Ian Bailey's solicitor welcomes any breakthroughs from advanced DNA testing in Sophie Tuscan du Plantier case
Exhibits being tested include the flat rock and large cavity block found at the scene and Ms Toscan du Plantier's dressing gown, leggings, vest and boots.
It is hoped that that any evidence obtained will allow Forensic Science Ireland to make comparisons with DNA samples from some 10 people identified as suspects during the original Garda investigation.
Speaking to RTÉ's This Week, solicitor Frank Buttimer said his former client had 'voluntarily provided DNA to establish his innocence' many years ago.
He described it as 'extraordinary' and 'worrying' that any alleged link or connection could be proposed given the passage of time and the fact the late Mr Bailey is 'not around to defend his name'.
Asked whether the information should be made public in the event Mr Bailey's DNA is found at the scene, Mr Buttimer said: 'I'm sure that in certain quarters there would be a rush to provide such information.
"Because in my belief, and certainly in my experience, that within certain sections of the police, there is still this ongoing belief that there is some kind of a link or connection between Mr Bailey and the crime that he has denied throughout his life from the time onwards that it happened, but I suspect that that would certainly emerge into the public domain for one reason or another.
He said there has 'always been a rush to put Mr Bailey's name out there as being connected with this offence in certain quarters'.
Mr Buttimer said there would be legal implications in the event that a suspect is identified.
"Insofar as Ian Bailey is concerned, we have this thing in Irish law called the presumption of innocence. Ian Bailey is presumed innocent by the State of Ireland,' he said.
ADVERTISEMENT
"He was never prosecuted, as we know, a completely spurious case was taken against him in France, where he was found guilty, but that was a predictable event.
"Were it to be the case that DNA points the finger in some other quarter, perhaps the French who were so vigorous in their pursuit of him might take time to reflect upon what happened to Ian Bailey during the course of his life."
He said Mr Bailey was 'always hounded and pursued over the 27 or 28 years from the time of that dreadful crime to the time of his death, it destroyed his life.'
Asked whether the DNA testing could provide a breakthrough in the case, Mr Buttimer said his understanding is that the technology has not been tested in the Irish courts.
"The one thing that would be of concern to me would have been the idea that he's just not around to defend himself, if there was any suggestion of any connection between him and the sampling.'
He said DNA evidence can be 'challenged' in certain circumstance and it is 'not the be all and end all of criminal investigation and forensic assessment'.
"I would absolutely say that every avenue should be pursued of any inquiry that's available to get to the truth of this appalling crime,' he added.
"It's a stain on on us, really, and it's a stain on our policing and our system. And if anything can be done, even at this late stage, I would absolutely welcome that.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
2 hours ago
- Irish Post
New hopes in identifying Sophie Toscan du Plantier's killer
GARDAÍ investigating the 1996 murder of French filmmaker Sophie Toscan du Plantier are awaiting new forensic analysis that could, for the first time, point definitively to her killer. The Garda Serious Crime Review Team has been working with Forensic Science Ireland (FSI) and US-based specialists M Vac Systems to re-test key exhibits from the near 30-year-old case. The M-Vac process, first developed in the early 1990s to detect bacteria, has since been adapted for use in criminal investigations. It sprays a sterile solution onto a surface while simultaneously vacuuming it back up, dislodging and collecting DNA material that may be trapped in rough or porous textures — surfaces where standard swabbing often fails. This summer, the technique was applied to items central to the murder scene, including a rock and a concrete block believed to have been used in the killing, as well as Ms Toscan du Plantier's clothing and footwear. Investigators hope that any viable DNA will allow comparisons with samples taken from suspects and other persons of interest during the original inquiry. Ms Toscan du Plantier, 39, was found dead outside her holiday home near Schull, Co Cork, on 23 December 1996. She had been beaten to death. Ian Bailey, an English journalist living locally, was twice arrested but never charged, and consistently denied involvement in the crimes. He died last year. A 2001 review by the Director of Public Prosecutions found no forensic evidence linking Bailey to the crime scene. The Irish Times reports that the gardaí say that all the exhibits have remained in Ireland during the review, despite reports suggesting they had been sent abroad for testing. They have declined to comment on whether the M-Vac process has produced a