logo
Love without a BTO flat: Tough housing choices facing mixed-nationality couples in Singapore, Money News

Love without a BTO flat: Tough housing choices facing mixed-nationality couples in Singapore, Money News

AsiaOnea day ago

With Singapore being more cosmopolitan in recent decades, and how connected we are globally, it is getting more common to see Singaporeans dating foreigners.
I belong to this 'minority' demographic, and dating a foreigner is possibly the least logical thing I've done in my life; because it forced me to realise one of the most painful realities of dating someone foreign for love: You're not eligible for a shared BTO flat as a married couple — foreigners can't own an HDB flat, so only one of you is the owner; and there are restrictions besides. Mixed-nationality couples are becoming more common
In 2022, about 20 per cent of marriages were between a Singaporean and a foreigner; a number that has stayed broadly similar over the past few years. So I find it quite surprising that today, there are still not many options for couples in this demographic.
I wouldn't really call us a minority, when we're nearly a quarter of every year's data set. A bigger piece of the pie compared to Singaporean-PR couples!
Anyway, back to the topic, for Singaporeans marrying foreigners, let's take a look at the choices of property I have considered, and why my partner and I ended up not going for them. Resale HDBs (Singapore)
The most common pathway for home ownership for Singaporean-Foreigner couples is resale flats. While there are still some eligibility requirements, it's not as restrictive as a BTO unit. Only Singaporeans can own the flat, and the foreign spouse will require a Long-Term Visit Pass* or a Work Visa* of at least six months; they must be listed as an Essential Occupant.
Before Covid-19, this was a possible reality. We were a bit too young to get married and commit to a mortgage together, so this was actually just Plan A for us to settle down in Singapore in a few years. But after Covid-19, we saw a huge spike in resale flat prices, and we were effectively priced out of the resale market:
Resale HDB prices were around $417 psf at around April 2020, the peak Covid period when Singapore had its Circuit Breaker. As of April 2025, the average resale flat price is around $649 psf.
So year after year, it became clear that resale would not be an option for us; not without derailing our long-term financial plans.
Plus, there was also an issue of non-equitable ownership, as my partner would not have been able to officially own the flat until he got his Permanent Resident (PR) status in Singapore. Since getting a PR is a shot in the dark with unclear requirements and timelines of acceptance, we also decided not to bet on the outcome. It would result in potential unfairness and insecurity, which might strain our relationship.
*Subject to HDB's terms regarding non-resident spouses 2-Room Flexi BTO / SBF (Singapore)
The next option we thought to try was to wait till I reached 35 years old, to get a 2-Room Flexi BTO. This was far from an ideal situation as we wanted to start a family, so a 2-Room Flexi wouldn't suffice. It also means waiting almost a decade to have this option available to us, and until then, we would have no other housing option available to us other than renting or living with my parents.
There's also the income ceiling of $7,000; which I unfortunately exceeded by just a little bit. This option then became impossible. Incidentally, when you apply for a 2-Room Flexi BTO with a non-citizen spouse, you can only look in non-mature areas. Frankly that's not very practical, as it means a less developed location, with limited room for starting a family.
So at this point Singapore started to feel too restrictive for housing, and we felt like we were bending and twisting just to meet HDB's public housing requirements. Privatised ECs (Singapore)
ECs are privatised after the 10th year, and are treated as fully private properties; so technically, we could buy and co-own ECs; but only out of their privatisation period. But if resale flat prices are too high, then the same can certainly be said of ECs, which are even pricier. Fully private properties were also out of the question. Renting (Singapore)
I've been renting in Singapore since I got my right to vote, and the rental market really isn't that bad if you value flexibility, and the ability to live in areas that you want (near work, near favourite hawker stalls, etc.)
Given the high prices in 2025, renting might not be a bad option for couples who are still figuring out their finances. And since Singaporean-Foreigner couples don't have that much access to public housing options in Singapore, it can be good to rent and test-drive the neighbourhoods you might eventually want to live in.
