Budget 2025: The teenagers feeling ignored by government's decisions
Photo:
Supplied
"Do not just invest in stats and numbers, invest in us."
That is the message from a group of teenagers grappling with some of the decisions made by the government in this year's Budget.
They came together along with child advocates, researchers and rangatahi to unpack the budget. with KiwiSaver, pay equity, employment and climate change all top of the discussion.
Save the Children Generation Hope Youth ambassadors opened the post-Budget chat hosted by the Child Poverty Action Group in Tāmaki Makaurau with these words.
"A budget is numbers, but numbers don't heal people, a budget is a promise but promises break without action, a budget is pointless without a plan.
"We've heard the speeches we've seen the headlines roll in; the words roll in like tides the tides that never quite reach the shore."
One of the youth ambassadors is 17-year-old Sonya.
She was concerned about what she feels are important parts of daily life that were missing from the budget.
"There was a lot about infrastructure and funding for big things, but not really the things that matter or the things that impact people on their daily lives.
"Kids that go to school, what are we going to do about buses? What are we going to do about traffic? What are we going to do about families and school lunches?"
One of the big changes affecting rangatahi is the tightening of the job seeker and emergency benefits.
18 and 19-year-olds on those will now have them means tested against their parents' incomes.
Year 12 students at Kelston Boys' High School Uelese and Nikolao are concerned about this.
"Do they know, especially in Polynesian households like our parents, have their own struggles, relying on them for the funding will put more stress and you know, more troubles on our parents," said Uelese.
"Yeah, I think it all goes back to the purpose of the government itself to provide positive outcomes for the general public, whether or not you have stable parents, I feel like everybody deserves what they're promised," Nikolao said.
The issue was of particular relevance for Uelese - whose mother has been impacted by the pay equity reform.
Year 12 Kelston Boys' High School student Uelese speaks at the event.
Photo:
Supplied
While its overhaul will save the government $2.7 billion a year.
The changes mean workers now face a higher threshold to prove they are underpaid due to sex discrimination.
Uelese is worried about how it will affect his mum and dedicated his opening speech to her.
"If my mom can't get ahead, how am I supposed to?
"This year's budget was meant to be about growth, but for so many families, especially those led by women, it feels more like being told to grow something from dry soil.
"You can't cut down the people who carry the load and expect the next generation to rise.
"This budget forgets the people who hold our communities and our children together, women, especially mothers."
Then there is KiwiSaver.
From July, 16 and 17-year-olds are eligible to get the government contribution and requirements for employers to match their deposits will kick in next year.
But the minimum contribution will go up from three percent of wages to four percent over the next three years.
The amount the government is contributing is being halved to a maximum of $261 a year.
The government said the increase in the default amount could leave KiwiSaver members with more than $100,000 in retirement.
But the Labour Party claims not everybody will benefit, especially younger people.
It claims the changes could mean an 18-year-old ends up with $66,000 less for their retirement.
Uelese and Nikolao are disappointed with the change.
"You know, finance is everything it would be good to, like, have that support that they've sort of halved.
"I mean, it's still there, but is half really enough to start something in, in this ever growing society," said Uelese.
The students also said there is one big thing missing in the budget, addressing climate change.
Instead, the government has set aside $200 million to invest in fossil fuel development at gas fields, reduce climate finance to the pacific and clawed back funds for government agencies working on ways to save energy.
Uelese said it was worrying.
"We're really educated on climate change and we know that it's like one of the biggest issues, if not the biggest issue that we're facing right now.