complete DNA profile, saying it is too early to draw conclusions, according to The Irish Times. The technology has been credited with solving long-unsolved murders in the United States, including cases from the 1970s and 1990s, where DNA was successfully recovered from items such as rocks and fabrics decades after the crimes. Death in West Cork ON DECEMBER 20, 1996, Sophie Toscan du Plantier embarked on a solo trip to her holiday home near Schull in West Cork. Three days later her beaten body was found outside her holiday. After several weeks of investigations without tangible results or leads, and despite no forensic or reliable witness evidence, Manchester-born Ian Bailey, a former journalist, came under suspicion. Bailey, who died in January 2204 of a suspected heart attack, always expressed his innocence, denying any knowledge of the crime. He never stood trial in Ireland. The Director of Public Prosecutions (in Ireland) ruled that insufficient evidence exists to convict. But a French court found him guilty of murder and in his absence — he refused to leave Ireland — sentenced him to 25 years in prison. What is the M-Vac system? THE M-Vac system is a specialist DNA collection tool developed in the early 1990s to detect bacterial contamination in the food industry. It has since been adapted for forensic use, particularly in cases where evidence may be embedded in rough or porous surfaces. The device works by spraying a sterile solution onto the surface while simultaneously vacuuming it back up. This action creates turbulence — loosening microscopic traces of biological material such as skin cells, blood, or saliva — which are then captured in the fluid. The collected solution is filtered and concentrated for DNA analysis. Because it can draw material from deep within textured surfaces, the M-Vac has been used successfully in historic and complex investigations where traditional swabbing techniques produced little or no result. Cases in the United States have seen the technology recover DNA from rocks, fabrics, and other difficult materials decades after crimes were committed. See More: Ian Bailey, Sophie Toscan Du Plantier, West Cork
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'Do you want to die?' Man's chilling words before shooting Irish mum
An Irish woman who was shot by her ex-partner in an attempted murder-suicide was told to go to his home to collect their child's belongings following their break-up, an inquest in Australia has heard. Eileen Gibbons, from Mayo, was shot in the stomach by Ralph Donald, her ex-partner, who said to her 'Do you want to die?' in a domestic violence-related attack at a house in Millner in Darwin in October 2023. After shooting her, Ralph took his own life in the tragedy. The inquest into Mr Donald's death in Darwin, which opened on Monday, heard that on October 3, 2023, Mr Donald contacted Ms Gibbons and told her to collect their child's belongings at his home address in Millner. About 6pm, Ms Gibbons arrived with their young daughter in the back seat. Mr Donald's mother greeted the pair and took her granddaughter inside the home while Ms Gibbons had a conversation with Mr Donald's brother, Charles. During this time, Mr Donald carried and kissed his daughter for the last time. Without warning, Mr Donald then exited the house to look inside his vehicle before returning to his bedroom. From there, he collected his Marlin .30-30 rifle and some rounds from his gun safe. Moments later, he was face-to-face with Eileen in the backyard and said to her 'Do you want to die?' Ms Gibbons turned to run but was gunned down with a single round. When the rifle flashed, Charles ran to the scene and shouted 'What are you doing?' at his brother before attending to Ms Gibbons, who was bleeding from the abdomen. What followed was 'an act of enormous bravery', according to Peggy Dwyer SC. Placing himself between his brother and the wounded woman, Charles noticed Mr Donald had started to reload his weapon Fearing for Ms Gibbons, Charles grabbed the bleeding mother and dragged her out of sight. When Charles heard a second gunshot, he thought the round was meant for him or Ms Gibbons, but would find out it was not. Charles then took it upon himself to administer first aid to Ms Gibbons while he also dialled emergency services and his other brother, Angus, for help. In a bid to secure the site, he went to the body of his brother and threw the live weapon under a nearby car. Eileen Gibbons who was shot and seriously injured in Darwin, Australia pictured in her hospital bed with her daughter Silvia as she is visited by her mum Eileen and aunt Marian Langan from Castlebar. (Image: Supplied) Speaking from Ireland via video link at the inquest, Ms Gibbons recalled the early stages of her troubled relationship. '(Ralph and I) were in a relationship almost immediately and I noticed (he) could raise his voice and there would be some arguments – I let that go on a number of occasions,' she said. 