Fuel tank left open caused large diesel spill at Christchurch prison
Photo:
Luke McPake / The Wireless
About 14,000 litres of diesel has leached into the ground at Christchurch Men's Prison, after the hatch of a fuel tank was left open.
The mistake,
first reported by RNZ on 6 June
, has potentially affected the water supply of neighbouring properties
Corrections custodial services commissioner Leigh Marsh said the overflow was identified on 25 May, when diesel was found in cable pits and underground infrastructure, but there was no evidence it had seeped into the ground at that time.
Contractors had been investigating an issue with diesel heating and a backup system in a block at Christchurch Men's Prison.
"Both Christchurch Men's and Christchurch Women's prison run off bore water, so we were very concerned if it was to go to soil that that water would be impacted so we immediately started testing, and there was no evidence to say immediately that that had gone to ground," he said.
WorkSafe, Fire and Emergency and Canterbury Regional Council were notified.
Daily testing of the prison bore water supply and surrounding soil began on 26 May and was extended to a 200-metre radius outside the prison perimeter two days later.
The samples remained clear until 6 June, when a sample taken from a bore on 28 May from 200 metres outside the prison perimeter came back positive for dissolved hydrocarbon, while the other samples remained clear.
Corrections then visited 40 properties south east of the prison and advised eight to stop using water from their private bores for drinking, cooking or feeding stock or animals and use water from other sources until the potential contamination was addressed. It remained safe for showering and washing.
Marsh said the majority of properties visited were vacant or were using the town water supply, not bore water.
If a property had not been visited by Corrections, or had a letter left in their absence, they were able to continue using their bore water, he said.
No diesel had been detected in the bores which supplied the prison, or in the stock water in the prison farms and there was no impact on prison operations, Marsh said.
There are two 20,000 litre fuel tanks at Christchurch Mens Prison, which hold the majority of its diesel, and a 1000-litre local tank which powers the heating of most of its buildings.
The large tanks were being replaced by Downer, with a temporary fuel tank installed while the work was carried out.
"It looks like that installation hasn't gone as planned and as a result, the diesel has gone from the big tank into the smaller tank, which feeds some of the prison systems.
"The large tank was able to continuously feed into the small one and it appears that an inspection hatch on the top of the smaller tank hadn't been attached properly."
Marsh said about 16,000 litres of diesel had flowed out of the tank, and only about 2000 litres were able to be recovered.
On 30 May, it was found diesel might have soaked into the ground through a crack in the floor of a switch room.
"It appeared that some of the diesel had gone into the ground at that point but our water testing continued to show that it was clear," he said.
Marsh said advice from the Canterbury Regional Council, Fire and Emergency and other scientific advisors was the diesel spill had not gone beyond that building, but as a precaution it began taking soil samples from a wider area, predominantly focused on where geologists said water would potentially flow underground.
The incident was being investigated and the exact cause was not yet known, but it appeared to be related to the installation and change over to a new fuel tank, he said.
Both tanks had since been lifted and checked for leaks, but the programme to replace the tanks had been stopped while the investigation was carried out.
A Downer spokesperson said it took immediate action following the diesel spill to determine the cause of the incident and to maintain site safety.
"We will continue to work closely with the New Zealand Department of Corrections, along with all relevant local stakeholders and regulatory authorities to manage the response, undertake thorough testing, and determine next steps."
Marsh said Corrections was focused on tracking any contamination and ensuring residents had the appropriate information if it appeared in their bores.
Advice it received from geologists and scientists was a layer of clay under the soil in the region would limit the spread of the fuel.
"It won't pass through the clay, so it's not going to hit down to the aquifer, but it's how much it moves along above that into what is quite a granitey, gravelly soil from the clay up."
The regional council said Corrections was leading the response to the diesel spill with its support and that of Health New Zealand.
General manager of regulatory implementation Paul Hulse said monitoring work was ongoing to understand what, if any, impact there might be from diesel entering the groundwater.
