Bahrain: 2% tax on remittances is rejected
Bahrain - The Shura Council has, once again, rejected a legislation that would have imposed a two per cent tax on each expatriate remittance, asserting that the 'disastrous' plan would only lead to money laundering.
Financial and economic affairs committee chairman Khalid Al Maskati yesterday said the bill would have a negative impact on the economy and encourage blackmarket and unauthorised cryptocurrencies.
He said MPs had overlooked several factors while approving the legislation in Parliament.
'This disastrous legislation will only reduce remittances made through official channels in favour of illegal money transfer systems,' Mr Al Maskati said during the weekly session yesterday.
In January, Parliament insisted on imposing the levy more than a year after the proposal was unanimously rejected by the Upper Chamber of the National Assembly – following a previous unanimous approval by MPs.
A joint vote of the National Assembly will be scheduled on the issue.
A joint vote has not been taken since 2002 to resolve disputed legislations, which means the topic would likely be put on hold until new MPs and Shura members in 2026 decide to take it up for reconsideration.
Mr Al Maskati further explained that the proposed legislation contradicted mutual and international agreements and conventions and would harm plans to attract investments.
'For instance, adopting the legislation would mean breaching the Unified Arab Investment Agreement which disallows imposing any restrictions – whether administrative, legal or financial – on Arab capital and investments,' he said.
Committee rapporteur Sadiq Al Rahma said the negatives far outweighed the positives and that the proposal was impractical.
'The expected revenue from two per cent tax is low and doesn't constitute as proper government income, while the damage to revenues from other related avenues would be grave,' he added.
'Around 72pc of expats earn less than BD200 a month and they will seek alternative illegal channels to send money.
'It means that either employers will have to increase wages or increase the cost of service.
'Besides, the move could encourage money laundering and result in losses for money transfer agencies, leading to a sequence of other disastrous outcomes.'
Member Ali Al Aradi said legislations are introduced to solve problems and foreign remittance wasn't a problem.
'I have been asking myself, why did MPs propose 2pc and not 0.5pc or 1pc or even 5pc – it is because the legislation was introduced without a comprehensive study,' he said.
Member Abdulla Al Nuaimi said approval of the legislation could lead to Bahrain becoming a haven for fraudsters.
'Instead of focusing on resolving issues related to foreign manpower and associated costs, MPs are putting emphasis on remittances as if it is the main problem,' he said.
Finance and National Economy Ministry officials, represented by the National Bureau for Revenue, earlier said the levy contradicted the basic principles of freedom of money transfer. It also violated the concept of tax as such levies should be inclusive, without anyone being singled out, which was not the case with this legislation, they added.
'The move will have a negative impact on the economy, in general, and the financial and commercial sectors, in particular,' said ministry officials.
'Imposing such a tax would cause massive damage as it will lead to the emergence of illegal transfer channels.
'The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund have, in numerous studies, shown that countries that took the approach have faced trouble controlling transfers and we do not want the same situation here.'
The officials added that such taxes wouldn't be paid by workers and would be forced on sponsors, which would add to the burden on businessmen.
'Such taxes will hugely affect expatriates in leadership positions in companies and banks in Bahrain and it could even lead to them moving to other countries,' they added. 'Bahrain is working towards being a more competitive regional hub. There are also companies that make regular transfers every day, in bulk, and such tax is just illogical and frustrating for them.'