"We actually need to get our butts up and start moving."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
28 minutes ago
- RNZ News
How Jacinda Ardern's ‘groundbreaking' climate law has become ‘a shell'
Jacinda Ardern said climate change was her generation's "nuclear-free moment". Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone When New Zealand passed the Zero Carbon Act in 2019, it was hailed as a world-first - a law with cross-party support that would enshrine climate ambition in law. Paired with the country's first Emissions Reduction Plan and billions of dollars in ring-fenced climate funding, it represented then-Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern's promise to tackle her generation's "nuclear-free moment" head on. Six years on, analysis suggests the law has been hollowed out to little more than a husk. While its legal targets remain, nearly every policy designed to meet them has been scrapped, most without replacement. Data collated by RNZ shows that since it came to power in 2023, the coalition government has repealed, defunded, or delayed dozens of climate initiatives - from electric bus funds to agricultural emissions pricing to subsidies for solar and wind. Officials have been ordered to stop planning for lower car use. Climate scientists have lost their jobs. And this month, a ban on exploration for oil and gas was repealed . "The Zero Carbon Act is a shell," said 350 Aotearoa strategic adviser Adam Currie. "It was supposed to be our lifeboat, but this government is deliberately drilling holes in it." Just a handful of the original policies remain. Instead, the coalition's climate plan leans heavily on a strengthened Emissions Trading Scheme, alongside pledges to double renewable energy, invest in carbon capture, and reduce agricultural emissions through new technology. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has insisted the country is "doing everything we can" to meet its targets, by focusing on the sectors that produce the greatest emissions. Climate change minister Simon Watts (L) with Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and other MPs. Photo: RNZ / Nathan McKinnon But the Climate Change Commission's 2025 monitoring report is now warning the coalition's plan won't be enough. New Zealand is likely to meet its first emissions budget (to 2025), the commission's July report said . But for the second and third emissions budgets, covering the decade to 2035, the commission finds current policies are unlikely to deliver. "In many sectors, there is no clear policy pathway to cut emissions at the pace and scale required," the report said, highlighting agriculture, transport, and energy as risk areas. "More work is needed - and soon - to lay the groundwork for emissions cuts after 2030." The commission was particularly concerned about the lack of plans for gross emissions reductions - actually cutting fossil fuel use - as opposed to relying on forestry to offset emissions. It noted that in the third budget period, 46 percent of planned reductions come from forest removals alone. "There is risk in relying on a single sector for a large proportion of reductions," it said. Delaying real action risked forcing more costly and disruptive changes later, and reduced the burden on future generations, the commission said. The government will formally respond to the commission in October. But Minister for Climate Change Simon Watts said the amendments it had made to the first emissions reduction plan were allowed under the law. "As a government we are prioritising policies that deliver cost-effective climate action for New Zealand," Watts said. "We removed actions that weren't expected to directly reduce emissions and, based on our current projections, we're still on track to meet our first emissions budget." At a time when many governments are backing away from climate goals, National has said - despite pressure from its coalition partners - it will not repeal the Zero Carbon Act. But critics argue that undermining it is no better. "In our view, the Act clearly requires a more ambitious and credible climate strategy - one that is less high-risk and reliant on pine trees," said Lawyers for Climate Action NZ's Jessica Palairet. "The government is also falling short of a core purpose of the Act - to provide a framework for clear, stable climate policy." Labour's climate spokesperson Deborah Russell. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER Labour's climate spokesperson Deborah Russell said the coalition's sole focus on the Emissions Trading Scheme, rather than considering other measures, had rendered the Act largely ineffective. "They're fulfilling the letter of the law in responding to the budgets and doing the plans, but they're not showing how they're going to get the emissions down." The Zero Carbon Act 2019 was not a standalone law - it amended the existing Climate Change Response Act 2002, transforming it from a policy tool into a legislative backbone for emissions reduction. The main function was to set legally binding long-term targets, intended to align with global efforts to limit warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. The Act committed Aotearoa to reaching net zero greenhouse