Trump's proposal for Gaza entangles Arab allies
His meeting Tuesday with Jordan's King Abdullah II stands to be an awkward moment as Trump continues to suggest Abdullah's country take in more Palestinians, who by some estimates already take up about half the population.
But Trump's proposal has been met with steep opposition from the greater Arab world, who see Palestinian resettlement as a nonstarter, in addition to going against decades of U.S. foreign policy on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
'Arab nations and global leaders have been clear in their opposition to the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians and the urgent need to rebuild Gaza so its people can live with dignity and security,' said Iman Awad, national director of policy and advocacy at Emgage Action, a Muslim American advocacy group, in a statement.
'In particular, we expect that the upcoming meeting with the Jordanian King will reinforce these concerns, underscoring the necessity of upholding international law and preventing the displacement of millions of Palestinians,' Awad added.
Trump sent shockwaves through the Middle East last week when he proposed the United States would take control of the Gaza Strip and rebuild it. He since has offered some new details of his vision, including that U.S. troops would not get involved, while sending mixed messages about the fate of Palestinians.
The president for weeks has said he would like to see Jordan, Egypt and other nations in the region take in Palestinians who would be relocated out of Gaza.
While the White House has suggested the relocation would only be temporary while Gaza is rebuilt — something officials have said could take 10 years to 15 years — Trump has been less clear about the long-term plan for displaced Palestinians.
'It would be my hope that we could do something really nice, really good, where they wouldn't want to return. Why would they want to return? The place has been hell,' Trump told reporters last week alongside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
But Trump then told Fox News's Bret Baier during a pre-Super Bowl interview that Palestinians would not have the right to return to Gaza after it is rebuilt 'because they're going to have much better housing.'
'In other words, I'm talking about building a permanent place for them because if they have to return now, it'll be years before you could ever — it's not habitable. It would be years before it could happen,' Trump said.
But Trump's proposal has fallen flat with the Arab nations that would be key to making it happen.
Leaders in the region have said efforts to displace Palestinians or move them into neighboring countries are a nonstarter. Egypt and Jordan — countries with peace treaties with Israel — oppose absorbing more Palestinians, claiming it poses a security risk, is destabilizing and threatens to provoke mass opposition.
Jordan already houses about 3 million Palestinians, many of whom have been displaced by prior wars.
Egypt announced Sunday it would host a summit of Arab nations on Feb. 27 to discuss the latest developments around the future of Palestinians, according to The Associated Press.
Some experts have suggested Trump's proposal may be a negotiating tactic, just as he used the threat of tariffs against Mexico and Canada to secure commitments to protecting the border.
But Trump administration officials have touted the president's proposal as an out-of-the-box suggestion to address a decades-long quagmire.
'Now is the time for the other governments and other powers in the region, some of these very rich countries, to basically say, OK, we'll do it. We're going to pay for this; we're going to step forward; we're going to be the ones that take charge,' Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Monday on SiriusXM.
'None of them is offering to do it,' he added. 'And I think that you can't go around claiming that you're a fighter for, an advocate for the Palestinian people, but you're not willing to do anything to help rebuild Gaza.'
Rubio is set to travel to the Middle East later this week, with stops planned in Israel, Qatar and Saudi Arabia.
Trump's controversial proposal will serve as the backdrop for a key meeting Tuesday, when the president hosts Jordan's king at the White House.
While in Washington, Abdullah is set to meet with Trump, Rubio, White House national security adviser Mike Waltz, special envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff and members of Congress. Abdullah met Sunday with Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
White House officials did not respond to requests for comment about what would be on the agenda for Tuesday's meeting, but the Gaza proposal is expected to be central to the visit.
Abdullah met Wednesday with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, the day after Trump first floated the idea of the U.S. taking over Gaza. The Jordanian royal court posted on social media following that meeting that Abdullah 'stresses the need to put a stop to settlement expansion, expressing rejection of any attempts to annex land and displace the Palestinians.'
A former National Security Council aide in the Biden White House argued Trump's comments about Gaza 'overshadow the meeting and start it out on a pretty rough note.'