Copyright 2022 Al Hilal Publishing and Marketing Group Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (Syndigate.info).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
8 hours ago
- The National
Lebanon's new government wins praise for first 100 days but there is a long road ahead
It is vital to look both ways now when crossing Riad Al Solh, a street in downtown Beirut between the parliament and the Grand Serail. In a highly secured zone, for years the only vehicles allowed through were those belonging to Lebanon 's military forces, MPs and the convoy of parliament speaker Nabih Berri racing to attend sessions. Now Riad Al Solh resembles a busy street again, as cars and motorbikes jostle for space. The area was closed off in 2019 amid a wave of anti-government protests, and concrete barriers were erected. While the wall was pulled down in 2022, restrictions still applied in the once-vibrant area that in recent years resembled a closed off fortress. The decision to reopen the area in a bid to restore life 'in the heart of the capital' was taken by Prime Minister Nawaf Salam and his new government, which came in following the election of President Joseph Aoun in January. It may seem like an almost inconsequential move in a country that already had such deep-seated problems even before Israel's war last year reduced vast swathes of Lebanon to rubble. But it was a step by the country's new leaders seeking a break from the past and trying to rebuild trust with a population reeling from economic crises, deep divisions, corruption and weak governance. Elected to fanfare, and led by the mild-mannered former ICJ head judge Mr Salam, how is the government performing 100 days after the cabinet gained parliament's confidence? 'It's not about being flashy' Diplomats and humanitarian officials have praised the government's practical steps in the face of the mighty tasks ahead. Multiple western diplomatic sources said they were optimistic about the Lebanon's new government and its genuine effort to make reforms, despite the pressure on it. 'It's not about being flashy,' said a senior humanitarian official in the country. 'It's about good realistic governance.' The source spoke of an increased climate of trust when dealing with the new government compared to its predecessor. 'It does have accomplishments it can be proud of,' Karim Bitar, a professor of international relations at Beirut's Saint Joseph University, said. He cited breakthroughs in the Beirut blast investigation, new appointments to the judiciary, the successful holding of municipal elections, including in areas where Israel continued to bomb, as well as the passing of a banking secrecy law and progress on reforms demanded by the International Monetary Fund to secure a $3 billion loan. The investigation into the 2020 Beirut port blast had been stalled by repeated legal impediments. Now it has not only resumed but the lead investigator has had his powers, which had been stripped by his own boss, fully restored. 'It seems the prosecutor is satisfied with the conditions under which he can act,' a senior government official told The National last month, noting that the investigation had resumed weeks after the arrival of a new government. The Lebanese Army has increased its deployment in south Lebanon as required by the Hezbollah-Israel ceasefire deal last year. Despite that, Israeli attacks on the south continue and they remain entrenched in five points of Lebanese soil. The humanitarian source gave the example of education as a sector that has long been underfunded and reliant on foreign aid. New operating procedures allow the monitoring of teacher and student attendance and the financial management of schools. Small steps admittedly, but this helps to improve confidence in institutions and allows for a stronger argument for investment in a sector long reliant on donors. The basic salaries of teachers have also been increased. While still less than before the economic crisis hit, the current pay level is more sustainable and not fuelled by ad hoc short-term measures, the source said. Daunting task ahead But while there is optimism and some progress, the task ahead is daunting. Hezbollah remains very much armed and a potent threat, despite the push to constrain it. Israel continues to bomb south Lebanon daily and occupy five points. On Thursday night, Israel sent thousands celebrating Eid Al Adha in Beirut's southern suburbs fleeing when it carried out multiple air strikes on the area. And there is no reconstruction plan for a country which needs at least $11 billion to rebuild. The reality is that 100 days are not long enough to undo so many years of damage, especially for a country whose economic crisis in 2019 was blamed on decades of financial mismanagement and corruption by the ruling elite. Gone are the heady days of 2018 when annual GDP was around $55 billion. Now it is less than half that. The billions of dollars of depositors' savings are still stuck in banks with no real plan to recover them. In the autumn, a major investor conference will take place in Beirut, where its hoped that international players will be shown that 'Lebanon is back in business'. But in a country where the effects of disastrous financial mismanagement, corruption and deep rotted instability are constantly felt, how can those from the largest institutions to the smallest business owner be convinced? 'There is no easy answer,' Economy and Trade Minister Amer Bisat told The National. He left his job in New York as the global head of emerging markets at the world's largest asset manager BlackRock to take up his cabinet role this year. 'We have to be realistic, there is no button we can push to go back. It's thorny and complicated.' Observers are also cautious. While progress is promising, it has been slow in some areas or non-existent in others. Crucially, with parliamentary elections only a year away, the cabinet has only around 12 months of its mandate left. 'Definitely the government is trying to do its job, it's arguably one of the best governments [in recent years],' said Prof Bitar. 'However, this government has a life expectancy that is relatively short.' While the senior humanitarian source was full of praise for the new ministers, they conceded that the deep-rooted state bureaucracy is still a nightmare. Bold, almost vague, promises by Mr Salam to finally implement the 1989 Taif Accord and respect the constitution have not happened. So while the government could be remembered as one that made important changes, it is one that has only so much time left. There are no guarantees Mr Salam will be Prime Minister after next year's elections. However, it is likely the traditional ruling parties will still be represented in parliament, and there are no guarantees that the well-intentioned steps this government has taken will be continued. 'I don't think that small and quick steps will bring back the confidence of investors,' said Mr Bisat. 'What will bring it back will be that investors know we are fixing these issues. 'I am certain of that, I am certain that if we do our jobs and [meet our] obligations, we will be able to bring the economy back. But we need to convince investors we are doing our homework. 'The good news is we've started, especially through the working plan that the Prime Minister, President and government has put forward of how we will address these files.'