gas emissions (excluding biogenic methane) by 2050, and to cutting biogenic methane from livestock and waste by 24-47 percent by 2050, with an interim target of 10 percent by 2030. Then-climate minister James Shaw and former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern at the passing of the Zero Carbon Act in 2019. Photo: RNZ / Dom Thomas To ensure progress, the Act also introduced a system of five-yearly emissions budgets, which cap total emissions across the economy. These budgets are not sector-specific but are supported by Emissions Reduction Plans (ERPs), which outline how the government intends to meet them through policies and funding across energy, transport, agriculture, and industry. This was meant to "anchor climate ambition in legislation", making a stable framework that would survive election cycles. The rest of the climate policies - from transport subsidies to decarbonisation incentives - were meant to fill out its bones. The following sections show what remains of that original body of work, what has been stripped away, and what has replaced it. NZ Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS): The ETS is the main market tool used to reduce emissions. The Labour government aimed to adjust its settings to balance direct emissions cuts and offsets like forestry. The coalition government instead wants to restore confidence by ending vintaging, treating forestry NZUs (New Zealand Units) equally, and reducing the number of credits available. Centre for Climate Action on Agricultural Emissions: The centre is a core component of the Luxon government's climate change response and one of the only major policies to continue from the Labour government. It houses both the national agriculture emissions research centre and a public/private partnership named AgriZeroNZ, designed to accelerate the development and uptake of emissions-reduction tools, practices, and technologies on farms. Electric Vehicle (EV) charging infrastructure: Labour's prior commitment to improving electric vehicle charging infrastructure across New Zealand continues, although the coalition government shifted from using grants to using concessionary loans, and light EVs began paying Road User Charges (RUCs) from April 2024. The government's target is 10,000 public EV charging points by 2030, however there are currently under 1400 in commission. Improved insulation standards: Efforts to improve insulation standards for new buildings, aiming for significantly reduced energy requirements for heating, remain ongoing despite initial plans to roll them back. Grant scheme for clean heavy vehicles: The Low Emissions Heavy Vehicle Fund aims to encourage businesses to adopt cleaner heavy vehicles, including trucks, heavy vans, and non-public transport buses. The fund received new funding in 2024. Cheaper public transport: Half-price public transport for under 25s and free transport for kids ended last year, but the discount remains in place for community service card holders. Regulated product stewardship for refrigerants: A mandatory product stewardship scheme for refrigerants, initially investigated under ERP1, is coming into effect from 2025. Sustainable aviation fuels partnership: Collaboration with Air New Zealand on sustainable aviation fuels remains ongoing. Coal boiler phase-outs : The government's commitment to replace all remaining coal boilers in schools by 2025 remains in place, alongside the broader ban on new low- and medium-temperature coal boilers and the phase-out of existing ones by 2037. Develop a Māori climate strategy: This initiative is intended to elevate te ao Māori and mātauranga Māori within the overall climate response. Despite a funding cut, this initiative remains ongoing. Half-price public transport for under 25s and free transport for kids ended last year, but discounts remain for community service card holders. Photo: RNZ/Nick Monro Many distinct policies and the overall framing of the Ardern era's emissions reductions plan (ERP1) have been altered, put on hold, or had funding cut by the current government. These include: Agricultural emissions pricing: ERP1 envisioned an emissions pricing mechanism for agriculture by 1 January 2025. The current government has delayed this to no later than 2030 and committed to keeping agriculture out of the NZ ETS. This is a fundamental change from the previous government's approach under the He Waka Eke Noa model. Climate Emergency Response Fund (CERF): The ERP1 established the CERF, which ring-fenced revenue from the ETS for climate initiatives, with an initial payment of NZ$4.5 billion. The current government ended the CERF in May 2024, meaning future climate investments will go through the usual Budget process. This discontinuation is estimated to result in a loss of 11-24 million tonnes CO2e of abatement over the first, second, and third emissions budget periods. Clean car discount: This initiative, which aimed to make electric vehicles more affordable, was an ERP1 policy. It was stopped on 31 December 2023. Sustainable biofuels obligation: This was an ERP1 initiative aimed at reducing freight emissions. It was discontinued as part of a government policy refocus in February 2023. Oil and gas exploration ban: The