'Driving a wedge with our allies especially in pursuit of goals that are unrealistic … and cause significant heartburn in the region for our allies, it just makes no sense,' the aide said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
a few seconds ago
- NBC News
Trump's tariff deadline is near. Here's a look at countries that have a deal — and those that don't
Come Friday, the world will have to contend with higher tariff rates from the Trump administration, raising the specter of even more economic uncertainty. For most countries, that can of worms has been kicked twice down the road, from 'Liberation Day' on April 2, to July 9, and now to Aug. 1. Back in April, President Donald Trump had claimed to have done 'over 200 deals' in an interview with Time Magazine, and trade adviser Peter Navarro had said that '90 deals in 90 days' was possible. The country has fallen far short of that, with only eight deals in 120 days, including one with the 27-member European Union. Here are where things stand in global trade. U.K. first to a deal The U.K. led the charge on trade agreements with the U.S., striking one as early as May. The framework includes a 10% baseline tariffs on U.K. goods, as well as various quotas and exemptions for products such as autos and aerospace goods. But even after Trump met with Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Scotland recently, some points in their trade agreement remain uncertain. That includes tariffs on U.K. steel and aluminum, which the U.S. agreed to slash. Talks about the U.K.'s digital services tax, which Trump wants scrapped, also seem to be continuing. Vietnam: tariffs more than halved Vietnam was the second to cross the line with the Trump administration, with Trump announcing a trade agreement on July 2 that saw the tariff imposed on Vietnam slashed from 46% to 20%. One point with Vietnam was a 40% 'transshipping' tariff on goods originating in another country and transferred to Vietnam for final shipment to the U.S., although it is not clear how this will be applied. Trump also claimed that there would be full market access to the country for U.S. goods. Chinese manufacturers have used transshipping to sidestep the hefty tariffs on their direct shipments to the United States, using Vietnam as a major transshipment hub. However, it seems that Vietnam was blindsided by the 20% rate imposed, according to a report by Politico. Politico said negotiators had expected a 11% levy, but Trump unilaterally announced the 20% rate. Indonesia: bringing down barriers Indonesia's tariff rate was cut to 19% from 32% in its agreement with Trump, announced on July 15. The White House said Indonesia will eliminate tariff barriers on over 99% of U.S. products exported to Indonesia across all sectors, including agricultural products and energy. The framework says the countries will also address various 'non-tariff barriers' and other obstacles that the U.S. faces in Indonesian markets. Philippines: marginal decrease Unlike its ASEAN counterparts above, which had sizable reductions in their tariff duties, the Philippines saw a decrease of a single percentage point, to 19% from 20%, on July 22. Manila will not impose tariffs on U.S. goods as part of the agreement, according to Trump, who praised the country for what he described as 'going OPEN MARKET with the United States.' In addition, Trump also said that the Philippines will work together 'Militarily,' without specifying any details. The two countries are already treaty allies, with Manila hosting U.S. troops and having a mutual defense treaty going back to 1951. Japan: rice and autos Japan was the second major Asian economy to come to an agreement with the U.S. after China, seeing its tariff rate cut to 15% from 25% on July 23, and being the first economy to see a lower preferential tariff rate for its key automobile sector. Trump called the agreement 'perhaps the largest Deal ever made,' while adding that Japan would invest $550 billion in the United States and the U.S. would 'receive 90% of the Profits.' The path to this agreement was fraught with uncertainty, with Trump saying days before the agreement that he did not expect the two countries to reach a deal. He described Japan on separate occasions as 'very tough' in trade talks and suggested the country was 'spoiled' for not accepting U.S. rice despite facing a domestic rice shortage. E.U.: some discontent remains The European Union's agreement with the U.S. was struck just days ago, after long negotiations. E.U. goods are now facing a 15% baseline tariff rate, half the 30% Trump had previously threatened the bloc with. Existing duties on autos will be reduced to 15%, and levies on some products like aircraft and certain drug generics will go back to pre-January levels. But the deal has been met with criticism, including from some European leaders. French Prime Minister Francois Bayrou went as far as saying it was an act of 'submission' and a 'dark day.' E.U. Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic, however, called it 'the best deal we could get under very difficult circumstances.' South Korea: also at 15% South Korea is the latest country to reach an agreement, on Thursday, with the terms being somewhat similar to the ones Japan received. The country will see a blanket 15% tariff on its exports, while duties on its auto sector are also lowered to 15%. South Korea 'will give to the United States $350 Billion Dollars for Investments owned and controlled by the United States, and selected by myself, as President,' Trump said. U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said '90% of the profits' from that $350 billion investment will be 'going to the American people.' However, South Korean President Lee Jae Myung said the $350 billion fund will play a role in facilitating the 'active entry' of Korean companies into the U.S. market into industries such as shipbuilding and semiconductors. China: talks still ongoing The Trump administration's trade talks with China have taken a different tack than those with the rest of the world. The world's second-largest economy was firmly in Trump's trade crosshairs from the moment he took office. Rather than a deal, China has reached a series of suspensions over its 'reciprocal' tariff rate. It was initially hit with a 34% tariff from 'Liberation Day,' before a series of back-and-forth measures between the two sides saw the duties skyrocket to 145% for Chinese imports to the U.S. and 125% for U.S. imports to China. However, both sides agreed to reduced tariffs in May, after their first trade meeting in Geneva, Switzerland. The truce was agreed to last until Aug. 12. China currently faces a 30% combined tariff rate, while the U.S. is looking at 10% duties. The countries' most recent meeting in Stockholm ended without a truce extension, but U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said that any truce extension will not be agreed to until Trump signs off on the plan. For countries without a deal, it appears that a higher global baseline tariff of about 15%-20% will be slapped on them, according to Trump, higher than the 10% baseline announced on 'Liberation Day.' Countries with a trade surplus with the U.S. will most likely see a higher 'reciprocal' tariff rate. Here are some key trading partners that have not agreed to a deal with the U.S. India: tariffs and a penalty On Wednesday, Trump announced a 25% tariff on India, with an additional unspecified 'penalty' for what he views as unfair trade policies and for India's purchase of military equipment and energy from Russia. 'While India is our friend, we have, over the years, done relatively little business with them because their Tariffs are far too high, among the highest in the World,' Trump said in a post on Truth Social. The 25% tariff rate is modestly lower than what Trump imposed on India on ' Liberation Day,' when he announced a 26% rate on the key trading partner, but at the high end of the 20%-25% range that the U.S. president said he was considering. Canada: an 'intense phase' There has been frequent back-and-forth between Canada and the U.S. over tariffs in recent months, with the country being hit by duties even before Trump announced his so-called 'reciprocal' tariffs. Canada is now facing 35% tariffs on various goods starting Aug. 1, with Trump threatening to increase that rate in case of retaliation. The rate is separate from any sectoral tariffs. Trump has repeatedly cited drugs flowing from Canada to the U.S. as a reason for his move to impose tariffs. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said earlier this week that the partners were in an 'intense phase' of talks, noting that it would be unlikely for an agreement not to include any tariffs, Reuters reported. Mexico: no sign of progress Like Canada, Mexico has also long been a U.S. tariff target, with Trump citing drugs and illegal migration as factors in his decision to announce levies on the U.S.' southern neighbor. The president has said that Mexico has not done enough to secure the border. Mexico is set to be hit with a 30% tariff, with any retaliation set to be met with an even higher rate from the U.S. The Mexican government has stressed that it is important for the trading partners to resolve their issues ahead of Aug. 1, but there have not been many signs of progress toward an agreement in recent weeks. Australia: sticking to the baseline Australia currently faces the baseline 10% as it runs a trade deficit with the United States. However, the country could be facing a higher tariff rate if Trump decides to raise his baseline rate to 15%-20%. Canberra has not been publicly known to be in trade talks with Washington, with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese reportedly arguing that Australia's deficit with the U.S. and its free trade agreement mean there should be no tariff on Australian imports. reportedly said was not prompted by Trump.