One downside is that Singapore repealed its rent control acts way back in 2001, so your rental rates will depend on what you can "lock-in" with landlords. I have heard horror stories of landlords increasing the rental prices of their property, forcing them to move or accept a higher monthly rate.
Also, while there is some flexibility in renting, it also takes some level of commitment. Getting married and applying for a Long Term Visit Pass (LTVP) for my partner was the first step, before we could even consider renting together. It's a lot of paperwork and hassle, to end up paying potentially high rental rates.
But there's an advantage to being married to a foreigner, which opens up a new avenue
Being married to a foreigner usually means you have options to live overseas and have a new life, outside the tiny red dot.
So if moving overseas is something that can be considered, it might not make much sense to commit to a property in Singapore, especially if your finances aren't ready for it yet. So while renting, you don't just need to be considering places in Singapore as well; you can use that time to also look at housing options in your partner's home country (or countries.)
And so, we landed on our final decision. Foreign property (Overseas)
When all other options in Singapore had exhausted themselves, we became the advocate for foreign property as a viable option for homeownership. Depending on where your spouse is from and what their country's laws are on property and land ownership, the restrictions on Singaporeans will look a bit different.
After talking about financial goals and how to maximise the results from our options, we have decided to get property overseas first as the barrier of entry is lower (cheaper properties even in Europe), and there are far fewer restrictions on property ownership overseas.
While property appreciation is not as high, we are in less debt and under less financial stress. In this uncertain economy, where we cannot be sure if our careers will last past our mid-thirties, I am very glad we don't have a 25-year Singaporean housing mortgage, but a manageable and humble European property that can serve us while we build our financial security. If you must stay and find a home in Singapore though…
It would be best if both of you were already married, and that your foreign spouse has employment in Singapore. This is important because, when applying for bank loans to finance your property purchase, the bank is going to take a look at your taxable take-home incomes.
If your foreign spouse is not employed in Singapore, the bank could lower the Loan-To-Value (LTV) ratio. You may be able to borrow 20 to 30 per cent less, depending on the bank in question. Also due to compliance issues, banks may not be able to use all of a foreigner's overseas income sources (e.g., even if your foreign spouse is getting dividends, rental income, or other monies from sources abroad, banks cannot always use it for loan application purposes.)
The upside is that home loan rates in Singapore can be much lower than in some other countries (around 3.75 per cent per annum as of 2025).
If a family is not yet in the picture, or you're lifelong singles, a 2-room flat, as mentioned above, might also be viable. But if you're a Singaporean-Foreigner couple who aren't married yet, note that you must be married within three months of key collection. Always consult relevant government bodies or a conveyancing lawyer before buying
Housing in Singapore is a pretty restrictive industry where there are many rules and laws in place; moreso for HDB than for private properties.
So please take our words at face value and when in doubt, go consult the relevant authorities before proceeding with your purchases. Be wary of so-called "grey area" issues to circumvent laws, such as trying to buy an HDB flat without declaring overseas property ownership. This could get your flat confiscated. Be open to your options
Don't be too sold on the Singapore dream where we go to university, graduate, get a job, get a BTO, start a family, plan for retirement… not all of us fit into that cookie cutter or want to, and that's okay. Don't feel guilty over circumstances you can't control.
A lot of us are currently stuck at successfully passing the BTO phase, and then what? We just don't move on with life? Nah, we just need to figure out alternatives and be open to our options. And that's my best advice on navigating life and personal finance.
Don't let the system determine your future for you.
[[nid:718869]]
This article was first published in Stackedhomes .

