Education activist Makaneta urges universities to rein in graduation stage 'chaos'
Makaneta's comments follow instances of graduates bringing traditional weapons such as knobkerries and assegais on stage, often incorporating them into elaborate celebratory dances.
While acknowledging the deep cultural roots of such expressions, Makaneta said the trend could pose a risk to the safety and dignity of the event.
'As we celebrate the achievements of graduates it is essential to reflect on the conduct of waving knobkerries and assegais at graduation ceremonies,' he said.
'While we understand the importance of cultural expression and celebration, we cannot ignore the concerns raised by the presence of these objects on stage.'
Graduation ceremonies across the country have become increasingly lively, with cheering families, singing and traditional dancing now a familiar feature. Makaneta warned that certain actions could disrupt proceedings and make others feel unsafe.
'Waving knobkerries and assegais can be perceived as intimidating or threatening and it is our responsibility to ensure everyone feels safe and respected.'
He emphasised that these traditional items could lead to 'unnecessary disruptions and delays', affecting the ceremony's flow and the experience of others in attendance.
'We encourage graduates to rather use their traditional weapons in the comfort of their homes where they will have plenty of time instead of delaying others on a graduation stage.'
Though Makaneta stressed cultural pride remains an integral part of South African identity, he drew a line between celebration and disorder.
'We love African celebration but some of the things we see on the graduation stage are no longer celebration but chaos,' he said.
'Graduation should be a sacred moment. Graduates should be encouraged to respect the stage and respect others waiting for their names to be called.'
Makaneta appealed to universities to develop clear guidelines that uphold cultural expression while ensuring the safety and dignity of graduation ceremonies.
'Traditional dancers must also respect the families who have travelled long distances to witness the graduation ceremony of their child. Let us not turn beautiful moments into disasters.'
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
6 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Livestock, rooibos and tortoises: Farmer conserves threatened species
In win for biodiversity, the The Lokenburg conservation servitude, concluded with landowners Nelmarie and Herman Nel, who farm sheep, cattle and rooibos tea, on their 4 500 hectares in the Nieuwoudtville district of the Northern Cape, ensures permanent protection of tortoise habitat. A conservation servitude is a legally binding agreement that protects land for conservation, permanently. This model blends farming and conservation, 'proving that biodiversity and livelihoods can thrive together', the EWT said of the farm that has been occupied by the same family for six generations. The farm received its title deed in 1774, and is also the only one to host a dwelling built by each one of the six generations that have lived on the property. The speckled dwarf tortoise, measuring just 6cm to 10cm, occurs only in scattered remnant patches of habitat from the West Coast inland to Namaqualand. Their survival is precarious: they mature slowly, females lay only one to two eggs after many years, and hatchlings are vulnerable to predators such as pied crows. 'We are currently working in quite large areas with various tortoise species and then obviously we want to conserve the environment in which they are found,' said 'For us it is quite important to get landowners involved in the process and to be the stewards basically for the species and then obviously all the associated biodiversity on the properties.' Specific tortoise conservation management areas have been designated on the farm, where targeted management actions and development restrictions will be in place. 'We've got designated areas where we want to make sure we can monitor and that's just over 1000ha specifically for the habitat for the speckled dwarf tortoise,' Brink said. 'That allows us to have conservation interventions, along with the landowners, to make sure that nothing detrimental is done to the habitat for this species.' Additionally, species-focused conservation actions include management of the pied crow population in the area, which is The conservation servitude is in one of the most botanically diverse regions in South Africa. Nieuwoudtville, in the Bokkeveld, a winter rainfall region in the transition zone between the fynbos and succulent Karoo biomes, is known for its unique vegetation and springtime floral splendour. The farm has a large variety of plant species given that it straddles four bioregions: North-West fynbos, the Western fynbos-renosterveld, the Karoo renosterveld and the Trans-escarpment succulent bioregions. The succulent Karoo biome, which has the greatest number of succulent flora on Earth, is one of only two arid zones that have been declared global biodiversity hotspots. More than 6 000 plant species, 40% of which are endemic and 936 of which are listed as threatened, occur in the biome. In 2023, the Nels became members of the South African Essential Oil Producers and have a vision to further expand the essential oil branch, to make it sustainable and economically viable for the benefit of the local community and environment, the EWT said. The family also aims to preserve their land for future generations, through sustainable farming practices alongside the preservation of the rich biodiversity on their land. The Lokenburg Biodiversity Management Plan, concluded between the Nels and the EWT, is the primary tool for the management of the Lokenburg conservation servitude. 