Sharjah 24
8 hours ago
- Sharjah 24
Sharjah Ruler continues to receive Eid Al Adha greetings
His Highness received congratulations on this significant religious occasion from sheikhs, senior officials, citizens, residents, tribal and religious community members, as well as representatives of educational institutions and dignitaries from across the country. Prayers for health and national prosperity The well-wishers expressed sincere congratulations and blessings, praying to God Almighty to return the occasion with good health and continued well-being for His Highness, greater prosperity for the UAE, and goodness and blessings for the Arab and Islamic nations. Dignitaries and officials in attendance The reception saw the presence of Sheikh Faisal bin Khalid bin Sultan Al Qasimi; Sheikh Abdullah bin Mohammed Al Thani, Advisor at the Ruler's Office; Sheikh Khalid bin Abdullah Al Qasimi, Chairman of the Sharjah Ports, Customs and Free Zones Authority; Sheikh Khalid bin Essam Al Qasimi, Chairman of the Department of Civil Aviation; Sheikh Salem bin Abdulrahman Al Qasimi, Chairman of the Ruler's Office; Sheikh Mohammed bin Humaid Al Qasimi, Chairman of the Department of Statistics and Community Development; Sheikh Majid bin Sultan Al Qasimi, Chairman of the Districts Affairs Department; Sheikh Saeed bin Saqr Al Qasimi, Deputy Chairman of the Ruler's Office in Khorfakkan; Sheikh Haitham bin Saqr Al Qasimi, Deputy Chairman of the Ruler's Office in Kalba; Sheikh Sultan bin Abdullah Al Thani, Director of the Department of Civil Aviation; a number of sheikhs, His Excellency Abdul Rahman bin Mohammed Al Owais, Minister of Health and Prevention, His Excellency Rashid Ahmed Abdulla bin Al Shaikh, Chairman of Al Diwan Al Amiri; heads of government departments and a multitude of citizens.
Sharjah 24
8 hours ago
- Sharjah 24
Hamdan bin Mohammed receives Eid Al Adha well-wishers
Eid greetings from dignitaries and officials Their Highnesses were greeted by sheikhs, dignitaries, ministers, and senior civilian and military officials who offered congratulations and blessings on the occasion of Eid al-Adha. Prayers for leadership and national prosperity Well-wishers prayed for the continued good health and well-being of His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Vice President, Prime Minister of the UAE, and Ruler of Dubai. They also prayed for further progress and prosperity for the UAE under its wise leadership. Military and government leaders extend Eid wishes Sheikh Hamdan and Sheikh Mansour also received Eid greetings from commanders of the Armed Forces, Dubai Police, State Security, General Directorate of Residency and Foreigners Affairs, Dubai Civil Defense, and members of the judiciary. Community members offer blessings Eid al-Adha greetings were also extended by heads of government departments, tribesmen, citizens, and members of the Arab, Islamic, and international communities residing in the UAE. The occasion was marked by wishes for peace and prosperity for the UAE, its leadership, its people, and the wider Arab and Islamic world.