'Over time it escalated, but I would say that from very early stages there were initial warning flags that his behaviour wasn't acceptable.' The inquest heard Mr Donald never physically assaulted Ms Gibbons, but the relationship grew more 'toxic', leading to their separation shortly after the birth of their child. Ms Gibbons told the inquest Mr Donald was under 'immense' stress, including financial, and struggled to get on top of his alcohol abuse. Eventually, Ms Gibbons and her daughter were constantly relocating to escape the environment. 'Were you effectively homeless?' NT Coroner Elisabeth Armitage asked her. 'Yes,' she replied. Set for five days, the inquest is expected to shed light on the circumstances leading up to the attempted murder-suicide and the measures which were taken to protect Ms Gibbons and her daughter. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gardaí take samples to try and identify ‘alien DNA' found on Sophie Toscan du Plantier's boot
A Garda cold case team reviewing the investigation into the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier (39) have begun taking DNA samples from retired gardaí and others to try to identify unknown DNA found on one of murdered woman's boots. Officers from the Garda Serious Crime Review team have drawn up a list of approximately 12 people who could have come in contact with Ms Toscan du Plantier's body following its discovery by neighbour Shirley Foster at her home at Toormore, near Schull, Co Cork, on December 23rd, 1996. Ms Foster alerted her partner, the late Alfie Lyons, and he notified gardaí and Sgt Gerard Prendeville and the late Garda Billy Byrne proceeded to the scene and cordoned off the area pending the arrival of colleagues from Garda District HQ in Bantry. [ 'We await with interest': Family of Sophie Toscan du Plantier supportive of fresh DNA tests in murder inquiry Opens in new window ] Garda technical experts took swab samples from Ms Toscan du Plantier's body and clothing as well as from a rock and concrete block used to bludgeon her to death, but forensic scientists were unable to find any DNA on the exhibits other than Ms Toscan du Plantier's own DNA. READ MORE But in October 2011, a team of French forensic scientists from the Institute de Recherche Criminelle de la Gendarmerie Nationale came to Ireland as part of a police team dispatched by investigating magistrate, Judge Patrick Gachon to examine the case. The French scientists were given access to the exhibits including the clothing Ms Toscan du Plantier was wearing on the night of her murder which included a short cotton top, long-John style underpants, boot-like shoes with socks sewn in the top and a blue dressing gown. The French police did not disclose whether they found anything in their forensic examination but in May 2018, chief suspect in the case, English journalist Ian Bailey revealed the French scientists had found what they described as 'alien DNA' on one of the victim's boots. [ Sophie Toscan du Plantier: Gardaí awaiting results of tests using advanced DNA collection Opens in new window ] Mr Bailey made the discovery that the French scientists had found the 'alien DNA' around some lace eyelets in one of the boots when he and his lawyers were given access to the French file when the French authorities decided to charge him with the voluntary homicide. Mr Bailey repeatedly denied any involvement in the killing and on May 8th, 2018, he told The Opinion Line on Cork's 96FM that 'my hope, my prayer if you will, is that the identity of the real murderer is revealed' before disclosing what he had found in the French file. 'I got all the forensic details. There were over 100 different blood samples collected at the scene – the vast majority of these were from Ms du Plantier (but) there was, apparently, according to the file, what was known as alien DNA – not her DNA. 'Quite clearly that did not match my DNA because I had given samples (to gardaí on New Year's Eve 1996) and they could check it against it,' said Mr Bailey, adding that he was astounded by the revelation that French had found DNA that the gardaí had missed. But now the Garda Serious Crime Review Team have begun gathering DNA samples from retired members of the force who served as either scenes-of-crime examiners or exhibits officers or were present at Ms Toscan du Plantier's postmortem on December 24th, 1996. In cases where the officers are deceased, they have made contact with family members to obtain samples while they have also made contact with the family of the late State Pathologist, Prof John Harbison to obtain a sample as they try to identify the alien DNA. 'We don't know where this DNA came from but we are going through the file rigorously, so we have started with the more obvious possible sources, those who were in contact with Ms Toscan du Plantier's body, gardaí, the pathologist, mortuary staff in a bid to identify it. 'The team are currently about halfway through the process in terms of the people they want to test so they will see what that yields but if they don't get a match, then they will review where they will go in terms of broadening out their inquiries,' said an informed source.
