maternal attachment to him. It's inappropriate. It's not ok. "My heart was in the right place. I actually thought I was doing the best job by him. There's a reason why these rules were put in place. I broke them. I thought I was doing right by him. I thought I was showing him unconditional love by a mother. I was just digging holes." Of another message, in which Leah suggested she would return the boy's confiscated mobile phone "for a love bite", she said: "I'm joking with him. I think I'm funny. It was just banter. I don't want a love bite off a 15-year-old boy, I have a husband. He was covered in love bites, we'd all been making fun of him. I was just referring to it and laughing about it." Leah was then referred to the WhatsApp exchange concerning the "love song", which she said was Waterfalls by TLC. She added: "I tried to make him listen to it. It's about a son who keeps doing wrong things and choosing the wrong path." Leah accepted that she had met with the boy in breach of her bail conditions, but said of this: "I seen him as my son. He was devastated and he needed me. He begged to see me. He'd been beaten up. He was scared. He needed his mum, and he considered me to be his mum. I shouldn't have gone." Leah then appeared to become tearful as she said: "I just wanted everyone to see that I really seen [the boy ] as my son, and I wanted to have my opportunity to show everybody that I know I was unprofessional, I know I was dramatic and I know I was ridiculous, but I never incited any sexual activity with [the boy ]. I just really, really thought I was his mum. I thought I was helping him."
Wales Online
17 hours ago
- Wales Online
12 'Easily dismissed' symptoms of deadly cancer that kills thousands every year
12 'Easily dismissed' symptoms of deadly cancer that kills thousands every year This type of cancer is the fourth most common among men, but it's vague symptoms leaves many simply dismissing the warning signs The subtle signs could be pointing to a number of serious conditions so it's best to consult your GP (Image: GETTY) Head and neck cancer is a group of cancers that originate in the tissues of these body parts, but it doesn't include cancers that start in the thyroid, oesophagus, windpipe or brain according to Macmillan. 12,200 people are diagnosed with head and neck cancer in the UK every year and it's the fourth most common cancer among men. Getting an early diagnosis and swift treatment can have a major impact on both survival and effects of the treatment as 4,100 people lose their lives to these cancers each year in the UK according to Cancer Research. However, many people dismiss the earliest warning signs as it can mimic everyday issues most people face. Medical negligence experts at Simpson Millar say they've also seen a rise in clients who were misdiagnosed, ignored or sent away with antibiotics, only to later receive a life-altering diagnosis. Kate McCue, Senior Associate Solicitor at Simpson Millar, says: "When it comes to head and neck cancer, timing really does make all the difference. 'Catching it early can lead to much better outcomes, not just in terms of survival, but also in how intensive the treatment needs to be, how long recovery takes, and what quality of life looks like after treatment." Common symptoms include: Persistent sore throat Mouth ulcers that don't heal Pain or difficulty swallowing A lump in the neck or mouth Changes in voice or speech Swelling or thickening in the cheek Loose teeth with no obvious cause Unexplained weight loss Ear pain or hearing problems A blocked nose on one side only Numbness in the tongue or lips White or red patches in the mouth If you experience these symptoms for more than two to three weeks or they begin to worsen, it's best to speak to your GP or dentist. The medical negligence experts also urged people to push for further testing if they feel something is wrong or that their symptoms aren't being taken seriously. Kate added: 'Too often, late diagnosis isn't just down to bad luck but a reflection of structural barriers that can and should be addressed. "If we want to reduce avoidable deaths from head and neck cancer, we need to fix the system. That means better access to GP and dental services, more targeted public health outreach, and making early diagnosis the norm.' Article continues below Tests for head and neck cancer can include blood tests, x-rays, CT scans, MRI scans and PET-CT scans or biopsies. If your doctor or dentist believes your symptoms may be pointing to cancer, you will likely get a referral within two weeks to see a specialist. If your only symptom is a lump in your neck, you could be referred to a neck lump clinic. These clinics can conduct ultrasound neck scans, biopsy of the lump and nasendoscopy which looks at the back of your mouth, nose and throat. People who smoke or drink excessively may have a higher risk of head and neck cancer, especially if they do both according to Macmillan. The cancer is also more common in men than women.
North Wales Live
a day ago
- North Wales Live
Woman pockets £5k diamond ring from jewellers after asking for glass of water
A woman pocketed a £5,000 diamond ring from a Welsh jewellers after asking for a glass of water. Megan Taylor went to Stephen Hughes Fine Diamonds in Swansea's Quadrant shopping centre when she asked a jeweller to show her some pricey diamond rings. The 28-year-old sat down with the sales assistant before the staff member took the rings out and went through them one by one with her on January 25 this year, Swansea Crown Court heard on Friday. While they were looking at the rings the defendant then asked the sales assistant for a glass of water, claiming she felt faint, reports WalesOnline. CCTV footage showed that when the sales assistant left the table to get the water Taylor slipped a solitaire diamond ring from the table into her pocket. She initially acted natural before deciding against purchasing a ring and walking out of the store minutes later. Dyfed Thomas, prosecuting, said the ring she stole amounted to a value of £4,950. Sign up for the North Wales Live newsletter sent twice daily to your inbox During a stock check days later the store realised the ring was missing and had not been sold. CCTV footage was checked and it clearly showed Taylor taking the ring and walking out of the store. When the defendant was arrested days later by South Wales Police on February 8 she didn't deny having taken the ring but claimed she was acting in confusion at the time of the offence. She said she may have been under the influence of alcohol and drugs at the time and later told the probation service she was epileptic and had a seizure on the morning of her crime. The court heard how Taylor recently received almost £70,000 in inheritance money but she had now spent all of that and had "no real funds", so she couldn't pay the £4,950 back to Stephen Hughes in less than a year. Hannah George, for Taylor, said her client did not recall where she put the ring and had "memory fog". "She doesn't know what she has done with the ring and she does not have the ring," Ms George told Judge Huw Rees. "Unfortunately those are my instructions," she said. "She has £790 a month universal credit. She has been frank about how she used the inheritance money. How she spent it was short-sighted if I can put it that way." Ms George said her client had no previous convictions. It was decided the defendant would repay the cost of the ring at a rate of £150 a month starting from October. Taylor, of Cae Bricks Road in Cwmbwrla, eventually pleaded guilty to one count of theft during a mention hearing after the case had been listed for trial. Judge Huw Rees, who in a previous hearing had adjourned matters in the hope the defendant would find the ring, told Taylor in the dock: "This is a very serious example of theft. "I've given you the opportunity to determine where the ring is and you maintain the position that you don't know where it is or what happened to it. "I have my own suspicions about this case which are relatively high but I should give you the benefit of the doubt." Judge Rees sentenced Taylor to an 18-month community order. She must also complete a 12-month mental health treatment programme and five days of a rehabilitation activity requirement.