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer
Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer

New Paper

time4 hours ago

  • New Paper

Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer

Singaporeans are replacing their phones every 2.7 years, contributing to some 2.9 million mobile phones being stowed away, a new study shows. But one Singapore start-up is hoping to change this and keep phones in circulation for five years here. This will be even longer than the global smartphone replacement cycle of 3.5 years on average. Cinch plans to meet this target by renting out instead of selling the devices to consumers, ensuring that the returned units at the end of the rental period are refurbished to get a new lease of life with another user. "We're trying to extend the useful life of these devices beyond the average refresh rate," said Mr Mahir Hamid, chief executive and co-founder of Cinch, which commissioned the study to better understand consumer behaviour. Its study, conducted between late 2024 and early 2025, involved interviews with firms that handle e-waste and used devices, as well as a survey of 500 Singapore-based respondents. Fresh from raising US$28.8 million (S$37 million) in funding led by Monk's Hill Ventures, Cinch is now actively pursuing consumers, letting them pay a monthly fee to rent the latest premium models of phones, laptops and other devices. Cinch will also foot 90 per cent of the repair cost of devices damaged due to accidents. For instance, the latest Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge with 512GB storage is available from Cinch for a rental fee of $70 a month over two years. At the end of two years, consumers would have paid $1,680. The same model can be bought from Samsung for $1,808. An Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max with 512GB storage can be rented from Cinch for $120 a month over 12 months. This will amount to a total of $1,440 at the end of the year. The same model costs $2,199 upfront from the Apple store. Customers can also buy direct from Samsung and Apple with an interest-free instalment plan, but it would require them to have a credit card from specific banks such as DBS, OCBC or UOB. "There is a massive segment of the population for which a $2,000 to $3,000 purchase can be a significant proportion of their monthly salary," said Mr Hamid. "A subscription model allows them to access the premium device." Cinch, which has been operating here since 2023, has been leasing mostly to businesses such as those in the retail, logistics, information technology and public relations sectors. Around 10,000 devices such as laptops, smartphones and tablets have been leased, most of which were returned and refurbished for a second or third customer. "Every refurbished unit needs to be as good as new," said Mr Hamid. "If it doesn't meet our standards, it doesn't go back into circulation." He said that all returned devices undergo a professional diagnostic sweep and complete data wipe so users do not have to worry about privacy leaks. Customers can buy their rented devices from Cinch if they wish, but it would likely cost more than buying from retailers such as Shopee or Lazada, said Mr Hamid, urging users to rent instead. Cinch has also partnered with waste management firm Alba Group since the start of 2025 to collect and recycle devices that can no longer be refurbished for new leases. During recycling, valuable materials such as precious metals and plastics are extracted from the e-waste. Singapore generates more than 60,000 tonnes of e-waste a year, according to a report by the National Environment Agency in 2018. This is equivalent to 73 mobile phones disposed of per person in Singapore. Slowing down the device replacement cycle will reduce the overall volume of electronic waste that needs to be collected, sorted and processed, an Alba spokesperson told The Straits Times. "Alba supports efforts like Cinch's to keep electronic devices in circulation for a longer period, as it aligns with our mission to reduce e-waste and promote a circular economy in Singapore," said the spokesperson. The leadership team of Cinch, which has been operating in Singapore since 2023. PHOTO: CINCH The leasing of laptops, smartphones and tablets has become a standard practice among some businesses, as it allows them to access the latest technology without incurring huge upfront costs. Leasing is also a way of reducing depreciating assets. Leasing firms typically cover a device's configuration, maintenance, repair and eco-friendly disposal. Telcos Singtel and StarHub have been leasing devices to businesses since 2020 and 2021 respectively, while M1 does so only as part of a more comprehensive suite of tech services. Singtel started leasing devices to consumers in 2018, but ceased the programme in 2022. Mr Keith Leong, Singtel's managing director of enterprise, said consumers find that they get better value from buying devices bundled with mobile plans. But businesses in sectors such as government, infocomm and aviation continue to lease from Singtel. While the device leasing meets the specific needs of some businesses, many consumers still choose to buy devices as it gives them full ownership and control, which can be cost-effective over the long run, said Mr Leong. "Ultimately, both models provide valuable pathways to equip a mobile workforce effectively," he said. Other rental firms such as Circular and have also been in the market since 2021 to wean consumers from device ownership. Apart from renting out phones, laptop, and gaming consoles, also rents out home appliances such as digital door locks and washing machines. Leasing an iPhone 16 Pro Max with 512GB storage space would cost between $69 and $82 a month for two years from Circular, depending on the phone's condition. The same model would cost between $92 and $99 a month for two years from Cinch's adviser Arvin Singh said that Netflix and Grab have proven that ownership of storage discs and cars, respectively, is not essential. "Netflix for many years now has disrupted ownership of DVDs and hardware... So I think it's not a strange concept for consumers. When it comes to phones, maybe a bit more education is required," said Mr Singh. However, Ms Tracy Tsai, vice-president analyst of consulting firm Gartner, said that phones cannot be compared to DVDs, cars or bicycles as phones carry confidential personal data. The cost-effectiveness of renting also comes into question if users upgrade frequently, she added. "But if users want to chase the latest phone every year, renting might be less of an issue."

