I would pay not to go to Thatcher the Opera
Oh. My. Goodness. Can you think of anything weirder than
Mrs T
, an opera based on the premiership of Margaret Thatcher?
But that's what's in store. It's the centenary of her birth this year and so someone had the genius idea of commissioning an opera, presumably on the basis that if a musical worked for Eva Peron – why not
Mrs T, the opera
? I'm thinking of a succession of pussy cat bows, statement handbags and firm coiffures for the mezzo soprano in the title role, Lucy Schauffer. And I am longing to see who gets cast as Denis.
But an opera is musical drama. It's not history. When it is history, like say,
Mind you, the composer, Joseph Phibbs, is not one for the rollicking, singalong melody. I think we're safe betting that the audience won't come out of the production, humming the tunes.
The librettist is Dominic Sandbrook, the historian and one of the two
There's nothing particularly discordant about the combination of Mrs Thatcher and classical music in itself. She wasn't a philistine, though she did once tell
The Guardian
that she particularly liked Handel on account of 'all those marvellous tunes'. Miriam Gross wrote a fascinating essay in
The Oldie
about researching her musical tastes and it turned out that she told Isaiah Berlin that she once took part in the Oxford university production of Prince Igor. Whaddya know? Plus she was in the university Bach chorus.
But the trouble with opera is that there isn't much room for nuance. It's good on murder, suicide, passionate trysts and dying of consumption and incarceration in a pyramid. It would be less good on policy arguments about privatisation, Commons debates and party conferences, though I can see that there's scope for good chorus action in a depiction of the miners' strike.
An operatic character is either bad or good, like a cartoon, because the music has to send out a message; he or she is rarely a matter of light and shade. And Mrs T was a complex and interesting character; she was divisive and combative and destructive in many of her policies, but she was also kind, principled and rather religious.
Dominic Sandbrook is too good an historian to be partisan, to give us a caricature, but there's a limit to what the form will allow.
I am, therefore, rather dreading
Mrs T, the opera
. It is unlikely to work as opera and it can't work as history.
It may however be good fun.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
9 hours ago
- BBC News
Adam Curtis takes us into a world gone Shifty
The documentary filmmaker Adam Curtis gives a guide to some of the key moments from his new series his documentaries, Adam Curtis has taken us everywhere from Russia during the breakdown of the Soviet Union, in TraumaZone, to the war in Afghanistan, in Bitter Curtis, whose work has been called "dazzling" and "terrifying" by critics, has set his sights on Britain at the end of the 20th century for the five-part BBC series time Curtis's signature style sees him use a bizarre array of archive clips to explore, he says, how "life in Britain today has become strange - a hazy dream-like flux in which no-one can predict what is coming next".In Shifty, clips of the major players of the era – Prime Ministers Margaret Thatcher, John Major and Tony Blair – exist alongside surreal moments sourced from the BBC's extensive archives, like avant-garde hairdressing competitions, suburban line dancing parties and children hot-wiring a the uninitiated, his documentaries can feel impenetrable, so we spoke to Curtis to curate and explain some of the key clips from the new also suggested a title for each clip that perfectly places viewers into the strange and murky world of Shifty. 'One of the few moments of honesty' One section details the rise of the musical remixes in the 1980s, and its societal implications – how, in Curtis's words, "we are trapped by a cascade of endlessly replayed images, songs, dreams from the past".However, he admits, "that's the way this series was made, so I'm just as bad. If it's become a prison, I may be one of the jailers."One way Curtis remixes the past is by reusing an interview with Sir Alan Budd that Curtis filmed for the 1992 documentary Pandora's a remarkably honest interview, the one-time chief economic adviser to the Treasury during Thatcher's tenure worries that "the people making the policy decisions… never believed for a moment this was the correct way to bring down inflation."They did, however, see that it would be a very, very good way to raise unemployment, and raising unemployment was an extremely desirable way of reducing the strength of the working class.""I've always been fascinated by that interview that Budd gave," says Curtis. "It's one of the few moments of honesty I've ever had from someone in power like that being interviewed." 'A past that was about to go' As a young BBC employee, Curtis worked on That's Life. The show combined consumer affairs with lighter stories – most famously, a dog that could 'say' the word credits his ability to juggle tragic and comic tones to this early role: "It showed me that you could go from a badly-built housing estate built on poisonous waste ground to a talking dog."In Shifty, clips of societal unrest exist alongside Bruno, a dog who is, according to his vet, "changing his sex" – their male organs disappearing and their female ones says that it was Bruno's owner that drew him to the clip: "The way she's sitting and her hair," he says, "it felt like a past that was about to go."Animals in his work can often represent our secret lives, he says – "they are these creatures who live with us who probably have a lot of hidden knowledge about us."For Curtis, animals also counterpoint what he calls the "highly pretentious" elements of his work: "They just entertain people." 