Labour-led government banned offshore oil and gas exploration. The current government reversed this ban. This reversal is estimated to lead to an extra 14.2 million tonnes of emissions to 2035, and 51.5 million tonnes of CO2 emissions up to 2050. Subsidies to large carbon polluters: Climate Change Minister Simon Watts rejected advice from Inland Revenue and Treasury to review hundreds of millions of dollars in climate grants to major emitters like NZ Steel, Methanex, Rio Tinto, and Fletcher Building, despite findings of "very limited results". Science sector reforms and cuts: The Te Ara Paerangi - Future Pathways science-system reform programme has been discontinued. There have also been job cuts at the National Institute of Water & Atmospheric Research (NIWA) which critics say will negatively impact climate change science, including marine biodiversity, climate modelling, and physical oceanography. Transport initiatives: The ERP1 aimed to improve travel choices by providing convenient, affordable public transport, walkways, and cycle lanes. The current government has ordered officials to end work on programmes that would reduce vehicle kilometres travelled (VKT) by passenger cars through providing alternatives like public and active transport. It also cut an initiative to increase the uptake of e-bikes, ended some public transport subsidies, got rid of equity measures to help low-income households access low-emissions cars, and defunded a $56 million fund specifically for electric buses. Auckland Light Rail and Let's Get Wellington Moving were canned, although the City Rail Link and extra Auckland busways will continue. A commitment to set a high threshold for investing in new roads was also discontinued. The current government is instead prioritising motorway funding and increasing speed limits. Equity and 'just transition' focus: Several ERP1 actions related to an equitable transition have been discontinued, including those which seek to support industries and workers to retrain in low-emissions jobs. The development of an income insurance scheme was also cut. Circular economy and bioeconomy strategy: ERP1 included a Circular Economy and Bioeconomy Strategy and supporting businesses moving to circular economy models. These actions have been stopped. Energy efficiency rebates: ERP1 included rebates for energy-efficient equipment. This has been stopped. New fossil-fuel baseload generation ban: ERP1 included a ban on new fossil-fuel baseload generation. This has been cancelled. New Zealand Battery Project: ERP1 stated that options for dry-year electricity storage through the New Zealand Battery Project would be investigated. This has been cancelled. Gas transition plan: ERP1 included developing a gas transition plan. This was associated with the Labour government's ban on offshore oil and gas exploration and has been abandoned with the reintroduction of exploration. Government Investment in Decarbonising Industry (GIDI) Fund: In 2020, the government created a $70m fund to incentivise companies with large fossil-fuel boilers to decarbonise. It has been closed to new applications. The estimated loss in emissions reductions from discontinuing the GIDI fund is 4.3 million tonnes of CO2e for 2026-2030. Forestry in the ETS: The Labour government introduced changes for "permanent forestry" in the ETS from 1 January 2023. The National-led coalition has announced an independent review of forestry in the ETS. The government is also limiting whole-farm conversions to NZ ETS forestry to protect highly productive farmland. Monitoring renewable electricity target: While ERP1 set an aspirational target of 50 percent of total final energy consumption from renewable sources by 2035, monitoring progress towards this target has been stopped. Climate finance: The New Zealand Green Investment Finance (NZGIF), a fund established to support renewable energy and other low-emission projects, has been stopped. Pacific climate finance: Future climate finance to help our Pacific neighbours was cut from $250m to $100m this year. Climate-Related Disclosures (CRD) Regime: The government has proposed raising thresholds so the regime applies to fewer large entities and reducing the liability exposure for entity directors. Warmer Kiwi Homes initiative: Funding for the Warmer Kiwi Homes scheme, including subsidies for hot water heating, low-cost energy efficiency measures, and an LED lighting scheme were cut, alongside funding for a community-focused outreach programme to target hard-to-reach households. Waste management: The government put four out of five waste minimisation policies on hold in 2024, including plans to improve recycling systems and introduce a kerbside food scraps composting scheme. The Waste Minimisation Fund also had its funding cut. Tikanga-based agriculture programmes: Dedicated funding for programs to support Māori aspirations in agriculture was cut. Native trees to absorb carbon: Funding for Establishing Native Forests at Scale, a research and planting programme, was cut by $50m in Budget 2024. Dedicated climate-focused farm advisory and extension services: This was intended to include multichannel information campaigns, extension programmes (workshops, action groups), and growing a