'It also makes provision for capacity building, future thinking and continuity of management, enables the management of the servitude in a manner that values the purpose for which it has been established, and ensures, through collaboration, that no detrimental forms of development, or agricultural activities, will take place within the focal areas,' the EWT said. South Africa has more tortoise species than any other country. Nine of the 13 Southern African tortoise species are found in the arid Karoo, where they face multiple threats such as habitat loss and degradation, predation, illegal collection and uncontrolled fires. Brink says of all the threats they face, the biggest is the degradation of their habitat. 'Obviously they occur in specific areas; they have specific needs for them to breed and only lay one egg after 10 years, for instance. They take a long time to mature, they have to get up to an older age and then they have one to two eggs and it's not necessarily every year that they can lay an egg,' 'If there's no food and they go searching for food, they With this servitude, there are six generations living on the land 'so there's an incredible love and passion for the environment and what they have on their farm. It's quite unique to get that, when you've got that generational history, going back to 1774 for the farm itself, so it's been so lovely to work with them,' she added. For her part, Nelmarie Nel said: 'With all the recorded descriptions of the beauty of our surroundings and the privilege of still living at Lokenburg six generations later, while continuing with traditional sheep, cattle, and rooibos tea farming, it is very dear to our family to preserve our environment with its incredible biodiversity for as long as possible. 'At Lokenburg, we see ourselves not just as farmers but as 'stewards of conservation.' We hope to make a positive contribution to our community, economy, and environment through this,' Nel said.
Mail & Guardian
3 days ago
- Mail & Guardian
Protected: G20 dialogue puts women at the heart of South Africa's just transition.
Oxfam South Africa Interim ED, Ms. Nkateko Chauke (left), with Keynote Speaker Ms. Lebogang Mulaisi from The SA Presidential Climate Commission. This content is password protected. To view it please enter your password below.
The Herald
4 days ago
- The Herald
Search for aerobatics pilot to resume off Durban beach on Friday
Family, friends and colleagues have paid tribute to a well-known aerobatics pilot who is missing after his light aircraft crashed into the sea on the Durban beachfront on Thursday. Search efforts for the pilot — whose name is known to TimesLIVE — of the light aircraft which crashed at Durban's Battery beach was called off on Thursday evening due to poor visibility and will resume on Friday. KwaZulu-Natal SAPS spokesperson Col Robert Netshiunda said the seasoned pilot from Johannesburg, who also flew commercial airlines, was the only one in the aeroplane. Friends and family posted tributes to the pilot, who participated in the 'Missing Man Formation' as a tribute to the late Capt Lorrie Raath at the Virginia air show on Sunday. 'Nothing ever prepares you for this. I can't believe it. Rest in peace, my friend. It was always an honour sharing the skies with you. A gentleman and an aviator of note,' said one friend. Another said it was a 'sad day for South African aviation with the passing of a legendary aerobatic pilot. Our condolences to his family and friends.' The National Sea Rescue Institute (NSRI) said the ZS-AEC Extra 300 plunged into the sea performing its final display at about 1.45pm, prompting an extensive multipronged search operation throughout the day. NSRI Durban duty coxswain Lorenzo Taverna-Turisan said an extensive search operation co-ordinated by the Aeronautical Rescue Co-ordination Centre took place at North Beach about half a nautical mile offshore after the aircraft accident. Taverna-Turisan said NSRI rescue craft from Durban and Umhlanga were nearby when the incident occurred. 'Despite the immediate and swift response and the ongoing extensive sea and air search operation, including police divers, metro police divers, a police helicopter and the NSRI rescue craft, there remains no signs of the missing man.' Police search and rescue divers conducted underwater searches for the pilot along with three NSRI rescue craft. Additional support was provided by various paramedics, eThekwini municipal lifeguards, eThekwini fire and rescue services and aviation authorities. The accident happened during a display and air show for the youth and public organised by the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) after a three-day aviation global summit — held at the Durban ICC. KwaZulu-Natal Transport MEC Siboniso Duma said the accident was an 'unfortunate end to a successful event'. 'The search and rescue team and other emergency services are doing everything possible to find the missing person.' He confirmed the family had been informed but maintained the matter was a sensitive issue that was also guided by strict protocols associated with the aviation authority but confirmed that proper analysis would be provided at the right time. Themba Thabethe, from the Accidents and Incidents Investigation division at CAA said high tides had scattered some debris from the plane over several kilometres just hours after the accident but confirmed that authorities were working on recovering it. 'There has been some wreckage that has been recovered and we're trying to reconstruct the accident scene. What makes our lives difficult is that because of the tide, some of the debris has already spread about 2km to 3km away.' Police and the CAA will investigate the accident. TimesLIVE