'A tragic figure' In this clip, an archivist at Cambridge University takes one of Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher's handbags out of a box, noting how the bag still smells strongly of her Thatcher's presence can be felt in much of the series, as we see the effects of her policies in the 1980s and 90s. Before Thatcher became Prime Minister in 1979, Curtis argues there was "a collective model of society, where people came together in factories, were exploited, then realised they had power as a collective group."He feels, however, that the closure of industries like mining led to "a society full of fragmented individuals who were powerful in the way they thought about their own desires, but actually on their own were powerless."Despite this, Curtis sees Thatcher as a "tragic figure", who unleashed forces she could not control."She was the last politician who had an idea of how to change the country," he explains. "She wanted to create a society in which politics doesn't have as much effect as it did, and should allow individuals to be loose and free." 'Ever more irrational assumptions' Another recurring character in Shifty is scientist Stephen Hawking, whose theories about multiple universes destabilised how we think about putting together the series, Curtis began to think of Hawking in parallel to Thatcher, he explains."She believed that rationality applied through money would regenerate the country. He believed that the rational power of mathematics will lead you to a unified theory that will explain the whole world."What fascinated Curtis about Hawking was how his seemingly rational theories led him to "ever more irrational assumptions"."When he says that matter is eaten by black holes, other scientists say that cannot be true. So he says there must be other universes where they don't eat the matter, so it balances out. To me, that's absurd."However, Curtis began to be touched by Hawking's humanity, like in a clip when we see him saying goodnight to his child. 'Very good trashy music' One of the threads of Shifty is what Curtis calls "the rise in confidence among people to talk about your own feelings, your own experience".This is shown in one of the documentarian's favourite clips, which sees two boys in Swindon discussing the banning of the song Relax by Frankie Goes to Hollywood due to its sexual imagery. The clip, from one of a series of public access shows which allowed members of the public air time on the BBC in the 1980s, ends with one of the boys out of nowhere adding that the government should legalise their willingness to criticise the BBC while appearing on it, we see a lack of deference to authority that Curtis thinks would have been unimaginable two decades also gave the filmmaker the chance to use the song Relax, one of a number of pop songs that feature in the song is central to the series's idea that the late 20th century in Britain was "wild and extraordinary, and had some very good trashy music in it, but it also unleashed a corrosive force".Shifty is available on BBC iPlayer on Saturday 14 June.
Scottish Sun
12 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Victorian English seaside town with no arcades or loud rides that has one of the UK's best beaches & is loved by celebs
Plus, a UK seaside town crowned top place in the world to take bored kids this summer SANDS GREAT Victorian English seaside town with no arcades or loud rides that has one of the UK's best beaches & is loved by celebs Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A PICTURESQUE town in Devon is home to one of the UK's most beautiful beaches - complete without arcades and rides. The Victorian town of Sidmouth in east Devon has a 200million-year-old coastline, being the gateway to the Jurassic Coast. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 The Victorian town of Sidmouth in east Devon has a pretty beach and even has no arcades Credit: Alamy 4 The town and beach are part of the Jurassic Coast Credit: Alamy What's more is that the town is also loved by celebs including Jeremy Vine and Stephen Fry. Fry stayed nearby the town when starring in the TV adaptation of Jeeves and Wooster. As for Jeremy Vine, the radio presenter got married nearby and spends summers returning to the town. In fact, when he set his first whodunnit novel called Murder on Line, in the town, he included a scene where a wave sweeps a radio station manager and her just-sacked DJ into the water together. Vine noted in The Guardian: "What I love most about Sidmouth is that it feels like a town going places. "It's chintzy in places, drab in others, but it feels real. "And real by the sea is a different kind of beauty." But celebrity visitors also extended to literary legends and royalty. Jane Austen - famous for her novels Pride and Prejudice and Northanger Abbey - spent the summer of 1801 in Sidmouth. The town had become a popular spot among high society due to its spa waters, mild climate and calming atmosphere. Trendy English seaside town has rooftop bar that 'feels like the Med' During the summer Austen was in Sidmouth, she had a fling with a young man - however, it had a tragic end. Her suitor caught typhus and died, ending the fleeting relationship. Austen isn't the only writer to have spent some time in the town - JRR Tolkien, the creator of Lord of the Rings and the Hobbit also holidayed at the seaside resort. Tolkien used to stay at Kennaway House, which is rumoured to be the location where he wrote the first parts of Lord of the Rings. And in the town itself, one of the pubs is believed to have inspired Aragon's introduction. Later, in April 1908, Beatrix Potter was also in Sidmouth. On family holidays, the popular children's writer would stay at the Hylton - where there is now even a plaque commemorating her stays. Potter used to talk of the views, her local walks in the area and also the atmosphere - which helped her to complete the Tale of Little Pig Robinson. 