Astronomer Says the Object Approaching Us From Beyond the Solar System Is Not What We Think
While we're only beginning to understand the unusual object, dubbed 3I/ATLAS, the discovery led to widespread speculation, with some scientists suggesting that it may be almost as old as the Milky Way galaxy itself, and billions of years older than our own Sun.
Unsurprisingly, Harvard astronomer Avi Loeb — who has extensively written about 'Oumuamua, the second interstellar object ever discovered, notably hypothesizing that it might have been a relic from an extraterrestrial civilization — has now waded into the discussion.
In a blog post on Medium, he argued that it will take more observations to conclude the nature of 3I/ATLAS, which is likely either a comet or asteroid. However, Loeb didn't rule out the "tantalizing possibility" that it was "sent towards the inner solar system by design" — a conclusion that's already proved controversial.
Loeb chided the editors of Wikipedia and the scientific journal RNAAS for striking the hypothesis from his contributions, showing once again that his theories about extraterrestrial probes visiting our solar system remain as contentious as ever.
The astronomer has remained steadfast in his belief that 'Oumuamua, an interstellar object first observed in 2017, may have been sent to us by an alien civilization, garnering him enormous attention in the media. He has even gone on to hunt for pieces of what he claims may be an alien spacecraft, based on detections of a three-foot, interstellar meteor crash-landing near Papua New Guinea in early 2014, by combing the ocean floor with a modified ship.
In other words, his latest comments about 3I/ATLAS are very much in line with what we'd expect from him.
In his blog post, Loeb announced that he had authored a new paper about 3I/ATLAS' unusual size. Based on its "anomalously bright" nature, the astronomer concluded that the object was roughly 12.4 miles in diameter.
That would make it considerably larger than 'Oumuamua, which only measured anywhere from 330 to 1,300 feet long.
However, those calculations raise more questions than answers.
The interstellar object's ' "size estimate makes little sense for an interstellar asteroid because the interstellar object 1I/'Oumuamua was 200 times smaller, and based on the statistics of asteroids in the Solar system, we should have discovered a million objects of the scale of 1I/'Oumuamua before spotting one interstellar object that is [roughly 12.4 miles] in diameter," Loeb wrote.
"We know that [12.4-mile] asteroids are rare, because non-avian dinosaurs were killed by an asteroid half that size 66 million ago, whereas meter-scale asteroids impact the Earth every year," he added.
However, subsequent observations forced Loeb back to the drawing board. Given the lack of "spectral fingerprints of atomic or molecular gas," 3I/ATLAS likely isn't a comet, as Loeb had initially suggested.
"If 3I/ATLAS is not an asteroid — based on the interstellar reservoir argument in my paper, nor a comet — based on the lack of the spectral fingerprints of carbon-based molecules around it, then what is it?" Loeb asked rhetorically, highlighting his "by design" theory.
Fortunately, there's still time for the scientific community to get a closer look.
"The size anomaly of 3I/ATLAS will be easily clarified by upcoming data," Loeb wrote. As it "gets closer to the Sun, it will get brighter. If it is a solid object without a cometary plume of gas or dust around it, then its brightness will increase inversely with the square of the decreasing distance from the Sun times the square of the distance from Earth."
"The simplest hypothesis is that 3I/ATLAS is a comet and we are missing the spectral features of its gaseous coma because of its large distance from Earth," he added.
But without any observed cometary tail, Loeb suggests there's a chance we could be looking at evidence of an extraterrestrial visitor.
"Let us instead maintain our childhood curiosity and seek evidence rather than pretend to be the adults in the room that know the answers in advance," he concluded."Science does not need to feel like a lecture in a classroom, summarizing past knowledge. It could be far more exciting if the teachers would be willing to learn something new!"
More on 3I/ATLAS: The Interstellar Visitor Hurtling Toward the Center of Our Star System Is Unimaginably Ancient, Scientists Say
Solve the daily Crossword
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
8 hours ago
- Forbes
‘World Will Go Dark On Aug. 2' Story Has Gone Viral — Here's The Truth
A total solar eclipse on July 2, 2019 in Paiguano, Chile. (Photo by) Getty Images What will happen on Aug. 2, 2025? There will be no total solar eclipse on Aug. 2, contrary to posts going viral across social media that suggest otherwise. There are claims that on Aug. 2, 'the world will go dark for 6 minutes' and that it's a 'sight you won't see again for 100 years.' Is it true? Nothing will happen on Aug. 2. For starters, no solar eclipse — now or in the future — can cause the entire world to go dark at once. It's impossible for the whole world to go dark at the same time (Earth always has a dayside and a nightside). What the posts are mistakenly referring to is a six-minute total solar eclipse, which is happening on Aug. 2 — not in 2025, but in 2027. It will bring the longest remaining totality of the 21st century. The sun disappears behind the moon during the Great North American Eclipse on April 08, 2024 in Mazatlan, Mexico. (Photo by) Getty Images On Aug. 2, 2027, a total solar eclipse will affect parts of Europe, North Africa, the Arabian Peninsula and the Horn of Africa. This will be a total solar eclipse with an extraordinarily long totality, but only for those in one specific place. That place is Egypt, with totality lasting 6 minutes 22 seconds close to Luxor, the temple-stewn capital of ancient Egypt. Luxor may be where a lot of eclipse chasers are heading, but there's plenty of choice. The path of totality will, in order of when totality will happen, be seen in southern Spain, northern Morocco, northern Algeria, northern Tunisia, northern Libya, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Yemen and Somalia. According to TimeandDate, 88.9 million people live in that path of totality. Does it go dark during a total solar eclipse? Yes and no. The light levels drop dramatically once the moon blocks all of the sun, but it's more of a deep dusk. But will the 'world go dark?' Hardly — the 2027 total solar eclipse will be visible from a 160-mile (275 kilometers) wide path of totality stretching 9,462 miles (15,227 kilometers). Aerial View of The temple of Hatshepsut near Luxor in Egypt, where a total solar eclipse on Aug. 2, 2027, will bring six minutes of totality. getty Total solar eclipses are predictable. If you come across a particularly long one — such as Aug. 2, 2027 — turn the calendar back 18 years, 11 days, and 8 hours (the time it takes for the moon to orbit the Earth 223 times) and you'll find another one. On Jul. 22, 2009, a totality lasting as long as 6 minutes and 39 seconds was possible in the Pacific Ocean southeast of Japan. It was the longest of the century, but few experienced it as its maximum (and, worse still, most people in China were clouded out). Fast-forward 18 years, 11 days, and 8 hours from Aug. 2, 2027, and you'll get to Aug. 12, 2045, and a very long total solar eclipse across the U.S., the Caribbean and South America. At maximum, totality will last 6 minutes and 6 seconds — near the southeast coast of Florida. All of these eclipses — 2009, 2027 and 2045 — are members of a family of moon shadows called Saros 136. Saros means 'the repetition,' a concept used by ancient Greeks to predict eclipses. Wishing you clear skies and wide eyes.