"As a precaution, on Friday 6 June Department of Corrections notified residents downgradient of the site with advice from Health New Zealand to not use water from their private bore for domestic use," he said.
Of the 40 properties visited, some were vacant and some were on town supply so were not affected.
Affected households should discontinue using their private supply for irrigation and stock use, he said.
Residents would be kept informed, including when they could resume use of their private bore.
WorkSafe said it was making enquiries to understand the circumstances of the incident.
Taumata Arowai did not respond to RNZ's request for comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Supreme Court judges grill Crown in David Tamihere appeal
David Tamihere. Photo: RNZ Supreme Court judges have grilled the Crown case in double convicted murderer David Tamihere's appeal in the High Court at Auckland. Tamihere was convicted in December 1990 of murdering Swedish tourists Urban Höglin and Heidi Paakkonen. His lawyers are appealing an earlier Court of Appeal ruling that found a miscarriage of justice but upheld his convictions. Crown lawyers began there submissions on Tuesday, with lawyer Fergus Sinclair giving the panel of judges background about Tamihere's movements through the bush around the Coromandel Peninsula, and the discovery of Höglin's body. Crown prosecutors Fergus Sinclair and Rebecca Thomson. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The Crown case at the original trial was that Tamihere was living in the bush when he murdered the couple near Crosbies Clearing north of Thames. "We know Mr Tamihere's last two trips involved spending time in the Wentworth Valley, and on trip one, spending days on that Eastern side," Sinclair said. "Multiple witnesses established that." Evidence had been presented at trial that two trampers identified Tamihere as a man they encountered at Crosbies Clearing with a young woman. Sinclair said Tamihere partly acknowledged and partly fictionalised trips he had taken around the area at trial, to conceal that he had been near to where Höglin's body was found. "Trip one, he said, North from Thames, has spent a long time around the Coromandel area, but he didn't," he said. "He went South, then East into the Wentworth, back the same way after more than a week." The second trip, Sinclair said, Tamihere claimed to have again gone North from Thames to the 309 Road, then down the main road almost to Thames, but swerved up Tararu Creek Road to where the couple's car was to steal it, but this too was wrong, instead claiming Tamihere had gone South and back to the Wentworth Valley. "It's not possible to forget that your last two journeys were to an entirely different part of the region," Sinclair said. "So much time spent in a completely different place, in the opposite direction." Sinclair referenced the conclusion reached by the Court of Appeal. "Mr Tamihere lied to conceal his presence in the Wentworth Valley, and did so because he knew police might find evidence there," he said. "The only evidence is the body, the only reasonable conclusion is that Mr Tamihere knew about the body." Chief Justice Dame Helen Winkelman sits alongside other Chief Justices. Photo: POOL/Stuff Sinclair faced scrutiny from the judges regarding whether claims Tamihere had lied had been put to him at trial. "It's a fundamental issue with the Crown's case," Chief Justice dame Helen Winkelmann said. "You're taking us and saying 'Mr Tamihere lied'. Statements are made contextually, lies, as juries are instructed, must be assessed contextually, if it's said to be a lie it must be put to the witness that it's a lie, it must be part of the case that it's a lie... "What are we to make of the fact that these things that you are now saying are lies, were to a greater or lesser extent not pursued at trial?" she asked. Sinclair said this was the fresh evidence exercise. "The issue is, does it disclose a miscarriage, and it is the Crown responding to a defence theory," he said. "The body is found, we now see more things, does it give rise to a miscarriage that is the issue." More scrutiny was put on the Crown's case by Justice Sir Joe Williams, who said their case came down to whether or not Tamihere had lied. "His lie, you say, is the thing that binds all of this together, Crown stands or falls on that lie," he said. "Without it you lose." David Tamihere's lawyers, James Carruthers (L) and Murray Gibson (R). Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Earlier on Tuesday, Tamihere's lawyer James Carruthers asked the question if his trial would have turned out differently if a fundamental error had not occurred. He quoted a case which said questions needed to be asked on what course a trial would have taken, if errors had not been made. "It's interesting to ask here what the course of the trial might have been like had it not started off in completely the wrong direction," Carruthers said. "And as we can see from the Crown's amended case, it would have taken on an entirely different complexion." Tamihere served more than 20 years of a life sentence in prison before being released on parole in 2010. He has always denied even meeting the pair and there have been lingering questions around the convictions. In 2020 the then Governor General, on advice from former Justice Minister Andrew Little, granted Tamihere a rare Royal Prerogative of Mercy. The case was referred back to the Court of Appeal to rule on whether there may have been a miscarriage of justice. That court, in July last year, found there was - but upheld Tamihere's murder convictions because there was evidence beyond reasonable doubt he murdered the tourists. This, in turn, was appealed to the Supreme Court which is hearing the case now. The hearing continues on Wednesday. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Litter of puppies dumped in Taranaki's national park, DOC investigating
The seven puppies were found by a member of the public in roadside vegetation in Te Papa-Kura-o-Taranaki. Photo: DOC / SUPPLIED A Department of Conservation investigation is underway after a litter of seven puppies was found dumped in Te Papa-Kura-o-Taranaki. The puppies, estimated to be about six weeks old, were discovered by a member of the public in the national park on 10 August. DOC ranger Cameron Hunt said aside from the disregard for the puppies' welfare, releasing pets or other animals on to conservation land was an offence under the Conservation Act and the National Parks Act. DOC could issue an infringement notice or prosecute anyone found responsible for bringing a domestic pet into national park or conservation land. Hunt said the man who found the puppies was heading up Manaia Rd to the maunga to enjoy a recent snowfall when he spotted something black and white moving in the roadside vegetation. "At first glance, he thought it was a puppy but carried on driving. He then turned around and headed back to confirm his suspicions - and discovered the litter of seven puppies." The puppies were found in Te Papa-Kura-o-Taranaki. (File photo) Photo: Supplied/DOC The puppies - thought to be a collie-working dog cross breed - were handed over to the SPCA, where they were vet checked, vaccinated and treated for worms. They were in extremely good condition and had been well fed prior to being found, but would not have survived the night in the freezing snowy conditions. Cameron said the puppies would eventually be made available for rehoming. "Someone made a deliberate decision and effort to abandon these puppies in the national park, and to do so would've required some sort of vehicle making a brief stop on the roadside. "We're hopeful anyone who saw what happened will contact us and share any information such as the make, model and colour of a vehicle - and better still a registration plate - or possibly descriptions of people they saw." He urged anyone who knew about the dumping of the puppies to contact 0800 DOC HOT and quote CLE-Works number CLE-9642. Any information passed on will be treated confidentially. Earlier this month, DOC publicised the case of a Northland woman who flagrantly breached the "no pets" rules and photographed herself with her six dogs in Tongariro National Park. One of the photographs showed the woman and a dog in front of a "no dogs" sign. In August 2022, DOC visitor centre staff encountered visitors carrying jacket-wearing cats in Te Papa-Kura-o-Taranaki , and in December 2023 a man was pictured with a domestic pet cat in the national park. Cameron said keeping pets such as cats, rabbits, ferrets, and others out of protected spaces, was essential to protect endangered species and pets were safe. "Domestic pets can spread diseases our wildlife has not been exposed to and cannot be protected from. These can devastate our taonga and the ecosystems they depend on. Dogs, in particular, pose a serious threat to kiwi and whio, both of which are found in Te Papa-Kura-o-Taranaki." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Gunshot victim taken to Palmerston North Hospital in serious condition
Inspector Ross Grantham Photo: RNZ / Alexander Robertson Extra police are on patrol in Levin after a man turned up to a healthcare centre with a gunshot wound to his thigh and shots were fired from a car at a house on Monday. Manawatū Area Commander Inspector Ross Grantham described recent shooting events in the area as "brainless violence" that put people at risk of harm. The gun-shot victim was transferred to Palmerston North Hospital in a serious condition and Grantham said enquiries were ongoing. More to come Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