4 Celebrities including Jeremy Vine and royalty such as Queen Victoria have visited the town Credit: Alamy As for royalty, Queen Victoria (who at the time of visiting was Princess Alexandrina) also frequented the town. In 1819, she stayed at Woolbrook Cottage - now known as the Royal Glen Hotel. However, the holiday was not particularly happy as her father became ill and died. For things to do in Sidmouth, there is plenty of choice, with the beach undoubtedly being the main attraction. This year Sidmouth Town Beach was awarded a Blue Flag for the sixth year in a row - recognising the pebble beach as being under excellent management including beach safety and water quality. Being amongst the cleanest beaches in the UK, it is a great spot to go for a dip when the sun is shining before heading into the town and grabbing an ice cream. My own experience of Sidmouth GROWING up, I always associated Sidmouth with 'that place that had donkeys'. This is due to Sidmouth being home to the free-to-visit Donkey Sanctuary that has over 100 donkeys that they have improved the lives of. It's a great spot for children and learning about animal welfare. Away from the sanctuary, I also visited the beach on occasions growing up. Sidmouth is pretty, but I often think people also forget how impressive it is with the dramatic cliffs dating back 200million years. They are part of the Jurassic Coast - which is made of vibrant reed sandstone cliffs from the Triassic period. They are a wonder to see and within the area, there are many places to go and things to do where families can learn more about the Jurassic Coast. But if you aren't done with exploring, you could always head over to Hill View along the coastal walk, which boast amazing views across the sea. One particularly special thing about Sidmouth though, is that it doesn't have any amusement arcades, loud sports bars or dodgy street food vendors. Instead, the places that these would usually be have been filled with galleries and antiques shops, independent retailers and tearooms. To get to the quaint town, from London it takes around four hours to drive. Alternatively, also from London, you could hop on a train to Honiton, taking around two-and-a-half hours before catching a bus from Honiton to Sidmouth. Britain's 'trendiest' beach town is also set for biggest transformation in a decade as fresh plans unveiled. Plus, a UK seaside town crowned top place in the world to take bored kids this summer.
Graziadaily
13 hours ago
- Graziadaily
Sydney Sweeney And Julianne Moore's New Thriller, Echo Valley, Is Out Now – But Is It Worth Watching?
Two of the biggest stars of the moment, Julianne Moore ( Sirens ) and Sydney Sweeney ( Anyone But You ) star opposite each other in the new thriller Echo Valley, directed by Michael Pearce and written by Brad Ingelsby, which is available to stream on Apple TV+. The story follows Kate Garrett (Moore), who works training horses on her southern Pennsylvania farm, when one night her daughter Claire (Sweeney) arrives at her door covered in blood that is not hers, and Kate has to decide what she is willing to do to protect her daughter. The film also stars Domhnall Gleeson, Kyle MacLachlan, and Fiona Shaw. But with a disappointing 50% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, is Echo Valley worth watching? Here's what the critics think. Peter Bradshaw at The Guardian gave the film two stars. 'The film gets mired in some very credulity-stretching stuff about what has to happen when bodies need to be recovered and the twisty finale is overwrought and silly,' he writes. 'The estimable cast all do their utmost but the overall effect is frustratingly implausible.' However, Kevin Maher at The Times called it 'American cinema for adults', awarding Echo Valley four stars. 'It's slightly illogical, yes,' he put, 'but by then we're so invested in the film and so attached to the characters that it hardly matters.' The Financial Times ' Danny Leigh also gave the film four stars. 'I'll take the side of the kind of film that is neither the nth instalment of a franchise, nor fishing for an Oscar, but simply seeks to entertain while also giving you something to chew on,' he reviewed. 'Echo Valley supplies just that.' Elsewhere Gleeson's turn as the film's villain has won praise for his ability to 'successfully create a manipulative monster'. A film fan on X also loved the film writing, 'Went to an early preview screening of #echovalley tonight and I loved it. Julianne and Domnhall are fantastic, and the storyline has so many twists and turns I didn't expect.' Another viewer posted, 'Sydney Sweeney in Echo Valley is magnificent in a visceral role. She displays an emotional intensity that captures the fragility and desperation of her character. Frankly, she is one of the best actresses around these days (though there was never any doubt).' So, despite a poor review from The Guardian and a mixed response (so far) on Rotten Tomatoes, there are plenty of people who have thoroughly enjoyed the film and think the plot is gripping and well-crafted. That means the only way to decide if it's worth watching is to watch it yourself. Echo Valley is available to stream on Apple TV+. Nikki Peach is a writer at Grazia UK, working across entertainment, TV and news. She has also written for the i, i-D and the New Statesman Media Group and covers all things pop culture for Grazia (treating high and lowbrow with equal respect).