New York Times
12 hours ago
- New York Times
Massachusetts governor proposes $400 million for colleges, citing federal ‘uncertainty.'
Gov. Maura Healey of Massachusetts announced on Thursday a plan to provide $400 million to support research projects at universities and colleges in the state, in what appeared to be a response to the Trump administration's moves to cut federal funding in higher education. The money, which must be approved by the State Legislature, would be aimed at retaining and creating jobs in research and development. In the Boston area especially, colleges and teaching hospitals that have fueled technological and biomedical advances over decades are cornerstones to the city's economy and identity. The governor's office cited a report by the Donahue Institute at the University of Massachusetts that found that federal research funding in the state supported more than 81,000 jobs. Massachusetts is also home to one of every 10 jobs in research and development in the country, the governor's office said. The Trump administration has sought to strip billions in research funding from schools in the state and around the country, including Harvard, in Cambridge, Mass., as part of what it says is a campaign against antisemitism. The White House has also sought to withhold federal money as a way to correct what it sees as a higher education system that is hostile to conservatives. Harvard has fought back on funding cuts in court, with a decision still pending, while some other schools have joined lawsuits brought by separate groups or reached deals with the administration that would free up the money. Ms. Healey, a Democrat, did not mention Harvard by name in a statement announcing the plan but made a reference to what prompted it. 'In the face of uncertainty from the federal government, this is about protecting one of the things that makes Massachusetts so special,' she said, adding that the state was a global leader in 'innovative research and the discovery of lifesaving cures.' Under Ms. Healey's plan, $200 million would go directly toward supporting research projects at hospitals, universities and independent research institutions. The other $200 million would help cover the costs of research, partnerships and joint ventures at public universities. Jenna Russell contributed reporting.
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Newly spotted comet marks third interstellar object seen in solar system
STORY: :: NASA/ATLAS/University of Hawaii Astronomers are tracking a newly spotted visitor to our solar system. :: K Ly at Deep Random Survey :: Olivier Hainaut et al./European Southern Observatory The object, likely a comet, is named 3I/ATLAS and hails from parts unknown. It's only the third time such an interstellar interloper has been observed in Earth's celestial neighborhood. :: David Jewitt/NASA/ESA/Space Telescope Science Institute NASA said it was first spotted on July 1 by an Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System, or ATLAS, telescope, located in Chile. :: Catalina Sky Survey/D Rankin The object is traveling at a speed of around 37 miles per second from the direction of the center of the Milky Way galaxy, and astronomers agree the presumed comet poses no threat to Earth... It will come no closer than 150 million miles away, about 1-1/2 times the distance between Earth and the sun. However, Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb has made waves in academic circles with his co-authored paper, 'Is the interstellar object 3I/ATLAS alien technology?" :: Catalina Sky Survey/D Rankin In it, Loeb and two other researchers argue that due to other unusual characteristics, it could actually be an alien probe on a mission. :: Olivier Hainaut et al./European Southern Observatory While Loeb concedes the object may in fact be a comet, he argues it's important for scientists not to rule out any possibilities. "The unusual trajectory of this object offers the possibility that it might have been designed so as to have some goals of a reconnaissance mission." MEECH: "It's irresponsible science.' :: NASA/ATLAS/University of Hawaii Karen Meech, a planetary astronomer at the University of Hawaii's Institute of Astronomy, dismisses the idea. 'This is just coincidence, the path that it comes through the solar system. There's a perfectly natural explanation for this. It is behaving like a regular comet. // It's developing a little tail, it's getting brighter as it gets closer to the sun. We know a few things about it, but everyone's intensively studying it..." :: Olivier Hainaut et al./European Southern Observatory 3I/ATLAS will reach its closest approach to the sun around October 30, when it will be about 130 million miles away from our star. :: File The only other such interstellar visitors were objects called 1I/'Oumuamua, detected in 2017, and 2I/Borisov, discovered in 2019. Reuters / NASA/ATLAS/University of Hawaii / CATALINA SKY SURVEY/D RANKIN / DAVID JEWITT/NASA/ESA/SPACE TELESCOPE SCIENCE INSTITUTE / RUBINOBS/NOIRLAB/SLAC/NSF/DOE/AURA / K Ly at Deep Random Survey / Olivier Hainaut et al./European Southern Observatory / ONLINE WEBSITE Solve the daily Crossword