Newsweek
a few seconds ago
- Newsweek
Donald Trump Issues Threat To Canada Over 'Statehood of Palestine' Move
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. President Donald Trump has said that Canada's support for a Palestinian state will make any trade deal between Washington and Ottawa "very hard." In a post on Truth Social, Trump referred to comments made by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney that Canada is planning to recognize a Palestinian state at the United Nations in September. "Wow! Canada has just announced that it is backing statehood for Palestine. That will make it very hard for us to make a Trade Deal with them. Oh' Canada!!!," Trump wrote. Carney's announcement follows United Kingdom Prime Minister Keir Starmer, who said earlier this week that Britain will recognize a Palestinian state in September unless Israel meets certain conditions. Last week, French President Emmanuel Macron announced that France would recognize the State of Palestine, becoming the first G7 nation to do so. Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney and President Donald Trump speaking during the G7 summit in Canada in June. Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney and President Donald Trump speaking during the G7 summit in Canada in is a developing story. More to follow.
CNBC
a few seconds ago
- CNBC
CNBC Daily Open: Is India is the first to face Trump's 'secondary' tariff on Russia?
In the frenzied run-up to Friday, Aug. 1 — the day when U.S. President Donald Trump's new tariffs come into effect (no more delays!) — America's major trading partners such as Japan, the European Union and now, South Korea, have come to an agreement with the country. All of them will be subject to 15% tariffs on U.S. imports of their goods. But India? Not only has there not been a deal yet, Trump unilaterally imposed a 25% tariff on the South Asian country — a higher-than-expected number, as analysts had widely expected India to secure a favorable deal with America. Worse, the tariff will exist alongside an additional "penalty," which Trump said is the price India has to pay for its military and energy transactions with Russia. That essentially sounds like the "secondary tariff" Trump had previously threatened to slap on Moscow. In doing so, Trump's actions seem to be suggesting that the White House's trade policies is not based simply on the balance of trade, as Trump is fond of bringing up, or even how much he likes you — see his admiration of the U.K.'s King Charles and the country's 10% tariff rate. It's also about who your friends are. Essentially, Trump appears to be implying that, even if you are an up-and-coming influential figure, if you hang out with the uncool kids (who buy Russian arms), you can't sit with us. Perhaps Trump can afford to alienate allies because the U.S. economy is still unexpectedly strong. It expanded 3% in the second quarter, much higher than the 2.3% Dow Jones estimate, and Magnificent Seven earnings are handily topping estimates. Much has been discussed about the decline of American exceptionalism, but, for now, the U.S. is still the queen bee. The Federal Reserve holds interest rates. The Federal Open Market Committee voted 9-2 on the decision — the first time since late 1993 that multiple governors cast "no" votes. Chair Jerome Powell said the Fed still needs to see the effects of tariffs on inflation. India to pay 25% tariffs on exports to the U.S. On top of that, Trump said Wednesday that the South Asian country will also face a "penalty" for dealing with Russia. Separately, South Korea has reached a deal with the U.S. that will see it subject to a 15% tariff rate, Trump announced. Meta Platforms and Microsoft beat earnings expectations. Year on year, Meta's revenue grew 22%, while that of Microsoft increased 18%. During extended trading, Microsoft shares jumped more than 8% to put the company's market cap above $4 trillion. U.S. stocks are weighed by Fed conference. The S&P 500 fell Wednesday. Asia-Pacific markets mostly declined Thursday. Shares of Samsung Electronics retreated after the firm reported a 93.8% year-over-year plunge in profit. Chinese markets fell on disappointing data on the country's manufacturing activity in July. [PRO] Investors are aggressively borrowing money to buy stocks. It's a sign of market exuberance, according to Jim Reid, head of macro and thematic research at Deutsche Bank, who added that this pace was last seen during market bubbles. Trump's tariff deadline is near. Here's a look at countries that have a deal — and those that don't Come Friday, the world will have to contend with higher tariff rates from the Trump administration, raising the specter of even more economic uncertainty. For most countries, that can of worms has been kicked twice down the road, from "Liberation Day" on April 2, to July 9, and now to Aug. 1. Here are where things stand in global trade. —