pipeline of trusted industry advisers. This has been stopped, although support continues through existing public and private advisory services. National Adaptation Plan: The coalition government discontinued a number of measures from the first National Adaptation Plan (NAP1) including work on risk management and planning for managed retreat. Although ERP2 outlines three adaptation goals, the Climate Change Commission noted there was not enough information to assess whether they are achievable. The government put four out of five waste minimisation policies on hold in 2024, including plans to introduce a kerbside food scraps composting scheme. Photo: Supplied / Auckland Council Carbon Capture, Utilisation, and Storage (CCUS): The government is developing an enabling regulatory regime for CCUS, with legislation expected this year, to allow industries to access this technology for emissions reduction and removal. Fast-track approvals bill: The controversial Fast-track Approvals Bill is designed to streamline and accelerate the consenting process for various development and infrastructure projects, including renewable energy. Critics say it allows the "override of environmental laws" and does not give sufficient weight to climate considerations, potentially making it more difficult to meet emissions budgets. Methane review: An independent review of biogenic methane science and targets has been initiated to provide up-to-date scientific evidence regarding methane's warming impact. It is widely expected the government will drop the methane target post-review. Electrify NZ: This aims to double renewable energy by 2050. This includes streamlining consenting processes through the Fast-track Approvals Bill. Work is underway to develop a regime for offshore renewable energy by mid-2025. Adaptation framework: Work is underway on an adaptation framework that aims to minimize long-predictable funding, improve information flows, and address market failures. Afforestation on Crown land: ERP2 includes exploring private sector partnerships to plant trees on Crown-owned land for afforestation. The policy is still under development. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
28 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Is Auckland really the 'City of Fails', or does it just have a cashflow problem?
Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown at the launch of the State of the City report. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Auckland has been labelled the City of Fails after its annual State of the City report, which highlighted glaring issues with the city's economy, productivity, innovation, education and more. Its flagging GDP, city sprawl, reliance on cars, a lack of walkability... the condemnation goes on. But it was not just this one report. Other issues have been regularly highlighted this year - the sudden increase in homelessness; endless road works and construction from the City Rail Link development; gaping holes where CBD developments have just stopped, the cranes in cold storage. All this while the South Island and rural communities are showing sparks of coming out of recession in a post-Covid era - it is a tale of two different economic recoveries. The Detail looks at what is wrong with Auckland, what is right and what needs to be done to make it better. Auckland Business Chamber chief executive Simon Bridges has been pushing the government to come to the aid of the city, where he is seeing the results of weak economic growth, a lack of investment and flagging retail trade. He says he has tried to put politics aside but, yes, it is possible his former job as leader of the National Party has helped his advocacy. "I think central government is listening," he says. "I think what we need to see now is just a bit of urgent action. If you think about Auckland, we've had several years of difficulty and you might say well, what's several more months? But the reality is even if things do get a bit better next year, there's a lot of pain out there. "I've put forward some ideas of things that could be done, but I don't have a monopoly on the answers. Ultimately what we want to see happen is stuff that is going to improve the sentiment and get some spending happening, because if Auckland was a business it would be a business with a cashflow issue." So far the government has not raced in to help with any short-term stimulus. Prime Minister Chris Luxon told RNZ he would "keep looking at what we can do", but an "Auckland-specific stimulus thing is quite difficult to do ... I don't know how you'd go about doing that". Bridges has given him a bunch of ideas, including relaxing visa requirements for Asian tourists to make it easier for them to come here, encouraging international students and letting Mayor Wayne Brown have his bed levy as a way of increasing council income and bidding for more big events to come to the city. "We're not rich enough that we don't need that money swilling around at a time when, in Auckland at least, hotel rates - occupancy and so on - is very bad. Worse than last year actually." There are some bright lights on the horizon, including the scheduled opening next year of the long-awaited City Rail Link, and the International