Top lawyer and former Rajah & Tann managing partner Patrick Ang dies at 61
Top lawyer and former Rajah & Tann managing partner Patrick Ang dies at 61

Straits Times

time9 hours ago

  • Straits Times

Top lawyer and former Rajah & Tann managing partner Patrick Ang dies at 61

Rajah & Tann Singapore mourns passing of Senior Partner Patrick Ang. Photo caption: Patrick Ang, 61, Senior Partner of Rajah & Tann Singapore and Vice-Chairman of Rajah & Tann Asia. He was Managing Partner of Rajah & Tann Singapore from 1 April 2019 to 31 March 2025. Photo credit: Rajah & Tann Singapore Top lawyer and former Rajah & Tann managing partner Patrick Ang dies at 61 SINGAPORE - Mr Patrick Ang, the former managing partner of 'Big Four' law firm Rajah & Tann (R&T), has died at age 61. The law firm confirmed his passing in a statement on June 14. Mr Ng Kim Beng, R&T managing partner, said: 'R&T has lost a celebrated lawyer, a selfless leader, and most of all, a cherished and deeply loved friend and colleague.' 'His sudden and unexpected passing leaves an immense void,' said Mr Ng. Mr Ang was a top insolvency lawyer with three decades of experience. He was best known for his handling of high-profile collapses including the likes of China Aviation Oil, Hin Leong, Lehman Brothers and Swiber. The top lawyer was also the first Singaporean and the fourth lawyer from Asia to be inducted into the American College of Bankruptcy, a global organisation for leading bankruptcy and insolvency practitioners. Mr Ang became managing partner of R&T in 2019, taking over from Senior Counsel Lee Eng Beng. During his tenure, he led the law firm's decade-long regionalisation drive under Rajah & Tann Asia, a regional network of law firms spanning across Southeast Asia and beyond. His leadership was recognised with the Managing Partner of the Year award at the Asia Legal Business South-east Asia Law Awards in 2024 and 2025. Just earlier this year, Ang handed the reins over to Mr Ng, an arbitration lawyer, while remaining vice-chairman of Rajah & Tann Asia. He leaves behind his wife and three daughters. In a tribute on June 14, Minister for Law Edwin Tong called Ang a 'formidable legal mind' with an 'unwavering stout heart for Singapore'. 'In my earlier years of practice, we often found ourselves on opposite sides of the table in complex restructuring matters,' wrote Mr Tong. 'Even then, I found it impossible not to respect him.' 'Patrick had a remarkable way of thinking several steps ahead – calm, strategic, incisive. He approached even the most difficult negotiations with integrity and grace, and never stole a match with an unfair point.' Mr Tong said Ang also helped with drafting Singapore's emergency Covid-19 (Temporary Measures) Bill and was recognised for his help with the Public Service Star (Covid-19) National Day Award. 'His passing is not only a profound loss to his firm, but also to the legal profession and to Singapore, which he served with quiet resolve, unwavering strength and deep purpose,' the minister said. THE BUSINESS TIMES Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer
Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer

Straits Times

time14 hours ago

  • Straits Times

Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer

Old mobile phones collected by waste management firm Alba Group, which are sent for sorting and recycling. PHOTO: ALBA GROUP Singapore start-up on a green mission to keep mobile phones in use for longer SINGAPORE – Singaporeans are replacing their phones every 2.7 years , contributing to some 2.9 million mobile phones being stowed away, a new study shows. But one Singapore start-up is hoping to change this and keep phones in circulation for five years here. This will be even longer than the global smartphone replacement cycle of 3.5 years on average. Cinch plans to meet this target by renting out instead of selling the devices to consumers, ensuring that the returned units at the end of the rental period are refurbished to get a new lease of life with another user. 'We're trying to extend the useful life of these devices beyond the average refresh rate,' said Mr Mahir Hamid, chief executive and co-founder of Cinch , which commissioned the study to better understand consumer behaviour. Its study, conducted between late 2024 and early 2025 , involved interviews with firms that handle e-waste and used devices, as well as a survey of 500 Singapore-based respondents. Fresh from raising US$28.8 million (S$37 million) in funding led by Monk's Hill Ventures, Cinch is now actively pursuing consumers, letting them pay a monthly fee to rent the latest premium models of phones, laptops and other devices. Cinch will also foot 90 per cent of the repair cost of devices damaged due to accidents. For instance, the latest Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge with 512GB storage is available from Cinch for a rental fee of $70 a month over two years . At the end of two years, consumers would have paid $1,680 . The same model can be bought from Samsung for $1,808 . An Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max with 512GB storage can be rented from Cinch for $120 a month over 12 months . This will amount to a total of $1,440 at the end of the year. The same model costs $2,199 upfront from the Apple store. Customers can also buy direct from Samsung and Apple with an interest-free instalment plan, but it would require them to have a credit card from specific banks such as DBS, OCBC or UOB. 'There is a massive segment of the population for which a $2,000 to $3,000 purchase can be a significant proportion of their monthly salary,' said Mr Hamid. 'A subscription model allows them to access the premium device.' Cinch, which has been operating here since 2023 , has been leasing mostly to businesses such as those in the retail, logistics, information technology and public relations sectors. Around 10,000 devices such as laptops, smartphones and tablets have been leased, most of which were returned and refurbished for a second or third customer. 'Every refurbished unit needs to be as good as new,' said Mr Hamid. 'If it doesn't meet our standards, it doesn't go back into circulation.' He said that all returned devices undergo a professional diagnostic sweep and complete data wipe so users do not have to worry about privacy leaks. Customers can buy their rented devices from Cinch if they wish, but it would likely cost more than buying from retailers such as Shopee or Lazada, said Mr Hamid, urging users to rent instead. Cinch has also partnered with waste management firm Alba Group since the start of 2025 to collect and recycle devices that can no longer be refurbished for new leases. During recycling, valuable materials such as precious metals and plastics are extracted from the e-waste. Singapore generates more than 60,000 tonnes of e-waste a year , according to a report by the National Environment Agency in 2018 . This is equivalent to 73 mobile phones disposed of per person in Singapore. Slowing down the device replacement cycle will reduce the overall volume of electronic waste that needs to be collected, sorted and processed, an Alba spokesperson told The Straits Times. 'Alba supports efforts like Cinch's to keep electronic devices in circulation for a longer period, as it aligns with our mission to reduce e-waste and promote a circular economy in Singapore,' said the spokesperson. The leadership team of Cinch, which has been operating in Singapore since 2023. PHOTO: CINCH The leasing of laptops, smartphones and tablets has become a standard practice among some businesses, as it allows them to access the latest technology without incurring huge upfront costs. Leasing is also a way of reducing depreciating assets. Leasing firms typically cover a device's configuration, maintenance, repair and eco-friendly disposal. Telcos Singtel and StarHub have been leasing devices to businesses since 2020 and 2021 respectively, while M1 does so only as part of a more comprehensive suite of tech services. Singtel started leasing devices to consumers in 2018 , but ceased the programme in 2022. Mr Keith Leong, Singtel's managing director of enterprise, said consumers find that they get better value from buying devices bundled with mobile plans. But businesses in sectors such as government, infocomm and aviation continue to lease from Singtel. While the device leasing meets the specific needs of some businesses, many consumers still choose to buy devices as it gives them full ownership and control, which can be cost-effective over the long run, said Mr Leong. 'Ultimately, both models provide valuable pathways to equip a mobile workforce effectively,' he said. Other rental firms such as Circular and have also been in the market since 2021 to wean consumers from device ownership. Apart from renting out phones, laptop, and gaming consoles, also rents out home appliances such as digital door locks and washing machines. Leasing an iPhone 16 Pro Max with 512GB storage space would cost between $69 and $82 a month for two years from Circular, depending on the phone's condition. The same model would cost between $92 and $99 a month for two years from Cinch's adviser Arvin Singh said that Netflix and Grab have proven that ownership of storage discs and cars, respectively, is not essential. 'Netflix for many years now has disrupted ownership of DVDs and hardware... So I think it's not a strange concept for consumers. When it comes to phones, maybe a bit more education is required , ' said Mr Singh. However, Ms Tracy Tsai, vice-president analyst of consulting firm Gartner , said that phones cannot be compared to DVDs, cars or bicycles as phones carry confidential personal data. The cost-effectiveness of renting also comes into question if users upgrade frequently, she added. 'But if users want to chase the latest phone every year, renting might be less of an issue.' Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store