Convention Centre. However, the infrastructure pipeline behind that is looking bleak, especially with government moves to cap rates rises, block councils from using other methods to raise money, and now the introduction of some hasty rules telling councils what they should focus on and how they should behave. The Local Government (Systems Improvement) Amendment Bill - which councils have just four weeks to submit on - tells them to stick to core services like roads, rubbish and water, and get rid of spending on cultural, community and environmental things - the nice-to-haves. The things the city is measured on internationally. North Shore resident Hayden Donnell is a senior writer for The Spinoff. He thinks the city is improving, and can list a raft of places in the CBD where it is lively, pedestrian-friendly and full of great cafes and restaurants. Donnell talks to The Detail about the good and the bad, including beaches, buses and bad planning rules. "I think we probably are a little bit negative about Auckland," he says. "Maybe we do undersell the fact that we have this beautiful natural environment, there's a lot of places that are going really well. "At the same time I think it's true ... there are lots of areas where we could improve, where the rest of the world has caught up with this thing called 'walkable areas' and 'pedestrian malls' ... that kind of vibrant shopping that you can go to Europe and experience doesn't really happen here to the same extent. "But we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that we're very fortunate." Something Aucklanders do have is Auckland FC, which has lit the city up with its nearly-all conquering ways this year, breaking A-League crowd records in its debut season. Auckland Football director Terry McFlynn grew up in a little village in south Derry, Northern Ireland. He has lived in Perth, Sydney and London. Now he lives in Auckland. "There's a lot of people that take a lot of pride in Auckland as a city and want to see it progress, and want to see a vibrant city, which I believe it is. "I think the restaurants and bars and that lifestyle that Auckland can give around the viaduct and down by the harbour ... you know it's second to none in the whole world in my opinion." Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter .
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Should Māori born overseas automatically be NZ citizens? Father fights for children classed as illegal overstayers
John Bryers Ruddock pictured with his children, who are 8, 9 and 12. Photo: John Bryers Ruddock / Supplied The descendant of a Treaty signatory, All Black and " the voice of New Zealand" is fighting for Māori to have automatic New Zealand citizenship. John Bryers Ruddock (Ngāpuhi), recently returned to Aotearoa to live with his three children - ages 8, 9 and 10. But, he was born in Australia and all three of his children were born in Hawaii. As a result, he was now navigating an expensive process to get his tamariki recognised as New Zealand citizens. Despite their whakapapa including a number of famous New Zealanders - their great grandfather was All Black Ron Bryers, their grandmother was celebrated singer Rhonda Bryers, known as "the voice of New Zealand" and their great great grandfather was an original signatory to Te Tiriti, the children were technically overstayers and unable to attend school. Bryers Ruddock told Checkpoint , he had asked for a Waitangi Tribunal hearing to discuss the issue and wanted to see some kind of intervention. He said having his children being labelled as overstayers was not something as a father he wanted to put them through. "It's red tape after red tape," he said. "It's been a costly process so far, I have to finalise the court orders, so still dealing with that, I've spent over $17,000 so far." Bryers Ruddock said he wanted the tribunal to look at his case and change the policy around citizenship for people of Māori descent who were born overseas. "I just feel, you know, my mum was an ambassador for this country and culture... it's something I want to do for our people." Bryers Ruddock said he had sent in an application for the children to get citizenship under Section 61 of the Immigration Act, which allowed Immigration NZ to issue visas in special circumstances, and was waiting for a sponsor to help him get either a student visa or residency. The treaty claim had been lodged by Hastings law firm Manaia Legal, he said. John Bryers Raddock and his three children recently moved to Wellington. Photo: John Bryers Ruddock / Supplied Minister of Internal Affairs, Brooke van Velden, said in a statement provided to Checkpoint, she was not looking to change the citizen act and said the requirements of citizenship applied to all applicants equally. "The outcomes depend on the information provided for each case not the ethnicity of the applicant." The minister had the discretion to grant citizenship to people who didn't meet requirements bur had exceptional circumstances. Van Velden's office said it had not yet received an application about Bryers Ruddock's children and they needed to go through the application process with internal affairs first. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
